Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand this about pronouns?

219 replies

HaveringWavering · 01/02/2022 22:11

When people state their pronouns they always say she/her, he/him or they/them.
Why the second part? Doesn’t everyone know that “her” goes with “she”, “him” goes with “he” etc?

Are there people who mix and match- she/him, they/her?

OP posts:
EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 02/02/2022 13:18

He/She/it (they?) isn't enough options for the 26 (or is it more now?) genders to be uniquely identified

It's >200 genders if I understand the uniqueness correctly. However, I don't think there are agreements about the pronouns and presentation for those and people's choice of presentation for each other those genders might influence the pronouns at any given moment.

user1471447863 · 02/02/2022 13:14

He/She/it (they?) isn't enough options for the 26 (or is it more now?) genders to be uniquely identified

If we can just make up out own pronouns then i'll be:
my name is:User147
my pronouns are: U+0007/U+0008

just to be extra awkward (and subtle about my thoughts on it)

Ionlydomassiveones · 02/02/2022 13:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

AndSoFinally · 02/02/2022 13:01

There needs to be a law stating people must demonstrate the correct use of there, they're, and their, before they're even allowed to think about buggering around with possessive pronouns 😡

eastegg · 02/02/2022 11:33

@MoreSmoresthansnores

I find it more shocking when I meet a young woman who insists on Mrs rather than first name... why... I dont get it at all. We all have labels we prefer for ourselves if we are honest. We don't all demand directives from HR about what we need to include on our email signatures to demonstrate those. (I'll have 'underpaid overqualified biological woman with caring responsibilities, don't call me son's-name-mum')
Love this. Can I have this label too please?
stripeyflowers · 02/02/2022 11:31

arargghhh *given

stripeyflowers · 02/02/2022 11:30

@babyjellyfish

The pressures, particularly on younger people, from the Woke sex and gender identity culture are producing an extremely confused and mixed-up generation. I do feel for them.

I think it would be better to just ignore it and wait for them to grow up/move on to the next fad, rather than legislating for this stuff to replace material reality in law.

Is this what becoming an old fogey feels like? I'm about to turn 36.

I agree. Their psychological development is being hijacked. They are not being give the chance to blossom and grow and 'realise' themselves.
babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 11:28

The pressures, particularly on younger people, from the Woke sex and gender identity culture are producing an extremely confused and mixed-up generation. I do feel for them.

I think it would be better to just ignore it and wait for them to grow up/move on to the next fad, rather than legislating for this stuff to replace material reality in law.

Is this what becoming an old fogey feels like? I'm about to turn 36.

MoreSmoresthansnores · 02/02/2022 11:27

A friend and I had exactly that conversation recently...we were catching up and friend said they bumped into X a mutual acquaintance who is now (very vocally on SM) non-binary. X isn't their new name BTW! Neither of us knew what pronouns to use to discuss this person. Until we both realised that between us it was compelled bollix and neither of us was going to judge the other. We reverted to She which was the pronoun we'd used for the previous 15 years we had all mutually known one another. X will never know this.

stripeyflowers · 02/02/2022 11:26

@babyjellyfish

I did have one experience of a young lad I just met telling his name along with information that he is asexual, and that 'most people are surprised when I tell them that.'

Good lord, why does he imagine anyone cares about his sexuality? Particularly people he has just met.

Yes, it's so wearying.

Incidentally, he is now no longer a 'he' called 'John' but a 'she' called 'Desdemona.'

The pressures, particularly on younger people, from the Woke sex and gender identity culture are producing an extremely confused and mixed-up generation. I do feel for them.

babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 11:24

In an NHS meeting last week where somebody spoke about how they felt disengaged from meetings where nobody but them were stating their pronouns. They made a point of not using pronouns during the meeting on the grounds that they didn't want to assume people's preferred pronouns so that is almost exactly how they spoke about others in the meeting.

Jesus, when does the actual work get done?

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 02/02/2022 11:23

but surely you wouldn't say "Jennifer called me yesterday and confirmed that Jennifer wanted all of those reporting to Jennifer to forward the initial draft to Jennifer and ask Jennifer to give Jennifer's approval before sending any emails on Jennifer's behalf" ?!

In an NHS meeting last week where somebody spoke about how they felt disengaged from meetings where nobody but them were stating their pronouns. They made a point of not using pronouns during the meeting on the grounds that they didn't want to assume people's preferred pronouns so that is almost exactly how they spoke about others in the meeting.

babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 11:09

That's always struck me as really odd, though. I agree that it's rude not to initially use/acknowledge somebody's name and launch straight into 'she' or 'he' - but surely you wouldn't say "Jennifer called me yesterday and confirmed that Jennifer wanted all of those reporting to Jennifer to forward the initial draft to Jennifer and ask Jennifer to give Jennifer's approval before sending any emails on Jennifer's behalf"?!

This is exactly what I do when talking about people such as Laurel Hubbard, Lia Thomas and Mridul Wadhwa, and I agree, it is unnatural and somewhat exhausting (but preferable to pretending the Emperor has very fine clothes).

babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 11:08

I did have one experience of a young lad I just met telling his name along with information that he is asexual, and that 'most people are surprised when I tell them that.'

Good lord, why does he imagine anyone cares about his sexuality? Particularly people he has just met.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/02/2022 11:03

I've had to drill it into myself to use they/them for everyone. It's a very unnatural way of thinking and speaking

I expect there's bound to be a time I'll get told that "they/them" won't do for so-and-so because they insist on being called she, just to keep everyone on high alert.

I really don't think that an English-speaking female expecting to be routinely referred to as 'she' in the third person can in any way be thought of as unreasonable or being difficult/demanding.

I’m afraid I’m old enough to have been brought up with “who’s she? The cat’s mother?” - for those not as antique as me, it means that it’s rude to refer to an absent person by a pronoun instead of their name.

That's always struck me as really odd, though. I agree that it's rude not to initially use/acknowledge somebody's name and launch straight into 'she' or 'he' - but surely you wouldn't say "Jennifer called me yesterday and confirmed that Jennifer wanted all of those reporting to Jennifer to forward the initial draft to Jennifer and ask Jennifer to give Jennifer's approval before sending any emails on Jennifer's behalf" ?! Confused

stripeyflowers · 02/02/2022 11:03

@donquixotedelamancha

I am so lucky to live in the North. I've never met someone who thinks they can dictate that others use heterodox grammar.

I really want to meet one, I'd have a lot of questions.

Me too. I am so looking forward to meeting them/him/her/it/those.

I did have one experience of a young lad I just met telling his name along with information that he is asexual, and that 'most people are surprised when I tell them that.'

I was indeed surprised myself. In my 50+ years on the planet I have never once announced myself with the words 'Hi, I am Jane and I am heterosexual.' Wine

babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 11:02

[quote HaveringWavering]@babyjellyfish great post. I studied French and was wondering about this. I love “wokisme” and “nothingburger”![/quote]
Glad you liked it!

Also worth noting that with the verbs where you either have an extra E or you don't, depending on the gender of the speaker, you cannot hear the difference in spoken French as the extra E is silent.

So in reality the gender of people has very little impact on written French, and even less impact on spoken French. Ironically, the gender of common nouns is far more significant.

LindaEllen · 02/02/2022 10:56

@SunshineArtist

I just use sex based pronouns for people, I don’t pander.
Good for you. Same.
HaveringWavering · 02/02/2022 10:53

@babyjellyfish great post. I studied French and was wondering about this. I love “wokisme” and “nothingburger”!

OP posts:
HaveringWavering · 02/02/2022 10:51

@Marmarind

So there is that, plus the fact that it only comes up when you’re not there to hear

I find it strange that people never refer to people as "he/she" while in a group setting.

"Granddad has been doing the garden, he's become very good at it, haven't you Dad?"

"Turn the music off, Emily is studying in here, she doesn't need the noise"

Surely it does get used at times when the person being referred to is present. I wouldn't say it's always rude.

I agree- “Who’s she, the cat’s mother?” is for situations where you don’t say the person’s name the first time you refer to them.

So in a meeting with a number of people- “I want to discuss the budget, but she said we don’t have time as she needs to join another call”, perhaps with a nod towards the person who said that.

Versus “I want to discuss the budget but Emily said we don’t have time as she needs to join another call”

I mean, I think that the whole specifying pronouns thing is a bit silly, but to say that we never use she/he/him/her/his/her while the person is part of the conversation (or written communication) is just wrong.

OP posts:
donquixotedelamancha · 02/02/2022 10:47

I am so lucky to live in the North. I've never met someone who thinks they can dictate that others use heterodox grammar.

I really want to meet one, I'd have a lot of questions.

APJ1 · 02/02/2022 10:24

I'm laughing so much at 'mew/mewself'! It's like a snooty, pretentious cat.

MiladyBerserko · 02/02/2022 10:22

I think we need to start asking how we find out if we have a cervix or not.

Will the NHS be issuing speclums?
Will they advise who should use them or where to put them in order to check if one is in possession of one ? Or will that be excluding some people who identify as having a cervix?

Marmarind · 02/02/2022 10:15

So there is that, plus the fact that it only comes up when you’re not there to hear

I find it strange that people never refer to people as "he/she" while in a group setting.

"Granddad has been doing the garden, he's become very good at it, haven't you Dad?"

"Turn the music off, Emily is studying in here, she doesn't need the noise"

Surely it does get used at times when the person being referred to is present. I wouldn't say it's always rude.

babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 10:11

@abeanbaked

Actually, my nhs trust sent out an email inviting 'anyone with a cervix' to book a smear, ffs. So I can imagine the terms 'chest feeding' and 'birthing person' will follow soon.
I'd be tempted to email them back asking whether you have a cervix or not.
Swipe left for the next trending thread