Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be glad Norway is banning breeding deformed dogs?

130 replies

AnakinthePadawhine · 02/02/2022 18:53

Norway will ban the breeding of King Charles and British bulldogs. I hope that this will catch on in other countries, and force breeders and Kennel Clubs to change their stupid and harmful standards?
Can pugs and French bulldogs be next?

www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2022/02/02/norway-bans-breeding-british-bulldog-king-charles-cavalier-spaniel/

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Whitney168 · 07/02/2022 09:36

@SirSniffsAlot

It is, sadly, a real horse - and not the most extreme example I could have chosen. There are (even) worse.

Yes, cat breeding is getting as out of control as dogs. The obsession with flat faced animals - cats dog rabbits - is alarming.

Some of these very extreme Arabs are truly disturbing now. Angry
Whitney168 · 07/02/2022 09:35

I am sure this will just be the start and there will be other breeds to come, so many which now seem to be so far away from a healthy population. French Bulldogs, Pugs surely next, for popularity, but others to come.

Seems a huge shame for Cavaliers, which are such a popular pet. I really wanted a Cavalier, but just couldn't bring myself to buy one as so few breeders are doing all the health testing needed, you'd be forever waiting (years, not talking 'oh I want it now') for a pup with sufficient testing. I hope breeders do heed this warning and get on top of it fast. It does seem that there would need to be some outcrossing to bring it back.

That said - there are plenty of registered breeds that are very healthy with years of science applied to health testing to get the breed in a very good position - and in no way should people assume that poorly bred designer crossbreeds are in any way the answer.

FFSFFSFFS · 06/02/2022 14:13

Cavalier Matters in the UK does awareness raising work

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 06/02/2022 12:56

I saw a poor thing trying to walk along the road the other day. It appeared to be a British Bulldog, but it looked all out of proportion and was struggling to walk. It had a squashed face and its body was too big for its legs.

When I was a lass, everyone had mongrels - healthy, hardy things with minimal neuroses or behaviour problems.

powershowerforanhour · 06/02/2022 12:41

Here's another horse- video near the bottom
horseyhooves.com/el-rey-magnum-arabian-horse-breeding/

Mumoblue · 06/02/2022 09:51

Good! We should be doing that here.

“Purebreds” are nonsense, and dogs are just going to keep getting sicker as breeders continue inbreeding them.

TheLeadbetterLife · 06/02/2022 09:44

@freckles20

Does anyone know if there are any UK based organisations trying to tackle this, or raise awareness?
I don’t know, but there should be.

A good start would be for people to stop regarding Kennel Clubs as the experts and arbiters of what a dog is, and see them for what they are - the self-appointed overseers of unregulated, incestuous genetic experiments.

A dog is a dog. Breeds are not real, they’re a social construct and Kennel Clubs seem to be a form of collective delusion perpetuated by people with too much time and money. No-one needs these poor, freak animals. They seem to be a by-product of 20th century wealth and leisure.

Some selective breeding for useful working traits is one thing, and the vast majority of the world’s working dogs are mutts, because aesthetic “standards” are irrelevant.

The KCs are not interested in the welfare and health of dogs. Restricting gene pools is always a one-way street to deformity, brain damage and ultimately extinction. Look at the Hapsburgs.

ClaraTheCelebrityPachyderm · 06/02/2022 01:45

Well done Norway. Breeding deliberately deformed animals is inhumane and downright criminal in my opinion. The breeders of these poor dogs are not dog lovers they're only in it for the money, and the buyers of these dogs are not dog lovers either. It breaks my heart to see these fashion statement pugs/bulldogs etc that waddle along gasping for breath.

SirSniffsAlot · 06/02/2022 01:37

It is, sadly, a real horse - and not the most extreme example I could have chosen. There are (even) worse.

Yes, cat breeding is getting as out of control as dogs. The obsession with flat faced animals - cats dog rabbits - is alarming.

freckles20 · 06/02/2022 01:35

Does anyone know if there are any UK based organisations trying to tackle this, or raise awareness?

Nevermindful · 06/02/2022 00:41

@SirSniffsAlot

And this is not a uniquely dog problem - though maybe they have suffered first so suffered the worst. Cats and rabbits both now being bred with flat faces. Excessive fur and too long/short ears also. Horses now being bred with increasingly concave faces.

It's going to get worst across all those species yet, I fear.

Is that an actual horse and not a photo shop? I had no idea that was a thing, surely you just want a horse to be … a horse?

It’s appalling what is being done to animals., and with no thought. I do worry about cats. I had a look at cats for sale (not actually going to buy one. I was just curious). It was all ragdoll mixes. Scottish folds. Various hairless options. Very flat faced Persians. I’m fairly sure that 90% of the ragdoll mixes were just slightly fluffy moggies. But even so.

longwayoff · 05/02/2022 14:48

Couldn't agree more. KC is appalling presiding over and encouraging these Frankenstein creations. Can't express enough contempt for them and all associates.

Buildingthefuture · 05/02/2022 08:21

I think it’s a very good thing and I hope it happens here and is increased to cover many more breeds that have so many physical problems bred into them. The KC is a shit show, an utterly irresponsible organisation.

SirSniffsAlot · 05/02/2022 08:17

And this is not a uniquely dog problem - though maybe they have suffered first so suffered the worst. Cats and rabbits both now being bred with flat faces. Excessive fur and too long/short ears also. Horses now being bred with increasingly concave faces.

It's going to get worst across all those species yet, I fear.

To be glad Norway is banning breeding deformed dogs?
To be glad Norway is banning breeding deformed dogs?
To be glad Norway is banning breeding deformed dogs?
freckles20 · 05/02/2022 01:32

@TheLeadbetterLife

I didn't say all cross breeds are automatically healthy. I'm saying the entire concept of creating and perpetuating breeds based on aesthetics is utterly disgusting, and hopefully one day people will look back on the practice with horror.

If someone decided to take an unusually short-legged person and make them reproduce with another unusually short-legged person, then continue to mate their descendants until they created a human "breed" with impractically short legs (plus inevitable genetic diseases), they'd be jailed.

That's literally all dog breeding is.

@TheLeadbetterLife I completely agree. It's horrific what we have allowed to happen to 'man's best friend' .

Problematic cross breeding is an issue too- but it is a separate issue with different problems.

freckles20 · 05/02/2022 01:29

It's a step in the right direction, but the tip of a disgusting iceberg which illustrates how monstrous humans can be.

We have created Frankenstein monsters by breeding for traits that have no relation to dog health, temperament or longevity.

I work with dogs and am amazed to find so many owners who simply had no idea of these issues when they selected their new puppy. They just chose a dog that they liked the look of. I strongly believe there needs to be more communication about this because too many people unwittingly choose a dog without being aware of these issues. These people are good people, who care deeply about their dog but were naive.

I know that the issue is huge and the juggernaut of unscrupulous breeding feels unstoppable- but I still think we need to try to gain control of this.

A complete overhaul of breed standards would be a great start- or let's even ban them altogether as I fail to see that they prioritise dog welfare at all.

I have a labrador. He is a working type build and he is small, and compact and slim. He is beautiful, but fails every labrador breed standard- his legs are too fine (which means he is lighter and may have better joint health as a result), he is too small (again this is likely to be beneficial to joint health), the gap between his front legs is too short (because he is small and slim), his head is too narrow, his legs are too long compared to his body. In a nutshell, to be considered 'well bred and to have good confirmation for KC standards' he should be heavier boned, shorter legged but with a bigger body, heavier broader head, wider gap between front legs etc.. All those things make for a handsome but big, heavy, cumbersome dog- in a breed which has challenges with joint health. It is a joke. Generally labradors which look like mine have less joint issues and can enjoy exercise freely to a great age. The heavier ones begin to struggle much sooner- it is so so sad to see.

TheLeadbetterLife · 05/02/2022 01:10

I didn't say all cross breeds are automatically healthy. I'm saying the entire concept of creating and perpetuating breeds based on aesthetics is utterly disgusting, and hopefully one day people will look back on the practice with horror.

If someone decided to take an unusually short-legged person and make them reproduce with another unusually short-legged person, then continue to mate their descendants until they created a human "breed" with impractically short legs (plus inevitable genetic diseases), they'd be jailed.

That's literally all dog breeding is.

Thelnebriati · 05/02/2022 00:53

It really isn't, and its a mistake to think all cross breeds are automatically healthy. Any cross can have an unwanted outcome.

TheLeadbetterLife · 05/02/2022 00:29

@Thelnebriati

Breeding records are essential to record bad matings that you don't want to repeat.
Only within the mad world of inbreeding animals for aesthetic reasons. It's circular logic.
Lifeisaminestrone · 04/02/2022 23:14

@yorkshireteaspoonie

I love cavaliers too. They are the most affectionate and loving dogs. There are some horrific breeders out there but there are some healthy well bred ones too.

Thelnebriati · 04/02/2022 17:08

Breeding records are essential to record bad matings that you don't want to repeat.

SantaClawsServiette · 04/02/2022 14:18

Yeah, there should be no serious need for breed books and purebred dogs, especially for pets. All it does is restrict the genetic pool.

It's actually quite difficult to find a mixed dog where I live.

You are actually more likely to find crosses used in some high performance working dogs like sled dogs. Racing sled dogs are very often a real mix of breeds. Even with dog racing there is genetic testing to make sure other breeds haven't been added to gain an advantage - that should tell us something.

TheLeadbetterLife · 04/02/2022 13:43

@Ylvamoon

even if breeders outbreed and start making them healthier, the non-freak dogs won’t be “recognised” by the Kennel Clubs

Totally agree! Search Levitt (?) bulldogs.

Also, when I was looking for a (healthy) dog from a breeder, I was told that it's ok to breed a carrier (for an genetic condition) with non carriers, especially if they are successful in the show ring.
Breeding for health is very difficult as you automatically move away from the perfect dog as per KC...

And that's exactly why the KCs should be disbanded. How can the idea of a perfect dog can be anything other than a healthy one?

Where I live, in Portugal, there are shepherds and goatherds everywhere, They all have dogs - some big, some medium-sized, some for guarding, some for herding. They're all intelligent and healthy, and they're all mutts. There's no reason why even a working dog has to be inbred (and the longer the line is bred, the higher the change it'll no longer be healthy or intelligent).

It's all absolute bollocks, and it makes me sick what these people do, while calling themselves dog lovers. There's no love, it's just greed.

Ylvamoon · 04/02/2022 13:16

even if breeders outbreed and start making them healthier, the non-freak dogs won’t be “recognised” by the Kennel Clubs

Totally agree! Search Levitt (?) bulldogs.

Also, when I was looking for a (healthy) dog from a breeder, I was told that it's ok to breed a carrier (for an genetic condition) with non carriers, especially if they are successful in the show ring.
Breeding for health is very difficult as you automatically move away from the perfect dog as per KC...

Swipe left for the next trending thread