Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be glad Norway is banning breeding deformed dogs?

130 replies

AnakinthePadawhine · 02/02/2022 18:53

Norway will ban the breeding of King Charles and British bulldogs. I hope that this will catch on in other countries, and force breeders and Kennel Clubs to change their stupid and harmful standards?
Can pugs and French bulldogs be next?

www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2022/02/02/norway-bans-breeding-british-bulldog-king-charles-cavalier-spaniel/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
EpicGem · 04/02/2022 13:15

It's a good move. The kennel clubs and breed clubs won't do anything to change the breed standards to prioritise the health of the dog. From what I understand, the Norwegian kennel club refused to do anything to sort out the issue which is why the ban was brought in.
Very reminiscent of the KC in the UK shrugging and saying nowt was wrong after the Pannorama (I think it was) expose of pedigree breeding and then palming it off to the breed clubs who also shrugged and didn't see a problem. Until Pedigree Chum pulled their sponsorship of Crufts and the BBC dropped coverage of it. Then it was, "well, maybe we can look at the standards." GSDs have gotten marginally better, but it's still painful to watch them. I have family that had GSDs, while both had arthritis in the hind legs towards the end of their lives, they were nowhere near that deformed. The police manage to breed functional GSDs, surely, it can't be beyond the scope of show breeders.
I have a Border Collie. She's from working lines. She taller at the shoulder than most male show line Border Collies because the show dogs are being bred smaller. I remember joking with someone at a trade stand at Crufts a few years ago that the show lines were breeding "teacup collies".

CeratopsofthePharoahs · 04/02/2022 11:20

Rhodesian Ridgebacks should be added to the list too. Breeding a dog to specifically have a mild form of spina bifida? Why, just why??

Someone I knew had one. It lived to the age of two when it had to be put down because its behaviour became uncontrollable. Turns out it had a severe infection in its spine that reached its brain because RR's have tiny holes in their skin in the ridged fur and infections can very easily get in. It's beyond cruel.

Cherrysoup · 04/02/2022 11:10

The Kennel Club has refused to publish results from research and really needs to be made to make breeding far more robust. They could have massively supported healthy breeding but have made it far too easy for breeders to fudge details and carry on breeding. Yes, a lot of it is down to public demand for trendy breeds, but the KC could make a big difference. It absolutely sickens me to see these poor creatures who simply aren’t fit for function.

Shadedog · 04/02/2022 11:02

The “breed standards” that have created this shit show should be banned. Flatter faces, smaller skulls, twisted vertebrae, droopy eyes etc being bred into dogs ON PURPOSE Is nothing short of monstrous. I’m not that old and I can remember when German shepherds could run around without looking like their spine curved right to the ground. There is one in my street who is only about 18 months and she can barely walk. We seem to have just accepted this as fine and started selling doggy staircases in BM bargains instead of stopping breeding dogs who can’t get onto the sofa aged 2.
My friend has a pug who she thinks is a JRT cross, but he’s a rescue so she’s not sure of the proportions. He’s a lovely dog, looks pug-like, but doesn’t snuffle when he breathes, he has longish legs and can run pretty fast. He’s still flat faced but it’s a start. My own dog is a longdog mongrel. Sight hounds are usually fairly healthy as the breeders aim for speed rather than cuteness but there is a trend towards very long faced dogs, especially borzois, which is unhealthy too. They end up with a huge overbite and can have breathing problems too.

Google "micro pocket bully" if you want to see how far humankind can fuck up another species

I know someone who paid £6k for one of these. It’s about 4 months take home pay for him. Ridiculous status symbol.

SirSniffsAlot · 04/02/2022 08:29

I thought any form of docking was banned!

Ear docking is illegal. But...

a) always someone willing to do it illegally
b) it is been legal to import them docked which allows a loophole
c) celebrities post docked dogs on their social media feeds and music videos (looking at you Rita Ora and co) turning them back into a fashionable accessory

ButtockUp · 03/02/2022 23:50

I'm still reeling over hearing that some breeds get their ears docked!!!

I thought any form of docking was banned!

TheLeadbetterLife · 03/02/2022 21:40

The idea of breeding these traits for fashion is so abhorrent.

As a pp said, even if breeders outbreed and start making them healthier, the non-freak dogs won’t be “recognised” by the Kennel Clubs. That is absolutely insane. Who gives a fuck what the KCs think?

Dog breeds are not a real thing, they’re just disgusting Dr Moreau-esque experiments perpetuated by fashion and greed. If people were inbreeding generations of humans to the point of obscene deformity, there would be outcry, and long prison sentences.

Kennel Clubs should be disbanded. All they do is justify the madness. Genetically, a dog is a dog. Just because some loon decided to create a malformed one and call it a breed doesn’t mean anyone should take them seriously. Even if they are wearing a blazer.

powershowerforanhour · 03/02/2022 19:59

To produce the tight double curl of the pug, or the stump or absent tail of the Frenchie, the coccygeal vertebrae must be deformed or absent. Then breed enthusiasts get all shocked when cervical, thoracic, lumbar or sacral vertebrae are deformed Hmm

Maneandfeathers · 03/02/2022 19:06

@EerieSilence it’s not a problem Grin!

I didn’t mean a natural loose type curl. I meant the tight corkscrew curl where there’s a fold underneath like a bulldog or the likes of frenchies that have 0 tail at all!
I know it’s not the end of the world but just why is it fashion to have no tail just a bum on display Grin Confused

The fashions are just bizarre to me, wrinkly faces and stumpy bodies…just why!

EerieSilence · 03/02/2022 18:56

@Maneandfeathers - Dobermanns have naturally curly tails too. Can't see why this is a problem.

Hummingbirdcake · 03/02/2022 16:35

Very good idea.

MsMeNz · 03/02/2022 16:32

Yeah I remember listening to a talk from a professor in evolution and he said the dogs that would survive a human apocalypse would be the type you would drawer as a kid just generic dog like, medium sized, mixed, average about medium fur etc, as all the dogs bread for specific hunting for humans or looks would die out sooner.
I really love king Charles spaniels they are beautiful, so kind and sweet and I want one, but I won't as I know a lot of health issues, will probably rescue a mutt instead 🙂

SirSniffsAlot · 03/02/2022 16:19

Upcurled tails come as a side-effect of selecting for friendly characteristics, i.e. the domestication process itself would appear to result in physiccal changes even when those changes are not part of the breeding selection criteria (you can include a seperation of coat colour into multiple distinct colurs and floppy ears).

So the upturned tail is not exactly (always) a selected physical trait but it's not quite the factory setting either.

In feral dogs that selection is likely still happening as a result of friendlier dogs being more succesful than fearful dogs (fearful dogs will scavenge near humans less, take food directly from humans less and, if they bite, more likely to be run off, injured or killed than the friendly ones).

In bred dogs there is definately some further selection going on for those breeds with exaggerated upturned tails, over and above the changes that happen as a side effect of domestication-selection.

Nice illustration of those changes seen in the famous fox experiment on domestication here which shows the changes mentioned.

To be glad Norway is banning breeding deformed dogs?
BoreOfWhabylon · 03/02/2022 12:26

YY Bideshi. Landrace dogs like the one in the illustration here
embarkvet.com/resources/dog-breeds/hong-kong-village-dog/

When I was a child we lived in the Far East and had one. He was the best dog ever.

Bideshi · 03/02/2022 10:50

@Maneandfeathers

On another breeding note what’s the attraction of breeding dogs without tails or tails that curl over anyway…last thing I want to see is a dogs bum hole proudly on display every time it walks past Confused

I prefer my dogs to resemble normal animals that can run, breathe have long legs and have a long noses. I also like functional ears and tails for reading body language. If your worried about someone coming for your dog because it’s so deformed you’ve got issues!!!

Dogs with that sort of tail are natural. If you go to India or the Far East all the dogs (millions and millions of them) are like that and they sure haven't been selectively bred. I do agree with your feelings on pencil sharpener bums on display, but it's a factory setting.
BashfulClam · 03/02/2022 09:35

Our downstairs neighbour when we lived in our flat had a pug. The noises that poor thing made just trying to walk around I couldn’t have a dog that sounded like it was dying just from a walk around the block. Also their eyes can just fall out the socket…when I read that I was shocked. I want a dog that can run and play and I can throw a ball for.

waterlego · 03/02/2022 09:16

So true @Postdatedpandemic. I assume many of those who buy pugs, Frenchies etc actually don’t really like going for walks so they choose a breed that can just about cope with a ten minute plod round the block once or twice a day.

I’ll admit I judge people who buy Frenchies and pugs from a breeder. Either they know about the health issues and they don’t care, or they haven’t bothered to spend five minutes Googling their chosen breed.

Postdatedpandemic · 03/02/2022 09:01

People like brachycephalic breeds, they come with built in brakes. If dogs all had the snout of a fox, legs of an African wild dog and lung capacity of a husky, owners would have to put in a lot of physical effort. Many dog owners do not want to do that.

Bitofachinwag · 03/02/2022 08:56

@FFSFFSFFS

I am So sad that Cavaliers are one of the two. I don’t understand why they haven’t just put in place much more rigorous bedding protocols which could Then breed out the health problems (mainly heart and syringomelia). It’s definitely a breed that can be saved if the work is done
Yes, it probably could.

They don't have flat faces.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 03/02/2022 08:55

Completely agree. Bog standard heinz 57 can't be had anymore (I spent years looking). We went for a Westie in the end as seems few inherited traits or problems. Just don't get the whole flat nose thing

JuergenSchwarzwald · 03/02/2022 08:36

Totally agree OP - so many dogs have major health problems from being bred to look pretty. It is outrageous. I don't even like dogs and I see a massive problem with it, yet so-called dog lovers have them as fur babies pets.

FFSFFSFFS · 03/02/2022 08:32

@SirSniffsAlot I know it’s so sad. I know there is a lot of work done in the uk by some cavalier group but then I see so many others breeding their own pets without doing mri etc not to mention puppy farmers. I still think the breed can be saved but I am getting less hopeful

Pterygoid · 03/02/2022 08:27

Excellent news.
Dog breeding should be controlled in general, with bans and punishment on the feckless who breed their pets to make money.

IntermittentParps · 03/02/2022 08:20

Velvet, huskies can have issues including hip dysplasia, epilepsy and eye problems. You can't just say some breeds are healthier because of what they look like.
Careful breeding is one thing; it's overbreeding that's the problem.

SirSniffsAlot · 03/02/2022 08:16

@FFSFFSFFS

I am So sad that Cavaliers are one of the two. I don’t understand why they haven’t just put in place much more rigorous bedding protocols which could Then breed out the health problems (mainly heart and syringomelia). It’s definitely a breed that can be saved if the work is done
An estimated 95% of CKC carry the genes for the skull malformation that causes Syringomyelia. They are dogs with lovely temperaments but I am not sure the breed can be ethically saved now.
Swipe left for the next trending thread