Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

David Beckham reveals wife Victoria has eaten the same meal every day for 25 years

538 replies

FlexibleWorkingDenied · 01/02/2022 19:22

Apparently Victoria Beckham will only ever eat grilled fish and steamed veg. Every day for 25 years. She says she won’t eat food cooked in oil, butter or sauces, red meat, or dairy.

AIBU to think life is too short to live without butter!

www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-10463673/David-Beckham-reveals-wife-Victoria-eaten-meal-day-25-years.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
UglyModernWindows · 02/02/2022 08:45

If DB had said VB has actually been vegan the past 25 years, people would be fawning over here instead and not one would say anything about her diet being restrictive, dull or her having a ED Hmm

Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 08:43

Have a good day flexible

Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 08:42

And if anyone thinks this is ok and is feeling brave, go over to the ‘invisible fat women over 40’ thread and tell them like you think it is over there.

It’s an active thread - I’m sure they’d love to hear your speculative thoughts about why some of them are so fat, what they eat, if they have an ED etc.

FlexibleWorkingDenied · 02/02/2022 08:40

@Quincythequince

Anyway, I have to work so I’ll let you all continue to make snide comments about VB, and then attempt to defend the OP was just trying to start a conversation.

Just put yourself in VBs shoes (or Keira Knightley or Zendaya any other slim celeb who often gets it) and tell me how you would like people picking your looks, motives, career, diet etc apart.

I did start this thread to have a conversation, and a conversation has been had, very much by you. You’ve kept this thread extremely active, so thank you Grin
OP posts:
Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 08:34

Anyway, I have to work so I’ll let you all continue to make snide comments about VB, and then attempt to defend the OP was just trying to start a conversation.

Just put yourself in VBs shoes (or Keira Knightley or Zendaya any other slim celeb who often gets it) and tell me how you would like people picking your looks, motives, career, diet etc apart.

Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 08:31

And the NHS is shit for all things to do with obesity and weight loss!

Most NHS staff in this area, that I know would freely admit that.

Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 08:30

@Gladioli23

You realise most people look at W:H now as an indicator of health, BMI takes a back seat!

It’s a crude, non-specific measure which is pretty useless, but still used as one factor!

If you were being more specific, a female range would be used and you look at W:H and wc generally.

So it's a "pretty useless" tool that is inaccurately represented by both the Lancet and the NHS, but is nonetheless useful enough to show VB is not underweight in spite of being under the healthy weights for both the NHS and this article in the Lancet, and also useful enough to tell the OP she is overweight in spite of being within the healthy weight ranges for both the NHS and the Lancet, and in spite of the fact that the Lancet article is actually about the association of BMI with mortality with the life expectancy - but is still unreliable except when you want to use it.

Gotcha.

I have not once on this thread said that I don’t think VB is underweight!

I have commented on people scrutinising her looks and her food.

So ‘Gotcha’ right back (who actually uses this phrase in every day discourse?)

The comment using BMI (based on OPs own measurements) was about (inappropriately) discussing someone in public forum.

And yes, it is an OW BMI, but not knowing anything about the OP, is a rather pointless and not particularly insightful comment:

Rather the point I was trying to make really.

You can bang on about the Lancet all you like - BMI is mildly useful at a population level with other info, and not very useful at a personal level (without other info).

Scientist, after scientist says it, time and time again.

Iamthewombat · 02/02/2022 08:30

@BadLad

At last, a rare glimpse into the fiercely guarded private lives of the Beckhams.
Hahahaha
Gladioli23 · 02/02/2022 08:22

You realise most people look at W:H now as an indicator of health, BMI takes a back seat!

It’s a crude, non-specific measure which is pretty useless, but still used as one factor!

If you were being more specific, a female range would be used and you look at W:H and wc generally.

So it's a "pretty useless" tool that is inaccurately represented by both the Lancet and the NHS, but is nonetheless useful enough to show VB is not underweight in spite of being under the healthy weights for both the NHS and this article in the Lancet, and also useful enough to tell the OP she is overweight in spite of being within the healthy weight ranges for both the NHS and the Lancet, and in spite of the fact that the Lancet article is actually about the association of BMI with mortality with the life expectancy - but is still unreliable except when you want to use it.

Gotcha.

Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 08:21

That ‘don’t dish it out’ comments were to other people, criticising me for commenting on you, in a similar way to that which you commented on VB.

Perhaps could have used a better phrase, but the point remains; it’s not ok to do this to anyone, and if you do, prepare to have yourself thrown under the microscope.

Your comments are nasty and malicious and snidely and have elicited some other awful comments, which you shouldn’t be surprised about tbh.

You know nothing (except tabloid fodder) about VBs diet - nothing. And if the DM and other gossip mags is considered a reputable source upon which to justify these comments, god help you.

3WildOnes · 02/02/2022 08:17

I am as slim as KM and VB. I don’t have an eating disorder, I have always been naturally slim and have tended to lose a bit of weight after each baby. I dont have a restricted diet like VB, I eat crisps, cake, biscuits etc, I probably just eat smaller portions of these foods and more vegetables, salads and soups than the average person. I try to make sure that half of my plate is vegetables.

Tal45 · 02/02/2022 08:17

Food is one of life's joys isn't it? Sharing food is such a pleasure and I can understand how he feels he misses out on that. I think it's a shame that she limits herself so much but if it's how she handles her eating disorder it might not be 'normal' but it's got to be better than not eating

We all know David Beckham is best when he doesn't speak though.

Clymene · 02/02/2022 08:14

@Exhausteddog

I would bet money that those people criticising her, have a weight problem!

I would say the opposite and say I bet all the people saying its quite normal probably have ED or issues with food themselves. As I said previously I think there is a high % of MN with ED themselves. I'm recovered from an ED I don't have a weight problem. I've been the same (healthy) weight , excluding pregnancy, for about 20 years.

VB is very thin, admittedly lots of celebs are and a lot of them probably also have ED. It's literally their job to look incredibly thin what society thinks is the ideal for a woman. A lot of professional athletes will also restrict calories and eat incredibly strict and possibly limited diets....but there is also a high incidence of bordrline ED in sports too, particularly ones where weight or bodyshape is paramount (jockeys, gymnasts etc)

I used to be anorexic - although I did eat a variety of food, just very tiny quantities of it.
I think this is why it's frustrating because while she admits she used to have an ED, the suggestion is that she hasn't any more. If this is an aspiration for anyone with an ED thinking that the same meal for 2 decades and working out for 2 hours a day is what healthy recovery looks like (imo) it's a potentially a misleading one. Obviously eating healthily and working out are not bad things - but I'd say the rigidity of it is still very much ED mindset. "If I "only" work out for 5 days a week, I'll get fat" or "if I swapped fish and steamed vegetables for a pasta dish once a fortnight, I'll be really out of control"

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
FlexibleWorkingDenied · 02/02/2022 08:12

@Quincythequince

Dear god flexible for the umpteenth time, just because you don’t mind people talking about you and scrutinising you, it doesn’t mean it’s ok!

What part of that are you failing to understand??

The ‘gotcha’ (your word, not mine) was to explain what I was doing and why!

If you think my behaviour is nasty, then reflect on your own! That’s like a bully telling someone not to hit them back, whilst punching them or another person! You don’t mind ‘being punched’… so what, doesn’t mean other people have to ignore it!

Your comments were speculative comments from you (have read them again) about her! You aren’t making reference to anything when you talk about her maintaining an unachievable body type and intimating the use of food for culture/family etc.

Stop backpedaling on a nasty thread you started, that hasn’t ended up with everyone agreeing you and has resulted in some horrible comments about another woman not here to defend herself.

I suppose the part I am failing to understand is that you are saying things like “don’t dish it out if you can’t take it” but I can take it.

You, by your own admission, are being nasty on purpose to try and get a reaction.

I am not trying to be nasty. You keep saying reread my comments and I’ll see they’re nasty, but I really don’t see that.

I’ve said VB’s diet is unusual, restrictive and interesting- it is.

I’ve said VB is thin- she is.

I’ve said VB lost weight between joining the Spice Girls and the height of their success- she did.

I have asked questions about whether her weight is linked to her success due to society’s upholding of a particular body type for women.

I have said her body type is unobtainable for many/most women and young girls- it is.

OP posts:
EishetChayil · 02/02/2022 08:09

David Beckham is such a knob. Victoria should have divorced his moronic ass years ago.

Walkaround · 02/02/2022 08:04

Both Kate Middleton and Victoria Beckham look on the too thin side of slim, imvho - ie a bit thinner than looks quite right on their body frames. They both give me the, “oh my God,” reaction, rather than the “wow” reaction. At what point does extreme control become an eating disorder? If they become ambassadors for the osteoporosis society, then the latter.

Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 08:01

For the same reason there’s an argument about men and women’s build for sports (I.e. more muscle for men) and so a competitive advantage for males, it’s true for BMI too. It is borne out in measures of body fat distribution as women have more fat naturally, that’s fairly straightforward to explain I think.

Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 07:57

@Gladioli23

So I find the comments about what is or isn't overweight interesting.

The Lancet reckons a healthy BMI is 20 to 25. It says the lowest mortality is found at a BMI of around 25.

www.thelancet.com/journals/landia/article/PIIS2213-8587%2818%2930288-2/fulltext

Given the Lancet has a high impact factor (method used for relating the strength of scientific journals) and is one of the highest rated journals for medicine, I don't think we can simply conclude that the scientific literature goes in one direction in relation to this.

The study is from 2018, so reasonably recent.

You realise most people look at W:H now as an indicator of health, BMI takes a back seat!

It’s a crude, non-specific measure which is pretty useless, but still used as one factor!

If you were being more specific, a female range would be used and you look at W:H and wc generally.

SafeMove · 02/02/2022 07:57

@MondayYogurt

Let her eat the damn fish, Dave.
Love this Grin

There seems to be a misconception on MN that weight is the only indicator of health. I understand it, as we have been given scales of under weight, healthy weight, over weight. I am now a healthy weight and more active than I have ever been in my life (I walk up fells weekly). I have been very underweight and slightly overweight in my 42 years. I now have a disease involving my heart and liver and I asked my consultants if I needed to do anything about my weight to help - they said no. Your weight has no bearing on your disease whatsoever. It didn't cause it and it won't effect it. So sometimes how healthy someone is inside does not match up with their external weight. There are some pretty unhealthy exchanges going on in this thread though!

Exhausteddog · 02/02/2022 07:56

Tbf Kate Middleton is just as thin imo.
Does she have an ed?

Quite possibly.

dayswithaY · 02/02/2022 07:55

Does she have an ed?

Most likely, yes. Again, she didn't look this way in her younger years and it's unusual for weight to drop off naturally as you get older.

Quincythequince · 02/02/2022 07:53

Dear god flexible for the umpteenth time,
just because you don’t mind people talking about you and scrutinising you, it doesn’t mean it’s ok!

What part of that are you failing to understand??

The ‘gotcha’ (your word, not mine) was to explain what I was doing and why!

If you think my behaviour is nasty, then reflect on your own! That’s like a bully telling someone not to hit them back, whilst punching them or another person! You don’t mind ‘being punched’… so what, doesn’t mean other people have to ignore it!

Your comments were speculative comments from you (have read them again) about her! You aren’t making reference to anything when you talk about her maintaining an unachievable body type and intimating the use of food for culture/family etc.

Stop backpedaling on a nasty thread you started, that hasn’t ended up with everyone agreeing you and has resulted in some horrible comments about another woman not here to defend herself.

Youngstreet · 02/02/2022 07:48

Tbf Kate Middleton is just as thin imo.
Does she have an ed?

David Beckham reveals wife Victoria has eaten the same meal every day for 25 years
David Beckham reveals wife Victoria has eaten the same meal every day for 25 years
Nomoreusernames1244 · 02/02/2022 07:48

Athletes eat incredibly restrictive diets to improve their performance and no one bats an eyelid

No, they don’t. They burn incredible amounts of calories and restricting diets excessively leads to injury and impaired performance.

Athletes pay attention to diet to ensure their nutrient needs are met. Yes anorexia is often rife in some sports like long distance running, and lowering weight can increase performance, but only short term. Long term restriction, as I said means they won’t perform.

Michael phelps famously detailed his macdonalds intake as that was the easiest way of eating enough calories to fuel his training.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 02/02/2022 07:46

@Exhausteddog

I would bet money that those people criticising her, have a weight problem!

I would say the opposite and say I bet all the people saying its quite normal probably have ED or issues with food themselves. As I said previously I think there is a high % of MN with ED themselves. I'm recovered from an ED I don't have a weight problem. I've been the same (healthy) weight , excluding pregnancy, for about 20 years.

VB is very thin, admittedly lots of celebs are and a lot of them probably also have ED. It's literally their job to look incredibly thin what society thinks is the ideal for a woman. A lot of professional athletes will also restrict calories and eat incredibly strict and possibly limited diets....but there is also a high incidence of bordrline ED in sports too, particularly ones where weight or bodyshape is paramount (jockeys, gymnasts etc)

I used to be anorexic - although I did eat a variety of food, just very tiny quantities of it.
I think this is why it's frustrating because while she admits she used to have an ED, the suggestion is that she hasn't any more. If this is an aspiration for anyone with an ED thinking that the same meal for 2 decades and working out for 2 hours a day is what healthy recovery looks like (imo) it's a potentially a misleading one. Obviously eating healthily and working out are not bad things - but I'd say the rigidity of it is still very much ED mindset. "If I "only" work out for 5 days a week, I'll get fat" or "if I swapped fish and steamed vegetables for a pasta dish once a fortnight, I'll be really out of control"

I couldn't agree more.

The amount of pro anorexic crap people have said on this thread is astounding and terrifying.

Being unhealthily thin, sticking to a rigid meal plan which is low calorie and low fat and not being able to deviate from it demonstrates someone in the grips of an ED.

People living with an ED are living with a monster in their head screaming at them and controlling every aspect of their life.