Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to disagree with a uni vice-principal that this is abusive?

84 replies

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 21:18

Today, I've seen this exchange.

Person 1: And most trans women aren’t men.

Person 2: They are males.

Person 1: And you are an abusive bigot for asserting so. Blocked.

This would be of very little significance, except person 1 is the vice-principal of a Scottish university. The University of the West of Scotland, to be precise.

Saying that "they are males" is abusive bigotry? In that case, is there any way that anyone could express their opinion that transwomen are transwomen without being called abusive or bigoted?

If senior academics can honestly believe the above is bigoted, what implications does that have for Scottish hate crime legislation in practice?

Link about the bill for those who haven't heard about it: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-53580326

YANBU: "these are males" is not abusive or bigoted to post.

YABU: "these are males" is an abusive and bigoted sentence.

to disagree with a uni vice-principal that this is abusive?
OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 03/02/2022 14:39

Not anti trans.
People can be as trans as they like.
What they cannot do is change sex. It is scientifically impossible to do so.
Stating a biological fact does not make you anti trans.

This. Put it on a banner. I honestly do not understand how this has become a controversial opinion. What am I missing?

Theeyeballsinthesky · 03/02/2022 14:29

He’s RT lots of stuff about terfs and how awful they are and how women get attacked a lot so it’s wrong to focus on trans women.

How to ppl this hard of thinking get jobs at universities?

hugr · 03/02/2022 14:25

@NoNever

He’s going to be torn to shreds by saying “most” transwomen are not men. That implies some are.
It looks like a facetious response to the previous tweet which ends with "Most men don't assault".
CityMumma78 · 03/02/2022 14:18

Surely University’s need to be regulated properly to stop the indoctrination of young impressionable adults!! A University is a place for higher education, expanded learning and freedom to explore and question however we are seeing more and more that lecturers and educators are using their platforms to spread their own personal left wing ideology. This just isn’t acceptable or progressive!

EishetChayil · 03/02/2022 08:26

@SarahBellam

But trans women are males. That’s a biological reality. Their plumbing is male. That’s not controversial, surely.

But it is, in this brave new world!

SarahBellam · 03/02/2022 08:24

But trans women are males. That’s a biological reality. Their plumbing is male. That’s not controversial, surely.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/02/2022 08:20

Shock I really hope his opinions aren't carrying over into the teaching of the nursing course!

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 03/02/2022 07:37

Scarily UWS have a nursing school. I wonder if they're driving the 'no more single sex wards, if you don't like it leave' agenda with their students?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/02/2022 07:33

Does the UWS have a biology department? Maybe the lecturers should Have A Word with the vice-principal.

OP posts:
montysma1 · 03/02/2022 00:41

Not anti trans.
People can be as trans as they like.
What they cannot do is change sex. It is scientifically impossible to do so.
Stating a biological fact does not make you anti trans.

ErrolTheDragon · 03/02/2022 00:08

@NoNever

He’s going to be torn to shreds by saying “most” transwomen are not men. That implies some are.
Yes... that's a pretty odd thing to say. I wonder if he can provide a definition of 'transwoman' and of 'men' which would enable that to make any sort of logical sense?
NoNever · 02/02/2022 23:48

He’s going to be torn to shreds by saying “most” transwomen are not men. That implies some are.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 02/02/2022 23:43

He doesn't understand basic biology and he doesn't respect women. Woman is a biological fact. Attempts to define it in any other way in order to look after the feelings of a minority of men are nonsensical not least because you can't actually categorise anything without some degree of stated and shared definitions. A category which means different things to different people is of no use to anyone and achieves nothing. This is a thinly veiled Attempt to remove female rights fir male benefit and either he doesn't care is too absorbed in his own needs to thnk about others. Either way he is incompetent.

ErrolTheDragon · 02/02/2022 22:29

YANBU.
It's rather worrying that a uni vice principal appears not to understand the meanings of the word 'male' and 'bigot'. Saying that transwomen are males is a simple, entirely neutral, objective fact.

ufucoffee · 02/02/2022 22:20

@FitAt50

You are not going to get much balance on here, mumsnet as a whole is very anti-trans. The majority seem to think they are just pervy men who pretend they want to be women, so they can spy on them in swimming pools or fitting rooms. I have only ever known 2 real trans women and they were lovely and have experience years of abuse.
Mumsnet is not anti trans. Some users are just against men saying they are women when they obviously aren't. If some men want to pretend they are women they can, obviously, crack on mate.
Mychitchatdays · 02/02/2022 22:03

The Uws is a real university!! It's a young one just not as aged as some.

The person in question is an idiot though and has many crazy ideas. I don't think he's actually put a foot on the campus. He doesn't reflect the lecturers and campus experience.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 22:02

@SickAndTiredAgain

Not the point you’re asking about but I don’t understand his first tweet “most transwomen aren’t men”. Most? Based on his subsequent tweet I would assume he’d be of the view that all transwomen aren’t men? And others would be of the view that transwomen are men. What is meant by “most”? Am I being stupid? Who are the transwomen who are men, in his view? I feel like I must be missing something obvious there.
Yeah, I didn't understand that either. If you can get what he means, please tell me!

twitter.com/JonPowles/status/1488911271344984068?t=O6X6AmbynkwKy_HbRTj5TQ&s=19

OP posts:
PonyPatter44 · 02/02/2022 21:59

He's probably absolutely terrified of being the next Prof. Stock.

SickAndTiredAgain · 02/02/2022 21:59

Not the point you’re asking about but I don’t understand his first tweet “most transwomen aren’t men”.
Most? Based on his subsequent tweet I would assume he’d be of the view that all transwomen aren’t men? And others would be of the view that transwomen are men.
What is meant by “most”? Am I being stupid? Who are the transwomen who are men, in his view? I feel like I must be missing something obvious there.

DomesticatedZombie · 02/02/2022 21:58

How in earth is it bigoted to state non controversial fact?
Would he respect students with gc views? Would he treat them equally and fairly?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 21:56

That's to TheOriginalEmu.

OP posts:
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 21:56

^There will be more to the exchange than just this.
Also he’s entitled to block who he likes regardless of his job.^

Um, you confuse me. I read the entire thread. I can link if you like, but I didn't want to drive more traffic that way. No point in adding to a pile-on. That's why I blurred out part of his username.

And I never said anything about whether he shouldn't be entitled to curate his social media. I'm non-plussed that a Scottish academic thinks "they are male" is bigoted to say!

OP posts:
EishetChayil · 02/02/2022 21:54

@FitAt50

You are not going to get much balance on here, mumsnet as a whole is very anti-trans. The majority seem to think they are just pervy men who pretend they want to be women, so they can spy on them in swimming pools or fitting rooms. I have only ever known 2 real trans women and they were lovely and have experience years of abuse.

You most probably won't answer this, but I'm interested to know: in what way is Mumsnet "anti-trans"?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 21:52

@FitAt50

I agree that its not bigoted, maybe they could have said "born male" but not bigoted.
Thank you for answering! Flowers
OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 02/02/2022 21:51

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

Today, I've seen this exchange.

Person 1: And most trans women aren’t men.

Person 2: They are males.

Person 1: And you are an abusive bigot for asserting so. Blocked.

This would be of very little significance, except person 1 is the vice-principal of a Scottish university. The University of the West of Scotland, to be precise.

Saying that "they are males" is abusive bigotry? In that case, is there any way that anyone could express their opinion that transwomen are transwomen without being called abusive or bigoted?

If senior academics can honestly believe the above is bigoted, what implications does that have for Scottish hate crime legislation in practice?

Link about the bill for those who haven't heard about it: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-53580326

YANBU: "these are males" is not abusive or bigoted to post.

YABU: "these are males" is an abusive and bigoted sentence.

There will be more to the exchange than just this. Also he’s entitled to block who he likes regardless of his job.
Swipe left for the next trending thread