Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to find the new Highway Code rules intimidating?

35 replies

Coffeeholix · 02/02/2022 14:05

Just to be clear, I’m a pretty confident person and not necessarily easily intimidated, but when out walking my dog I prefer to cross the road in my own time. I have trained my dog to sit and wait before crossing a road and have never liked cars stopping and waving us across unless there’s an island in the middle so I don’t have to worry about cars coming the other way not stopping. I like to cross in my own time.

With the new rules, I feel harassed. For example, there is a road I have to cross which is by a mini roundabout. So the cars coming off the roundabout should stop if I’m waiting. However, the road bends round a little and cars coming towards the roundabout often don’t see me until the last minute and aren’t obliged to stop and let me cross anyway. Sometimes I get the impression cars heading into my road, not yet crossed the roundabout, are sitting waiting for me to cross before they even reach my road, other times cars stop really abruptly and wait for me to cross but they aren’t stopping from the other direction.

It just creates confusion and stress and the car waiting for me to cross is probably swearing under their breath, along with traffic behind them, because I’m not moving fast enough. I hate keeping people waiting.

Anyway, sorry this is a slightly long post but does anyone else feel uncomfortable about these new rules? Or is it just me?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kazzyhoward · 02/02/2022 20:06

@Whitefire

There's a difference between slowing down and coming to a halt.
If it's a typical 90 degree turn onto a narrower road in a built up area, then the car turning should probably be down to 15-20 mph, maybe less depending on visibility around the corner. They certainly shouldn't be turning at 40 mph+. Anyway, they should be indicating and braking (hence brake lights), so the cars behind should be well aware of the potential for the car turning to slow or stop.
Whitefire · 02/02/2022 19:55

There's a difference between slowing down and coming to a halt.

WindyState · 02/02/2022 19:24

@Whitefire

I was wondering about this today, I go past a turn for a new housing estate that has a lot of foot traffic going over. The road it is off is NSL, so potentially you could have a car at an absolute standstill on a 60mph lane.
Do cars turning off it not, y'know, slow down to make the turning?
bungaloid · 02/02/2022 19:08

I find it psychologically interesting that we are all conditioned to yield to the almighty car and this change has made me ponder this. Why should it be an imperative not to delay a car, why can't those bastards wait a few seconds for a pedestrian, cyclist or horse rider (I say that as a bastard car driver).

Kazzyhoward · 02/02/2022 18:57

@Whitefire

I was wondering about this today, I go past a turn for a new housing estate that has a lot of foot traffic going over. The road it is off is NSL, so potentially you could have a car at an absolute standstill on a 60mph lane.
How is that different to if there was any other obstruction on the side road, i.e. bin lorry, etc?
lampygirl · 02/02/2022 18:44

I feel it’s been taken a bit far. It’s only at junctions for a start, so if you are crossing the high street mid way along drivers do not have to stop, just wait and cross as normal. Drivers stopping and beckoning people across at random traffic calming islands on straight roads are not correct. I’m the same as you though OP. Whether walking or using a cycle path where it crosses a road if I’ve come to a stop I hate drivers who beckon me across. I don’t mind if they obviously flash and slow down while I’m still moving but if I’ve come to a stop I feel a need to ‘reset’ before going again so the car has made me stop by not looking like it will let you across, then last minute let you across, then look annoyed when you don’t go quickly enough.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 02/02/2022 18:31

@WindyState

The rules are there to encourage drivers to have more awareness towards pedestrians. That's it. No one is forcing you to cross the road if you don't want to.
So does it become a bit of a standoff? The driver stops to let the pedestrian cross, the pedestrian doesn't cross, the driver is supposed to stop so doesn't move....
Hawkins001 · 02/02/2022 18:28

One driver today seemed to forgot the rules that pedestrians have priority as they turned into a car park and turned straight in front of me, rather than waiting until I had crossed

megletthesecond · 02/02/2022 18:09

Yanbu.
I'm mostly a pedestrian and I will continue to not budge until the road is clear in my opinion. I'm not leaving my safety up to drivers.

I've drummed it into my kids too. Don't move until it's clear and never move even if a driver gestures you.

inthewest · 02/02/2022 18:04

I quite like it and have interpreted as a hierarchy, with the most vulnerable road users having more right to way so a pedestrian over a car or cyclist, but also a car over a lorry etc. as they are the most likely to be killed or seriously injured in a collision.

Whitefire · 02/02/2022 17:59

I was wondering about this today, I go past a turn for a new housing estate that has a lot of foot traffic going over. The road it is off is NSL, so potentially you could have a car at an absolute standstill on a 60mph lane.

Pinkymcperky · 02/02/2022 17:42

Seems to me the rule has been out in place to protect all the people in their phones or with headphones in who step into the road without looking. I’ve always looked out for them anyway, you could always see in advance who wasn’t going to stop. I think there will be less accidents

UselessASD · 02/02/2022 17:34

I’m a pedestrian and don’t like the rule. I’m partially sighted and find speed difficult to tell as well as seeing that a driver is waving me across the road. Even before the rules I’ve had at least one driver swear at me for not crossing (when the started again and were level with me).

I can see the rule is clear, but don’t think enough drivers are aware of it. Even if I am correct and have right of way I’ll come off much worse if I cross and a car or larger vehicle doesn’t stop.

WindyState · 02/02/2022 17:26

Well yes. You will always get arseholes. No amount of rewriting the HC will change that.

In reality what people are going to do is pretty much carry on as normal. Pedestrians will cross if it's safe to do so and decent drivers will be looking out for pedestrians crossing or about to cross.

Twentypast · 02/02/2022 17:22

@WindyState

This is the rule:

"At a junction, drivers, motorcyclists, horse riders and cyclists should give way to pedestrians crossing or waiting to cross a road into which or from which you are turning."

It's not confusing. Motorists just need to look out for pedestrians waiting to cross when they are turning into roads. This is not difficult. The driver would be slowing down (and following cars likewise) to make the turn. If a pedestrian doesn't want to cross they can remain where they are or wave the car on.

The amount of angst over this is absurd.

In theory anyway. Today I was crossing. I had started to cross and a car turned into the side road and had no intention of stopping. I actually had to step back towards the kerb.

With the new rules he should have stopped even if I hadn't started to cross let alone with me already being in the road.

I got a mouthful of abuse - which was nice....NOT.

Kazzyhoward · 02/02/2022 17:14

@WindyState

This is the rule:

"At a junction, drivers, motorcyclists, horse riders and cyclists should give way to pedestrians crossing or waiting to cross a road into which or from which you are turning."

It's not confusing. Motorists just need to look out for pedestrians waiting to cross when they are turning into roads. This is not difficult. The driver would be slowing down (and following cars likewise) to make the turn. If a pedestrian doesn't want to cross they can remain where they are or wave the car on.

The amount of angst over this is absurd.

Yep, fully agree. People making a big deal out of nothing, If a pedestrian doesn't want to cross, then they can just stand back on the pavement rather than waiting at the edge - that's a pretty clear signal to traffic they're not ready to cross.
JuergenSchwarzwald · 02/02/2022 17:08

This is interesting. I was out running yesterday evening and stopped in the middle of a road on a traffic island as a car was coming. There was nothing behind it so I was happy to wait but he stopped for me. I hadn't thought that it was down to the new rules but maybe it was. I think that is misinterpreting them - if I am on a safe traffic island they don't have to stop especially if there is nothing behind them.

Coffeeholix · 02/02/2022 16:27

@WindyState

This is the rule:

"At a junction, drivers, motorcyclists, horse riders and cyclists should give way to pedestrians crossing or waiting to cross a road into which or from which you are turning."

It's not confusing. Motorists just need to look out for pedestrians waiting to cross when they are turning into roads. This is not difficult. The driver would be slowing down (and following cars likewise) to make the turn. If a pedestrian doesn't want to cross they can remain where they are or wave the car on.

The amount of angst over this is absurd.

Yes the written rule is clear, however in practice it’s not as straight forward. For one thing pedestrians do not want to be harassed by drivers who think they’re doing the right thing by stopping and waving them across only to get aggressive when the pedestrian does not cross. And yes I have seen this happen, and said driver has sped off in a huff.

For another thing, have children who walk to school on their own got enough confidence to ignore a waiting driver or is this going to panic them into crossing when a car is coming the other way? I’ve talked to my kids about this, but I’m not sure enough info has been put out there for other parents to do the same.

OP posts:
TheChip · 02/02/2022 16:22

@WindyState

This is the rule:

"At a junction, drivers, motorcyclists, horse riders and cyclists should give way to pedestrians crossing or waiting to cross a road into which or from which you are turning."

It's not confusing. Motorists just need to look out for pedestrians waiting to cross when they are turning into roads. This is not difficult. The driver would be slowing down (and following cars likewise) to make the turn. If a pedestrian doesn't want to cross they can remain where they are or wave the car on.

The amount of angst over this is absurd.

Thats not bad then. That's what was in the theory
WindyState · 02/02/2022 16:08

This is the rule:

"At a junction, drivers, motorcyclists, horse riders and cyclists should give way to pedestrians crossing or waiting to cross a road into which or from which you are turning."

It's not confusing. Motorists just need to look out for pedestrians waiting to cross when they are turning into roads. This is not difficult. The driver would be slowing down (and following cars likewise) to make the turn. If a pedestrian doesn't want to cross they can remain where they are or wave the car on.

The amount of angst over this is absurd.

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 02/02/2022 16:02

I'm a dog walker and I like to cross in my own time as well. It's going to be confusing for both pedestrians and motorists.

I wonder how assistance dogs are going to manage.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 02/02/2022 15:40

@TheChip

I've just done my theory test not long before the new change. A lot of it was on about cyclists and how they have priority etc. But nothing was in there about pedestrians like is mentioned on here.

It even stated that you should not wave them across the road incase traffic at the other side doesn't stop and causes an accident.

Is this now the case? If so it's a bit stupid for the reason I just mentioned.

It even stated that you should not wave them across the road incase traffic at the other side doesn't stop and causes an accident.

There is long-standing case law on this holding a drive who waved a pedestrian across a road was held partly to blame for the pedestrian's injuries when they were struck by another vehicle.

Namechangehereandnow · 02/02/2022 15:28

The new rules are ridiculous … I’m all for letting pedestrians across the road, but there are times that’s just not safe - and, like yourself, some pedestrians prefer to do as they feel safe/dog behaviour etc … I think the rules are just going to cause lots of confusion, lots of aggression 🤷🏻‍♀️

WindyState · 02/02/2022 15:21

Well if traffic stops and waits for you, you can always just stay on the pavement or wave them on. As I said, nobody is forcing you to cross. Who cares if the driver is "put out?"

It means that drivers are required to be watching for pedestrians on street corners as they turn into side roads. This is a good thing.

Coffeeholix · 02/02/2022 14:52

@WindyState

The rules are there to encourage drivers to have more awareness towards pedestrians. That's it. No one is forcing you to cross the road if you don't want to.
I do want to cross the road, just don’t want traffic to stop and wait for me. If I cross, I’m risking a car not seeing me from the other direction, if I don’t cross then the stopped driver is confused and put out and probably thinks I’m being “difficult”.

I just don’t see how this protects pedestrians.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread