Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

David Beckham reveals wife Victoria has eaten the same meal every day for 25 years

538 replies

FlexibleWorkingDenied · 01/02/2022 19:22

Apparently Victoria Beckham will only ever eat grilled fish and steamed veg. Every day for 25 years. She says she won’t eat food cooked in oil, butter or sauces, red meat, or dairy.

AIBU to think life is too short to live without butter!

www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-10463673/David-Beckham-reveals-wife-Victoria-eaten-meal-day-25-years.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Sceptre86 · 02/02/2022 07:41

It does sound like an eating disorder and it was very unkind for David to share that with the world. At my thinnest I had to be very rigid with my diet and I was up until I got pregnant.

Exhausteddog · 02/02/2022 07:30

I would bet money that those people criticising her, have a weight problem!

I would say the opposite and say I bet all the people saying its quite normal probably have ED or issues with food themselves. As I said previously I think there is a high % of MN with ED themselves. I'm recovered from an ED I don't have a weight problem. I've been the same (healthy) weight , excluding pregnancy, for about 20 years.

VB is very thin, admittedly lots of celebs are and a lot of them probably also have ED. It's literally their job to look incredibly thin what society thinks is the ideal for a woman. A lot of professional athletes will also restrict calories and eat incredibly strict and possibly limited diets....but there is also a high incidence of bordrline ED in sports too, particularly ones where weight or bodyshape is paramount (jockeys, gymnasts etc)

I used to be anorexic - although I did eat a variety of food, just very tiny quantities of it.
I think this is why it's frustrating because while she admits she used to have an ED, the suggestion is that she hasn't any more. If this is an aspiration for anyone with an ED thinking that the same meal for 2 decades and working out for 2 hours a day is what healthy recovery looks like (imo) it's a potentially a misleading one. Obviously eating healthily and working out are not bad things - but I'd say the rigidity of it is still very much ED mindset. "If I "only" work out for 5 days a week, I'll get fat" or "if I swapped fish and steamed vegetables for a pasta dish once a fortnight, I'll be really out of control"

Gladioli23 · 02/02/2022 07:24

So I find the comments about what is or isn't overweight interesting.

The Lancet reckons a healthy BMI is 20 to 25. It says the lowest mortality is found at a BMI of around 25.

www.thelancet.com/journals/landia/article/PIIS2213-8587%2818%2930288-2/fulltext

Given the Lancet has a high impact factor (method used for relating the strength of scientific journals) and is one of the highest rated journals for medicine, I don't think we can simply conclude that the scientific literature goes in one direction in relation to this.

The study is from 2018, so reasonably recent.

Ridiculeisnothingtobescaredof · 02/02/2022 07:20

I think he was maybe joking or exaggerating? But i could be wrong

MondayYogurt · 02/02/2022 07:19

Let her eat the damn fish, Dave.

Mummadeze · 02/02/2022 07:10

It is a healthy meal to have every night. I actually see the sense in it. I don’t eat dinner most evenings because I am perpetually trying to fast and lose weight so it is a step up from eating nothing!

longwayoff · 02/02/2022 06:57

Her teeth! Her bones! No fats at all? Blimey that sounds very unhealthy. Poor Victoria, its none of our business what she eats and her husband is unkind to have said this. I hope not to see the slim volume that would be the Beckham cookbook though.

DetMcNulty · 02/02/2022 06:49

Yeah, I don't get what so abnormal about it to be honest. My DP's family pretty much eat meat and 2 veg every night, and she looks a lot healthier than they do.

tackling · 02/02/2022 06:31

@Oblomov22

This is not ok. It's not balanced, in the mind nor in the diet. It shows a mental state that is not the norm.
I mean, god forbid someone isn't normal Grin
BadLad · 02/02/2022 06:29

At last, a rare glimpse into the fiercely guarded private lives of the Beckhams.

Oblomov22 · 02/02/2022 06:28

This is not ok. It's not balanced, in the mind nor in the diet. It shows a mental state that is not the norm.

tackling · 02/02/2022 06:21

Can't see the problem at all - except for a husband making fun of a wife in public and opening her up to comments like all of these. What a piece of shit.

PandoraP · 02/02/2022 06:07

Is she not just Hollywood thin? I would be less concerned about someone eating fish and veg every day (though she probably only has one meal a day judging from her size) than someone gorging themselves on junk food. You can eat a lot of calories with no nutritional value.

DetMcNulty · 02/02/2022 06:06

I'm just back from a week's yoga / well being treat, and that's basically what we were fed every night too (I'm veggie, so minus the fish for me). If i had a chef who could cook for me and make it as delicious as it was, i'd probably stick with it too, I do feel better for it and it's changed what I feel like eating just in that short time, so I'd imagine after doing it for a while you'd just lose that craving for any heavy type food.

2 hours working out doesn't seem that extreme either, I do similar every day (blame my giant dogs for that), and if she's definitely doing that much, she must be getting enough calories to give her the energy.

Goatinthegarden · 02/02/2022 06:06

There is a lot of speculation here. All we know for sure is that VB is very slim. Presumably she has dieticians, PTs and chefs. I would hope that they ensure she eats what she needs, even if restricted. None of us actually knows though. We also don’t know whether she is interested in food, happy with her diet, or desperate to eat something else.

She is subject to so much scrutiny and is a product of the 90’s where female celebs had to be skeletal or they would be publicly shamed. She has made her fame and fortune through her image. It is debatable as to whether she is a victim or a victor.

Athletes eat incredibly restrictive diets to improve their performance and no one bats an eyelid.

Let’s just concentrate on our own eating, health and fitness.

GiantHaystacks2021 · 02/02/2022 03:09

Anyone who has eyes in their head can see that she clearly does have an ongoing and long term eating disorder.
That is not something to celebrate, admire or respond to with guff like; "it works for her" - that's just nonsense.

Leave her to it - she'll be like that for life.

As for her husband, the less said about him, the better.
Qatar much?
There are rumours flying around that they have been quietly separated for years but stay together because -- Brand Beckham.
There have been persistent allegations for years that he just cannot keep it in his pants.

I have also heard that they do loads for charity privately and have quietly given away very, very large sums of their own money.

FlexibleWorkingDenied · 02/02/2022 02:25

@shadesofrose

I wish I'd eaten the same tiny meal forever. I have a feeling that my forever everyday meal if I was ever to last like this would be chocolate cake something like an 8 servings one. It's up to VB what she eats. She's under a lot of pressure to look good I'm sure.
Do you really wish you’d eaten the same tiny meal forever though? (I just picked your comment out at random, there are lots of others saying similar). You know when people say about working too much that no one lies on their death bed wishing they’d worked more, they lie there wishing they’d spent more time with their family etc. Will you lie on your death bed thinking “I really wish I’d eaten less cake (or butter, or bread, or steak, or whatever your personal persuasion is)”? Or will you think I wish I’d eaten more of my favourite things and been more relaxed about it!

It’s been very interesting to read about many differing attitudes towards food on this thread, which was my intention in starting it. Thank you to all who’ve shared.

OP posts:
WildImaginings · 02/02/2022 02:13

I don't comment on anyone's weight in a nasty way, overweight or underweight.

Quincy, you seem to think all overweight people have some sort of problem with people who are 'skinny' as you put it - not the case. If you notice, I've made no comment on VB either way throughout this thread.

I don't like ANYONE badgering anyone about their weight. Which you have done repeatedly to OP. You've said yourself you wanted to give OP 'a taste of her own medicine'. You've made yourself into as much of an awful person as you believe the OP to be so well done.

FlexibleWorkingDenied · 02/02/2022 02:08

@Quincythequince

wildimaginings are you actually for real?

My comments, in which I haven’t called the OP fat at all (the female range described here isn’t bullshit and I’ve already explained why; you not believing it doesn’t make it less true) are in your view the reason people get eating disorders?

This, despite me saying it’s horrid to discuss peoples food and intentions and not to do it, and giving the OP a taste of her own medicine?

The phrase dish it out but can’t take it springs to mind.

Have you read the speculative shit that the OP has said time and time again in this thread?

Questioning the level of fame related to weight, commenting on food enjoyment in the home and for occasions, querying why VB lost so much weight etc, picking apart meals.

But my comments are apparently damaging?

Go back and re-read every post from the OP and tell me how they aren’t damaging to the person being discussed.

And if OP is ok with it, then she won’t mind her own scrutiny.

But of course none of this is ok is it. People feel they can comment nastily on the skinny ones, but as soon as any mention of OW takes place, people are up in arms.

I think it’s you that is missing the point here and if I saw someone making derisory comments about another person in the same fashion, I would do the same thing again.

And for the record, I’ve been on another thread today discussing how poorly overweight people are treated and how our healthcare system lets people with weight problems down. So it might be useful to direct anger more constructively! Starting with unkind, catty gossiping might be a good place.

I don’t understand why you keep saying things like “don’t dish it out if you can’t take it” and “give the OP a taste of her own medicine”- it’s not some big “GOTCHA” moment, I’ve repeatedly said please do dish it out, I can take it. You threatened to start a thread about me (a comment which I notice has been deleted so I assume mumsnet deemed it a personal attack- fwiw it was not me that reported it), I said yeah fine do that. You asked me about my weight and diet, I answered. You commented I eat too much salt. I don’t mind at all. Please don’t feel that you’ve somehow offended me, made me feel bad, given me a taste of my own medicine or that you’ve dished out something I can’t take. You’re trying to make out that I’m dishing out something I can’t take- I’ve said I can take it, it’s not double standards. I’m happy with my body, my weight and very happy with my diet. Even being 0.4 overweight. The comments you’ve quoted of mine about VB from this thread are regarding her weight in relation to society’s perception of celebrity culture in the 90s (eg asking questions why did she lose so much weight and would she have been chosen for the spice girls if she was overweight). The celebrity culture was toxic then.

Look I don’t think we’re going to agree (obviously) and I tried to draw a line under it when I went to sleep (up again with the baby now) but I want to make it very clear that despite trying to be nasty on purpose to teach me a lesson, you haven’t “given me a taste of my own medicine” and I can take what you can dish out, so you haven’t proven any point.

OP posts:
SunshineArtist · 02/02/2022 01:52

I haven't thought about the Beckhams for ages. This has got us all going, hasn't it?

You must have missed the numerous other threads about them. The threads about Brooklyn have attracted some particularly nasty comments.

Saltyquiche · 02/02/2022 01:44

Lots of comments and judgments, however it’s only her business what she eats. If I could I’d eat curry every day (homemade)

Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 01:09

@limitedperiodonly

I haven't thought about the Beckhams for ages. This has got us all going, hasn't it?
Best comment on here.

At least two hours of my life I won’t get back.

Gah.

limitedperiodonly · 02/02/2022 01:07

I haven't thought about the Beckhams for ages. This has got us all going, hasn't it?

Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 01:07

I didn’t ram home any 0.4 difference in OPs BMI and wild has already corrected that.

I have no idea what you are on about.

The only correction I made is that someone (wrongly) corrected another poster on a calculated BMI, so I clarified the correct figure.

And OP shouldn’t be criticising somebody’s else’s health status; thin or otherwise!

I’ll say it again - treat people the way you want to be treated!

Correcting a basic BMI calculation, a relatively useless number, is far milder than OPs comments!

But people get upset because you can’t comment on excess weight, only underweight!

I don’t make up the BMI categories- that’s not on me!

Every continuous variable has to have a cut off at some point, that’s just how categories are created.

Same for blood glucose, cholesterol, BP etc.

Weight is no different!

KTB19 · 02/02/2022 01:04

@Bogiesaremyonlyfriend

I'd quiet happily eat the same meal every day. Food sucks and I'm not at all bothered by it. Wish I could not eat, save a ton of time.
Absolutely this. I hate strong food smells and much prefer to eat a lot of foods cold. The look of horror on colleagues faces when I eat cold soup out of the can.

There are some foods I do enjoy eating but if there was a pill I could take to get my nutrition from, I would take it.

I get tired of people commenting on my appetite and food choices. It has fuck all to do with them.

I have an autoimmune condition that affects my appetite and my medication also affects it. But also, I have never been a foodie anyway.