Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to disagree with a uni vice-principal that this is abusive?

84 replies

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 21:18

Today, I've seen this exchange.

Person 1: And most trans women aren’t men.

Person 2: They are males.

Person 1: And you are an abusive bigot for asserting so. Blocked.

This would be of very little significance, except person 1 is the vice-principal of a Scottish university. The University of the West of Scotland, to be precise.

Saying that "they are males" is abusive bigotry? In that case, is there any way that anyone could express their opinion that transwomen are transwomen without being called abusive or bigoted?

If senior academics can honestly believe the above is bigoted, what implications does that have for Scottish hate crime legislation in practice?

Link about the bill for those who haven't heard about it: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-53580326

YANBU: "these are males" is not abusive or bigoted to post.

YABU: "these are males" is an abusive and bigoted sentence.

to disagree with a uni vice-principal that this is abusive?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UndertheCedartree · 06/02/2022 21:20

@SolasAnla - thank you.

SolasAnla · 04/02/2022 23:12

[quote UndertheCedartree]@SolasAnla - ok, well I still have no idea what he's going on about![/quote]
Its willy wagging for the removal of single sex women's spaces.

Usual male posturing to advocate to exclude some special males from males spaces.

These special males must be reclassified out of the men/male classification.

Women be kind.
When you are told that the penis is not attached to a male believe, and accept the words as the truthful proclamation.
Trust that these special males are special.
It never happens but if the occasional "incident" happens and a girl/woman is harmed just its just an occasional "incident".

Willy wagger short hand for pro-penis access to womens spaces and any collateral damage is acceptable margin of error.

UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 19:17

@SolasAnla - ok, well I still have no idea what he's going on about!

FurbleSocks · 04/02/2022 19:12

@Joolsin

Weremales yes.Aremales no. They are transwomen.

@FurbleSocks You have misinterpreted my meaning - as I typed this sentence, I was referring to the pp who "used to know two transwomen", so I referred to them in the past tense as she knew them in the past, not as they were male in the past. Because, as others have said, the fact is that every cell in their bodies was, is and always will be male. How they wish to outwardly present themselves can, of course, change infinitely if that is their preference, but they can't change their basic biology.

I was referring to the original exchange the OP screen shotted. The person used the word are and I challenged it with were. I don't remember your particular post.
Joolsin · 04/02/2022 18:40

Weremales yes.Aremales no. They are transwomen.

@FurbleSocks You have misinterpreted my meaning - as I typed this sentence, I was referring to the pp who "used to know two transwomen", so I referred to them in the past tense as she knew them in the past, not as they were male in the past. Because, as others have said, the fact is that every cell in their bodies was, is and always will be male. How they wish to outwardly present themselves can, of course, change infinitely if that is their preference, but they can't change their basic biology.

SolasAnla · 04/02/2022 10:47

@UndertheCedartree

I'm guessing when he says 'most' he means some men call themselves 'trans' in order to invade women only spaces. I may be wrong but what else could he mean? But if it is this then that wilis exactly the issue with allowing transwomen in these spaces, if men can just call themselves 'trans' if they aren't even actual transwomen. But the whole thing is confusing! Don't think he knows what he is on about but just wants to appear 'woke'.
He knows exactly what he is saying.

The opening was about how males wont claim to be trans while quoting from a thread complaining about MN.

He went on to claiming that a human with a penis is not male but female.

No one is that ignorant and yet has managed to advance in a career to be appointed to managment role in a Uni.

TheMarzipanDildo · 04/02/2022 00:32

And to the person who suggested there would be more to this- I really really doubt it. This is the level of debate. Women are getting reported to the police for saying that men shouldn’t be in women’s prisons.

TheMarzipanDildo · 04/02/2022 00:30

You can tell he doesn’t know what the arguments are- “most” transwomen are not men?! What does that mean? I would argue that that is more “bigoted” than suggesting that all transwomen are of the male sex which is just biological fact and pretty key to being a transwoman.

SolasAnla · 04/02/2022 00:21

@TheKeatingFive

My point is that is the sort of language that perpetuates those stereotypes.

I don't see any point in trying to ignore those stereotypes exist either. They do. I believe personally that they are societally constructed, which is why I stated that clearly and put them in inverted commas. I don't feel I've been unclear in my meaning, so I'm not entirely sure what you're trying to achieve here.

So is barking at strangers and random cats and sniffing genatalia a sterotypical male or a female activity or a type of social construct?
UndertheCedartree · 04/02/2022 00:17

I'm guessing when he says 'most' he means some men call themselves 'trans' in order to invade women only spaces. I may be wrong but what else could he mean? But if it is this then that wilis exactly the issue with allowing transwomen in these spaces, if men can just call themselves 'trans' if they aren't even actual transwomen. But the whole thing is confusing! Don't think he knows what he is on about but just wants to appear 'woke'.

Theunamedcat · 03/02/2022 23:39

I clarify they are born male its a clear factual statement that I've told my son he will be argued with if he repeats that because that's exactly what he believes I've also told him never discuss it with his sister because she believes people are clownfish its going to be hard for him growing up with his absolute black and white thinking he will struggle

bishophaha · 03/02/2022 23:34

No worries.
I guess I think of it a bit like "crooked Hilary" - if two things are associated all the time it tends to get perpetuated. The inverted commas get lost as terms are repeated...!
Not trying to pick an argument. (Honest). I think we can agree to disagree!

TheKeatingFive · 03/02/2022 23:23

My point is that is the sort of language that perpetuates those stereotypes.

I don't see any point in trying to ignore those stereotypes exist either. They do. I believe personally that they are societally constructed, which is why I stated that clearly and put them in inverted commas. I don't feel I've been unclear in my meaning, so I'm not entirely sure what you're trying to achieve here.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 03/02/2022 23:22

A male who has transitioned to a female (gender identity not biological sex). That is the definition of a trans woman. Not born woman. Trans(itioned) to woman. Yes DNA and anatomy may say they were born male but they identify as female. I'm not sure why that's so hard to understand.
I think it's hard to understand because male means biological sex and does not relate to one's identity. The stubborn refusal to ever define the concept of a female gender identity does not help.

bishophaha · 03/02/2022 23:21

No, I reiterate, I read your post. That means I didn't miss things.

You said those things were 'female' and 'male', according to stereotypes. My point is that is the sort of language that perpetuates those stereotypes.

I would say 'feminine-coded' or something is what you're actually trying to say, is it?

Again, just musing on the language we use and why we feel compelled to bring sex-labels into descriptions of clothes and behaviour when even in the same sentence we acknowledge they are unrelated to the sexed body.

TheKeatingFive · 03/02/2022 23:15

That's why I was confused that you still used sex-labels for stereotype things

Did you miss the bit where I specified 'according to social stereotypes'?

herpainsceased · 03/02/2022 23:15

YADNBU.

bishophaha · 03/02/2022 23:11

I did read your post Keating! That's why I was confused that you still used sex-labels for stereotype things. And just wanted to point out (to the thread in general) that the two things are separate.

No matter how many people like to confuse them or use them interchangeably. I think it's important we are clear in our language when talking about things that can be male/female (usually bodies and cables) and things that can't.

(Not having a go - general musing on my part!)

TheKeatingFive · 03/02/2022 23:06

But you're aware there is no actual 'female' or 'male' way to live

You're equating the label given to the sexed body with an assortment of cultural stereotypes.

If you read my post you'll see I acknowledged all of that

bishophaha · 03/02/2022 23:06

A male who has transitioned to a female (gender identity not biological sex). That is the definition of a trans woman.

Genuine question - what exactly do you mean by 'transitioning'?
Do you think it is/should be anything more than saying "I am a woman actually"?

A lot of trans folk would say they didn't change anything, they were always their gender. Do you think it is gatekeeping to say you need to 'transition' or change anything about you to be trans?

bishophaha · 03/02/2022 23:04

@TheKeatingFive

I have sympathy for people with gender dysphoria. It sounds really hard. I support people living how they want to live, dressing how they want, acting in ways that are more 'female' or 'male' according to social stereotypes without any censure.

But it is not an appropriate or helpful response to cultivate an illusion that changing sex is possible. Or to deny that one's biological sex isn't important in certain situations (for example, when people can be triggered by it, in competitive sport, when it comes to sexual attraction). That's the issue.

But you're aware there is no actual 'female' or 'male' way to live - unless, I suppose, it directly relates to your body parts (menstruating, for example, might be described as a 'female way to live')?

You're equating the label given to the sexed body with an assortment of cultural stereotypes.

I argue they should not be linked and in fact we should be making an active effort to dissociate the two, not say that 'being kind' or 'liking shopping' or something is a 'female' way to live. It's got nothing to do with the female body.

TheKeatingFive · 03/02/2022 23:00

You would look a bit of a plonker trying to argue with a blonde person that they are brunette. Were brunette yes. Are brunette no.

What an absolutely ridiculous comparison

Yes DNA and anatomy may say they were born male but they identify as female

But DNA and anatomy don't change and that's what determines sex. What you 'identify' with is neither here nor there. What if someone identifies as a fish. Or a Maori. It doesn't make either of those true.

TheKeatingFive · 03/02/2022 22:56

I have sympathy for people with gender dysphoria. It sounds really hard. I support people living how they want to live, dressing how they want, acting in ways that are more 'female' or 'male' according to social stereotypes without any censure.

But it is not an appropriate or helpful response to cultivate an illusion that changing sex is possible. Or to deny that one's biological sex isn't important in certain situations (for example, when people can be triggered by it, in competitive sport, when it comes to sexual attraction). That's the issue.

MrHavelIsHot · 03/02/2022 22:47

No. They’ll always be male.

And I don’t think I’d be the one that looks like a ‘plonker’ when a male is claiming to be a female. Unless you’re someone who thinks trans women ever actually pass as women.

Migrainesbythedozen · 03/02/2022 22:46

@FurbleSocks 97% of born men, per medical data, retain their penis and testicles. It is apparently less than 3% that actually transition.

Less than 3% actually transition. Less than 3%. So on that basis, were male, ARE male.

Swipe left for the next trending thread