Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Headteacher had me on loud speaker without informing me

88 replies

sparklesmakelifebetter · 02/02/2022 22:21

So my son has SEN, but is in a mainstream High School. He is massively struggling (mainly anxiety related).

I received a call out of the blue from the Principal demanding I come in for a meeting: which is essentially a pre permanent exclusion meeting. (Even though I have a meeting booked with the SENCo and behaviour lead for next week to start an EHCP process). I've never spoken to/dealt with this gentleman before, but found him rude, Anything I said I was cut off. But my biggest upset is that I have now discovered that I was on loudspeaker, in front of at least 2 other members of staff, yet he didn't mention this to me. I've sort legal advice regarding the schooling issue, but my question is:

Is it common courtesy to be told you are on loud speaker or not?

Had I known I was being listened to by others I would not have engaged in the conversation at all, saving it all for the meeting. 1 person is someone relevant to my child, the other someone unrelated to his schooling.

Yes: You are being unreasonable, you don't need to be told if you are on loudspeaker and if others are listening.

Or

No: You are NOT being unreasonable to expect to be informed you are on loudspeaker and who else is present, especially within a professional environment.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
StickySnotBalls · 13/11/2022 09:03

PurpleButterflyWings · 12/11/2022 23:46

Why isn't the poster who keeps doing this being banned? The one who bumped this up has posted about 20 times since 9pm-ish. Surely, they should be zapped? Confused

Agree

PurpleButterflyWings · 12/11/2022 23:46

Why isn't the poster who keeps doing this being banned? The one who bumped this up has posted about 20 times since 9pm-ish. Surely, they should be zapped? Confused

LaGioconda · 12/11/2022 23:44

ZOMBIE THREAD

LaGioconda · 12/11/2022 23:43

Leafblowertime · 12/11/2022 21:27

Yeah mate that’s not your decision. I know you mean well but you don’t get to call it based on limited info;

It would be an awfully good idea to check the dates on threads before telling anyone else off for acting on limited information.

Leafblowertime · 12/11/2022 21:27

mathanxiety · 02/02/2022 22:43

YANBU.

He sounds completely unprofessional.

Your child shouldn't be in pre exclusion status. None of this should have happened.

Yeah mate that’s not your decision. I know you mean well but you don’t get to call it based on limited info;

Ukelelele · 12/11/2022 21:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

justasking111 · 04/02/2022 14:06

@wombat1a

50/50, I think 90% of calls I make today either I am on speakerphone or the other person is. It is so common that that is my expectation so I would not even think to ask/to tell the other person. WRT to others in the room, if the matter did not concern them/was private then I would say something to warn the other person so they would not say something 'in front' of the others.
Well if I worked in your office that would irritate me. Its distracting. I get it when told this call maybe monitored, but I do have some expectation of privacy otherwise
wombat1a · 04/02/2022 08:22

50/50, I think 90% of calls I make today either I am on speakerphone or the other person is. It is so common that that is my expectation so I would not even think to ask/to tell the other person. WRT to others in the room, if the matter did not concern them/was private then I would say something to warn the other person so they would not say something 'in front' of the others.

WidgetyWoo · 04/02/2022 07:34

*shouldn’t be

WidgetyWoo · 04/02/2022 07:33

@NeverDropYourMooncup - Okay, to reiterate , it isn’t everyday health information that general school staff need to know. If you’ve worked in a school, I’m concerned that you don’t understand that not all information needs to be shared

If I teaching someone, for example, I might need to know that they have PTSD. I might be made aware of a particular triggers… but I would not need to know any more detail about what had happened to them, and I wouldn’t ask.

Someone in a school might need to know about a health issue that would be treated as an emergency in school - but they would not need to read a consultants letter than has the persons medical history, and even mention of family medical history, in other to do this - although that letter might be shared with one or two staff members who needed to record diagnosis.

Can you understand that there are distinctions? This includes mental and emotional health and family relationships. If the person does not need to know the information in order to do their job then they should be given the information or present when it is being discussed.

If I’ve been privy to a conversation where someone has been discussed in front of me, which has happened frequently as many workplaces don’t train staff properly in confidentiality, or enforce it, then I leave the room.

Safeguarding does not mean open season on sharing information, it still needs to be justified.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 03/02/2022 23:02

[quote WidgetyWoo]@NeverDropYourMooncup - Nonsense. It’s nothing to do with being “lowly” and it was information that few staff need. She doesn’t need it. My child is entitled to some privacy, her health and circumstances are not up for discussion with every man and his dog.

I’ve worked in supposedly confidential services and I know that in some settings, staff get far too comfortable sharing information, with the attitude of “well,we all work here”. That is unacceptable.

Putting someone on speaker without telling them (so that they can withdraw consent if necessary) is also unacceptable.[/quote]
Why wouldn't a first aider (as it's usually the admin who have this job, as teachers aren't required to and TAs are generally actually working with their allocated children) need to know about medical conditions?

It's a damn sight easier to know that a child has diabetes before they turn up with a hypo, epilepsy before they're called to a classroom because somebody is having prolonged absences and that they have been self harming so that appearing at Reception can be discreetly handled rather than sending them back to class because they seem upset but can't tell her why because there is somebody else there.

I don't think you quite appreciate the particular nature of what goes on in schools - admin staff often know the children better, as they talk to them one on one rather than in large classes where the loudest can drown out the needs of the quieter ones. And children will often speak to them precisely because they aren't teaching staff.

It's one of the reason why admin all have to do safeguarding training just as much as the teaching staff do - they have different but equally important opportunities to see things that aren't right, whether medical, emotional or behavioural.

WidgetyWoo · 03/02/2022 22:33

@NeverDropYourMooncup - Nonsense. It’s nothing to do with being “lowly” and it was information that few staff need. She doesn’t need it. My child is entitled to some privacy, her health and circumstances are not up for discussion with every man and his dog.

I’ve worked in supposedly confidential services and I know that in some settings, staff get far too comfortable sharing information, with the attitude of “well,we all work here”. That is unacceptable.

Putting someone on speaker without telling them (so that they can withdraw consent if necessary) is also unacceptable.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 03/02/2022 21:02

@WidgetyWoo

You should know who data is being shared with a why. It’s the same as copying unnecessary people into an email

I recently had the school receptionist copied into an email regarding my daughters reduced timetable - fine, she might need to know as she is checked in late. But she doesn’t need to know details of my daughters private health details in order to do her job, and I’ll be raising it in the next meeting.

The lowly receptionist is probably the lowly first aider who looks after your child if she's ill or injured.

It might make it easier for her to do her job if she's given a clue before there's an issue.

WidgetyWoo · 03/02/2022 15:00

You should know who data is being shared with a why. It’s the same as copying unnecessary people into an email

I recently had the school receptionist copied into an email regarding my daughters reduced timetable - fine, she might need to know as she is checked in late. But she doesn’t need to know details of my daughters private health details in order to do her job, and I’ll be raising it in the next meeting.

WidgetyWoo · 03/02/2022 14:57

I’d report it as a data protection breach. Information should be shared on “a need to know” basis (did the other people in the room need to know that info to do their jobs?) and then with minimum info

justasking111 · 03/02/2022 14:15

@sparklesmakelifebetter

Thankyou to everyone who has given advice. The meeting was cancelled by my ex, as he has decided he wanted more time. So in turn I have more time to prepare now and will take all comments on board.
I'm so glad your ex backed you up on this
whywouldntyou · 03/02/2022 10:39

I can ALWAYS tell when someone puts me on speaker (I phone schools a lot) and ALWAYS call them out on it. I don't mind but it is unprofessional to do it without telling me. The call goes echoey when on speaker, but that may be because I am used to it and know what to listen out for.

CoffeeRunner · 03/02/2022 10:30

Is there not a consent issue? In that you need to be asked if you consent to the conversation taking place in front of X, Y & Z?

Admittedly I work in a different environment (healthcare) but for any meetings/appointments via phone like this we have to gain consent of the patient for X, Y & Z to be involved. I would have thought similar guidelines would apply to schools too TBH.

StationaryMagpie · 03/02/2022 10:11

@Askingforfriend

If you are in the US, which I suspect you are, you would do well to inform the school in writing that you intend to record the meeting. I recorded IEP meetings, it wasn't because I feared being bullied (my kid's school was amazing), but because DH usually couldn't attend meetings. I had to give them notice that I was going to do it and they usually recorded too and gave me notice once I had. If there is not enough time to give notice for your state (24 hrs in mine) then that is a very valid reason to reschedule. If I felt like I was being backed into a corner I would DEFINITELY not have a meeting without recording. People can't get away with as much crap if they know there is a legal record (i.e. correct notice)
She won't be in the USA if its an EHCP she's doing.
sparklesmakelifebetter · 03/02/2022 10:09

Thankyou to everyone who has given advice. The meeting was cancelled by my ex, as he has decided he wanted more time. So in turn I have more time to prepare now and will take all comments on board.

OP posts:
Imitatingdory · 03/02/2022 10:01

The EHCP process is governed by statutory timescales. Unless you have to appeal, which many parents do, the process takes a maximum of 20 weeks. If the LA fail to stick to the timescales you can begin JR proceedings - usually the threat is enough.

Don’t allow the school to unlawfully exclude DS. Refuse to pick him up unless you are given formal exclusion paperwork each and every time. How many days of FTE has DS had?

Asdf12345 · 03/02/2022 10:00

Courteous but not essential to be told would be the view in my field.

Generally at my work if someone down the food chain is making the call but with someone of significant influence/seniority listening in (usually whilst doing something else) it’s explicitly stated, if however someone fairly senior is leading the call they don’t necessarily say.

LuluBlakey1 · 03/02/2022 09:36

Just to add- an EHCP is often a long process- up to and beyond 7 months by the time the assessments ate completed and it is submitted and actually considered. Here, anyway, they are painfully slow. He is unlikely to be moved schools to specialist provision until the EHCP is in place.

If he manages in this mainstream school when teachers use the EP suggestions, he is unlikely to qualify for specialist provision - in my experience.

Harrysmummy246 · 03/02/2022 09:35

@sparklesmakelifebetter

"I think the speaker phone thing is rude but compared to the fact that you think your son is about to be excluded, it is a very minor issue. Does you son want to stay at the school?"

@Grida I know you are right. The loudspeaker thing is minor in comparison to the issue itself. But it has set all sorts of alarm bells off for me. I don't trust this Headteacher now. It's one of the things I'm going to mention, but just wondered if social etiquette has changed so much that, this is acceptable practice now?

No I don't want him at the school. I requested a meeting 3 weeks ago, stating 'clearly he needs a more specialised provision, so could I have a meeting to discuss this and start the EHCP process'.

The school put in some great measures following an Educational Psychologist report. These measures have/do work, but only around 50% of his teachers follow them. The ones who follow the things put in place, have no issues with him, the ones that don't send him out of lesson daily. He suffers massively with anxiety. He has missed so much schooling from fixed term exclusions and unofficial exclusions, that he's now so far behind, he's embarrassed in each lesson.

So you need to go in saying this. You need to be prepared to stand up for yourself in this situation if you are cut off. Take a note pad, make notes of everything said.
LuluBlakey1 · 03/02/2022 09:31

[quote mathanxiety]@Sandynorm, I disagree. She should have been told who else was privy to the call and she should have had the option of opting out if she wasn't expecting to be put on speaker or have others taking part in the conversation, even if they were just listening in.

Courtesy is a mark of respect. I is the foundation of trust and cooperation in professional discussions, and especially in discussions about sensitive matters such as the educational needs of a child.

[/quote]
This ^^

I have no idea what the behaviour issues are relating to OP's child but, whatever would be the best option for the child, can be unmanageable by a school if the behaviour is out of control. Heads have a duty of care to all students and staff and they have to balance those needs, their resources and the bigger picture with a child.

Mind you, some schools do try to move children on when there is not a need to, before an EHCP is in place, because they don't want all of the hassle that comes with managing a child likely to continue to have very challenging behaviours under the protection of an EHCP.

OP- would he do better in another school? Some schools are very nurturing places for children who have SEN, some schools are not. It often depends on the culture of the school. An individual teacher who can help, like the one you mentioned who helped your son, but a school that does not (as it sounds in this case) rarely works, precisely because of what you described- as soon as that teacher leaves the support goes too. In the best schools the support is ingrained in the culture of the school, not reliant on individuals choosing or not to behave supportively.

Swipe left for the next trending thread