Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think doubling the price will mean the group closes?

218 replies

NotMuchNotice · 03/02/2022 09:56

A small problem granted but I'm wondering if it's reasonable to think this is exactly what will happen?

I've attended a toddler group with my child since last September when it started running. It's held in community building so doesn't actually cost those running it anything for the space and they have been fortunate to get lots of toys and resources donated however despite this I appreciate there is the cost of the time given by those volunteering to run the group.

The group costs £2.50 per child and whilst lovely it's never been exceptionally popular, most weeks they have between 10-15 people. This is likely because it's quite a deprived area and there are many groups here that run for free or a very nominal donation supported by lottery funding or local support services. This group is probably one of the most expensive of its type in the area but I like the atmosphere, those running it are lovely and so I've no problem paying.

However this morning out of the blue we've received an email saying the price is doubling to £5 per child starting immediately with tomorrow's session. I really want to support the group and to help it keep running but am really surprised at such a huge increase in price and can't help feeling that this is going to mean tomorrow's group is probably going to be the last one. Am I being pessimistic or would you feel the same?

OP posts:
NotMuchNotice · 03/02/2022 15:08

It’s very random that they’ve still not explained the reason for the cost hike.

Indeed, the lack of clarity is frustrating.

And if they were expecting 15 children to pay £5 and can now drop it to £3.50 they’ve not explained what they’re going to do to cover the £22.50 difference they needed this morning.

I'm guessing they didn't actually need the money to be viable as otherwise surely they will be back in the same situation in a few weeks or months time?

'Do they have a committee? Committee meetings or anything like that?*

Nope no committee or anything like that.

OP posts:
tttigress · 03/02/2022 15:01

£2.50 seems too low.

I get the impression certain groups just keep going at these low rates due to the generosity of the organisers who most surely be making a lose.

Teateaandmoretea · 03/02/2022 14:57

I used to run one that was £2.50 and the breakeven point several years ago was around £45.

The 45 included £20 to hire the hall, craft materials, snacks, wear and tear, insurance.

The attendance used to vary wildly from week to week and it would go from being really quiet to building and getting busier. Then it would get really really busy one week and then drop right down again (presumably because everyone had found it being rammed a totally hellish experience so didn't fancy a repeat). We used to have to try and predict this pattern Grin

What I find odd OP is that they haven't explained why the price has gone up and then they've changed their mind without explanation.

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 14:56

@NotMuchNotice

So I emailed and we've had a response saying that upon reflection and after numerous responses they are going to increase the fee to £3.50.

There was still no reasoning within the email for the sudden rise in cost but obviously I wasn't the only one who felt an increase up to £5 was too much.

It’s very random that they’ve still not explained the reason for the cost hike.

And if they were expecting 15 children to pay £5 and can now drop it to £3.50 they’ve not explained what they’re going to do to cover the £22.50 difference they needed this morning.

Do they have a committee? Committee meetings or anything like that?

SeasonFinale · 03/02/2022 14:50

If there are so few people attending anyway how many are volunteers? I suspect they don't pay to attend because they volunteer to run it which means there are even fewer contributing to running expenses.

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 14:50

[quote gogohm]@BlowDryRat

Even if they aren't paying rent there's heating, electricity, expenses for the helpers (assuming volunteers) you are not realistic about how much it costs to just have toddler group. We own the hall and at £1.50 we break even, if we had to rent it would be £34.50 just for the rent of the hall![/quote]
You have heating and electric costs because you own the hall, most groups don’t have that.

And most volunteers at a toddler group won’t be getting expenses - reimbursed for buying snacks/drinks at most. They can’t claim expenses legitimately for many things (that’s not to say many don’t, but legitimately they can’t).

londonrach · 03/02/2022 14:49

Most groups are 50p or £1. The most expensive I went to for £1.50 per child and 50p for adult but has bouncy castle and bouncy slide and some vvv posh toys. No one in their right mind pay £5. If I paid that much I'd go to a play class like messy play or forest school. Yanbu. I suspect there be very few going now

gogohm · 03/02/2022 14:45

@BlowDryRat

Even if they aren't paying rent there's heating, electricity, expenses for the helpers (assuming volunteers) you are not realistic about how much it costs to just have toddler group. We own the hall and at £1.50 we break even, if we had to rent it would be £34.50 just for the rent of the hall!

NotMuchNotice · 03/02/2022 14:41

So I emailed and we've had a response saying that upon reflection and after numerous responses they are going to increase the fee to £3.50.

There was still no reasoning within the email for the sudden rise in cost but obviously I wasn't the only one who felt an increase up to £5 was too much.

OP posts:
Lifeismeh · 03/02/2022 14:33

Our local one was £1 per child, they’ve now upped it to £2 per child, a compulsory snack which is £1.50 per child and we’ve all been out on a rota to set up, prepare the snacks, clean and take everything down.
It’s went from a lovely cheap morning out if we have no other plans to a £7 cleaning expedition.

We’ve stopped going 😂

I’d email for clarification of the price hike as like other have said - There’s a lot ‘better’ activities you could do for that price!

LoveMae · 03/02/2022 14:33

@EL1984

I think £5 is a bargain!! The two toddler groups we go to are £18 per time and £30 per week for a swimming lesson 😅 no biscuits or tea st any of them.

I would also say 15 kids is quite a lot to attend, especially in covid times when everything has been restricted in numbers for some time.

£5 is worth it to get out of the house and provide some entertainment for them, especially in winter.

I'm sorry. WHAT?!

I raised my DS in London and would never have paid more than a fiver for a group, ever.

ThinWomansBrain · 03/02/2022 14:31

To be honest whether or not they pay for the space isn't really relevant surely.
How can it not be relevant? If they have to cover say £50 hall fees, who is going to subsidise the shortfall?
Maybe they started off anticipating numbers would rise - who knows?
It does seem bizarre to attempt to introduce such a huge increase without any explanation.

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 14:22

@lanthanum

I can quite imagine that some churches will be putting up (or introducing) hire fees, partly because of the impending rise in heating costs, and partly because they may be struggling financially altogether - they are likely to have lost hire/events income over the last couple of years, and probably donations/regular giving as well. Some of the funds set up to help venues that had lost income weren't available to churches.
Most of them round here have been smart enough to realise that pricing groups out of using their halls would be counter productive.

The council however, now they’re a different story. They’re going with one price across the board now - so toddler groups and scouts have to pay the same as the boot camp guy who is charging people £25 a session. And yet they’re surprised that their daytime keys are all decamping to churches…

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 14:20

@Monopolyiscrap

It sounds like the issue is low attendance though. So sad as it is, if not enough people want the group, it will close.
15 paying children at a group isn’t low attendance. Especially when they charge full price for babies.

They’ll have less now at £5 a head

Lockdownbear · 03/02/2022 14:18

I think £5 is a bargain!! The two toddler groups we go to are £18 per time and £30 per week for a swimming lesson 😅 no biscuits or tea st any of them.

But what are you actually getting for that £18? The must be more expensive than a couple of hours actual childcare in a nursery.
Not a toddler group where mums help out.

Op they'd be as well to move to a softplay, they quite often do discounts for preschoolers off peak.
I think £5 is a lot for a toddler group

lanthanum · 03/02/2022 14:15

I can quite imagine that some churches will be putting up (or introducing) hire fees, partly because of the impending rise in heating costs, and partly because they may be struggling financially altogether - they are likely to have lost hire/events income over the last couple of years, and probably donations/regular giving as well. Some of the funds set up to help venues that had lost income weren't available to churches.

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 14:14

@ADisgruntledPelican

This is a perfect example of why running voluntary community groups is such a thankless task. Everyone feels entitled to complain but has no motivation to get involved.

And fwiw most Church halls charge for hire even to people involved in the Church because tbh they are the people who tend to use Church halls. Hmm

Yet many church halls don’t charge remotely high rates, if at all, to toddler or baby groups as they are one of the few groups that use them in the morning.

Volunteer groups can be a thankless task but not because people question doubling the price with one day of notice and no explanation…

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 14:13

Why would nicely worded emails help?
If the church has increased rent, the cost to parents increases. If parents can't or won't pay, it folds. That is how it works.
With rising fuel bills all groups that are not subsidised will see a rise in charges.

AnnaBegins · 03/02/2022 14:06

Affluent countryside area here. The stay and play toddler groups charge £2 per family for a cuppa and biscuit and room hire, and the sling library's stay and play session with free sling help is £3 per family to cover cake and room hire. The toddler group is able to invest in new toys too from proceeds.

For £5, we could attend a half hour baby music class or 1 hr forest school type activity, or 1hr role play village thing, £5.50 for 1.5hrs baby gymnastics, for £7.50 45 mins baby sensory. So £5 for a playgroup would be in competition with these.

I hope some nicely worded emails about how much parents will miss the group, from a range of parents, will make them reconsider and maybe charge £3.

CraftyGin · 03/02/2022 14:00

If things are too cheap, people don't value them.

Our M&T is very cheap (£2 per family) but it is a massive undertaking to put it together every week. We have to have a team to set up the room the night before (retired men, btw), as well as those who run it on the day and clear up. There's a lot of preparation, eg for the craft and to buy refreshments.

We charge per family, but then you get childminders who bring about 6 children. The nans that come do tend to voluntarily pay for the cousins separately, as they genuinely appreciate what they are getting.

Babies are not cost free - we have stock of nappies and wipes for emergencies and it's amazing how often they are used. They then leave the dirty nappies even though we ask for them to be taken home.

Churches have expenses and get nothing from the government or council. Income comes from stewardship or by letting their premises. Although churches are charities, mission budgets are spread across many areas, not just toddler groups.

3scape · 03/02/2022 13:52

Locally there are toddler groups that charge but they're quite clear it's a voluntary payment. I was always happy to pay (and would often pay with a note every few weeks to avoid change issues), but i remember once when I'd been discussing my ex leaving they kept discreetly reminding me I didn't have to pay, it turned out about half the group paid regularly, others were more as and when. Could it be less people than you think are paying?

Blondeshavemorefun · 03/02/2022 13:47

To double any price is a lot

Where £2 in one area or £5 in a richer area so £4 and £

Guess it’s what you are used to - m&t here in south east were £3 per child or £5 family

I haven’t bern to a m&t fir 2yr due to covid and now baby blondes a
Is at school

Tho soft play and other indoor activities are more or have to pay fir stuff as takes up a space and numbers limited

So was say £6 per child but now £4 but have to pay fir adult as well so £8

Why not say to the others in group that you know or like to set up a coffee am at yours and others each week

Each one host a week

Porcupineintherough · 03/02/2022 13:36

@WhatAWasteOfOranges

But there are other ways of running a group to cover costs, fundraisers, bake sales, local grants, working with the church etc I just don’t think it’s realistic asking people to pay more than £2.50
There are but they all involve more time and effort from the volunteers. Maybe they dont have more time to give?
Porcupineintherough · 03/02/2022 13:34

I think you are looking at this backwards. If the group cant cover it's running costs then yes it will have to close. It doesnt need to keep running at a loss just because.

If it closes then the space can be used for something else that does pay. And the volunteers can use their time towards something more sustainable.

WhatAWasteOfOranges · 03/02/2022 13:33

But there are other ways of running a group to cover costs, fundraisers, bake sales, local grants, working with the church etc
I just don’t think it’s realistic asking people to pay more than £2.50

Swipe left for the next trending thread