Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Why didn't Mumsnet delete my post??

190 replies

Larafromthe80s · 02/02/2022 21:42

Just curious... I started a thread which detailed a lot of information about a situation I was in, thankfully I'd name changed for it!
Anyway it blew up and got picked up by a regional media outlet
I reported the thread to Mumsnet and continued to do so over the following 72 hours, as well as emailing them directly.
By this point the article was in 3 nationals and around 6 regionals

A family member screen shot the news article from his Facebook newsfeed to me saying as a joke "this isn't you isn't" as he he hadn't actually read the article, only the headline and thought it was just coincidental. And it was me 😖
I was mortified and am living in fear that the people it was about will have seen it.
Why did Mumsnet take so long to delete it, is that normal?

OP posts:
Lampshading · 03/02/2022 08:44

If a poster puts down information they later realise is capable of being used to identify them (and GDPR is clear this can relate to any information), and Mumsnet is a processor of that information under GDPR, do they not have a right under GDPR to withdraw their consent to the processing of that information and request its removal ?

No...

suggestionsplease1 · 03/02/2022 08:42

[quote girlmom21]@Monopolyiscrap you've never written a GDPR policy in your life and if you have I'd strongly recommend the company gets a new one written. [/quote]
I don't know why this poster is coming in for all these personal attacks when nobody has put forward a credible rebuff of what they are saying..

Can you explain...

If a poster puts down information they later realise is capable of being used to identify them (and GDPR is clear this can relate to any information), and Mumsnet is a processor of that information under GDPR, do they not have a right under GDPR to withdraw their consent to the processing of that information and request its removal ?

If not, why not?

AlternativePerspective · 03/02/2022 08:39

Anyone who isn’t aware that posting on an Internet forum is putting their story out there in the public domain shouldn’t be posting on the internet.

Whether it’s the tabloids or not is irrelevant. MN is already a public platform, you lose control over who reads it the instant you post it. Even if it isn’t picked up by the tabloids.

It’s little wonder that so many children fall victim to grooming and bullying online when adults seem to be completely oblivious to how the internet actually works.

Also, people need to stop kidding themselves that mn is all about support. MN may be by parents for parents but mn is predominantly a chat forum which happens to contain some postings where people receive support.

There’s a reason why AIBU is the top visited board here and a reason why mn promote this fact. They want to encourage chat, lively discussion, disagreement, debate, and sometimes that means that people will post their personal stories and may or may not receive support, although the former is definitely not a given.

MN want this to be a chat forum not a support forum. Anyone who thinks otherwise is kidding themselves.

Sparklingbrook · 03/02/2022 08:27

And so? If it's important to them that others read their story, they can always post their own thread

It's not 'important that others read their story' they are trying to help the OP and others by sharing it.
So you are saying if you see a thread where you have direct experience of the problem you shouldn't comment on it and try and help the OP, but start your own thread about it instead? Right. Confused

ludocris · 03/02/2022 08:23

@Sparklingbrook

This crap about 'people taking time and effort to respond' is utter bullshit. MN isn't your personal file storage system

In many cases when the topic has been sensitive posters have poured their hearts out with their own upsetting experience which they thought might help the poster, plus others going through the same. Then the whole thing gets deleted, leaving everyone unable to see it.

And so? If it's important to them that others read their story, they can always post their own thread.
girlmom21 · 03/02/2022 08:21

@Monopolyiscrap you've never written a GDPR policy in your life and if you have I'd strongly recommend the company gets a new one written.

Sparklingbrook · 03/02/2022 08:16

This crap about 'people taking time and effort to respond' is utter bullshit. MN isn't your personal file storage system

In many cases when the topic has been sensitive posters have poured their hearts out with their own upsetting experience which they thought might help the poster, plus others going through the same. Then the whole thing gets deleted, leaving everyone unable to see it.

Kennykenkencat · 03/02/2022 08:12

@Migrainesbythedozen

Why doesn't Mumsnet employ Caveat Emptor. I think that you really need to think carefully before posting on here, and if you take the risk, and your thread is picked up by the media and is identifiable - TOO BAD. You made the choice to post. Everyone knows there is a chance their thread couple be picked up. Ffs, everyone knows that! So don't post unless you are prepared to accept that. People put time and effort into responding, and the OP, who made the choice to post, knowing the risks, then decides to whinge and get the thread deleted. It's immature. Post knowing the risks, or don't post at all. There should be absolutely no thread deletions just because the OP 'changed their mind'. I am so bloody sick of this. You take the risks, and that's that.
Why don’t journalists do their job and check sources before filling up their “news” media with what could be (and in some cases probably is) pure fiction.

Buyers of news media should be aware that the news seems to be somewhere between pure fiction and someone’s opinion on how they want the general population to think.

Take away the copy and paste SM content and their is very little news left

ludocris · 03/02/2022 08:08

@Migrainesbythedozen

Why doesn't Mumsnet employ Caveat Emptor. I think that you really need to think carefully before posting on here, and if you take the risk, and your thread is picked up by the media and is identifiable - TOO BAD. You made the choice to post. Everyone knows there is a chance their thread couple be picked up. Ffs, everyone knows that! So don't post unless you are prepared to accept that. People put time and effort into responding, and the OP, who made the choice to post, knowing the risks, then decides to whinge and get the thread deleted. It's immature. Post knowing the risks, or don't post at all. There should be absolutely no thread deletions just because the OP 'changed their mind'. I am so bloody sick of this. You take the risks, and that's that.
This just about summarises what's wrong with MN today. What sort of an attitude is this?? How about people posting for the first time, who haven't seen this miserable business of threads being picked up by lowlife newspapers? How about people posting in desperation because they need urgent advice to escape a DV situation? People who are mentally unwell or under the influence and post too much info? How about a little bit of fucking empathy?

This crap about 'people taking time and effort to respond' is utter bullshit. MN isn't your personal file storage system. If what you are posting is so profound and enlightening, perhaps keep your own record, so you have all of your heartfelt advice safely archived.

As if anyone needed reminding, MN is supposed to be a forum for parents, by parents, to offer support and guidance. I think what you're looking for is the online equivalent of a gladiator's arena.

suggestionsplease1 · 03/02/2022 08:01

@CatNameChange101

I don't know whether posting stuff here counts as identifiable for the purposes of GDPR

It doesn’t Smile

Can you explain this further please?

If a poster puts down information they later realise is capable of being used to identify them (and GDPR is clear this can relate to any information), and Mumsnet is a processor of that information under GDPR, do they not have a right under GDPR to withdraw their consent to the processing of that information and request its removal ?

If not, why not?

Sparklingbrook · 03/02/2022 07:56

A lot of threads about celebrities are pulled because they're not in the spirit. Stacey Solomon and Adele being recent ones.
Why do people want to come on here to criticise Meghan Markle in particular? Confused

cakeambush · 03/02/2022 07:45

@caringcarer

If you want something removed instantly just have a little moan about Meghan Markle and it will be taken down in a flash.
I was going to say the same thing! No criticism of her allowed here - it's the one thing guaranteed to get a thread pulled.
Lampshading · 03/02/2022 07:43

@BrambleRoses

It’s far too simplistic to say people ‘shouldn’t’ post, or only post within the exact perimeters of what certain posters deem acceptable.

I think one of the problems is that you can be pushed into giving out more information than you want - some posters can be very demanding and you also can be subjected to a certain amount of ridicule either for name changing or for refusing to give our certain pieces of information. That’s often by the same sorts of posters who are here ridiculing people for giving out personal info. Funny, that.

Well it's not about the parameters of what other posters feel is acceptable, but should be within the parameters of what you, yourself feels you'd be happy with absolutely anyone knowing- including potentially those involved.

That's true, but it's a messageboard and if you feel you cant say no that detail isn't needed or not happy to share that then perhaps it's not the place for you. Self responsibility should still be a thing. Mumsnet needs to make money to survive, to do that it needs posters, if people keep posting and threads get deleted all of the time they'll find somewhere else. Perhaps like children now have Internet safety lessons some adults would benefit too

marqueses · 03/02/2022 07:40

Tbf though @runningoutofnewnames if you aren't aware that msm and other websites trawl the internet for click-baity content from other sites then maybe you shouldn't be posting such personal information if you're new to the internet

runningoutofnewnames · 03/02/2022 07:34

@Migrainesbythedozen

Why doesn't Mumsnet employ Caveat Emptor. I think that you really need to think carefully before posting on here, and if you take the risk, and your thread is picked up by the media and is identifiable - TOO BAD. You made the choice to post. Everyone knows there is a chance their thread couple be picked up. Ffs, everyone knows that! So don't post unless you are prepared to accept that. People put time and effort into responding, and the OP, who made the choice to post, knowing the risks, then decides to whinge and get the thread deleted. It's immature. Post knowing the risks, or don't post at all. There should be absolutely no thread deletions just because the OP 'changed their mind'. I am so bloody sick of this. You take the risks, and that's that.
That's pretty much how it used to be. MN have moved away from that because, thankfully, they're human and felt compassion for those with good reason for posts to be deleted.

MN's MO is to help make parents lives easier, not fuck them up.

And no, not everyone knows the Daily Mail trawls this site for stories, what a nasty attitude.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 03/02/2022 07:27

I posted a thread about a personal and potentially identifying situation a few weeks ago which made the top of the ‘trending now’ section of the website. It was very outing and I hadn’t thought to name change so was worried about it being picked up by the press someone in real life seeing it and being able to search through my past posts. The thread was deleted within about fifteen minutes of me reporting it and asking for it to be removed even though it had plenty of replies. I assumed this was standard but maybe not.

AlternativePerspective · 03/02/2022 07:17

It’s far too simplistic to say people ‘shouldn’t’ post, or only post within the exact perimeters of what certain posters deem acceptable not really.

Posters seem to be under the misilusion that they’re posting in a “safe space” when actually they’re doing nothing of the sort.

Even if your thread isn’t picked up by the tabloids it’s still in the public domain with potentially publicly identifiable information on it if you so choose to share it.

People give far too much credibility to the press when they say that mn should be deleting posts, yet there are examples of people whose posts have been recognised by someone they know reading them on here.

Essentially, posting on mn is like standing blindfold in the street and preaching your personal business to the passers by. You have no idea who they are, but they can see who you are. If you wouldn’t be comfortable doing that in the street then you shouldn’t be doing it on a public website.

Sparklingbrook · 03/02/2022 07:11

It’s far too simplistic to say people ‘shouldn’t’ post, or only post within the exact perimeters of what certain posters deem acceptable

It’s not about what certain posters deem acceptable though. It’s about posting stuff that posters then regret and want deleting. Very often after posters have spent time commenting and trying to help.

BrambleRoses · 03/02/2022 06:58

It’s far too simplistic to say people ‘shouldn’t’ post, or only post within the exact perimeters of what certain posters deem acceptable.

I think one of the problems is that you can be pushed into giving out more information than you want - some posters can be very demanding and you also can be subjected to a certain amount of ridicule either for name changing or for refusing to give our certain pieces of information. That’s often by the same sorts of posters who are here ridiculing people for giving out personal info. Funny, that.

Sparklingbrook · 03/02/2022 06:49

The criticism of both Meghan Markle and the McCanns on here has been disgusting so I can’t blame MNHQ for not wanting those threads up.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 03/02/2022 03:33

@caringcarer

If you want something removed instantly just have a little moan about Meghan Markle and it will be taken down in a flash.
or criticise the McCanns
HoppingPavlova · 03/02/2022 03:29

I think if you request to take your post down, Mumsnet should be legally obliged to do so,or if not legally,then morally.

The problem there is they would essentially have an empty site. AIBU wouldn’t exist as OP would post, everyone responds ‘yes you are, very much so’, OP says ‘I don’t agree with you all’, then asks for the thread to be deleted simply because they didn’t get the echo chamber they wanted.

Or, OP comes on and says ‘my neighbours butchers aunts therapists cousin feels the cold at 25deg, always has the heating on and moans about the bill - aren’t they being unreasonable. Then comes back and asks for it to be deleted because they believe that will completely identify ??? I’ve seen that on situations which people believe are unique yet could literally apply to 25% of the population.

The end result would be a site with no visitors as there is no point, 90% if threads would be deleted within hours of anyone posting, so seems pointless reading or commenting. Limited traffic to site = greatly decreased revenue = site closing down.

Kennykenkencat · 03/02/2022 02:51

Newspapers pick up articles from here all the time, it's shit that they do but it's a risk we all take when posting on public forums

I always thought journalists were supposed to check their sources before “going to print”

Anyone could make up complete BS and it gets printed in a national newspaper as truth.
Why bother doing a degree in journalism if all you are going to produce is copied and pasted fiction and comments from SM.

Utterly bizarre they do this as if anything badly affects someone’s mental or physical health If they aren’t careful there could be blood on their hands and a court case to defend.

KangSaeByeok · 03/02/2022 02:33

Only on Mumsnet could you have a thread descend into who knows more about GDPR 🤣

Flutterflybutterby · 03/02/2022 02:32

They were really lovely and understanding when it happened to me. Deleted immediately, helped change name on old posts, etc. Honestly really great. I guess it depends who receives your message maybe??

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread