Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP and I never disagree about money but....

127 replies

DPpension · 02/02/2022 21:37

We just disagreed about money.

We both live together and own a property in both names with 50/50 split on the deeds. I’ve tried to make this post as unbiased as poss so bear with!

We have always split household bills according to an equal 40% of take home pay.

So one of us takes home 3.2k per month and one of us 1.9k.

The 1.9k Person contributes £780 and the 3.2k person contributes £1300 which is circa 40% of our net take home pay each. The rest of the money is that persons to do what they see fit.

Both pensions are matched by employer at 10% but given their higher earnings the higher earner pension is higher overall.

We’ve disagreed tonight about whether the contribution should be based on net pay or gross pay.

Should it be split by gross or net?

OP posts:
Cottonfrenzie · 03/02/2022 06:50

@FrangipaniBlue

I agree it should be net but I think you need to separate out the pensions issue from the bills.

Whether/how you fairly even up the pensions imbalance depends on 2 things for me.

If the lower earner has the lower earnings through mutual agreement ie they became a SAHP, part time or whatever to raise DC then it needs evened out in a fair way.

But if there are no DC and the inequality is purely down to the two individuals different career choices then I'm inclined to say tough, it is what it is?

What would the lower earner like to see happen to even out the pensions? For example, would they like to save an equivalent amount to what the higher earner is putting in their pension or do they have the option to top up their pension to a similar level?

Whichever you went with, that money should come out BEFORE you calculate the bills, so effectively reducing the lower earners "net" pay? Higher earner then pays slightly more towards the bills if that makes sense?

I don't agree however with the MN view that both partners should have the same "spending" money left. I'm a lot higher earner than DH but that's because I've worked harder over the years to further my career.

I pay more towards the household costs and I pay more towards family treats, but I don't see why I shouldn't also have more leftover at the end to treat myself (if I wanted to) as well?!

As the lower earner in my relationship I completely agree with this post

My husband pays more of the bills etc as he earns more. We pool savings. He has more disposable income, but it's not like I can't afford to do anything so I'm fine with that. He has a bigger pension than me - it never even occured to me I should get him topping up mine! I find it an odd idea really. He works in a sector where he will always earn more than me (I'm a teacher). It was my choice to pick this career and his choice to pick his. I really don't think im entitled to a completely even spilt as I don't think he should subsidise my life choice. It's enough of a subsidy in the bill spilt.

I don't understand the thought process behind the opening post to be honest. Only maybe if the lower earner sacrificed some of their career/pension whilst being a sahp or in some other way which may have benefited the higher earner

BarbaraofSeville · 03/02/2022 06:02

^We’ve disagreed tonight about whether the contribution should be based on net pay or gross pay.

Should it be split by gross or net^

Neither. You have highlighted the unfairness when people split contribuutions as X% of salary, when there is a big difference. The percentage the higher earner has left is much larger and in extreme circumstances you could have the lower earner with little or no personal spending money and the higher earner with many times more.

It would be more fair to combine incomes, pay out all joint costs, possibly look at some extra pension for the lower earner out of joint money, save for joint household costs like holidays, appliance replacement, property maintenance etc and split the remainder 50/50.

Of course you could consider the reasons for the earnings disparity. if the lower earner earns less simply because they're in a lower earning profession like nursing or teaching, they shouldn't be disadvantaged in a way that would be reasonable if they had chosen to work part time or not progress because they expected to be supported by the higher earning partner.

WutheringHeights66 · 03/02/2022 05:59

Is the higher earner paying pension contributions before tax?

bowlingalleyblues · 03/02/2022 05:55

Net

bonetiredwithtwins · 03/02/2022 05:54

Net

If you want a bigger pension go out and earn more 🤷🏻‍♀️

Totalwasteofpaper · 03/02/2022 05:48

Net.

The pension is going to be smaller as they earn less! They aren't owed the same pension.

A pension isn't a basic outgoings it's a tax efficient saving. If they want to they should up their contribution using the 60% disposable income remaining.

Hightemp · 03/02/2022 00:15

Husband has retired.We just share all our income…husbands income higher than mine but all in the same pot !

Chloemol · 03/02/2022 00:05

Net. That’s the available money to cover

GettingThemFromHereToThere · 02/02/2022 23:55

@GeorgiaGirl52

So DP is not your DH. You have no DC in common, only a 50/50 property. You are really just roommates. Split the household bills 50/50 and each pays for their own car, phone, insurance, takeaways, haircuts, etc. This includes pensions. Start saving so that when you break up you will have the money to buy our his share of the property. Then when you get a new DP, he can be a boarder and pay you rent.
How disrespectful are you!

Where do you get off telling someone this? It's so judgemental and arrogant!

GettingThemFromHereToThere · 02/02/2022 23:50

So my OH and I have very different incomes.

The way we work it is we split everything so we're left with the same disposable income each month.

So that means, for us, that one of us pays ALL the bills AND transfers the other a set amount each month. Then what we do with the disposable income is up to each of us.

Pensions - the higher earner has considerably more and will retire with considerably more. But not a lot we can do about that. I mean, the higher earner could give more to the lower earner to put in a private pension, but we don't do that currently.

Greenlight4 · 02/02/2022 23:40

Net. On paper my wage looks significantly less than my partners, in real life its a much smaller difference

GeorgiaGirl52 · 02/02/2022 23:08

So DP is not your DH.
You have no DC in common, only a 50/50 property.
You are really just roommates. Split the household bills 50/50 and each pays for their own car, phone, insurance, takeaways, haircuts, etc. This includes pensions. Start saving so that when you break up you will have the money to buy our his share of the property. Then when you get a new DP, he can be a boarder and pay you rent.

HamCob · 02/02/2022 23:05

The op hasn't outlined their circumstances but it seems to be assumed they are childless I was pointing out that the lower earner may legitimately be expected to the same amount of disposable income in some circs.

HamCob · 02/02/2022 22:59

@altiara

But at the same time you are 50:50 on the deeds so if you split up, lower earner gets more even though they are contributing less.
Contributions aren't necessarily financial. The partner may be shouldering the burden of childcare and housework to enable the other partner to be a high earner.
cheekychaplin · 02/02/2022 22:58

@HamCob

What's unfair about that? Of course a higher earner will have more money left.

Well you wouldn't think it was particularly fair if you'd given up a highly paid job to work part time, look after the kids and do all the shitwork at home whilst your partner climbed the career ladder.
Not saying this is the case here but it's not much of a stretch of the imagination.

OP didn't mention kids so it's entirely fair for the higher earner to have more money to spend.

HamCob · 02/02/2022 22:57

What's unfair about that? Of course a higher earner will have more money left.

Well you wouldn't think it was particularly fair if you'd given up a highly paid job to work part time, look after the kids and do all the shitwork at home whilst your partner climbed the career ladder.
Not saying this is the case here but it's not much of a stretch of the imagination.

CrinklyCraggy · 02/02/2022 22:57

How can you be married to someone who can afford better restaurants and holidays than you can?

altiara · 02/02/2022 22:56

But at the same time you are 50:50 on the deeds so if you split up, lower earner gets more even though they are contributing less.

Lollypop701 · 02/02/2022 22:51

The employer % is going to be higher for DP as his wage is higher. Pension contributions can be made by employers before or after tax. If you are the lower earner and you want to plan for an independent retirement you need to put more in if you need to.

Personally I couldn’t be with a partner who would see me live frugally in my life whilst they lived it up, just as if they were struggling I’d support them. But I digress…

roxisolerenshaw · 02/02/2022 22:48

Net

D0lphine · 02/02/2022 22:43

Are you planning to get married OP?

Merryoldgoat · 02/02/2022 22:42

What's unfair about that? Of course a higher earner will have more money left

It depends on the circumstances doesn’t it?

Fairly new relationship, no children, fine.

Been together years, own property together, less fine.

Kids too and one earning less owing to pt job for childcare? Not fine.

To me these arguments always boil down to are you a partnership or not? When it’s starts getting to ‘gross or net’ type arguments it’s not a partnership.

Merryoldgoat · 02/02/2022 22:38

It should be net but I don’t understand the thing about the pension…?

I also don’t understand why you’re both putting in the same percentage given the disparity in wage.

Dillydollydingdong · 02/02/2022 22:37

Net

FreestyleInTrance · 02/02/2022 22:37

We split everything so that we both have the same amount of 'fun' money each month.

Initially we did split everything on a percentage basis (based on net pay), but the reason I earned less is because I was doing 4 long days... and (because our nursery was a flat daily rate) doing 5 standard days and paying an extra full day at nursery would have actually seen us £600 a year worse off (plus meant more time in childcare for our DD). It didn't seem fair that I got less 'fun' money despite working longer days, saving us money AND doing a full day's childcare on my day "off".... so after lengthy disagreements we switched to equal amounts :)

Swipe left for the next trending thread