Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to disagree with a uni vice-principal that this is abusive?

84 replies

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 21:18

Today, I've seen this exchange.

Person 1: And most trans women aren’t men.

Person 2: They are males.

Person 1: And you are an abusive bigot for asserting so. Blocked.

This would be of very little significance, except person 1 is the vice-principal of a Scottish university. The University of the West of Scotland, to be precise.

Saying that "they are males" is abusive bigotry? In that case, is there any way that anyone could express their opinion that transwomen are transwomen without being called abusive or bigoted?

If senior academics can honestly believe the above is bigoted, what implications does that have for Scottish hate crime legislation in practice?

Link about the bill for those who haven't heard about it: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-53580326

YANBU: "these are males" is not abusive or bigoted to post.

YABU: "these are males" is an abusive and bigoted sentence.

to disagree with a uni vice-principal that this is abusive?
OP posts:
FurbleSocks · 03/02/2022 22:42

@DomesticatedZombie

What is a transwoman, Furble?
A male who has transitioned to a female (gender identity not biological sex). That is the definition of a trans woman. Not born woman. Trans(itioned) to woman. Yes DNA and anatomy may say they were born male but they identify as female. I'm not sure why that's so hard to understand. I identify as blonde though my DNA and roots say I'm a brunette. You would look a bit of a plonker trying to argue with a blonde person that they are brunette. Were brunette yes. Are brunette no.
MrHavelIsHot · 03/02/2022 22:38

It’s not abusive. It’s just facts, they’ll always be male. Just because they don’t want to be doesn’t mean someone saying it is abusive.

3peassuit · 03/02/2022 22:36

If they’re not males what are they transitioning from?

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 03/02/2022 22:34

Were males yes. Are males no. They are transwomen.

If they were born male, they are still male. It is not possible to change from what you were born no matter how much you want it. Bullying people into stopping stating these facts does not change them.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/02/2022 17:38

Yes. I was still pissed off when the other person said she was confused about the first comment.

So I did not bother screenshotting and anonymising it, or c&p'ing; instead I linked directly.

If she'd asked six hours later, I'd have c&p'ed again. As she asked when I was still seething, I just gave her the information.

What in this confuses you? The idea that other mumsnetters are human beings?

OP posts:
Walkaround · 03/02/2022 17:37

There is nothing wrong with being a trans woman (ie someone of the male biological sex who feels very strongly that they are of the female gender), and it is right to fight to be accepted as such and not abused and mistreated for being the person you are, or told that you are actually a man and should identify yourself as such at all times. There is something wrong with stealing the words and identities of others, though. There are men, women, trans men and trans women. Cis woman is an unnecessary fabrication. You should not fight for acceptance by pretending there is no difference between women and trans women, because that’s a lie and does not win the acceptance craved, it actually reveals the belief that you will never actually be accepted for who you are, so you want everyone to pretend you are in fact something else altogether.

slashlover · 03/02/2022 17:28

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

Just for the purposes of further clarification, for *@slashlover*

If I go to the effort of screenshotting and typing out a conversation verbatim/c&p'ing multiple posts in order to preserve the partial anonymity of someone (who I don't actually like!) and someone then uses the effort I went to, to imply I never even saw the conversation in context, I will be pissed off.

And then, I will say "fuck it, and just link directly. Because I am a human being, not an emotionless robot. If you would prefer me to maintain the moral high ground, don't taunt me down from it.

Your reply saying you wouldn't drive traffic was to OriginalEmu, then you went ahead and posted it despite them not replying after that.

Anyway, enjoy your pile on because of the job the tweeter does.

ufucoffee · 03/02/2022 17:26

[quote Eightiesfan]@ufucoffee
Mumsnet is not anti trans. Some users are just against men saying they are women when they obviously aren't. If some men want to pretend they are women they can, obviously, crack on mate.

And therein lies the problem, you clearly have no understanding of gender dysphoria and the absolute horror both men and women have to live with through fear of people exactly like you. The fact you label ‘transwomen’ as men ‘pretending’ they are women is sheer ignorance. Educate yourself.[/quote]
No it's not ignorance to state the truth. Saying 'educate yourself' in a po faced sanctimonious manner won't make anyone suddenly agree with you

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/02/2022 17:24

[quote Eightiesfan]@ufucoffee
Mumsnet is not anti trans. Some users are just against men saying they are women when they obviously aren't. If some men want to pretend they are women they can, obviously, crack on mate.

And therein lies the problem, you clearly have no understanding of gender dysphoria and the absolute horror both men and women have to live with through fear of people exactly like you. The fact you label ‘transwomen’ as men ‘pretending’ they are women is sheer ignorance. Educate yourself.[/quote]
None of this is relevant to what I asked. But seeing as you're following this tangent, please be aware that you're being old-fashioned. Not all trans people experience dysphoria, and it is transphobic to imply that dysphoria is a prerequisite for being trans. It's gatekeeping.

OP posts:
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/02/2022 17:20

Just for the purposes of further clarification, for @slashlover

If I go to the effort of screenshotting and typing out a conversation verbatim/c&p'ing multiple posts in order to preserve the partial anonymity of someone (who I don't actually like!) and someone then uses the effort I went to, to imply I never even saw the conversation in context, I will be pissed off.

And then, I will say "fuck it, and just link directly. Because I am a human being, not an emotionless robot. If you would prefer me to maintain the moral high ground, don't taunt me down from it.

OP posts:
Eightiesfan · 03/02/2022 17:02

@ufucoffee
Mumsnet is not anti trans. Some users are just against men saying they are women when they obviously aren't. If some men want to pretend they are women they can, obviously, crack on mate.

And therein lies the problem, you clearly have no understanding of gender dysphoria and the absolute horror both men and women have to live with through fear of people exactly like you. The fact you label ‘transwomen’ as men ‘pretending’ they are women is sheer ignorance. Educate yourself.

TheKeatingFive · 03/02/2022 16:54

Scientific american disagrees with you

They are also talking utter nonsense.

Also - how do we know he wasn’t referring to gender?

There is no consensus about what constitutes gender. As far as I can see it's nothing more than a bunch of societal stereotypes. Which is fine, but not in anyway shape or form something that trumps sex.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/02/2022 16:52

Namechange466

You're saying that male and female are gender words now?!
Is this just in humans, or are they being redefined across the animal kingdom?

If I want to breed baby horses (foals) from my mare, how can I communicate to someone else that I would like to borrow someone else's horse with a penis, not a horse with some kind of masculine gender identity?

OP posts:
Migrainesbythedozen · 03/02/2022 16:49

@Namechange466 Stop posting femphobic junk-science articles.

Male DNA cannot change into female DNA.

Science disagrees with you. DNA disagrees with you. Biology disagrees with you. Anatomy disagrees with you.

Migrainesbythedozen · 03/02/2022 16:46

@FurbleSocks They are still males, and will be til the day they die. Their DNA says so. Their anatomy says so. Their biology says so. A male can't change into a female.

Namechange466 · 03/02/2022 16:46

@TheKeatingFive

Were males yes. Are males no.

From a biological POV that's utter nonsense

Scientific american disagrees with you

blogs.scientificamerican.com/voices/stop-using-phony-science-to-justify-transphobia/

Also - how do we know he wasn’t referring to gender?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/02/2022 16:46

@slashlover

Um, you confuse me. I read the entire thread. I can link if you like, but I didn't want to drive more traffic that way. No point in adding to a pile-on. That's why I blurred out part of his username.

That lasted 6 minutes until you posted the link.

Yeah, OriginalEmu's accusations made me change my mind.

Your point?

OP posts:
RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 03/02/2022 16:44

Were males yes. Are males no. They are transwomen

They were males and they are males.

TheKeatingFive · 03/02/2022 16:42

Were males yes. Are males no.

From a biological POV that's utter nonsense

DomesticatedZombie · 03/02/2022 16:39

What is a transwoman, Furble?

FurbleSocks · 03/02/2022 16:38

[quote Joolsin]@FitAt50 But those two real transwomen were males, otherwise they wouldn't be transwomen, they would just be women. The fact they are male is what makes them transwomen[/quote]
Were males yes. Are males no. They are transwomen.

SolasAnla · 03/02/2022 16:32

The original themes something, something about trust and predators.

Advocating / claiming women need to be kind and allow penis people into single sex womens spaces.

Argues that penis people are women. 😴

Tapdancing to avoid saying women should be arrested for refusing to accept the existance of a female penis.

This gets to be so predictable.

Pretend that its a problem women have to come to terms with
So..... his penis areas are not to be changed to accomadate the other type of penis person.
Presumption (rebuttable) that his penis is a male penis but other penis not a male penis.

Yep ...
Verbal abuse, mandated trust obligation and predictors of predator behaviours 🙄

slashlover · 03/02/2022 16:32

Um, you confuse me. I read the entire thread. I can link if you like, but I didn't want to drive more traffic that way. No point in adding to a pile-on. That's why I blurred out part of his username.

That lasted 6 minutes until you posted the link.

Migrainesbythedozen · 03/02/2022 16:05

@FitAt50

You are not going to get much balance on here, mumsnet as a whole is very anti-trans. The majority seem to think they are just pervy men who pretend they want to be women, so they can spy on them in swimming pools or fitting rooms. I have only ever known 2 real trans women and they were lovely and have experience years of abuse.
@FitAt50 Please don't lie, gaslight and misrepresent. Mumsnet is not anti-trans at all. It is pro-women's safety and women's rights. If you see that as 'anti-trans', then that says so much more about your mindset than it does Mumsnet.
Migrainesbythedozen · 03/02/2022 16:03

@TheOriginalEmu I know you are looking for excuses to justify his behaviour, but there was no more to it than that. I was blocked by him for merely saying women deserve safe spaces. Another poster who was raped by a transwoman was also blocked by him. These TRAs are dangerous and their hatred for women is truly and genuinely palpable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread