Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and I disagree on what to say to ds….

83 replies

TheApexOfMyLife · 03/02/2022 08:54

Ds is 18yo, in his last year of A levels.

Ds has had a gf for a while, he isn’t talking about her that much. We know about her because she a came few times, he stayed at hers a couple of time but that’s it.
DH saw ds a couple of days ago with another girl ‘being very close together’. DH is now referring to her as ‘ds second gf’.

Now, DH is furious as he basically thinks ds is cheating on his gf. That’s a sensitive subject for DH who was cheated on before and he wants to have stern words with ds…

I would say I have no idea what’s going on between ds and his (original?) gf. No idea if he is actually ‘an item’ with the girl DH saw.
If I was having a conversation, I’d go more along the lines of ‘whatever you do, please ensure that everyone knows where they stand - if you are together or not, if you are exclusive or not. And btw, please use condoms for everyone, Incl yours, safety’.
Or maybe not having any conversation at all because it’s his life….

So what would you say?
YABU: cheating is never OK. Time for really stern words with ds
YANBU: we actually have no idea what going on. A general reminder to be a decent and respectful person would be the most we should do.

OP posts:
Beamur · 03/02/2022 10:35

You can't tell him off. You don't know the facts and he's an adult.
You can have a conversation, refect what you have seen and why that concerns you and remind him to behave with integrity towards the women in his life.

gannett · 03/02/2022 10:32

Your DH doesn't know enough about the situation to jump to conclusions or fly off the handle. It'd be unreasonable to barrel in all guns blazing and wouldn't make your son amenable to listening.

But it would be reasonable to say to your DS, I saw you with another girl the other day, what's going on there? Are you still going out with Girl 1? Does she know about Girl 2?

There may be an innocent reason - he's split up with Girl 1 and didn't tell you; or he's just friends with Girl 2.

Or if he is cheating, he might try to fob you off. You can make it very clear and be very stern at that point about how much you disapprove of cheating and tell him about the harm it causes other people. You can do that "hypothetically" without necessarily accusing him of cheating - but it will make your position clear, and hopefully make him think twice about his actions.

TolkiensFallow · 03/02/2022 10:28

I think you need to establish the facts.
If the facts are that he is cheating then I do think it’s your responsibility as a parent to tell him his behaviour is unacceptable.
If it is casual and everyone is aware of the facts then that’s different.

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 03/02/2022 10:28

I don't know why the immediate response, or even the follow-up response, should be to "have a go at" him. He's an adult where you freely admit that you don't even know if he's dating the first girl still. Kindness and an open conversation with some guiding of thoughts would be best. A conversation of "How are you?", talk about something bin controversial like work, then "How are things with X?" would be a good start. If he says he's still with X or broken up, then you can ask about the new girl. If he says he's seeing both, then ask if they both know, how (not if) he's going to tell them, if he thinks it might be considered disrespectful etc.

GiantSpider · 03/02/2022 10:25

It sounds like your DH is leaping to conclusions. Maybe DS has split up with the first girl? Going in all guns blazing isn't the best way to gain your DS's trust - he'll get all defensive and I don't blame him. Try to get your DH to calm down!

NoSquirrels · 03/02/2022 10:22

Improving communication all round sounds like the right thing to do. I’d avoid your DH making judgemental assumptions or accusations- if he can’t moderate himself in the spirit of gentle enquiry it’s better you tackle it.

TheApexOfMyLife · 03/02/2022 10:20

You see I am uncomfortable with havig a go at him wo knowing all the ins and outs.
I am also keen on avoiding the judgemental route (whihc is really where DH is). Yes it is true that I have a major issue with cheating. But he is an adult. And he is still 18yo.
If it was for me, I'd say that if you are going out/having sex, then you ought to be exclusive but I am aware that not everyone thinks like this for example.

OP posts:
TheChip · 03/02/2022 08:57

I would say either option is okay.