Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Headteacher had me on loud speaker without informing me

88 replies

sparklesmakelifebetter · 02/02/2022 22:21

So my son has SEN, but is in a mainstream High School. He is massively struggling (mainly anxiety related).

I received a call out of the blue from the Principal demanding I come in for a meeting: which is essentially a pre permanent exclusion meeting. (Even though I have a meeting booked with the SENCo and behaviour lead for next week to start an EHCP process). I've never spoken to/dealt with this gentleman before, but found him rude, Anything I said I was cut off. But my biggest upset is that I have now discovered that I was on loudspeaker, in front of at least 2 other members of staff, yet he didn't mention this to me. I've sort legal advice regarding the schooling issue, but my question is:

Is it common courtesy to be told you are on loud speaker or not?

Had I known I was being listened to by others I would not have engaged in the conversation at all, saving it all for the meeting. 1 person is someone relevant to my child, the other someone unrelated to his schooling.

Yes: You are being unreasonable, you don't need to be told if you are on loudspeaker and if others are listening.

Or

No: You are NOT being unreasonable to expect to be informed you are on loudspeaker and who else is present, especially within a professional environment.

OP posts:
Nordicwannabe · 03/02/2022 09:04

My son could see and hear this conversation from another room

Like catswhiskey, I think this is far more serious than the other teachers (although other teachers was pretty poor too). Especially not telling you. It's reasonable for a parent to expect to be able to speak freely with teachers but choose a different way to frame things to a child with SEN. By not telling you your son could hear they could have damaged your relationship with your son. Do you think allowing your son to hear a phone call summoning you was s way to intimidate or bully your son?

Askingforfriend · 03/02/2022 08:45

If you are in the US, which I suspect you are, you would do well to inform the school in writing that you intend to record the meeting. I recorded IEP meetings, it wasn't because I feared being bullied (my kid's school was amazing), but because DH usually couldn't attend meetings. I had to give them notice that I was going to do it and they usually recorded too and gave me notice once I had. If there is not enough time to give notice for your state (24 hrs in mine) then that is a very valid reason to reschedule. If I felt like I was being backed into a corner I would DEFINITELY not have a meeting without recording. People can't get away with as much crap if they know there is a legal record (i.e. correct notice)

Anniegetyourgun76 · 03/02/2022 08:45

It's a breach of confidentiality and potentially runs foul of GDPR rules, I'd definitely complain, this was a private conversation and you didn't give permission for details to be disclosed to others no matter how that's done. This is no different to having a conversation with you them going to announce everything said in the staffroom, both are unacceptable breaches.

Fatmax22 · 03/02/2022 08:41

@Shuffletime

YABU to expect to be told you're on loudspeaker, simply because many school computers are set up to only have sound work through the board/big screen.

But you should 100% be told that other people were present for the meeting. That is not OK at all.

I don't know where you got this idea but I can assure you that headteachers all have access to a phone that they can use for private conversations.
Catswhisky · 03/02/2022 08:28

My son could see and hear this conversation from another room,

Your son could hear a phone call about him and they didn’t tell you he was listening. That to me is even worse than other teachers being present.

Shuffletime · 03/02/2022 08:14

@sparklesmakelifebetter

No, sorry I misunderstood and assumed zoom meeting or similar where you'd need speakers.

Phone call is a different matter. Although I still wouldn't automatically think being on loudspeaker was the issue, more that other people were present without your knowledge.

sparklesmakelifebetter · 03/02/2022 08:05

"I think the speaker phone thing is rude but compared to the fact that you think your son is about to be excluded, it is a very minor issue. Does you son want to stay at the school?"

@Grida I know you are right. The loudspeaker thing is minor in comparison to the issue itself. But it has set all sorts of alarm bells off for me. I don't trust this Headteacher now. It's one of the things I'm going to mention, but just wondered if social etiquette has changed so much that, this is acceptable practice now?

No I don't want him at the school. I requested a meeting 3 weeks ago, stating 'clearly he needs a more specialised provision, so could I have a meeting to discuss this and start the EHCP process'.

The school put in some great measures following an Educational Psychologist report. These measures have/do work, but only around 50% of his teachers follow them. The ones who follow the things put in place, have no issues with him, the ones that don't send him out of lesson daily. He suffers massively with anxiety. He has missed so much schooling from fixed term exclusions and unofficial exclusions, that he's now so far behind, he's embarrassed in each lesson.

OP posts:
sparklesmakelifebetter · 03/02/2022 07:50

@exLtEveDallas

It is common courtesy, but it is not illegal as such.

In a safeguarding capacity, We were advised to make calls to ‘tricky’ parents on loudspeaker with a witness following unfounded allegations of wrong doing/saying. Not saying that is what has happened here, just didn’t want you to go in there with wrong information.

Yes I could totally understand this, but all previous contact with others at the school has been positive. I have tried extremely hard not to be that tricky parent. But surely even in that instance you would tell the parent that x and y were present and could hear the phone call?
OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 03/02/2022 07:40

You’d surely let the parent know someone else was listening though?

exLtEveDallas · 03/02/2022 07:31

It is common courtesy, but it is not illegal as such.

In a safeguarding capacity, We were advised to make calls to ‘tricky’ parents on loudspeaker with a witness following unfounded allegations of wrong doing/saying. Not saying that is what has happened here, just didn’t want you to go in there with wrong information.

HugeAckmansWife · 03/02/2022 07:26

shuffletime that's a ridiculous point. This was a senior member of staff making the kind of phone call that would happen in an office. I've never worked in a school where it wasn't possible to have a normal phone call.

PoAhOh · 03/02/2022 07:23

I would be worried that the children can hear these conversations, if your son heard you then surely other children could too ??

So sorry are going through this Flowers

Jellycatspyjamas · 03/02/2022 07:22

You need to work with the school if you want him to stay there.

The school already know how to support him, they stopped the support and he started to struggle. I’d suggest the school needs to work with the parent rather than lying and bullying the OP.

imip · 03/02/2022 07:20

Do not home educate, do not let school force you into it. This is off rolling. If you home educate a SEN student, you are responsible for providing their special educational provision, including the cost of it. Tell school you need to postpone the meeting as you want to be supported, either by SENDIASS or a friend. Tell them that you are applying for a EHCP needs assessment as you feel that without that support his needs can’t be met. You said it yourself that when he got extra support things were ok. This shows a plan is necessary.

cansu · 03/02/2022 07:18

Getting an ehcp takes a while usually around six months from requesting the assessment. It won't have an immediate impact on his difficulties. A permanent exclusion suggests quite serious behaviour issues. You need to work with the school if you want him to stay there.

Tiramysu · 03/02/2022 07:18

You should always be told if you're on loudspeaker and who else is present

Pahahahahahahahee · 03/02/2022 07:13

It wasn't just a phone call it was a meeting. They hijacked you
Postpone the meeting as they have moved the goal posts and you now need more time to take extra advice in view of this
Do not agree to them holding the meeting without you

onlyconnect · 03/02/2022 07:11

I haven't read the whole thread but absolutely think that any time anyone is on speaker they should be told. If I pick up in the car on blue tooth, the first thing I say always is who is in the car.
Sadly though, I don't think this is the norm I see it all the time where people put calls on speaker and don't say.
I do though think you should tell that head if you can. ( sorry can't comment about the rest as haven't rtwt)

Sodthebloodypicnic · 03/02/2022 07:01

Absolutely YANBU this HT sounds like a sly fucker truing to force through exclusion before EHCP can be initiated (echo to previous posters). And has already shown he is dodgy with the speakerphone incident.

Also you are not a naughty child and don't have to jump to the headteacher calling a next day meeting. It's a deliberate tactic to outnumber you and make sure you are unprepared.

  1. Postpone the meeting until a convenient time when someone can attend with you
  2. Request an agenda and the invite list of who will be there
  3. Keep your paper trail

Best of luck op

Grida · 03/02/2022 06:45

Sorry, just seen that you were going to discuss the ehcp with the SENCo next week.

Grida · 03/02/2022 06:43

I think the speaker phone thing is rude but compared to the fact that you think your son is about to be excluded, it is a very minor issue. Does you son want to stay at the school? Do you like the school? Is it the right environment for your son? If so, go to the meeting and discuss everything that you and the school can do to keep him there. The more willing you are to work with them, the harder it will be for them to exclude him. Also, ask them if they would recommend an EHCP now.

PepInYourStep · 03/02/2022 01:46

In all honesty I’d postpone the meeting until you can have advocacy services involved particularly given you’re starting the EHCP, the school need to give reasonable notice of a meeting like that. If the HT is already being underhand I’d certainly not be attending on my own.

I also agree with this strongly and the stuff about the paper trail.

PepInYourStep · 03/02/2022 01:43

Is it common courtesy to be told you are on loud speaker or not?

IMO it's definitely common courtesy to tell someone they are on speakerphone, and also to immediately take them off it when it becomes apparent that the call requires it, or say "sorry, I'll have to ring you back" and end the call, with the explanation at the time or to follow depending on the circumstances. And ring back in the appropriate time frame of course!

If a parent is ringing about a child, then it's at least 95% certain that it will be confidential.

This headteacher seems to be very unprofessional to not have done any of those things. Disgusting, really.

mummykel16 · 03/02/2022 01:24

@sparklesmakelifebetter

So my son has SEN, but is in a mainstream High School. He is massively struggling (mainly anxiety related).

I received a call out of the blue from the Principal demanding I come in for a meeting: which is essentially a pre permanent exclusion meeting. (Even though I have a meeting booked with the SENCo and behaviour lead for next week to start an EHCP process). I've never spoken to/dealt with this gentleman before, but found him rude, Anything I said I was cut off. But my biggest upset is that I have now discovered that I was on loudspeaker, in front of at least 2 other members of staff, yet he didn't mention this to me. I've sort legal advice regarding the schooling issue, but my question is:

Is it common courtesy to be told you are on loud speaker or not?

Had I known I was being listened to by others I would not have engaged in the conversation at all, saving it all for the meeting. 1 person is someone relevant to my child, the other someone unrelated to his schooling.

Yes: You are being unreasonable, you don't need to be told if you are on loudspeaker and if others are listening.

Or

No: You are NOT being unreasonable to expect to be informed you are on loudspeaker and who else is present, especially within a professional environment.

It's sly, but not surprising. Yanbu
Imitatingdory · 03/02/2022 00:52

Don't wait to apply for an EHCNA, you can apply yourself now. IPSEA have a model letter you can use. If the LA refuse to assess appeal. The majority of appeals are upheld.

Follow up all verbal conversations with emails so you have a paper trail should you need it.
Be careful with SENDIAS, some are good, but too many are not and just repeat the LA's unlawful practices. IPSEA and SOSSEN are better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread