Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think doubling the price will mean the group closes?

218 replies

NotMuchNotice · 03/02/2022 09:56

A small problem granted but I'm wondering if it's reasonable to think this is exactly what will happen?

I've attended a toddler group with my child since last September when it started running. It's held in community building so doesn't actually cost those running it anything for the space and they have been fortunate to get lots of toys and resources donated however despite this I appreciate there is the cost of the time given by those volunteering to run the group.

The group costs £2.50 per child and whilst lovely it's never been exceptionally popular, most weeks they have between 10-15 people. This is likely because it's quite a deprived area and there are many groups here that run for free or a very nominal donation supported by lottery funding or local support services. This group is probably one of the most expensive of its type in the area but I like the atmosphere, those running it are lovely and so I've no problem paying.

However this morning out of the blue we've received an email saying the price is doubling to £5 per child starting immediately with tomorrow's session. I really want to support the group and to help it keep running but am really surprised at such a huge increase in price and can't help feeling that this is going to mean tomorrow's group is probably going to be the last one. Am I being pessimistic or would you feel the same?

OP posts:
JustLyra · 03/02/2022 17:07

@CraftyGin

Who said anything about them being a charity?

I don't know a church that isn't.

I must have misread as I thought the post you commented on was referring to the group rather than the church.

The OP hasn’t said that the group is run by the church

caringcarer · 03/02/2022 17:07

My DM used to volunteer at her church and make tea/coffee for adults once one week and twice the following week. She always made her own biscuits to take so shortbread or cookies and she sometimes did the story corner too. She did this until she was 80. She loved to do it and said it kept her young. She did it for so many years that she recalled reading stories to the parents when they were tots. If there are volunteers to run things and set up/pack away then cost can stay lower. They had a book exchange for parents running too.

CraftyGin · 03/02/2022 17:03

Who said anything about them being a charity?

I don't know a church that isn't.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 17:01

Getting grants for generic toddler groups even in deprived areas is no longer as easy as it once was.

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 17:00

@CraftyGin Charities don't make profits

Who said anything about them being a charity?

CraftyGin · 03/02/2022 16:59

Churches for example can access funding pots so can offer free of low cost access.

Tell me more!

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 16:59

Nope no committee or anything like that.

That’s interesting. Who runs it? Is it a parent or someone from the church? Are there no meetings? No annual “please can someone be the treasurer because Maureen’s kids are now in their 20s and she really wants to give up?” type things?

That’s very odd because if they are a group in their own right there should be a trail - policies, checks, accounts and the likes.
If they are part of the church then that should also be very clear so you know what part, if any, of the fee is going to the church (be it hall hire or otherwise).

@MrsAvocet Volunteer groups don’t pay for DBS checks.

CraftyGin · 03/02/2022 16:56

@NotMuchNotice

Whether the area is socially deprived or not doesnt effect the running costs of the group

Of course the group being in such an area doesn't affect how much it costs to run the group but it will obviously impact in how much they can reasonably charge.

The fact they have emailed to sya they have changed their minds does leave me wondering if the amount they were asking was to cover necessary costs or with a view to making a profit as like others have pointed out surely if they needed to increase the price sue to rising costs they couldn't then change their minds a few hours later? As you've said the costs are the costs.

Charities don't make profits.
JustLyra · 03/02/2022 16:54

@Porcupineintherough

Whether the area is socially deprived or not doesnt effect the running costs of the group, and as we both keep saying, prices are increasing across the board. It's either viable or it's not, the church is either able to continue subsidising it, or it isnt but that prices are increasing, no I dont find that surprising at all.
Most often it can actually. Churches for example can access funding pots so can offer free of low cost access.

The demographic of the area can have a direct impact on the costs.

caringcarer · 03/02/2022 16:48

Could it be that in the past there were no hire fees for church hall but now with electricity going up and cleaning cost due to Covid the group leaders have been told they have to pay to hire hall? 100 percent increase seems unlikely otherwise. I would probably pay it if my child liked to go and there were a few free places for tots who's parents were on benefits. It will just depend on people's budgets. I paid £1 a session 25 years ago for just a tea/coffee and biscuit.

Chickychoccyegg · 03/02/2022 16:37

I run a toddler group from a community building and of course we have to pay to hire it, its £25 per session, we charge £2.50 per child which includes a snack, cup of tea and a biscuit, and croft materials, we make enough to cover costs only.
£5 per child is very expensive, I have been to one that cost that much before, it was never busy and didn't last very long, itsntoo much.

MrsAvocet · 03/02/2022 16:32

Well to be fair, they might have felt that £5 week was enough to run the group comfortably but now they've realised that they'll use too many members they've decided they can manage short term on £3.50 whikst they think of other fundraising plans. Or maybe they had plans yo purchase some new equipment that they have now abandoned. Who knows?
I think you'd be reasonable to ask for a justification for the increase, and the lack of transparency would bother me too. I don't know what rules apply to toddler groups but I'd expect any not for profit organisation to have a committee and a constitution, to protect the people running it as well as the users.

GettingThemFromHereToThere · 03/02/2022 16:23

YANBU. I live in a relatively affluent area in the South East.

£5 is the cost of a proper kids session, like a dance group or a franchise music group.

It's £2.50 for our local toddler groups (and probably free for those who genuinely can't afford it).

The volunteers don't get paid - otherwise they'd be employees. The money is literally to cover the materials, teas and biscuits.

£5 is excessive and I'd not go. It would also definitely put off people with twins or siblings

NotMuchNotice · 03/02/2022 16:19

Whether the area is socially deprived or not doesnt effect the running costs of the group

Of course the group being in such an area doesn't affect how much it costs to run the group but it will obviously impact in how much they can reasonably charge.

The fact they have emailed to sya they have changed their minds does leave me wondering if the amount they were asking was to cover necessary costs or with a view to making a profit as like others have pointed out surely if they needed to increase the price sue to rising costs they couldn't then change their minds a few hours later? As you've said the costs are the costs.

OP posts:
Eviethyme · 03/02/2022 16:17

my local group was 50p per person and per child and have just increased to £1.50 PP which i think is fair. my local soft play is £4.50 per child under 10 and my local HUGE soft paly is £5.80 per child or £3 for under 4s

Eviethyme · 03/02/2022 16:13

Thats more than soft play :O

Porcupineintherough · 03/02/2022 15:56

affect sorry

Porcupineintherough · 03/02/2022 15:56

Whether the area is socially deprived or not doesnt effect the running costs of the group, and as we both keep saying, prices are increasing across the board. It's either viable or it's not, the church is either able to continue subsidising it, or it isnt but that prices are increasing, no I dont find that surprising at all.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 15:53

I do think they should share why this is happening.

NotMuchNotice · 03/02/2022 15:51

@Porcupineintherough

As you say, unless you have been living under a rock everyone is aware that the cost of everything is increasing so why would this be a surprise? And as for greedy, seems to me you are getting a very good deal but if there are many better local offers then sure people should be encouraged to go for them.
So you genuinely wouldn't bat an eyelid at something doubling in price in a socially deprived area where many, many people were struggling to pay the bills before everything went up. The demographic isn't a surprise to those running the group hence why I was surprised they had made this decision.
OP posts:
Porcupineintherough · 03/02/2022 15:46

As you say, unless you have been living under a rock everyone is aware that the cost of everything is increasing so why would this be a surprise? And as for greedy, seems to me you are getting a very good deal but if there are many better local offers then sure people should be encouraged to go for them.

NotMuchNotice · 03/02/2022 15:42

They don't owe you an explanation.

Of course they don't but we're all adults and it makes much more sense if you are transparent with each other. At the end of the day if they don't offer clarity they risk people thinking it's being done out of greed.

Surely it's in their best interests to be honest if it's due to rising costs, unless you've been under a rock everyone is well aware that everything is getting more expensive.

OP posts:
Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 15:40

Of course volunteers can legally claim travel expenses such as travel. But very few do in practice.

MrsAvocet · 03/02/2022 15:36

Cost can be a difficult line to walk when you're running any kind of group. You need to charge enough to cover costs and ideally keep something in the bank for a running replacement programme for any equipment, and a safety net unforeseen expenses, but not so much that it puts people off attending.
I think the organisers of the OP's group aren't doing themselves any favours by failing to provide an explanation for the price rise. Most people are unaware of the expenses involved in running any kind of club or group and so naturally feel aggrieved if prices go up and they aren't getting anything extra for their money.
I'm on the committee of a sports clu so it will be a bit different but the general principles are tge same I expect. Our biggest cost is facility hire, followed by insurance and affiliation to our governing body. Our volunteers don't get any payment for their time but we do cover expenses - though most of us claim far less than it costs us. But things like First Aid courses, Safeguarding courses, training new coaches and CPD for existing volunteers are covered by the club. Our governing body covers our DBS certificates but I'm not sure how that would work for an independent group. Even stuff like keeping the first aid kits up to date and buying things like cleaning materials, tea and coffee etc mount up over time.
Like others, I'd suspect the Church have put the hall hire up (I would be amazed if they are providing it free as most Churches can't afford to do that) but of the organisers don't share that info, it makes people a bit suspicious. However, unfortunately if they can't balance the books they will have to close. There may be grant funding available for the group but unfortunately this usually takes quite a long time to sort out.
In my experience, the running of the actual sessions of any kind of club or group is the easy part - it's keeping things going behind the scenes that is the more time consuming and difficult job.

Porcupineintherough · 03/02/2022 15:36

The lack of clarity is frustrating

They don't owe you an explanation. Smile This is their offer to you, you can take or leave it. Or if you think you could do better for less then go for it, start your own group.

Swipe left for the next trending thread