Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think doubling the price will mean the group closes?

218 replies

NotMuchNotice · 03/02/2022 09:56

A small problem granted but I'm wondering if it's reasonable to think this is exactly what will happen?

I've attended a toddler group with my child since last September when it started running. It's held in community building so doesn't actually cost those running it anything for the space and they have been fortunate to get lots of toys and resources donated however despite this I appreciate there is the cost of the time given by those volunteering to run the group.

The group costs £2.50 per child and whilst lovely it's never been exceptionally popular, most weeks they have between 10-15 people. This is likely because it's quite a deprived area and there are many groups here that run for free or a very nominal donation supported by lottery funding or local support services. This group is probably one of the most expensive of its type in the area but I like the atmosphere, those running it are lovely and so I've no problem paying.

However this morning out of the blue we've received an email saying the price is doubling to £5 per child starting immediately with tomorrow's session. I really want to support the group and to help it keep running but am really surprised at such a huge increase in price and can't help feeling that this is going to mean tomorrow's group is probably going to be the last one. Am I being pessimistic or would you feel the same?

OP posts:
JustLyra · 04/02/2022 06:35

I’m not getting into specific debate with people but the funders I mentioned funded our toddler group until it closed (there is now free ones a couple of days in a new children’s centre).

I also didn’t say it wasn’t hard work to find, apply and organise. As the one who has done it for the groups I mentioned I’m well aware of that - however it came up because the OP (and another poster for another group) said she was willing to do stuff.

After what I received in PM I won’t be contributing further, but if OP, or anyone, wants to chat about funding applications or the differences in applying to the ones I mentioned feel free to message me.

All of their sites tend to have details of current or past applicants as well and those are very helpful for ideas of what groups asked for and how they sell themselves.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 03/02/2022 21:49

@EL1984

I think £5 is a bargain!! The two toddler groups we go to are £18 per time and £30 per week for a swimming lesson 😅 no biscuits or tea st any of them.

I would also say 15 kids is quite a lot to attend, especially in covid times when everything has been restricted in numbers for some time.

£5 is worth it to get out of the house and provide some entertainment for them, especially in winter.

Again, not everyone can afford £5 a week!
Concestor · 03/02/2022 20:34

I think it's outrageous charging that, but...I used to run a toddler group. I got the hall free, the toys were donated, but I would have to get there an hour before to set it all up, stay an hour after to put it all away, and feed both me and my child while there, so it cost me four hours of my time and £10 each week. I ran it for over six years but got really fed up by the end as it was costing me so much just to run it for other people.
We did get donations from some people which I used to buy more toys, but never very much and not enough to even cover my costs of being there.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 03/02/2022 19:37

The thing is, the limited team of people involved may be good at, say, running a group operationally but crap at communication / financial management / understanding the demographic they serve etc.

Yes, to answer your OP, if there are other options available locally, the area is deprived, the group is nothing special, this group will close.

The church nearest me does a lovely playgroup 2x a week and hosts after school activities, and nary a mention of the big guy. Though TBH if you'll entertain my toddler for 2 hours on a rainy Monday for £3 you can go ahead and sing about Jesus if you like.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 19:11

Yes agreed it is all work.
It is also not unusual for a tiny group with a constitution not to have the formal meetings they are legally supposed to have. If you have been running for a while and everyone knows what they are doing, they may not want to give up extra time for formal meetings that no one except the volunteers has ever come to.
I have done a lot of volunteering, and generally people are very quick to tell you what you should do, but very reluctant to actually do what they are suggesting themselves.

Porcupineintherough · 03/02/2022 19:08

I deal with the Lottery a lot. It will not fund the running costs of a common or garden toddler group. In order to draw down funding for that youd have to wrap it all up in a parcel of wider delivery for a target group and the amount if work to even put a bid together would be massive, certainly far, far too much for a group of volunteers who only want to give a couple of hours a week.

Tesco's are a possibility but certainly round here the projects that are most selected are those which have tangible outputs - new play equipment etc

Gregg's I dont know about.

But again, this is all work. And there seems to be an assumption that there is someone willing to do it.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 19:00

@JustLyra there is no way Children in Need will fund a generic parent and toddler group.
The Lottery will give grants for specific vulnerable groups e.g. mums referred by HV at risk of postnatal depression.

Google Magic Little Grants - £500 - an independent parent and toddler group would get that.

Most parent and toddler groups that need to subsidise the cost do fundraising.

Redarrow2017 · 03/02/2022 18:42

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

CraftyGin · 03/02/2022 18:41

Well said, Margaret.

MargaretThursday · 03/02/2022 18:29

Having worked in a church office where rooms were hiring out, it's reasonably likely that even if they have "links" to the church they may well be paying room hire.

Every man, cat and dog thinks the church "should" give them rooms for free or next to free.
They're either "doing it for a good cause", "it'll be good advertising for you" or "supporting a charity" or "links to the church."
"Links to the church" means anyone with any tentative reason. Such as fifteen years ago they helped serving refreshments at an event, or their next door neighbour assured them that if they said they knew him they'd get it for free because their uncle had their funeral there, or (an old favourite) "the minister said they could definitely have it for free."
I'll also say that the groups who have it for free are also far more likely to take the micky with damage, going over hours, using things without asking etc.

I'd guess that either the church has significantly put the prices up, because they've kept them low for ages and now they can't afford to.

Or the leaders, have been told that they have to pay now. Whether that's because they now aren't really connected to the church, or whether they're causing issues, or whether the church is just in a financial position that they need to ask for payment.

Thing is, if you have a group in a room for free it is costing the church. Lighting, heat, toys, cleaning, disposal of nappies etc. Plus you also have that being there you are stopping another group coming and paying.

You also have the situation that if they've split from the church, having been affiliated with them, they will need their own liability insurance. Another thing that isn't cheap!

MrsAvocet · 03/02/2022 18:07

Thanks JustLyra that would be great if it's possible. We have found that every fund we have approached have only offered funding for very specific projects which is not what is always needed. I can understand their perspective but I don't think its always the best thing. But I'm derailing the thread so I'll shut up!

NotMuchNotice · 03/02/2022 17:57

Is it run with the expectation that it will eventually be a paid, low-hours job for the organiser, or is it run by parent volunteers?

Honestly I couldn't tell you with 100% certainty. One of the people running it is also a parent but I don't know if any of them are actually paid.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 03/02/2022 17:45

I have a funding spreadsheet with organisations listed that our lovely secretary pulls together. I’ll ask her if she’s ok with me sharing it on and if she says yes I’m happy to pass it on.

She’s our genius at picking up on “x are promoting funding for y”. She finds them and I apply.

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 17:43

@MrsAvocet

Were those grants for specific projects though *@JustLyra? I've looked for help with general running costs so that we could subsidise membership fees etc for the junior members of our club but have had no joy. If I'd wanted to buy equipment or team kit, there were multiple possible sources but as Porcupine* says we've found no-one who will help us with normal running costs - that has to come from the members, either via weekly subs or fundraising events. We've actually had to think twice about a recent equipment purchase because whilst we'd get grant funding for the initial outlay, there'd be significant ongoing running costs that weren't covered and we would have struggled with after the first year.
Both. Generally it’s the running costs that we apply for because we have enough equipment now that we just replace things as and when.

The bulk of our funding is for room hire, travel expenses, training, insurance (though I will say I know the council have cut the funding for this right down and I haven’t started the new funding hunt yet), then things like snacks (healthy eating/obesity is the one to go down with that) and other consumables.

I’m on a train so I’m thinking off the top of my head, but to give an example - we charge £1 a day for afterschool club (with exemptions for parents who can’t afford it) and £10 a week for 3 hours a day playscheme in the holidays.

Don’t get me wrong - the week before funding runs out we’re counting the pennies, but it’s how we run.

MrsAvocet · 03/02/2022 17:37

Were those grants for specific projects though @JustLyra? I've looked for help with general running costs so that we could subsidise membership fees etc for the junior members of our club but have had no joy. If I'd wanted to buy equipment or team kit, there were multiple possible sources but as Porcupine says we've found no-one who will help us with normal running costs - that has to come from the members, either via weekly subs or fundraising events. We've actually had to think twice about a recent equipment purchase because whilst we'd get grant funding for the initial outlay, there'd be significant ongoing running costs that weren't covered and we would have struggled with after the first year.

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 17:26

My comments on grants have all been based on the OP’s comment that the group isn’t a church group (no bible stories or obvious links). Just that one or two people involved are linked to the church

Saz12 · 03/02/2022 17:24

Is it run with the expectation that it will eventually be a paid, low-hours job for the organiser, or is it run by parent volunteers?

If none of the attendees ever volunteer (either they don’t offer or are not asked to), then I’d assume the intention is for it to make a modest profit for the organiser. So it’s a business who should be looking at how much people will pay for the service.

If it’s parent-volunteers then they’re likely to be trying to have a “cushion” for times when numbers are low, or don’t want to fundraise, or have no clue what people can / will pay.

I’d not shell out £5 for a toddler group!

CraftyGin · 03/02/2022 17:23

Grants and trust are there to advance the Christian faith, so it is difficult to see how a toddler group would be able to compete for these limited funds.

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 17:20

[quote Porcupineintherough]@JustLyra its actually really quite difficult to find Grant's that cover things like day to day running costs, room hire etc. Grants for equipment yes, for repairing the roof possibly but for subsidising a toddler group? Well you name some because I know many who'd be interested.[/quote]
I’d have to go through the list as we haven’t run toddlers for the last 12 months, but off the top of my head Lottery, Children in need (their programme is current changing though, which is a shame as they were excellent for training costs), Tesco, Greggs, the Rowntree foundation can be hit and miss depending on your area.

They all have grants to the toddler group, as well as the before and after school club and playscheme, I chaired.

Porcupineintherough · 03/02/2022 17:13

@JustLyra its actually really quite difficult to find Grant's that cover things like day to day running costs, room hire etc. Grants for equipment yes, for repairing the roof possibly but for subsidising a toddler group? Well you name some because I know many who'd be interested.

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 17:13

@CraftyGin

I must have misread as I thought the post you commented on was referring to the group rather than the church.

The OP hasn’t said that the group is run by the church

The OP said the space was cost-free, so I would conclude that it's a church ministry.

Ah. That assumption explains the charity comment.

Fair enough.

JustLyra · 03/02/2022 17:11

@NotMuchNotice

That’s interesting. Who runs it? Is it a parent or someone from the church? Are there no meetings? No annual “please can someone be the treasurer because Maureen’s kids are now in their 20s and she really wants to give up?” type things?

It's run by a few people only one of whom I believe is linked to the church and to the best of my knowledge there are no meetings and no committee.

If it’s not run by the church then there should be a committee and a constitution. There should be insurance, accounts, policies and paper trails.

If it is run by the church it may come under their policies and the likes, but there should be details on stuff.

That’s maybe why there’s no talk of accessing funding despite the deprived area - you need to have proper paperwork and setup to access the vast majority.

CraftyGin · 03/02/2022 17:11

I must have misread as I thought the post you commented on was referring to the group rather than the church.

The OP hasn’t said that the group is run by the church

The OP said the space was cost-free, so I would conclude that it's a church ministry.

NotMuchNotice · 03/02/2022 17:08

That’s interesting. Who runs it? Is it a parent or someone from the church? Are there no meetings? No annual “please can someone be the treasurer because Maureen’s kids are now in their 20s and she really wants to give up?” type things?

It's run by a few people only one of whom I believe is linked to the church and to the best of my knowledge there are no meetings and no committee.

OP posts:
ChoiceMummy · 03/02/2022 17:08

@NotMuchNotice

Whether the area is socially deprived or not doesnt effect the running costs of the group

Of course the group being in such an area doesn't affect how much it costs to run the group but it will obviously impact in how much they can reasonably charge.

The fact they have emailed to sya they have changed their minds does leave me wondering if the amount they were asking was to cover necessary costs or with a view to making a profit as like others have pointed out surely if they needed to increase the price sue to rising costs they couldn't then change their minds a few hours later? As you've said the costs are the costs.

Or it means, as often happens, that the volunteers are dipping into their own pockets and subsidising the group even more.

@NotMuchNotice I wonder how often you buy your child a snack when out or an equivalent of a Happy Meal? Does that not cost a similar amount?

Let's face it, if there was such an amazing free group that met your needs, with your sentiments, you'd be going to it surely? So this group obviously offers something that warrants the money.

But now the price is reduced, I presume that you'll be volunteering to run and steer the group in the right way, putting your money where your mouth is, so to speak?

Swipe left for the next trending thread