Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Why didn't Mumsnet delete my post??

190 replies

Larafromthe80s · 02/02/2022 21:42

Just curious... I started a thread which detailed a lot of information about a situation I was in, thankfully I'd name changed for it!
Anyway it blew up and got picked up by a regional media outlet
I reported the thread to Mumsnet and continued to do so over the following 72 hours, as well as emailing them directly.
By this point the article was in 3 nationals and around 6 regionals

A family member screen shot the news article from his Facebook newsfeed to me saying as a joke "this isn't you isn't" as he he hadn't actually read the article, only the headline and thought it was just coincidental. And it was me 😖
I was mortified and am living in fear that the people it was about will have seen it.
Why did Mumsnet take so long to delete it, is that normal?

OP posts:
Mintine · 03/02/2022 02:08

I think if you request to take your post down, Mumsnet should be legally obliged to do so,or if not legally,then morally.
And if it's down to Mumsnet getting paid and that's why they don't,then this is absolutely appalling.
It puts me.off using it

AlternativePerspective · 03/02/2022 02:03

While i agree that mn hq have an inconsistent approach to this the reality is that if you will post identifying information on a public website then there is a chance the people you don’t want to read it will read it, even if it doesn’t get picked up by the tabloids.

You and you alone are responsible for what you put online, once you type out your life story and make it public knowledge you lose the right to control what happens to it or who reads it.

It genuinely baffles me that people compromise themselves so much and then seem to think that its someone else’s responsibility to deal with. It isn’t.

MN isn’t responsible for your safety, you are.

Marvellousmadness · 03/02/2022 02:02

Its not mumsnet fault that you made your post way too outing Confused its well known the posts from here end up on other media outlets.
Bit silly on your part really. Only yourself yo blame in this situation op

Migrainesbythedozen · 03/02/2022 02:02

Why doesn't Mumsnet employ Caveat Emptor. I think that you really need to think carefully before posting on here, and if you take the risk, and your thread is picked up by the media and is identifiable - TOO BAD. You made the choice to post. Everyone knows there is a chance their thread couple be picked up. Ffs, everyone knows that! So don't post unless you are prepared to accept that. People put time and effort into responding, and the OP, who made the choice to post, knowing the risks, then decides to whinge and get the thread deleted. It's immature. Post knowing the risks, or don't post at all. There should be absolutely no thread deletions just because the OP 'changed their mind'. I am so bloody sick of this. You take the risks, and that's that.

Ellowyn · 03/02/2022 01:57

@Larafromthe80s

Just curious... I started a thread which detailed a lot of information about a situation I was in, thankfully I'd name changed for it! Anyway it blew up and got picked up by a regional media outlet I reported the thread to Mumsnet and continued to do so over the following 72 hours, as well as emailing them directly. By this point the article was in 3 nationals and around 6 regionals A family member screen shot the news article from his Facebook newsfeed to me saying as a joke "this isn't you isn't" as he he hadn't actually read the article, only the headline and thought it was just coincidental. And it was me 😖 I was mortified and am living in fear that the people it was about will have seen it. Why did Mumsnet take so long to delete it, is that normal?
Mumsnet gets a lot of free publicity/traffic to this site when they exploit their contributors this way. If they didn't want this to happen they would copyright everything.

I'm sorry this happened to you.

CatNameChange101 · 03/02/2022 01:41

I don't know whether posting stuff here counts as identifiable for the purposes of GDPR

It doesn’t Smile

runningoutofnewnames · 03/02/2022 01:40

Caveat - that MN is considered publishers doesn't mean we're NOT responsible for our words here (before anyone takes what I said to mean you won't get in trouble for being libellous! You could well, it's just MN would get in trouble too)

runningoutofnewnames · 03/02/2022 01:38

@CatNameChange101

She posted identifiable information online. That is not Mumsnet breaching GDPR… They have done nothing to make her identifiable, OP did that on her own.
Mumsnet are considered the publishers of our words, in law. It doesn't matter that we write them. Mumsnet still publishes them on the web, and continues to publish them as long as the content is live.

If any of us write something libellous here, for example, Mumsnet is responsible for it in the eyes of the law, in the same way as a news website would be for publishing what people say. Gina Ford used this to her advantage when she didn't like what people here were writing about her. She threatened to hold Mumsnet responsible.

I don't know whether posting stuff here counts as identifiable for the purposes of GDPR as I don't know enough about GDPR - but I do know that it's wrong to say that because we write the content that MN isn't responsible for it - they are.

Ozanj · 03/02/2022 01:05

I think the posters who get deleted within 20mins ‘because of x y z) are fake articles. The ones posted by real people make them money so they don’t like to delete them.

UniversalAunt · 03/02/2022 01:01

‘ I learnt years ago that if you wouldn’t post it with your full name, don’t post it.’

Good advice.
Also, don’t write anything in an email about someone that you would not say to their face. Once such an email is sent, it is beyond your control & can be shared.

CatNameChange101 · 03/02/2022 01:00

Monopoly the issue is several others who ‘know about’ GDPR have disputed what you have said, and held similar reasoning for saying it was nonsense. You have back-pedalled not very well and are now just digging your heels in.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 00:53

@phishy This is a public chat forum. Of course I don't write here as I would at work. You want me to post an executive summary of my recommendations?
It is simply a chat forum.
I never said I was a lawyer.
I do know about GDPR and it irritates me to see people who obviously don't understand GDPR legislation telling me I am wrong.
But it is simply a chat forum. I am not posting in the manner I would for an employer and it is bizarre for you to think I would.

CatNameChange101 · 03/02/2022 00:48

Yep. Precisely.

phishy · 03/02/2022 00:43

@CatNameChange101

So why did you say ‘under GDPR they have to delete’?
She’s clearly not a lawyer, no lawyer I know would make that statement without being able to back it up. And then backtrack to say that by ‘they have to delete’ she actually meant she would advise deleting.

That kind of wishy washy advice would make everyone doubt her at my company.

musicviking1 · 03/02/2022 00:37

I'd never post about my life on MN I read and sometimes reply to something but that's about as far as I will go. The cookie permissions on this forum alone tells me this site loves to sell my data so no way would I post my life story here for that to be sold too.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 00:36

I have explained above.

CatNameChange101 · 03/02/2022 00:31

So why did you say ‘under GDPR they have to delete’?

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 00:28

@phishy I am explaining in some detail the actual legal position. I am clarifying the situation.
When I have written GDPR policies I would have advised deleting as the legislation suggests strongly that forums do apply.
But as I said until there is case law no one can be 100% sure. That is how legislation works. Unless the legislation or case law relates to your specific situation, then it is always a matter of legal opinion.

Hawkins001 · 03/02/2022 00:27

@Larafromthe80s

Well... lesson learned. Thanks for the insight and I guess it makes sense about driving traffic. I doubt I'll ever post asking for advice, giving the level of information I did again. I'm pretty convinced those spoken about must have seen it, the only good thing is that the comments on the Facebook posts of the papers were 99% in my favour but even so, I really didn't want people seeing my posts that publicly 😪
I understand your perspectives, but tis a public site, yes I guess there's public, then theirs the m,s,m so to speak.
Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 00:24

@CatJumperTwat No, you are wrong. In spite of your insults, I do know about GDPR. You have not even bothered engaging with the points I have made.
There has been little understanding of what counts as personal data. For example, the comment that it only applies to specific information such as names, addresses and NI numbers. That shows a lack of understanding of the legislation. There is a legal definition of personal data and it is far wider than some on this thread appear to understand.

breakdown19 · 03/02/2022 00:23

I am surprised at MnHq.
The mods in the old days were compassionate and would join in occasionally with the odd thread
And would def delete something like this
Sorry you have been outed locally Op:

phishy · 03/02/2022 00:22

But you said ‘they gave to delete it’, @Monopolyiscrap

Are you backtracking?

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 00:21

@CatNameChange101 I was explaining in detail what the legislation actually says. It is safer to delete threads on request with identifying information as GDPR legislation appears to cover forums.
But only a court case would clarify for sure if it did apply.

This is not an unusual situation. Most legislation is clarified through court cases leading to case law.

CatJumperTwat · 03/02/2022 00:19

Bloody hell Monopolyiscrap just admit you don't know a thing about GDPR and stop digging!

CatNameChange101 · 03/02/2022 00:13

Monopoly you clearly have no idea what you’re talking about. You’ve gone from saying ‘under GDPR they have to delete’ to ‘it’s based on individuals legal opinions. There’s no definitive yes or no answer.’ I’m quite lost on what your actual point is now, other than just being contrary.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread