Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this rebate announced today is a total con

258 replies

Viviennemary · 03/02/2022 18:19

So this so called rebate has to be paid back. It isnt exactly a rebate then is it?

OP posts:
Akire · 06/02/2022 09:26

You could get furlough and still work long as it wasn’t for the company who paid you furlough. So yes some people got 80% then got another full time job.

userxx · 06/02/2022 08:46

@User8721643839

So when my carpet fitter said he got 20k furlough pay from the government, and still worked through, does this mean he will pay it back, or we all have to pay it back for him?? I'm pissed off

Furlough pay or SEISS ? If it was furlough, he's employed and should not have been working, if it was SEISS then working was permitted under the correct restrictions.

Mumoblue · 06/02/2022 08:10

I’m on UC and I don’t want this “loan”.
I’m barely getting by as it is, why do they want to put me in debt for five years?
I doubt that prices are going to fall quickly, and my payments won’t increase.

It really feels like the government is saying “Well, we’re going to bury you, but we’ll start out with a small hole”.

I actually don’t know what I’m going to do.

User8721643839 · 06/02/2022 07:53

So when my carpet fitter said he got 20k furlough pay from the government, and still worked through, does this mean he will pay it back, or we all have to pay it back for him??
I'm pissed off

SickAndTiredAgain · 06/02/2022 07:49

If four people share it's unlikely the bill will be in all 4 names. Usually bill is in just one name even in two adults household AFAIK.

From what’s been said, I’m not sure that will matter. If they live together, their bill will be reduced by £200 towards the end of the year. If they then all move out and live alone, their bills will all be raised by £40 a year, regardless of if they were named on the bills before. My understanding is that it’s £200 off all bills this year, and £40 on all bills for the next 5. Not like a regular loan against a specific person.

Graphista · 05/02/2022 23:05

@Tealightsandd mainly as big oil donates to Tory party I suspect

@1dayatatime I find it VERY hard to believe that the issues you mention are WORSE and more expensive than the ones we're currently dealing with!

No option is going to be perfect but generally speaking wind and tidal power is cheaper and has less impact on environment than fossil fuels and it would mean we (uk) would be in charge of our own energy supplies

1dayatatime · 05/02/2022 21:57

@Graphista

The problem with tidal barrages like the proposed one for the Severn or Swansea Bay is that they simply silt up behind the barrage needing massive amounts of dredging. Plus they are very expensive to build.

Tidal turbines have been tried but they tend to get damaged by floating stuff (trees, shipping containers or list nets) that hit them at high speeds due to the fast tides.

Wind turbines are a good idea but offshore wind turbines are very expensive to build and connect to the shore. Onshore wind is much cheaper but faces a lot of opposition in planning permission from locals objecting to its visual impact on the countryside.

Plus of course there ether problem of where do you get electricity when it's not windy or sunny (solar).

Tealightsandd · 05/02/2022 21:45

@Graphista I wonder why we're not doing that? Ideally we'd be looking to increase green energy for the longer term future, but in the meantime use our own fossil fuels rather than importing.

Graphista · 05/02/2022 21:12

@Tealightsandd just commented on my thread I don't know why we're not investing in tidal and wind power a lot more in this country! We've great access to tidal power!

Tealightsandd · 05/02/2022 19:48

better solution would be to make the existing old person's winter fuel allowance of £400 taxable income to make sure it goes to the poorer pensioners. Then take the money saved to extend it to all low income households, a bit like Universal Credit.

That would exclude the many households really struggling but who are just a little above the UC/benefits threshold.

Tealightsandd · 05/02/2022 19:46

@Viviennemary

If four people share it's unlikely the bill will be in all 4 names. Usually bill is in just one name even in two adults household AFAIK.
Yes. Our energy company refused to have both DP and me on the bill. They told us only one name allowed.

And when I used to houseshare, just one person was on the bill and the rest of us paid our share to that particular flatmate.

And repayable when they believe the costs will come down (although of course, as Rishi says, they don’t have a crystal ball, just basing it on what they believe now).

Well it would help if we invested in our own natural resources - our coal and gas, instead of increasingly expensive supply imported from other countries. Particularly when there's current diplomatic tensions. (More environmentally friendly too, due to lower travel carbon footprint).

Viviennemary · 05/02/2022 12:15

If four people share it's unlikely the bill will be in all 4 names. Usually bill is in just one name even in two adults household AFAIK.

OP posts:
FatFredsFriedEgg · 05/02/2022 12:09

@Furrydogmum

It is definitely a con for people who buy/rent their first home after the £200 payment as according to Martin Lewis they will automatically make the 5 yearly £40 payments too!
Conversely if you were to (for example) move in with a partner when you'd previously both had your own homes you'd only repay £200 instead of £400.
Furrydogmum · 05/02/2022 11:37

It is definitely a con for people who buy/rent their first home after the £200 payment as according to Martin Lewis they will automatically make the 5 yearly £40 payments too!

Graphista · 05/02/2022 11:31

But I am more than happy to take it and pay it back over the next 5 years if that helps those who really need it.

But it doesn't! It's not really helping anyone

His scheme has more holes in it than a sieve.

It's a sieve without the mesh.

My current position is I MAY get help if I apply and allow the council to decide I'm worthy or not. But I may not. I'm trying to find a new place to live as because of my disability worsening I can no longer manage in my current home.

So It's entirely possible I WON'T get any help in this flat but when I move to a new one I'll be repaying the help I NEVER got!

So no it's absolutely not helping those of us worse off!

oopsIdiditagaintoo · 05/02/2022 10:40

@Mennex

How will they ever keep track of this? I have been with 4 energy companies in the last 5 years! Even if you don't switch to get the best deal, what about people that move house, or emigrate. What about people who get divorced and move to a new house?

How will they ever keep track of which household stillmowes money? The only way they could realistically do it would be to link it to the meter itself via the MPAN number. So anyone moving house in the next 5 years to a non new build will have to pay off someone else's installments. Fine if they're leaving a house with a similar debt but what if they're coming from abroad or moving out from home or getting divorced?

Who would try and implement such an overly complicated system?

It isn't that complicated.

Everyone who has a gas and electricity account on 1st October 22 will get a £200 credit.

Everyone who has a gas and electricity account from 2023 onwards will pay an extra £40 a year for 5 years.

Mennex · 05/02/2022 10:37

How will they ever keep track of this? I have been with 4 energy companies in the last 5 years! Even if you don't switch to get the best deal, what about people that move house, or emigrate. What about people who get divorced and move to a new house?

How will they ever keep track of which household stillmowes money? The only way they could realistically do it would be to link it to the meter itself via the MPAN number. So anyone moving house in the next 5 years to a non new build will have to pay off someone else's installments. Fine if they're leaving a house with a similar debt but what if they're coming from abroad or moving out from home or getting divorced?

Who would try and implement such an overly complicated system?

oopsIdiditagaintoo · 05/02/2022 10:12

[quote 1dayatatime]@oopsIdiditagaintoo

My apologies for not reading your previous post. I posted on the fly whilst doing the laundry![/quote]
No worries! I think we're in agreement.

I think this is a terrible idea. It's a bit like VAT in that it isn't really progressive.

I'd rather they just gave £200 to those on low incomes. Link it to UC / DLA / pension credits, or something along those lines.

They've tried to dress it up as being help for everyone and failed miserably.

1dayatatime · 05/02/2022 09:59

@oopsIdiditagaintoo

My apologies for not reading your previous post. I posted on the fly whilst doing the laundry!

1dayatatime · 05/02/2022 09:57

@Suzanne999

Sunak said on Martin Lewis programme that’s it would be too complicated to make it optional. As it’s a loan doesn’t there have to be a loan agreement signed? What happens if I have to accept it then die?

As I understand it Family A gets the £200 to repay @ £40 per year for 5 years. Oldest dc then leaves home, sets up own energy a/c and £40 pa will be deducted even though they never had £200 as an individual……..

Also if energy prices don’t drop next year ( or even stay the same) do the Govt loan another £200 per household so repaying £80 pa….and so on year on year.

His scheme has more holes in it than a sieve.

If you die before full repayment then technically the original supply company that took the money from the Government could come after the estate for an outstanding debt. More likely is that they will simply write it off.

You raise a really got point about what if energy prices stay high - do we get another £200 loan and so on.

Also if a new energy supply company was set up after October 2022 and never took the "loan" from the Government then they wouldn't have to charge new customers the £40 repayment and would then be able to undercut those existing suppliers that did.

Lastly if you switch suppliers over the next 5 years then there is the considerable administrative cost of tracking and transferring your £40 repayment back to your original supplier that took the £200 "loan".

The whole thing is really badly thought through.

A better solution would be to make the existing old person's winter fuel allowance of £400 taxable income to make sure it goes to the poorer pensioners. Then take the money saved to extend it to all low income households, a bit like Universal Credit.

oopsIdiditagaintoo · 05/02/2022 09:50

In your example the DC that leaves home, sets themselves up in their first new or rented home in their first job will be considerably less well off than the parents that received the original £200 "loan". This is a regressive tax.

That's a point I made myself up thread.

Taxes aren't always progressive btw. It depends on the political system in place.

1dayatatime · 05/02/2022 09:48

@oopsIdiditagaintoo

"Lots of people don't get things like child tax credit but they have to pay for it via their taxes anyway."

++++

But taxes need to be progressive ie taxing those with higher income/ wealth more than those less well off.

In your example the DC that leaves home, sets themselves up in their first new or rented home in their first job will be considerably less well off than the parents that received the original £200 "loan". This is a regressive tax.

oopsIdiditagaintoo · 05/02/2022 09:08

As I understand it Family A gets the £200 to repay @ £40 per year for 5 years. Oldest dc then leaves home, sets up own energy a/c and £40 pa will be deducted even though they never had £200 as an individual……..

This is why it's a tax, not a loan. You pay it even though you've never benefited from it.

Lots of people don't get things like child tax credit but they have to pay for it via their taxes anyway.

Suzanne999 · 05/02/2022 08:33

Sunak said on Martin Lewis programme that’s it would be too complicated to make it optional. As it’s a loan doesn’t there have to be a loan agreement signed? What happens if I have to accept it then die?

As I understand it Family A gets the £200 to repay @ £40 per year for 5 years. Oldest dc then leaves home, sets up own energy a/c and £40 pa will be deducted even though they never had £200 as an individual……..

Also if energy prices don’t drop next year ( or even stay the same) do the Govt loan another £200 per household so repaying £80 pa….and so on year on year.

His scheme has more holes in it than a sieve.

Thelazygoat · 05/02/2022 08:03

I am lucky at the moment I don't need the £200. I know to some it is very welcome. But I am just concerned that a government can force people into debt like this. I don't care what the amount is or that the repayments will be spread. It could be £10 and I would not be happy. It is £200 this time. But what is stopping them doing this again with a much higher amount. I don't know how this can be legal. But if they do it once they will do it again and before we know it we will all be owing the government thousands.

Swipe left for the next trending thread