Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a child knowing they’ll spend 4 or 5 days in nursery?

383 replies

mvmvmvmv · 01/02/2022 19:58

AIBU to have a child knowing they’d likely be in nursery 4 days a week after my maternity, and likely going to 5 days a week by age 3? Is it unreasonable to have a child knowing they will need to spend so much time in nursery? Is it cruel?

We have zero family nearby, and family finances mean we both pretty much need to work full time (one of us could drop to 4 days for a year).

I don’t want to use a nanny or au pair as I’d want my child to have social interaction with other kids. There are v few childminders near us so unlikely to be an option. The local nursery is very good tho.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cafedesreves · 09/02/2022 20:21

I can't think of any point in history where children would have had the sole attention of the mother all day. Children have been looked after by other people since the beginning of time.

franciacorta · 09/02/2022 19:42

@formalineadeline

Vygotsky also wrote a lot about stages of child development and concluded that children are simply not ready for constant social interaction in peer groups until the age of 3 although begin to be more open to the outer world from the age of 1.

I think you're misrepresenting this. For starters, the zone of proximal development - i.e. pushing beyond the comfort zone being key for developmental progression - comes from Vygotsky. And totally undermines the point you are making.

Children at those ages aren't interacting anyway. They start out ignoring the children around them entirely, then reach a developmental stage where they play alongside other children and then progress to share toys whilst playing and then eventually interacting in a meaningful sense.

So they interact in accordance with their developmental level.

Children cannot learn or show behaviours and skills before they have developed the cognitive ability to do so. You can't learn anything earlier than you have the cognitive ability to do whatever it is.

That is simply not how the human brain works. Children are not simply inexperienced adults who can learn things as fast as they're exposed to them - it is entirely dependent on cognitive development. Hence why children of the same age make the same errors of reasoning.

Different children develop at different rates. That's not new information.

The zone of proximal development is Vygotsky's most famous theory but he also studied the stages of child development and critical (sensitive) periods which affect the learning process. Proximal development of 12-18 m.o. also hugely relies on interaction with a primary caregiver (and not peers). Although to some extent I agree that pushing children beyond their comfort zone and encouraging them to learn could not be a bad thing, that doesn't necessarily happen naturally (their stage of development is still pretty much sensorimotor) as children are put in a formal social setting where they are cared for by an adult who looks after other children too (and the ration is not always great) and are expected to follow certain routine and rules. To expect a 1 year old 'love' their nursery in the same way a 3-4 year old might is simply not realistic.
formalineadeline · 09/02/2022 17:44

Vygotsky also wrote a lot about stages of child development and concluded that children are simply not ready for constant social interaction in peer groups until the age of 3 although begin to be more open to the outer world from the age of 1.

I think you're misrepresenting this. For starters, the zone of proximal development - i.e. pushing beyond the comfort zone being key for developmental progression - comes from Vygotsky. And totally undermines the point you are making.

Children at those ages aren't interacting anyway. They start out ignoring the children around them entirely, then reach a developmental stage where they play alongside other children and then progress to share toys whilst playing and then eventually interacting in a meaningful sense.

So they interact in accordance with their developmental level.

Children cannot learn or show behaviours and skills before they have developed the cognitive ability to do so. You can't learn anything earlier than you have the cognitive ability to do whatever it is.

That is simply not how the human brain works. Children are not simply inexperienced adults who can learn things as fast as they're exposed to them - it is entirely dependent on cognitive development. Hence why children of the same age make the same errors of reasoning.

Different children develop at different rates. That's not new information.

franciacorta · 09/02/2022 16:28

[quote Eycaluptus]@franciacorta I'm not interested in the topic. I'm interested in reassuring women returning to work that their children will be safe, happy and well looked after. [/quote]
To each their own I suppose..)

Eycaluptus · 09/02/2022 16:25

@franciacorta I'm not interested in the topic. I'm interested in reassuring women returning to work that their children will be safe, happy and well looked after.

franciacorta · 09/02/2022 15:58

[quote Eycaluptus]@franciacorta

In fact I read in one of the studies that acquiring new skills and learning new things earlier than they would do at home is a defense mechanism for young kids as they find themselves in a less secure environment

Please link to this study. It doesn't sound that reputable. [/quote]
You should perhaps do your own research if you are interested in the topic. This is part of the concept known as pseudo- independence. It actually develops rather early in children and is known to be a coping mechanism. Bowlby for example thought that "separation anxiety can be excessively low or be altogether absent, giving an erroneous impression of maturity. He attributes pseudo- independence under these conditions to defensive processes. A well-loved child, he claims, is quite likely to protest separation from parents but will later develop more self-reliance". Vygotsky also wrote a lot about stages of child development and concluded that children are simply not ready for constant social interaction in peer groups until the age of 3 although begin to be more open to the outer world from the age of 1.

Eycaluptus · 09/02/2022 14:40

@franciacorta

In fact I read in one of the studies that acquiring new skills and learning new things earlier than they would do at home is a defense mechanism for young kids as they find themselves in a less secure environment

Please link to this study. It doesn't sound that reputable.

franciacorta · 09/02/2022 11:25

@Crimesean

I don't think most DC 'love' going to nursery at a young age (younger than 3) - they invariably would prefer to be with their parents, it's a biological imperative.

My DS really didn't like nursery - when he was very little (13 months till about 2.5) he didn't seem to dislike it, but once he was able to properly articulate his feelings he made it very clear that he didn't like nursery. We looked at getting a nanny but couldn't find one, so we reduced our hours at work so he only went 2 days till he started at the pre-school attached to the school. On the 2 nursery days DS was in tears at drop off, even though he'd settle quickly it was clear he didn't want to go and wasn't happy. It still breaks my heart Sad

Hopefully your DC will be fine at nursery, some are and some aren't, but I'm just warning you in case your DC turns out like mine and really doesn't like it - it's SO hard and upsetting.

This..I think most very young children eventually have to 'love' nurseries as they hardly have any other choice. They adapt to the environment as humans do. In fact I read in one of the studies that acquiring new skills and learning new things earlier than they would do at home is a defense mechanism for young kids as they find themselves in a less secure environment (other kids, key worker/different adults vs a primary caregiver at home spending one on one time with a child) and need to adapt really quickly. This is not bad actually but is often quite difficult for sensitive or high need children. But we all choose what's best for our families so really it's the responsibility of the parents - understand what's best for their child and family overall and make decisions based on that.
Mumoblue · 09/02/2022 11:01

Speaking as both a mum who is a SAHM (though not by choice, I literally can’t work right now because of, ironically, lack of access to childcare) and someone who has worked in nurseries- it’s fine.

This thread has highlighted how some users honestly think childcare workers are lazy, unintelligent glorified babysitters and unfortunately just showcases the lack of respect for the workers.

We do real work and develop real bonds with the children in our care. I took a break from childcare to do other work because you put a lot of yourself into it and I was finding it emotionally draining.

If your child goes to nursery 4-5 days a week, they will be with people who are actively tracking their development and looking for ways to encourage it, people who have literally signed up to care for your child- and they do, in my experience, actually care.

It’s fine.

cafedesreves · 09/02/2022 10:51

@nellly here is a report by the Sutton Trust

www.suttontrust.com/our-research/a-fair-start-equalising-access-to-early-education/

Of course, what's really important is finding the right childcare. For some kids that will be childminder, others nursery. My son genuinely really enjoys it and I know it's right for him.

Crimesean · 09/02/2022 09:24

I don't think most DC 'love' going to nursery at a young age (younger than 3) - they invariably would prefer to be with their parents, it's a biological imperative.

My DS really didn't like nursery - when he was very little (13 months till about 2.5) he didn't seem to dislike it, but once he was able to properly articulate his feelings he made it very clear that he didn't like nursery. We looked at getting a nanny but couldn't find one, so we reduced our hours at work so he only went 2 days till he started at the pre-school attached to the school. On the 2 nursery days DS was in tears at drop off, even though he'd settle quickly it was clear he didn't want to go and wasn't happy. It still breaks my heart Sad

Hopefully your DC will be fine at nursery, some are and some aren't, but I'm just warning you in case your DC turns out like mine and really doesn't like it - it's SO hard and upsetting.

BeKind2022 · 09/02/2022 08:43

My kids went full-time and yes there were days when it was hard to leave them but they are grown up now (early teens - early 20s) and neither has needed therapy due to full time nursery. They were so well prepared for schools compared to some other classmates at school who had never attended any nursery / daycare.

They also have happy memories of their time there.

SpinsForGin · 09/02/2022 08:22

nellly
Please don't feel crap. Lots of us have done it and our children thrived! All the research shows that it's not detrimental.
We're all just doing our best! ❤️

nellly · 09/02/2022 08:14

@cafedesreves

Also the comment about not having control is slightly concerning... yes I have control over what childcare my son goes to but I don't micromanage every activity.

It has been proven many times that staying at home until school age is actually detrimental to a child's development

Can you link to studies or articles about this, this thread has made me feel crap that I have to put my 1 year old into nursery to o back to work. I looked around for ages and I'm really pleased with the one we've chosen but it's not being at home with mummy is it Sad
cafedesreves · 09/02/2022 07:34

Also the comment about not having control is slightly concerning... yes I have control over what childcare my son goes to but I don't micromanage every activity.

It has been proven many times that staying at home until school age is actually detrimental to a child's development

cafedesreves · 09/02/2022 06:46

@navydear

I'm sorry but there is not one single positive that I can think of for a child to be in a crèche before the age of 3. A child of 1 or 2 years does not even play with other children, they just play along side them. Taking a child from their sleep at all hours of the dawn to bring them to a service to be cared for mainly by young girls, who, let's be honest are mostly tired and hungover of a Monday morning, is nothing but cruel. How can this substitute the love that child should be receiving from their mother all day. One on one attention and the feeling of being nurtured and loved is what these babies should be receiving, not dropped into a room of god knows how many other toddlers of the exact same age with all the very same needs and demands. It's bonkers if anyone thinks that this is natural. I can't imagine my little girl spending 10 hours of the day in a business. Where is the lazy hours of cuddling on the sofa, the long hugs and kisses, the listening ear of a mammy while listening to their stories over and over. I know people don't have choice but instead of trying to pretend that this is all okay, maybe start fighting for change so mothers can afford to be at home with their babies untill at least school age. These years are so formative, yet you hand your child over to experience things, see and hear things that you have no control of, these years shape your child's future and you are not there to ensure it is shaped by the best way possible.
This is just a bit odd... I don't know many kids willing to cuddle on the sofa for hours. How old is your DC? DS has been off nursery for 3 weeks with COVID and chest infection. He's desperate to get back!
Changechangychange · 09/02/2022 02:56

Where is the lazy hours of cuddling on the sofa, the long hugs and kisses, the listening ear of a mammy while listening to their stories over and over

You must have a strangely docile child if they are willing to sit on the sofa with you for ten hours a day being cuddled.

Mine also always had lots of new stories to tell me, perhaps because he left the sofa and did fun things at his nursery. If yours is telling the same story over and over perhaps she is bored?

Embracelife · 07/02/2022 13:56

Where is the lazy hours of cuddling on the sofa, the long hugs and kisses, the listening ear of a mammy while listening to their stories over and over

Ummm in the evening?
Really you spentc10 hours a day doing that ? Baby didn't have a nap? You didn't put her down to sort the washing or go on mumsnet? ha ha

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/02/2022 23:17

navydear
I'm sorry but there is not one single positive that I can think of for a child to be in a crèche before the age of 3. A child of 1 or 2 years does not even play with other children, they just play along side them. Taking a child from their sleep at all hours of the dawn to bring them to a service to be cared for mainly by young girls, who, let's be honest are mostly tired and hungover of a Monday morning, is nothing but cruel. How can this substitute the love that child should be receiving from their mother all day. One on one attention and the feeling of being nurtured and loved is what these babies should be receiving, not dropped into a room of god knows how many other toddlers of the exact same age with all the very same needs and demands. It's bonkers if anyone thinks that this is natural. I can't imagine my little girl spending 10 hours of the day in a business. Where is the lazy hours of cuddling on the sofa, the long hugs and kisses, the listening ear of a mammy while listening to their stories over and over. I know people don't have choice but instead of trying to pretend that this is all okay, maybe start fighting for change so mothers can afford to be at home with their babies untill at least school age. These years are so formative, yet you hand your child over to experience things, see and hear things that you have no control of, these years shape your child's future and you are not there to ensure it is shaped by the best way possible.”

What a load of tripe.

(I was a SAHM)

Your characterisation of nursery workers is offensive. My eldest daughter is an highly qualified nursery professional and better equipped to work with little ones than most parents.

Rosebel · 06/02/2022 23:07

@navydear

I'm sorry but there is not one single positive that I can think of for a child to be in a crèche before the age of 3. A child of 1 or 2 years does not even play with other children, they just play along side them. Taking a child from their sleep at all hours of the dawn to bring them to a service to be cared for mainly by young girls, who, let's be honest are mostly tired and hungover of a Monday morning, is nothing but cruel. How can this substitute the love that child should be receiving from their mother all day. One on one attention and the feeling of being nurtured and loved is what these babies should be receiving, not dropped into a room of god knows how many other toddlers of the exact same age with all the very same needs and demands. It's bonkers if anyone thinks that this is natural. I can't imagine my little girl spending 10 hours of the day in a business. Where is the lazy hours of cuddling on the sofa, the long hugs and kisses, the listening ear of a mammy while listening to their stories over and over. I know people don't have choice but instead of trying to pretend that this is all okay, maybe start fighting for change so mothers can afford to be at home with their babies untill at least school age. These years are so formative, yet you hand your child over to experience things, see and hear things that you have no control of, these years shape your child's future and you are not there to ensure it is shaped by the best way possible.
I'm assuming you are a SAHM. How lucky you can afford to be. Ideally I'd like to be at home but my son loves nursery. Always smiling when he goes in and gets so many more experiences than he would if at home with me. We have plenty of times for cuddles and stories thanks. We spent a couple of hours today just reading his baby bear book and cuddling. He's not in nursery 24/7.
Onatree · 06/02/2022 19:18

Wow who are these babies that are being woken at dawn for nursery? Both mine have always arisen long before us and usually practise singing around daybreak alongside the dog. I have a coffee machine on my bedside table.

The you hungover girls. Now then. Key person is a mum of 2, 2 in the same nursery as our toddler - different room. Former key person - grandmother of 4, aged 59 - absolute legend. I credit her single handedly with toilet training my older one and teaching him all sorts from phonics to kindness. Manager - grandmother of 3. Deputy manager - fellow mum of toddler - we were pregnant together. Somehow these people appear rather normal and not drunk on Monday mornings.

But what do I know.

I am just a Professor.

Justgettingbye · 06/02/2022 09:32

I think @navydear needs to get their head out their arse and leave to safety of their 4 walls to see what really goes on in the real world

MindyStClaire · 05/02/2022 14:20

I've only scanned the last few posts but the bits they've quoted have really annoyed me.

  1. There are more grandmothers than teenagers working at my DC's nursery. The students they do have are kind, caring and enthusiastic.
  1. At nursery my DC get a huge range of experiences that it just wouldn't be possible to replicate at home, as well as growing with other children in a way we just wouldn't be able to replicate. They also feed them much better than I would! I'm in no way saying that nursery is superior to home. But it's not inferior.
  1. I worked hard through school, college and professional qualifications until my mid 30s. Why I should suddenly change personality and wish to stay home for a few years (7 years between my eldest being born and my youngest starting school, btw) when no such pressure is put on my husband I have no idea.
  1. The women who work at our nursery are fantastic. They should be valued for their experience, expertise and nurtering. That they are paid such shit wages (especially in comparison to male-centric careers with similar levels of qualifications) is a huge failing of our society, with clear roots in misogyny.
  1. Alas, no waking our baby to get to nursery. I fucking wish, haven't needed an alarm clock for a long time. Grin
eatthatcake · 05/02/2022 14:04

It's absolutely disgusting and insulting for real victims of abuse, to relate 'children in childcare settings' to child cruelty, abuse and neglect. Any poster that has used the words cruel/neglect to describe this situation, hang your heads in shame!

Bunnycat101 · 05/02/2022 13:42

“I'm sorry but there is not one single positive that I can think of for a child to be in a crèche before the age of 3. A child of 1 or 2 years does not even play with other children, they just play along side them. “

This is also just bollocks as well. Both of my girls have developed real and lasting friendships at nursery well before 3. A good nursery provides so much benefit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread