Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a child knowing they’ll spend 4 or 5 days in nursery?

383 replies

mvmvmvmv · 01/02/2022 19:58

AIBU to have a child knowing they’d likely be in nursery 4 days a week after my maternity, and likely going to 5 days a week by age 3? Is it unreasonable to have a child knowing they will need to spend so much time in nursery? Is it cruel?

We have zero family nearby, and family finances mean we both pretty much need to work full time (one of us could drop to 4 days for a year).

I don’t want to use a nanny or au pair as I’d want my child to have social interaction with other kids. There are v few childminders near us so unlikely to be an option. The local nursery is very good tho.

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 02/02/2022 12:42

I meant I'm not sure why so many people opt for having children when it means such a financial stretch that the child spends most of their week in childcare. Having children is a choice

What if your financial situation changes?
What about people who want to work? Are they not allowed children?

Joystir59 · 02/02/2022 12:34

@OfstedOffred

I know loads of families do this but I'm not sure why?

Because a family requires a home, food, elec/gas/water bills, clothes etc...

These things cost money, and where else does a normal family get money if not from work?

Generally speaking, short of abuse etc, poverty is the worst thing for a child in terms of long term impact. Working is the best way to prevent poverty.

Does that clear things up for you?

I meant I'm not sure why so many people opt for having children when it means such a financial stretch that the child spends most of their week in childcare. Having children is a choice
SpinsForGin · 02/02/2022 12:27

when they're effectively palmed off on to the cheapest childcare provider?

I can safely say there was nothing cheap about the nursery we used! It was more than our mortgage! But 100% worth it ...they were amazing.

Poppy709 · 02/02/2022 12:26

I am so shocked at how rude some people are being about women going to work.
Actually, being happy to leave their main caregiver is a sign of secure attachment, so a child missing nursery is fine!!

And I don’t even know what to say about this…

However if 12 hours a day in child care is the option some want to go for and think that the child is going to have well rounded relationships and a happy full life go for it

Attachment is my professional specialism (in the job I enjoy and wanted to return to) suggesting that going to nursery is going to prevent a child having positive relationships is nonsense.
I went back 3 days a week when my son was 9 months, and I consider myself immensely privileged to be part time. I’m going back full time when he is 2, and he will do 3 days a week in nursery and 2 with grandparents. We need the money, like others have said, one thing that will really screw a child over is poverty. The important thing is to make sure that the time you are with your child is quality time OP. I’m honestly so shocked with the people suggesting people who work full time shouldn’t have children, I love my job and I’m good at it. I’m a better mum because I work, I couldn’t be a SAHM.

SpinsForGin · 02/02/2022 12:25

Noone can say that under the age of 2 or 3, there is any gain from being away from their parents that isn't achieved after that age point.

This it true but it's also not detrimental for a child under the age of 2 to be in childcare provided that it is high quality childcare. While it might not be hugely beneficial for a young child to be in childcare it certainly isn't damaging...which is what some people are suggesting.

However, what is beneficial for a child is not living in poverty and having happy parents. Therefore, if this means parents going out to work and putting their young child in childcare it WILL be beneficial for the child overall.

Parents make decisions which are best for their family unit. For some, that involves one parent staying at home and for others it involves going out to work. Both are valid choices and we shouldn't be vilifying people ( although it's always aimed at women!) for making different choices to ones we have made.

MadameHeisenberg · 02/02/2022 12:21

I was a sahp 🤣🤣 Yep, no doubt.

ChoiceMummy · 02/02/2022 12:18

@MadameHeisenberg

SAH is a mug’s game, for all involved.

It’s not a foregone conclusion but often, by the time the child gets to school, they’re clingy, stressed-out and socially immature compared to their peers. They pick up every bug going and lose educational time while sick. They develop out-dated and sexist ideas about gender roles (having a career is only for men).

The mother (and it is overwhelmingly the mother), unless married to someone very rich (so almost nobody), damages their career prospects, pension, financial security & independence, becoming beholden to a man to keep her. This often causes power imbalances in relationships.

The Dad gets the easiest time of it, but he still shoulders the burden of being the only earner, which is a precarious situation for most (unless independently wealthy, and again that’s almost nobody).

Society loses out as SAHPs are economically inactive - they don’t contribute to general taxation and their skills in the workforce and communities are lost.

I’ve no doubt a select few people make it work whilst avoiding any of this, but they’re few and far between.

When Ofsted Inspect Children’s Centres, they will be assessing how well the Centre delivers the core purpose, as this will give a clear indication as to the success of centres in improving outcomes for children and their families. Universal Services 1. High quality, inclusive, early learning and childcare

So you think that it's better for a young baby to have to experience all of the above when they cannot verbalise and rationalise any of this do you, when they're effectively palmed off on to the cheapest childcare provider? I'd rather have a 4 or 5 yo adhusting to school than a 6 month old adjusting to losing their mother predominantly and no understanding why nor any concept that they'll even return for them!

Being a sahp doesn't have to mean the child doesn't attend groups and mix with other children Socially. Doesn't mean that they don't attend any nursery at all. It's about better balance in a time lier fashion that is focussed on the children's best interests.

Noone can say that under the age of 2 or 3, there is any gain from being away from their parents that isn't achieved after that age point.

As for gender stereotypes, that's more an individual family issue.

As is those who say that they work ft with a baby in ft childcare so the baby understands a work ethic. Absolute rubbish. I was a sahp, my child went to school, I returned to work and hey presto my child fully understands work ethics!

SpaghettiArmsMurderer · 02/02/2022 12:00

Sounds completely normal to me. And probably better for the child than what my parents did with me, which was a combination of nursery, childminders and relatives - being in the same place every day probably gives more stability/routine.

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 02/02/2022 11:47

@Aaaabbbcccc

Honestly there are really a lot of dim people on here who want to justify giving up their lives to SAH. Whatever makes you feel better, ladies.
And there seem to be quite a few who are clearly pretending that it doesn't bother them when their rude and overly-defensive comments give exactly the opposite impression.

Fortunately it looks like most people here seem to be able to discuss their differing opinions reasonably while being happy with the choices they have made and not overly judgemental about the ones others have taken.

SpinsForGin · 02/02/2022 11:45

Do you not think you is a sad indictment that your child actually misses nursery but not you?

I've always though it was great that my child loved nursery and now loves school. It doesn't mean he doesn't love or miss me and his dad when we're not there. My aim as a parent was always to raise a child that was confident and independent as they will get so much more out of life.

That you need to chat about his day because you're living such separate lives at such a young age?

But this is brilliant! I love hearing about the things he gets up to when I'm not there. It makes me proud and still amazes me that he's developing his own little life. It's not sad at all. It wonderful.
We also don't live separate lives. We just don't spend all day together.

Do you live a separate life from your partner because they go out to work and do things without you?

Eh ho, least parents like this get to tuck them in at night.

Because of course that's all we do. We don't do any other aspect of parenting at all. ......don't be so bloody ridiculous.

ChoiceMummy · 02/02/2022 11:37

@Darkstar4855

Mine went from 10m and loves it. Misses it terribly when they shut for two weeks at Christmas. I make sure I do lots of fun stuff on the days he is home and I always tuck him in to bed at night, give him lots of cuddles and time to chat about his day etc.
Do you not think you is a sad indictment that your child actually misses nursery but not you? That you need to chat about his day because you're living such separate lives at such a young age? Eh ho, least parents like this get to tuck them in at night.
Butteryflakycrust83 · 02/02/2022 11:14

Honestly, pre DC I thought the same as you, but my DD LOVES nursery, she gets so much more stimulation, learning, social engagement than she would with me all day.
It also gives me a chance to work, feel like myself rather than just a mum, and I cannot wait for pick up and spending my evenings and weekends with her. We are then more or less rested for fun family quality time at a weekend, and by earning a salary it will afford us more opportunities.
Could there be some flexibility with the nursery hours? I start work later so I do drop off at 9 and my husband finishes work at 4 so she's picked up by 5 - this way its not such a log day for her.

MadameHeisenberg · 02/02/2022 11:05

SAH is a mug’s game, for all involved.

It’s not a foregone conclusion but often, by the time the child gets to school, they’re clingy, stressed-out and socially immature compared to their peers. They pick up every bug going and lose educational time while sick. They develop out-dated and sexist ideas about gender roles (having a career is only for men).

The mother (and it is overwhelmingly the mother), unless married to someone very rich (so almost nobody), damages their career prospects, pension, financial security & independence, becoming beholden to a man to keep her. This often causes power imbalances in relationships.

The Dad gets the easiest time of it, but he still shoulders the burden of being the only earner, which is a precarious situation for most (unless independently wealthy, and again that’s almost nobody).

Society loses out as SAHPs are economically inactive - they don’t contribute to general taxation and their skills in the workforce and communities are lost.

I’ve no doubt a select few people make it work whilst avoiding any of this, but they’re few and far between.

BrambleRoses · 02/02/2022 10:59

Same, @HardbackWriter

And I do find it a really odd thing to say anyway as it seems to suggest that having a baby / toddler is all people want. I had a baby not to have a baby but to have a family, and I adored my son as a baby and I adore him as a toddler.

I’m sure I’ll adore him when he’s a teenager too!

HardbackWriter · 02/02/2022 10:54

I love it when people say 'why even bother having a child if you're going to put them in nursery?', as if people who work full-time continue to just lead child-free lives after having children, no change at all. My life changed hugely radically and completely when I had my first child and he became the single biggest focal point of it. That remained true when I went back to work full-time, was still true when I dropped a day at work, was still true when I didn't work for 10 months of maternity leave after having his brother (though obviously now he is an equal focal point!). I'm now back to work four days a week and I still feel like being a parent is my biggest, toughest and most absorbing job - I certainly don't feel that I do so little of it that I barely notice I have children at all, as those comments seem to suggest!

QueenLagertha · 02/02/2022 10:44

My DS has always went 3 days to nursery and 1 day per week to each grandparent. I can't see a problem with it. I have a cleaner and get groceries delivered so the wends are ours for the three of us to do as we please. We go swimming, days out, tea and cake, long walks. Hopefully start up foreign holidays again now pandemic is over.
I hope his childhood is better than mine with a SAHM who had zero patience and rarely brought us anywhere. I would've preferred to have been in childcare.
Obviously there's a massive difference between my Mum and a SAHM who is able and willing to provide their child with a range of experiences and socialising. I do think DS has benefited from spending time with various other children and adults. His social skills are excellent and have been commented on by his pre schools teacher. I felt so guilty during the pandemic when he was stuck at home with just us.

GrendelsGrandma · 02/02/2022 10:33

The other thing is - are family finances about basic things like mortgage and utilities?

Having kids will wallop your lifestyle so most of what you now spend on going out, hobbies, buying clothes, holidays etc will be cut quite radically. Unless you're already living on a shoestring.

GrendelsGrandma · 02/02/2022 10:29

YANBU, so long as it's a decent nursery

However - you can't always control everything and plan like this. You might have a child with special needs, conceive twins, get shafted by your employer on mat leave, get made redundant, have PND and not be ready to go back full time, simply lose your mind a bit...

Having minimal leave and working FT is the norm in places like the US, but it's not easy. Housework takes up way more of your time post-children so it would be a struggle to have two FT working parents and no help with things like cleaning.

If you have to, you'll muddle through as best you can but you can't plan things 100%. I'm guessing you've already thought about ways to reduce outgoings by moving etc?

OfstedOffred · 02/02/2022 10:28

I know loads of families do this but I'm not sure why?

Because a family requires a home, food, elec/gas/water bills, clothes etc...

These things cost money, and where else does a normal family get money if not from work?

Generally speaking, short of abuse etc, poverty is the worst thing for a child in terms of long term impact. Working is the best way to prevent poverty.

Does that clear things up for you?

SpinsForGin · 02/02/2022 10:28

@Joystir59

I know loads of families do this but I'm not sure why? Why do you want a child?
Do you really not know why people use childcare?

Do you not think it's really insulting to ask someone why they want a child if they are going to use childcare?

Parker231 · 02/02/2022 10:27

@Joystir59 - I’m assuming you’re joking!

MadameHeisenberg · 02/02/2022 10:25

Is it cruel to have a child knowing their father will likely spend much of the week away from them, at work?

No? So it’s not cruel for mothers to do it either.

LuckySantangelo35 · 02/02/2022 10:25

@Joystir59

I know loads of families do this but I'm not sure why? Why do you want a child?
Have you really no idea why parents may need to use a nursery/childminders/ nanny? Really?
Joystir59 · 02/02/2022 10:22

I know loads of families do this but I'm not sure why? Why do you want a child?

OfstedOffred · 02/02/2022 10:20

Of course yanbu this is exactly what most working people do.

I think it's nice if you & partner are able to play around with your hours a little to work in some shorter hours or a day week off, but of course this isnt possible in many jobs and the bills need paid. Your child needs a roof over their head, food to eat and those things have to be paid for, working is the only option for many.