Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Why didn't Mumsnet delete my post??

190 replies

Larafromthe80s · 02/02/2022 21:42

Just curious... I started a thread which detailed a lot of information about a situation I was in, thankfully I'd name changed for it!
Anyway it blew up and got picked up by a regional media outlet
I reported the thread to Mumsnet and continued to do so over the following 72 hours, as well as emailing them directly.
By this point the article was in 3 nationals and around 6 regionals

A family member screen shot the news article from his Facebook newsfeed to me saying as a joke "this isn't you isn't" as he he hadn't actually read the article, only the headline and thought it was just coincidental. And it was me 😖
I was mortified and am living in fear that the people it was about will have seen it.
Why did Mumsnet take so long to delete it, is that normal?

OP posts:
ResilienceWanker · 03/02/2022 13:44

Ah, I didn't realise you could delete tweets yourself Blush don't use it other than to complain to the council about missed bins Yes, fair enough.

I've had MN posts deleted, but it does sound a bit of a lottery. I've seen people saying "I'll put up a photo and then get MN to take it down in 15 min" which seems especially risky if it's not a given it will be/ has to be removed upon request! But then I suppose those aren't the kind of posts/ threads that people visit the site to see.

Maybe I should just add a fuck to the end of every post I make to have a sort of integrated self destruct button through guaranteed reports. Though I could see that getting me banned pretty quickly.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 12:32

Twitter does allow you to delete your own posts, so probably do comply with GDPR.
The fact that people copy the tweets just shows how difficult it is to erase something once it has been made public.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 12:30

@ResilienceWanker which is why I think MN do delete posts when an OP says it has become identifying towards them. But MNHQ does appear to delay deleting a post when it is getting them publicity.
But yes the cost of proving this suspicion and taking them to court is beyond most of its users.

ResilienceWanker · 03/02/2022 11:42

[quote Monopolyiscrap]@ResilienceWanker that is a really thoughtful post.
There is in journalism legally a test as to whether a story is in the public interest. This is frequently tested in court when famous people seek court injunctions or sue over published stories. What is in the public interest is a complex legal question.
But I would be hard-pressed to see why a stranger unknown to the public, writing about a personal family issue, would meet the test of a public interest issue.[/quote]
Exactly monopolyiscrap (I agree, it really is crap Grin). They will obviously argue that there is public interest, as the public IS interested in it because they are clicking and engaging. And in terms of libel or invasion of privacy or whatever, I'd think we would be unlikely to succeed - mainly because, as many others have said, we've put our story in the public domain - but also are very unlikely to have the knowledge or finances to challenge the paper on those grounds in court!! They may also argue that while the data is personal, its not identifying (apart from to anyone who knows the situation personally - who would already have reached a conclusion as to who was unreasonable or whatever) so you're not suffering any financial or reputation loss as a result... blah, blah... As I think the bar in those kind of cases is different.

But if they are considered to be processing your personal data (as suggestions suggests, even if that is converting the forum post on MN to a newspaper article) then why aren't they bound by the obligation of "subject access requests" etc and people having the right to ask for removal of that data, which I think is a Thing?

I've had an article about me in a paper that I would rather have not been there (there, that's a piece of personal information right there...). It caused a lot of problems, and most of what it said was untrue. The journalist contacted me beforehand and asked for comments, but my employer didn't let me say anything and produced a statement to give to the journalist without my input. The whole thing felt really unfair (and indeed was!) and it was pre GDPR anyway. I weathered the shit show over the following week or so, and then got on with life. I'm not ashamed of it and am happy to talk about it to anyone who's interested (and many who aren't Grin). I was and am angry at the journalist, but his argument would have been it was in the public interest so the fact he used my personal data without my consent was irrelevant. The fact his interpretation of public interest was due to him ascribing incorrect motive/ interpretation to that personal data is what pissed me off. But hey... these things happen, and I wasn't able to set the record straight/ put my side across even though that was offered to me, as I was scared of my employer and didn't want to make things inadvertantly worse for me or anyone.

I suppose the whole thing is similar to journalists digging round to find old tweets from celebrities expressing "unacceptable" opinions, and using that against them years later... It's their personal data, but used in the "public interest" to discredit them. I appreciate it may not be a GDPR issue (partly as they hadn't asked for the incriminating evidence to be removed from twitter or wherever so the platform still had their consent to process it in that way), but I can't quite see how not!

But in my case I'm reeeeeaaaallly not a celebrity, and also hadn't done or said anything unacceptable Halo so public interest in the situation shouldn't have extended to public interest in me iyswim. Similarly posters who end up in the DM - they haven't done anything wrong by posting, or indeed in their situation (necessarily GrinWink), but people ascribe intentions and motives and whatnot to them that they lose control over, which is why it can feel so painful, especially if they can be recognised personally- so Flowers to the OP.

ludocris · 03/02/2022 11:01

@Sparklingbrook

Well then it doesn't really matter, does it? If they're not bothered enough to post their own thread, then how much are they going to care that their post was deleted from someone else's thread?

That makes no sense.

Are you quite alright? What's difficult to understand? You suggested people might be put out that they had shared their experiences on a thread which then gets deleted. I said 'that's OK, they can post their own thread'. You said 'they're unlikely to do that'. I said well then what's the issue? If they want to 'pour out their heart' on MN they can do so on their own thread. If they're not inclined to do so, they're obviously not that bothered.
Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 10:07

@ResilienceWanker that is a really thoughtful post.
There is in journalism legally a test as to whether a story is in the public interest. This is frequently tested in court when famous people seek court injunctions or sue over published stories. What is in the public interest is a complex legal question.
But I would be hard-pressed to see why a stranger unknown to the public, writing about a personal family issue, would meet the test of a public interest issue.

suggestionsplease1 · 03/02/2022 10:06

@ResilienceWanker

The whole question of GDPR/ personal data is interesting. I know nothing about it in legal terms, but in general terms, surely anything you post relating to you/your life is indeed personal data. It may not be recognisable to anyone who doesn't know you, or even lots of people who do, but it is still personal data. It may become more identifying paired with other things posted on separate threads under the same username of course, and that could provide a fair amount of information about you that you may be unhappy to remain in the public domain, even though you posted it in the first place. Yes, it's your own mistake, but it is understandable that you may not appreciate at the time and want to remove some of that personal data from the public record.

At least one journalist has been jailed for publishing a series of "hints" about individuals whose identities were protected. I didn't know these individuals and didn't even know of them other than in the context that was being written about, but it was clear to me that the journalist was publishing sufficient "personal information" about them that was easily confirmed by other sources, so I was able to identify them as individuals. (of course, without the media attention on this issue I wouldn't have known and wouldn't have identified them... but that's by the by) This wasn't a GDPR issue - rather a contempt of court one - but it does prove that personal information isn't limited to name/ dob etc in order to be recognisable.

I "willingly" give my personal data to sign up to marketing emails and so on, to get discounts - but am entitled to withdraw my consent from that at any time. And the company processing that data has to remove me from their list. That isn't public data, admittedly, but even if I agreed to make my name available on a list on a website as a condition, and then withdrew consent for that - while I couldn't stop anyone copying or anything while it was still available (fair enough) - I would expect it to be removed if I asked for it.

I'm not clear though whether MN is "processing" that personal data in GDPR terms - publishing it, definitely. Or indeed whether the DM is also therefore processing your personal data even if you didn't give it to them willingly. Otherwise anyone could write to a newspaper with a story they didn't like about them and get it removed on the grounds they are using personal data without consent! There must be a "public interest" (or journalism? ) exclusion to GDPR in that case - if it is even relevant. And MN would also fall under that too, I'd have thought, even though it's a different model. Though I'd have hoped, in good faith, they WOULD remove a post that I'd asked them to... albeit maybe not a whole thread, unless that thread would be unreadable as a result!

My understanding is that 'processing' under GDPR can be very minimal...Mumsnet converting your typed words into a forum post is processing.
username103842 · 03/02/2022 10:06

I hate that the media take stories from MNs OP. It is really lazy journalism. You have my sympathy. I have often wanted to ask for advice/get objective opinions but I'm too scared to post because of it. I think family/friends often take your side so sites like Mumsnet can be good to get a better perspective.

ResilienceWanker · 03/02/2022 10:01

The whole question of GDPR/ personal data is interesting. I know nothing about it in legal terms, but in general terms, surely anything you post relating to you/your life is indeed personal data. It may not be recognisable to anyone who doesn't know you, or even lots of people who do, but it is still personal data. It may become more identifying paired with other things posted on separate threads under the same username of course, and that could provide a fair amount of information about you that you may be unhappy to remain in the public domain, even though you posted it in the first place. Yes, it's your own mistake, but it is understandable that you may not appreciate at the time and want to remove some of that personal data from the public record.

At least one journalist has been jailed for publishing a series of "hints" about individuals whose identities were protected. I didn't know these individuals and didn't even know of them other than in the context that was being written about, but it was clear to me that the journalist was publishing sufficient "personal information" about them that was easily confirmed by other sources, so I was able to identify them as individuals. (of course, without the media attention on this issue I wouldn't have known and wouldn't have identified them... but that's by the by) This wasn't a GDPR issue - rather a contempt of court one - but it does prove that personal information isn't limited to name/ dob etc in order to be recognisable.

I "willingly" give my personal data to sign up to marketing emails and so on, to get discounts - but am entitled to withdraw my consent from that at any time. And the company processing that data has to remove me from their list. That isn't public data, admittedly, but even if I agreed to make my name available on a list on a website as a condition, and then withdrew consent for that - while I couldn't stop anyone copying or anything while it was still available (fair enough) - I would expect it to be removed if I asked for it.

I'm not clear though whether MN is "processing" that personal data in GDPR terms - publishing it, definitely. Or indeed whether the DM is also therefore processing your personal data even if you didn't give it to them willingly. Otherwise anyone could write to a newspaper with a story they didn't like about them and get it removed on the grounds they are using personal data without consent! There must be a "public interest" (or journalism? ) exclusion to GDPR in that case - if it is even relevant. And MN would also fall under that too, I'd have thought, even though it's a different model. Though I'd have hoped, in good faith, they WOULD remove a post that I'd asked them to... albeit maybe not a whole thread, unless that thread would be unreadable as a result!

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 09:50

@MorningStarling

On the issue at hand, try to think of whatever you write online as being the same as if it were printed in a newspaper or book. Once it's printed and distributed, there's usually no way of recalling it. Especially once copies have been sold.

The difference with writing online is that it's distributed to the public immediately.

That is not true. Books are recalled and pulped after court cases. It may be relatively rare, but it happens. It is true that whatever the law, once something is out there, it is very difficult in practice to stop it from spreading. Look at super injunctions taken out in Britain to stop media publishing details of something e.g. affair. Usually if there is interest, foreign press just publish it instead. And then it ends up on social media. Trying to play whack a mole with multiple social media platforms is a herculean task. So legally the British public should not be able to read about something, but making that happen in practice is almost impossible if there is enough public interest.
Sparklingbrook · 03/02/2022 09:48

Well then it doesn't really matter, does it? If they're not bothered enough to post their own thread, then how much are they going to care that their post was deleted from someone else's thread?

That makes no sense.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 09:46

Those posting saying GDPR does not apply are like those people who said that Ring doorbells which store images are not covered by GDPR. They are commenting based on what they want the law to be. I remember before this court case multiple people on MN said of course GDPR does not apply as anyone should expect to be filmed in public.

Ring doorbells are a good comparison. Under GDPR CCTV is explicitly covered, but RING doorbells are not. But they are not explicitly excluded either. But like CCTV they record and usually store personal images on public property, so could reasonably be expected to be included. However, only a court case could make that explicit. And a court case has said they are covered, so that is now case law.

Forums are not explicitly mentioned in GDPR legislation, but the identifiable personal information that some people post clearly meets the definition under the act. And MN is clearly the processor of that information. So I don't see how it couldn't apply.

You may think it shouldn't apply because the person themselves is posting that information, but that is not how GDPR works. People can withdraw consent for information freely given in most circumstances.

MorningStarling · 03/02/2022 09:38

On the issue at hand, try to think of whatever you write online as being the same as if it were printed in a newspaper or book. Once it's printed and distributed, there's usually no way of recalling it. Especially once copies have been sold.

The difference with writing online is that it's distributed to the public immediately.

MorningStarling · 03/02/2022 09:36

CaroleFuckingBaskin:
They probably get paid for a thread....
marqueses:
Paid by whom?
Why would anyone pay to post a link to a free website?

Advertisers. Every time someone loads up a page, adverts are loaded too. Every ad loaded, every click on an ad, every purchase on an ad generates revenue. A tiny amount, but tiny amounts add up.

ludocris · 03/02/2022 09:32

@Sparklingbrook

Erm...no. I'm saying if they get upset that it's going to be deleted if the whole thread gets deleted, THEN they can start their own thread about their experiences if they so desire

Erm well they could I suppose but if they were specifically posting to help someone it’s unlikely. 🤷‍♀️

Well then it doesn't really matter, does it? If they're not bothered enough to post their own thread, then how much are they going to care that their post was deleted from someone else's thread?

It's a pretty weak argument against deleting threads...

Hshuznw · 03/02/2022 09:29

@Sparklingbrook

This crap about 'people taking time and effort to respond' is utter bullshit. MN isn't your personal file storage system

In many cases when the topic has been sensitive posters have poured their hearts out with their own upsetting experience which they thought might help the poster, plus others going through the same. Then the whole thing gets deleted, leaving everyone unable to see it.

That was my thread. Mine turned from asking an AIBU about an incident to one where posters were being really supportive and some were pouring their hearts out. But once the DM picked it up, I had to ask for it to be deleted because I didn’t want anyone I knew in real life to know my personal past. I felt terrible, as some posters were amazing, and I didn’t even have a chance to thank them before bringing it down as in the short time it was up in the DM, I had been identified by two people in real life who then came here and learnt things about me I wish they didn’t.

I still wish I could remember those posters names to thank them for their support.

runningoutofnewnames · 03/02/2022 09:14

[quote girlmom21]@suggestionsplease1 Mumsnet aren't sharing any personal data. They're an anonymous forum.[/quote]
Legally, Mumsnet are considered a publisher of the words we write here., in the same way a news site is responsible for what its journalists write and it publishes.

It doesn't matter that they're not moderating each of our comments. They host the website and publish our words. Whether they choose to check them or not is their choice. It doesn't change the fact that they're - legally - the publisher.

If someone posts personal information in a post, then Mumsnet have. effectively, published that data and are responsible for it.

This is the case for libel law. (If we say something dodgy, MN are responsible for it as well as us).

I don't know how it works wrt GDPR law, but taking an apparent common sense approach of "well they're not responsible for what we write" may not be applicable when you're getting into legal responsibility.

Sparklingbrook · 03/02/2022 09:08

Apparently it doesn't matter about the T&Cs because nobody ever reads them when they join.

suggestionsplease1 · 03/02/2022 09:05

[quote girlmom21]@suggestionsplease1 Mumsnet aren't sharing any personal data. They're an anonymous forum.[/quote]
They are processors of information under GDPR, are they not?

The terms and conditions referred to do not conflict with my statement, which was about the right of an individual, under GDPR, to withdraw their consent to the processing of personal information and request its removal.

Those T&C's are a reasonable warning to people but they don't negate a processor of information's obligations under GDPR to comply with a request to stop processing it and remove it (as long as it has come to their attention and within a reasonable timeframe, I imagine).

Sparklingbrook · 03/02/2022 08:59

Erm...no. I'm saying if they get upset that it's going to be deleted if the whole thread gets deleted, THEN they can start their own thread about their experiences if they so desire

Erm well they could I suppose but if they were specifically posting to help someone it’s unlikely. 🤷‍♀️

SusannaQueen · 03/02/2022 08:58

I once posted a picture of my lunch out, instead of my Docs (boots), I asked for the pic to be deleted and it was within minutes, and they sent me a lovely email reply. I think it probably depends on who is moderating and how many are on duty at any time. Obvious things like Megan posts will be picked up by filters and moderated quickly.

Why doesn't Mumsnet employ Caveat Emptor. I think that you really need to think carefully before posting on here

Part of the problem is some posters don't realise it's possible to trawl through their post history and other posters do this gleefully. So whilst the OP might think they haven't given too much away, someone else will link other info which makes it identifying. This sometimes happens even if you name change.

NerrSnerr · 03/02/2022 08:57

Why don’t journalists do their job and check sources before filling up their “news” media with what could be (and in some cases probably is) pure fiction.

Have you read these articles. They are not saying that 'mum definitely did this thing at this time' they are more like 'mum posts on Mumsnet stating that every hates that they called their baby doochbag'. It is factual in that it is true that someone said that on Mumsnet even if the situation isn't true.

It's not about good journalism- they pick the ones that'll make good clickbait titles and will initiate discussion (which is why there's always loads of baby names ones).

People need to take responsibility for what they post online. If you think it'd be identifying if it's picked up by the daily mail it's identifying on here too.

girlmom21 · 03/02/2022 08:52

@suggestionsplease1 Mumsnet aren't sharing any personal data. They're an anonymous forum.

ludocris · 03/02/2022 08:49

@Sparklingbrook

And so? If it's important to them that others read their story, they can always post their own thread

It's not 'important that others read their story' they are trying to help the OP and others by sharing it.
So you are saying if you see a thread where you have direct experience of the problem you shouldn't comment on it and try and help the OP, but start your own thread about it instead? Right. Confused

Erm...no. I'm saying if they get upset that it's going to be deleted if the whole thread gets deleted, THEN they can start their own thread about their experiences if they so desire.
Lampshading · 03/02/2022 08:48

Of your registration data, only your Mumsnet or Gransnet username is displayed on screen for other users to see – but posts on Mumsnet or Gransnet Talk are visible to anyone on the internet. So when posting, you should bear in mind that any personally identifying details you include in the text or pictures you post could be seen by anyone.

We also provide an anonymised copy of all Talk posts to a handful of carefully chosen organisations so that they can analyse social trends. None of your personal information is ever shared and we remove usernames before sharing this information.

Registered members of Mumsnet or Gransnet can start discussions and add comments, pictures and videos to existing discussions within Mumsnet or Gransnet Talk’s forums under ourTerms of Use. This is optional in the sense that it’s up to you whether you post on a Mumsnet product or not; if you do post we always store the contents of those posts. These posts are public, but of your registration data, only your username is displayed on-screen. Your username is picked by you when youjoin a Mumsnet product; on Mumsnet you can change it at any time inMy Account.

Mumsnet or Gransnet forums (with the exception of some topics, like'Off the beaten track') are visible to search engines. This means that any personal information users choose to share in their posts on a Mumsnet product can be seen widely. We cannot control who sees these posts.

In all your posts across Mumsnet, in personal messages to other users, and in choosing your username, you should be mindful about the possibility that information you choose to disclose could lead to someone working out who you are in ‘real life’. For example, anything that references your real life name, your children’s real names, where you live or your date of birth could make it easy for someone to work out who you are.

Mumsnet and Gransnet are sites for grown-ups and we believe that our users are adults who can decide for themselves what information they choose to share on Mumsnet and Gransnet Talk. That said, if you’re ever worried that you’ve said too much, hit ‘report’ on one of your posts and explain the problem to our moderation team; they will be happy to help if they can.

You should be aware that the moderation team and a small number of other members of staff at Mumsnet and Gransnet have access to your Talk posts and can see that content in combination with your registration data. We restrict the number of staff who have access to this data to the minimum and we constantly review this. You can check your registration data inMy Account.

We provide a copy of all Talk posts to a small number of organisations for analysis or to create software analysis tools to analyse brands and sentiment towards topics. Your personal data and username are not included in the copies of posts that we provide to these organisations

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread