Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this rebate announced today is a total con

258 replies

Viviennemary · 03/02/2022 18:19

So this so called rebate has to be paid back. It isnt exactly a rebate then is it?

OP posts:
murasaki · 03/02/2022 23:10

Yes to your last paragraph, I'd rather it went where needed.

It reminds me of when Peter Stringfellow phoned up to hand back his winter fuel allowance and they wouldn't/couldn't let him do it. So he donated it to charity. Which was great, but really???

Graphista · 03/02/2022 23:06

The idea is to target lower income families

Except the proposed help for lower income households is very vague and uncertain!

They're bailing out energy companies and trying to make out they're doing consumers a favour.

But then that's what I and others that understand what the tories are like know this is their priority

Just to throw another spanner in the works - is anyone on thread aware that the energy companies said this was only the 1st of 2 price hikes? That there's likely to be another next April too? - read in a business journal a few weeks back but can't remember which one annoyingly

High prices remaining for 2-3 years

How would a council tax rebate work for those getting council tax support?

This was my immediate question. And I've not seen a satisfactory answer yet!

I believe councils also have extra funds to distribute to those struggling

The info on this is EXTREMELY vague and not at all reassuring!

It’s feels very much like old workhouse handouts come to a panel, we will judge your story how well we think you should be coping and check bank systems to for what you may or may not have been buying.

This is my fear! Not because I'm profligate but because I don't trust councils to make these (moral!) judgments

If it's £200 off your bill, how will people on pre-pay meters receive that? They're usually the lowest income households too

This also applies to me

Sunak is probably unaware such things exist, and therefore hasn’t considered them.

Oh he knows!

He just DOES NOT GIVE A SHIT!!

And it's not like they didn't know this was coming either!!

What do you expect the government to do, pay your energy bills?

Seriously?

How about GOVERN

Which includes MANAGING THE ECONOMY and not pulling crap like brexit and huge tax breaks for the wealthy while increasing levels of poverty!

It would be better to ensure people use energy more efficiently and insulate homes.

Do you REALLY think the poorest of us don't ALREADY do this as far as we're able?

I'm in Scotland I haven't had my ch on all winter because of this! I use as little energy as possible - that includes ALREADY doing as little as possible in my own home that uses energy from laundry to bathing to heating to cooking...

There's fuck all else I can do to cut back that wouldn't involve me going hungry or becoming ill from lack of heat!!

Plus I like many others on thread who are kind and thoughtful enough to recognise they aren't the ones that need the help - I would rather the help went to those who DO need it and not unnecessarily to those who don't!

Good grief!!!

murasaki · 03/02/2022 23:04

Surely normally you have to sign for a loan. Where do I have to sign for this one I don't want? I'd rather just pay my bills, even if higher. I don't see how it can be legal? Am I missing something here?

Viviennemary · 03/02/2022 23:00

I was busy correcting that. Blush anyway a measly £200 won't make much difference to people on a low wage struggling with rapidly escalating costs. It's a poor show all round.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 03/02/2022 22:58

I am not hard up and don't need £200 towards my fuel bill. Znd iv ZI was strugglinb on z los wzge then £200 woulfnt mzke z fifference on z los wage dith rapidly esczlating prices. Its z fubbixh idez.

OP posts:
SickAndTiredAgain · 03/02/2022 22:54

The £200 is not really a loan to each household where the household must pay it back. The best way to look at it is that all electricity bills will be reduced by £200 in October 2022. From April 2023, all electricity bills will be increased by £40 a year for five years. The government is lending the money to the energy companies who will have to pay back what they borrow.

Somebody who gets a house for the first time after April 2023 will not benefit from the £200 discount, but will still have to pay the extra £40 on their bills each year up to and including April 2027

So I guess on a similar vein, if a couple who currently live together get the £200, and then they split up, they both pay back £200 each (Assuming they then live alone)?
But two single people (living alone) now who both get the £200 and then move in together will only pay back £200, not £400?

BuickMcKane · 03/02/2022 22:43

What do you expect the government to do, pay your energy bills?

Literally no one on this thread has said that. The majority have said they'd rather opt out of this loan.

Mossstitch · 03/02/2022 22:42

My electricity company can't even get my name right despite phone calls and two copies of deed poll so I wouldn't hold out much hope of them getting this right. Can you imagine when you move house or all the couples splitting up trying to get finances sorted as to what is owed, I reckon it will all go pear shaped and end up another write off like the billions on PPE!

SickAndTiredAgain · 03/02/2022 22:37

@saleorbouy

What do you expect the government to do, pay your energy bills? The government aren't a bank, all their money is derived from the population of tax payers so if it's handed out for utility bills it won't be spent on health, social care or education. High energy prices are a long term issue and will not be fixed by short term handouts. It would be better to ensure people use energy more efficiently and insulate homes. I understand keeping warm, cooking and paying bills is a big issue for everyone but it's nieve to think the government can just hand out cash ad-infinitum to see us through. This needs a much better approach to a very big long term issue.
A lot of people on this thread are just saying they’d rather just pay the £200 at the time rather than spread out. They aren’t saying that they want all their bills paid, literally no one has said energy should be free, just that they don’t want a compulsory loan they don’t need. Even interest free, why would I want or need a £200 loan when I could just pay the £200?
Ariela · 03/02/2022 22:29

@Tealightsandd

If only some of the furlough fraudsters had a moment of guilt, and decided to donate their ill-gotten gains to a cost of living fund.
Hmmn, I think HMRC are chasing the wrong people one of my friends works as a part time self employed cleaner due to caring/helping her mother (not disabled enough to get carer benefits) and having pre school kids. She lost all her customers in the first lockdown as they were home and did it themselves, and only managed to gain a tiny bit back around May time last year as she has fairly specific hours she can work due to her OH's job so it's been tricky to find stuff to fit in with the children, plus there's been a glut of cleaners trying to pick up additional work as so many put their cleaners off. She tried to get a job in a local shop but they were too inflexible on hours, she tried to get other jobs but didn't manage it. She's always paid a tiny amount of tax/NI - we're talking less than £500/year, so she's only just over the tax threshold, but it's money they need to run their household. So naturally she claimed 2 I think (not all) of the the offered SEISS grants to survive. However she had a letter back from HMRC saying as she hasn't traded in 20/21 she needs to pay back the SEISS grants AND moreover, she had to pay half the SEISS grant in 'tax on account' in January and pay again the same again in July - and because she paid no tax in 20/21 , she cannot ask for the amount to be reduced as she can only ask for it to be reduced if she thinks she will earn less. You can't earn less than £0. When she rang they just said because she didn't manage to earn anything, then her self employed business is considered closed, which is why she has to pay the grants back. She's had to borrow several thousand off her dad.
saleorbouy · 03/02/2022 22:29

What do you expect the government to do, pay your energy bills? The government aren't a bank, all their money is derived from the population of tax payers so if it's handed out for utility bills it won't be spent on health, social care or education.
High energy prices are a long term issue and will not be fixed by short term handouts.
It would be better to ensure people use energy more efficiently and insulate homes.
I understand keeping warm, cooking and paying bills is a big issue for everyone but it's nieve to think the government can just hand out cash ad-infinitum to see us through. This needs a much better approach to a very big long term issue.

BuickMcKane · 03/02/2022 22:15

Essentially they're putting the entire adult population in debt by £200. Those who can afford their bills and then some likely won't notice the repayments to any great extent.

Those who already struggle to pay their bills will struggle even more when they have to pay this back. What then? They get further into debt. The credit score they might've been working on for ages goes to shit again. Then with non payment it's sent to debt collection. Then it's a CCJ or bailiffs at the door.

If that's how this pans out, the conservatives have done what they always do - made the poor, poorer.

sociallydistained · 03/02/2022 22:07

@LakieLady

I'm fortunate in that I was able to fix my energy costs early and I won't see a rise till Nov 2023. My energy bills are low anyway (£80pm), because I live alone in a well insulated house .

I don't need the so-called rebate, and I certainly don't want to have the repayment added to my bills when they're likely to be rising anyway, because my fixed-rate deal will be ending. If an opt-out was possible, I'd go for it.

The council reduction is welcome though. At £120+ a month (after the single person discount), it's my biggest bill by quite some distance.

I am in the same boat. Annoying but welcome the council tax discount on my one bed flat which is £120
Tealightsandd · 03/02/2022 22:04

If only some of the furlough fraudsters had a moment of guilt, and decided to donate their ill-gotten gains to a cost of living fund.

Tealightsandd · 03/02/2022 22:02

@Ariela

And for those people living in a HMO or split into flats where the electricity is paid by the landlord and they individually have a meter to pay the landlord back, get nothing because a) their electricity is paid by the landlord (not them) , so despite being disabled/cannot work so minimal income, they cannot claim any help or grants with heating.
That's a very good point.

So, many of the very poorest and most vulnerable won't get desperately needed help.

I don't think it's a completely terrible idea. The basic premise, at least. But it clearly needs some tweaking.

A lot of people will find it more possible to pay off £40 in instalments rather than one big bill in one go.

And also the council tax rebate is a good idea... I think. Not if it means taking away yet more money from very cash strapped local councils. Public services will be cut even more if that's the case.

truthfullylying · 03/02/2022 22:00

@VivX

It is total rubbish. Sunak needs to use a dictionary. It is not a rebate nor a discount. It is a loan.
Absolutely correct!
Happygirl79 · 03/02/2022 21:59

Conservatives sell themselves to the voters as the low tax party (pardon the pun) All are a bunch of liars without a clue how to govern. We know they can't even organise a p... up in a brewery although they can every Friday in 10 Downing Street. This loan is a ridiculous idea and doesn't help anyone

BuickMcKane · 03/02/2022 21:57

@Mundra

If it's £200 off your bill, how will people on pre-pay meters receive that? They're usually the lowest income households too Angry
I was wondering this too. When we moved in here we realised it has pre-payment meters and couldn't be bothered to change them. Likely they'll take off the repayment of the loan every time you top up. I'll pass on that thanks. Depending on how business is (I run my own business), how much I can afford to put in the meter fluctuates. I'd rather not be paying off a loan I didn't ask for.
SickAndTiredAgain · 03/02/2022 21:54

@Mundra

If it's £200 off your bill, how will people on pre-pay meters receive that? They're usually the lowest income households too Angry
Sunak is probably unaware such things exist, and therefore hasn’t considered them.
MouseyMoose · 03/02/2022 21:54

@Mundra

If it's £200 off your bill, how will people on pre-pay meters receive that? They're usually the lowest income households too Angry
Martin Lewis has covered this, it's not been sorted yet but will be in the form of a voucher or cheque most likely. You won't miss out on it but no idea how it would be paid back!
Mundra · 03/02/2022 21:51

If it's £200 off your bill, how will people on pre-pay meters receive that? They're usually the lowest income households too Angry

ENoeuf · 03/02/2022 21:45

cptartapp

We're on an E band so will get nothing (moved in after property extended/property was rebranded). Attached next door to neighbours in a C band (they extended and never moved) who will get the rebate. So not only do they pay two bands less council tax, they get money back too now and we get zero.

Snap - we are band E as a run down 4 bed and the house directly next are extended from 3 so 5 bed and one with a new annex but not reassessed so will get the rebate. Never have the Tories done anything for us.

Ariela · 03/02/2022 21:43

And for those people living in a HMO or split into flats where the electricity is paid by the landlord and they individually have a meter to pay the landlord back, get nothing because a) their electricity is paid by the landlord (not them) , so despite being disabled/cannot work so minimal income, they cannot claim any help or grants with heating.

Akire · 03/02/2022 21:39

The extra council funds are like old crisis loans. I just looked at my council they don’t have to be paid back but you have to have pretty good sob story ready with evidence and be willing supply all bank statements etc to back up your story. It’s feels very much like old workhouse handouts come to a panel, we will judge your story how well we think you should be coping and check bank systems to for what you may or may not have been buying. If we think it’s worthy you may get some cash when your desperate. Many will be put off by that it’s not even like social workers or Gp or teachers who know family can authorise a one off payment from the pot.

PreparationPreparationPrep · 03/02/2022 21:15

Yes this kind of funding is what my LA only make available to support those on a very, very, very low income - think FSM level.
I am band E - so As well as higher council tax / higher utilities/ NI increase etc. I do not qualify for any rebate!

Swipe left for the next trending thread