Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand this about pronouns?

219 replies

HaveringWavering · 01/02/2022 22:11

When people state their pronouns they always say she/her, he/him or they/them.
Why the second part? Doesn’t everyone know that “her” goes with “she”, “him” goes with “he” etc?

Are there people who mix and match- she/him, they/her?

OP posts:
Natty13 · 02/02/2022 20:02

@Theeyeballsinthesky

Yep it’s starts with people nodding along when Dave in accounts decides they’re a woman and starts using she/her because it’s the nice thing to do and ends with men in womens refuges, on all women shortlists and in woman’s sports because you’ve already accepted that men can be women right?
Yeah, I don't have a problem with this tbh.
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/02/2022 18:04

This is exactly what I do when talking about people such as Laurel Hubbard, Lia Thomas and Mridul Wadhwa, and I agree, it is unnatural and somewhat exhausting (but preferable to pretending the Emperor has very fine clothes).

In an NHS meeting last week where somebody spoke about how they felt disengaged from meetings where nobody but them were stating their pronouns. They made a point of not using pronouns during the meeting on the grounds that they didn't want to assume people's preferred pronouns so that is almost exactly how they spoke about others in the meeting.

Oh, I completely agree when you're up against the current Zeitgeist and people who introduce 'issues' - but when you have the 99.99% of people who both are and 'identify as' either female or male with the universally-understood associated pronouns, without any drama, it would be pointless.

Person who wrote it used “they/them” throughout the entire report to refer to the man involved in the incident. Hubby changed it to “involved/injured person” throughout because the report was reading as though more than 1 person was involved. Then 2 people paid him a visit. Asked him why he changed the “inclusive” language. So he told them “It’s confusing language. This is a legal document.

Did the man involved identify as anything other than standard male? If there was no knowledge/suggestion that he did, but somebody still insisted on avoiding the use of 'he' to refer to him, surely the whole nature of inclusive language is such that it must also include the 99.99% of people who do identify as she or he - corresponding with their biological sex - and do not wish or accept to have 'they' assigned to them against their will?

How can 'inclusivity' be deliberately designed to exclude almost everybody?!

Lostinafjord · 02/02/2022 17:51

Found a wonderful list of further neo-pronouns
neopronouns-list.tumblr.com/

MoreSmoresthansnores · 02/02/2022 17:36

My employer is all over the pronouns thing and other 'trendy' inclusivity issues.... but pays its predominantly female workforce wages so low that many colleagues have 2 jobs, get UC, can't afford pensions and in some cases have had to access hardship funds. Yet they've managed to send us on multiple training courses about all kinds of things like this. I can't say more in case its outing. But when I was asked to do pronouns on email signatures you can imagine how receptive to that I was! Most of the directors are men. And they all earn over 90k a year, some over £150k.
So yes. We do need to wake up.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 02/02/2022 17:29

Yep it’s starts with people nodding along when Dave in accounts decides they’re a woman and starts using she/her because it’s the nice thing to do and ends with men in womens refuges, on all women shortlists and in woman’s sports because you’ve already accepted that men can be women right?

babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 17:25

Why does it matter? Read them, accept them and honour them. Just like you wouldn't want someone to refer to you incorrectly.

Because using the pronoun "she" to refer to a male person implies that we believe trans women are women.

And if we all do that, the International Olympic Committee listens and says, "since we all agree that trans women are women, it's fine for Laurel Hubbard to compete as one".

Respecting the pronoun nonsense will be interpreted as giving tacit consent to the word "woman" being rendered meaningless.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 02/02/2022 17:25

Ah I see the beee kind brigade have arrived

Pronouns in emails signatures show you agree with an ideology that says a man is a woman because he says he is

No thank you

MoreSmoresthansnores · 02/02/2022 17:22

@LampLighter414 I read and accept (begrudgingly) a lot of things. I usually honour them too. It's called being a functioning member of society / responsible employee.
I think those who are campaigning for this kind of thing to be standard and saying its nothing, its a courtesy etc (incidentally I think its dying out anyway so not many) are not that interested in reading wider on the subject and understanding the wider issues. And its a huge tick box for employers who genuinely don't actually care on any real level. No 'side' is a winner.
Rather than shouting down us 'dinosaurs/terfs/Karen's/old bags etc perhaps stop for a second to think why it isn't as harmless as it seems.
And I say that as someone who has spent a lifetime campaigning for inclusion and would never deliberately hurt/offend anyone. It's one of the most Sheep things I have seen in the last 5 years or so (and there's a lot of competition for that)

FuzzyPuffling · 02/02/2022 17:05

Surely the neutral singular is "it", not "they"?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 17:03

@LampLighter414

Why does it matter? Read them, accept them and honour them. Just like you wouldn't want someone to refer to you incorrectly.
Honour? I don't go around honouring anyone much!
LampLighter414 · 02/02/2022 17:02

Why does it matter? Read them, accept them and honour them. Just like you wouldn't want someone to refer to you incorrectly.

babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 16:36

You inspect the genitals of everyone you encounter? Bit weird.You inspect the genitals of everyone you encounter? Bit weird.

No. Helpfully, humans have evolved to develop a variety of secondary sex characteristics post puberty which make adult men and women look obviously different from each other and prevent us from wasting our time and gametes accidentally trying to mate with members of the same sex.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 16:34

P.S. does it puzzle you that before women first got the vote in 1918, there are no records of men being required to prove they had a penis before they went into the ballot box?

How did the men tell who wasn't entitled to vote? Hmm?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 16:31

You inspect the genitals of everyone you encounter? Bit weird.

Unless you're an alien from outer space, no-one needs to do that to tell men and women apart.

Welcome to Earth, btw. Have you tried French cuisine yet?

jaggynettles1 · 02/02/2022 16:28

@SunshineArtist

I just use sex based pronouns for people, I don’t pander.
You inspect the genitals of everyone you encounter? Bit weird.
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 16:22

By the way, talking of emoji pronouns, I came across some people using pawprint 🐾 emojis as pronouns, which were supposed to be pronounced they/them/theirs as appropriate.

When I read through with the attention required, I noticed the writer was using the pawprints for there too. If you can't distinguish between their, there and they're, maybe you're not ready to invent new pronouns and educate us all on their use.

babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 16:05

@PurgatoryOfPotholes Yes, that's it! Well done.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/02/2022 15:58

@babyjellyfish

That was Halsey.

The article that covered the furore ended up alternating she/her and they/them through the entire piece.

Surely there is a risk of readers not understanding whether the article is about a single person or more than one person?

I saw something just recently where somebody had been pulled up for not using "they/them" pronouns for another person and responded to say that in the context (which was medical) it needed to be absolutely clear that there was only one person and not several people, and using "they/them" could have confused things.

I wish I could remember what it was.

You may be recalling this

Hubby had to review an incident report at work today. Person who wrote it used “they/them” throughout the entire report to refer to the man involved in the incident. Hubby changed it to “involved/injured person” throughout because the report was reading as though more than 1 1/

person was involved. Then 2 people paid him a visit. Asked him why he changed the “inclusive” language. So he told them “It’s confusing language. This is a legal document. It reads in the plural. There can be no confusion about how many people are involved in the incident”. 2/

& they walked away with a flea in their ear, back to HR. Guess what colour hair they had. Hubby wasn’t being a nob. The document was incoherent. If needed in a court case it would be thrown out. This is what unnatural & forced change of language is doing to us. #SexNotGender end/

twitter.com/Sal_Robins/status/1485944990539063303?t=aTBO2JxKrIgcOdp2T9IZ_g&s=19

IntermittentParps · 02/02/2022 14:59

@VeryQuaintIrene

Still giggling about "mew". Dare I add it to my email signature, I wonder (I do have 5 cats)?
I'd love to do the same, and maybe a cat face picture too Grin
VeryQuaintIrene · 02/02/2022 14:38

Still giggling about "mew". Dare I add it to my email signature, I wonder (I do have 5 cats)?

user1471447863 · 02/02/2022 14:31

@AndSoFinally

There needs to be a law stating people must demonstrate the correct use of there, they're, and their, before they're even allowed to think about buggering around with possessive pronouns 😡
And your and you're too obviously. Additionally if they also don't know the difference between bought and brought it should be permissible to beat them to death with a Collins Dictionary.
VelvetChairGirl · 02/02/2022 14:04

just ignore it all and use name

babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 13:50

I would support both those laws!

HaveringWavering · 02/02/2022 13:46

@AndSoFinally

There needs to be a law stating people must demonstrate the correct use of there, they're, and their, before they're even allowed to think about buggering around with possessive pronouns 😡
Could we also, while we are at it, maybe extend the law to one which requires an exam on the appropriate use of the reflexive pronoun? If we can wipe out misuse of “myself” and “yourself” then at least something positive will have become of this renewed focus on pronouns!
OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 02/02/2022 13:42

@EmbarrassingHadrosaurus

He/She/it (they?) isn't enough options for the 26 (or is it more now?) genders to be uniquely identified

It's >200 genders if I understand the uniqueness correctly. However, I don't think there are agreements about the pronouns and presentation for those and people's choice of presentation for each other those genders might influence the pronouns at any given moment.

Of course, the more genders they invent, the more obvious it becomes that things such as toilets, prisons and sports are in fact supposed to be segregated according to sex (of which there are two), not gender.
Swipe left for the next trending thread