Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand this about pronouns?

219 replies

HaveringWavering · 01/02/2022 22:11

When people state their pronouns they always say she/her, he/him or they/them.
Why the second part? Doesn’t everyone know that “her” goes with “she”, “him” goes with “he” etc?

Are there people who mix and match- she/him, they/her?

OP posts:
strawberrrycheeesecake · 02/02/2022 06:15

Can I just ask though- what if you met someone where you genuinely couldn't tell what they were? I had this recently where someone asked me a question where I had to refer to someone whose name I didn't know in my answer and I 100% could not tell you what gender they were at all. I asked a friend what I should have done because if I'd said "he has one" or "she has one" I wouldn't have had any idea if I was calling them by the wrong thing. I wouldn't like if it I was a masculin looking woman ans referred to as "he" nor I guess if I was feminine looking man and called "he". I don't want to make people sad so I'm happy to use pronouns wherever people have stated them 🤷‍♀️


Then surely referring to that person as they/them would suffice if you genuinely didn't know if male or female?!

LoisLane66 · 02/02/2022 06:12

I CBA with any PC nonsense. Never have and never will subscribe to it.

MimiDaisy11 · 02/02/2022 06:12

I started watching a YouTube video about a topic I was interested in. Nothing to do with feminism or gender etc. The host specified her pronouns as She/her/hers with pauses between each one. I wonder if there’s anyone who wants their possessive pronoun different from the others 😂.
Her name was something like Lucy or Sarah and was clearly female so not like anyone would have thought differently. I stopped watching.

TheCurrywurstPrion · 02/02/2022 05:55

I hope it’s a fad that will soon die out. I find it boring and infuriating in equal measure.

MoreSmoresthansnores · 02/02/2022 05:37

@Ozgirl75

It’s times like this that I’m glad I don’t really know anyone between the age of 15 and 35 because if someone told me how to refer to them behind their back, I would consider them an absolute fool and would simply refer to them as “that bloody blue haired twat”
Grin
MoreSmoresthansnores · 02/02/2022 05:35

Yes. It's something that only people with too much time on their hands do. It adds nothing to Trans inclusion and in my opinion just makes people care less about it all by diminishing it.
My 13 yo declared within 30 seconds of watching the most recent Queen eye that the presenter who is very obviously a gay male was an attention-seeker and she even said (and I must admit I was quite proud/realised I'd indoctrinated her well) that he was 'picking out the bits of woman he wanted while still being a man, and telling women what to wear and how to look'.
Isn't it enough you're a man without also now wanting to own 'she'? Bit grabby taking our pronouns too!
A 13 year old knew this.

Ozgirl75 · 02/02/2022 05:28

It’s times like this that I’m glad I don’t really know anyone between the age of 15 and 35 because if someone told me how to refer to them behind their back, I would consider them an absolute fool and would simply refer to them as “that bloody blue haired twat”

RegardingMary · 02/02/2022 05:23

God knows OP

When I was at uni at briefly lived with a girl whose partner was non binary. They flitted between he / they / she sometimes on an hourly basis, with absolutely no heads up either verbally or based on what they wore. My flatmate would become incandescent with rage if you ever used the wrong pronoun, even when 2 hours earlier it was the right one.

When I think of those pronouns added on thd end of emails I always imagine them spending all day repeatedly changing their email signature

garlictwist · 02/02/2022 05:12

I work with university students who love a good pronoun and like to announce them at the start of teams calls.

One guy always says his pronouns are he/them. That does not make sense to me.

Anycrispsleft · 02/02/2022 05:02

I think it's to pad it out, so it sounds more like some sort of official Thing.

daisychain01 · 02/02/2022 04:54

@giveyou2reasons

YANBU! It's ridiculous.

As for the "what do you do if you can't tell if they're male/female or want to be recognised as male/female", you just do the best you can, probably avoid using any pronouns at all in their presence. At a pinch, I'd use "they". Tbh, if they're offended by someone not knowing their gender, they need to give clear cues (clothing, hair, etc). If it's important to someone, it's rarely that difficult to communicate nonverbally that they're a man or a woman (or want to be perceived as such). I'd never intentionally offend, but I can't read someone's mind (or DNA).

I've had to drill it into myself to use they/them for everyone. It's a very unnatural way of thinking and speaking

I expect there's bound to be a time I'll get told that "they/them" won't do for so-and-so because they insist on being called she, just to keep everyone on high alert.

daisychain01 · 02/02/2022 04:47

@Franca123

I've met a lot of people and this has never happened to me. I'll cross that bridge when I come to it.
I'd prepare yourself in advance, rehearse in front of the mirror and make sure you're word perfect.

Take it from me, when you encounter this pronoun Olympics stuff it can take you by surprise and you end up saying it wrong and get pounced on by the pronoun police. "Don't you know 'Ali' wants to be known as they/them/their when they aren't in the room and can't hear you anyway."

It's like the bloody thought police.

A massive power trip imo.

HappyDays40 · 02/02/2022 04:26

They have started talking about people putting pronouns on ends of emails now. I will try to use preferred pronouns but cwill not remember people chop and change.

GreenWheat · 02/02/2022 04:09

Personally I just put GreenWheat (I/You/He/She /It/You(pl) /We/They). Job done 😁.

IndigoC · 02/02/2022 02:59

@AutomaticMoon

I must only be addressed as Your Highnyness
My husband recently informed me that he identifies as a deity and his pronouns are God/Him. 😂
dipdye · 02/02/2022 02:22

Does it mean we have to call them that?

Hello 'he'

Sounds a bit, un, odd?

Or is it so we know he's a man/woman? He's called Eric?!

What's the point in it?

giveyou2reasons · 02/02/2022 02:18

YANBU! It's ridiculous.

As for the "what do you do if you can't tell if they're male/female or want to be recognised as male/female", you just do the best you can, probably avoid using any pronouns at all in their presence. At a pinch, I'd use "they". Tbh, if they're offended by someone not knowing their gender, they need to give clear cues (clothing, hair, etc). If it's important to someone, it's rarely that difficult to communicate nonverbally that they're a man or a woman (or want to be perceived as such). I'd never intentionally offend, but I can't read someone's mind (or DNA).

Cheeseplantboots · 02/02/2022 02:13

@TheresSomebodyAtTheDoorNeil

Fuck knows.

Some blue haired friend of dds demanded to know mine a while ago (( well slowly becoming ex friend. Dd finally saw sense and started backing off when she kept trying to convince her she must have an issue with SOMETHING.)) ..... She got the Paddington bear stare. (( I barely know the girl)) Im considering investing in a pair of glasses to perch onto the end of my nose for added effect Biscuit

My daughter has a friend like this too. She too is backing away from said friend. She said it’s exhausting being her friend.
Monty27 · 02/02/2022 02:08

@Ionlydomassiveones

Thankfully I don’t know a single person in RL who would even humour this crap. I hope it fades away as the non-thinking woke dipshits that sign up to it grow up.
Right there with you! Lost for words 😂
TheresSomebodyAtTheDoorNeil · 02/02/2022 02:04

Fuck knows.

Some blue haired friend of dds demanded to know mine a while ago (( well slowly becoming ex friend. Dd finally saw sense and started backing off when she kept trying to convince her she must have an issue with SOMETHING.)) ..... She got the Paddington bear stare. (( I barely know the girl)) Im considering investing in a pair of glasses to perch onto the end of my nose for added effect Biscuit

Kinneddar · 02/02/2022 01:53

I know someone who uses Mx/they. 🙄

Its a minefield!!!

Littlesnail · 02/02/2022 01:28

Personally, I think they're lacking ambition with only 2 pronouns.

If I have to start declaring pronouns, I'll use Latin - ea/eius/ei/eam/ea.
Then I can be offended both by the use of the wrong pronoun and by the shabby grammar of the offender.
Once they get the hang of dative/ablative etc, I might switch to Russian/other languages in cyrillic script.

Eightiesfan · 02/02/2022 01:22

I work in a boys secondary school where the use is rife amongst students to the degree that when speaking to the class collectively it has become uncomfortable to use the term boys or gentlemen as we have several students transitioning. One of them although registered with our school attends all his lessons at the girls school across the road. Schools are also dropping the term Head Boy/Girl and replacing it with Head Student which I am all in favour for.

However, hadn’t really thought about why it’s necessary to use both he.him etc but I am going to ask one of my students tomorrow!

Jacaranda75 · 02/02/2022 01:09

Load/of/attention/seeking/bollocks.

Aprilx · 02/02/2022 01:04

@Ionlydomassiveones

Thankfully I don’t know a single person in RL who would even humour this crap. I hope it fades away as the non-thinking woke dipshits that sign up to it grow up.
@Ionlydomassiveones

I have unfortunately started to see people do it on my LinkedIn, “real”people that I have worked with in the past, not random connections.

Only women though, I haven’t seen any men do it yet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread