Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inspired by another thread. Is accent mocking ever OK ?

259 replies

toddymummy · 01/02/2022 11:43

This one has always bothered me. Being from mixed European heritage, but not having an accent myself- I have found myself the subject of accent/ gesture mocking many times.

It doesn't happen as much anymore as it used to,say 10-15 years ago, but it does occasionally happen.

Is it ever OK ? People mock all kinds of accents- Irish, Scottish, Welsh, French, Italian, German.

It really bugs me, especially if it's done repeatedly and especially if it's done at work.

AIBU ?

OP posts:
CailleachGranda · 02/02/2022 09:07

I've had it and I've just looked at them
Quizzically and asked why they were speaking like that.

Didn't do it again

RampantIvy · 02/02/2022 09:02

I would never mock anyone's accent. That isrude.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 02/02/2022 08:54

It depends if you're mocking the person you're imitating.

I get quite cross when Essex accents are depicted as being a bit thick, Cockney as a bit dodgy and anything Southern as stuck up.

RampantIvy · 02/02/2022 08:41

Why would they care though

It's just friendly small talk isn't it? It's boring waiting in a slow moving queue, so something like that is an ice breaker. If DH heard an accent that was local to where he came from they might talk about pubs they know it people they know. People don't care. They are just being friendly.

shouldistop · 02/02/2022 08:38

I don't think it's ok to mock anyone about anything to be honest.

Porcupineintherough · 02/02/2022 08:38

@ChangingLife yeah, no.

HardbackWriter · 02/02/2022 08:38

I think it's not until you're a minority in some way that you really realise what a fucking PITA it is being different, and how relentless it can be being reminded that you're different

I think it's also that people don't realise how tedious it is getting the same comment constantly, even if it isn't offensive, and how self-conscious it can make you feel. I used to have a boyfriend who was 6'8 and there was nothing particularly offensive about someone commenting on his height but it was absolutely constant, everywhere he went, the same witless comments from strangers. Each one individually wasn't being rude but the cumulative effect used to really get him down. It's the same if your accent doesn't 'fit' - even 'harmless' comments aren't fun if it happens everyday everywhere you go.

ChangingLife · 02/02/2022 08:35

@RampantIvy

“you’re from x aren’t you, I can tell by your accent”. So random, so rude

In what way is that rude? Confused

If I was talking to a random stranger at, say, Leeds Bradford airport, and the person I was chatting to asked what part of London I was from I wouldn't find that in the least bit rude. Honestly, asking where someone is from isn't the least bit rude. I'm baffled.

Why would they care though? Does it matter in any way? Does the place where you grow up make you who you are? Or is it the origin of your parents who makes you who you are?

Eg you are white and have a Scottish accent. Does it matter?

You are from asian origin and you have a Scottish accent? What’s the most important do you think? What does the accent from where you grew up or the skin colour say about the person? Does it say anything about who they are, if they are kind, intelligent, whatever else people associate with that.

Would people ever comment on a so called neutral accent? If the person was again let’s say brown would they comment on the neutral accent? (Even though you could argue that said ‘neutral accent’ says just as much as one from Yorkshire or Birmingham about where they are coming from etc…)

Asking about someone’s accent because you are interested about where they are coming from/about them is one thing.
A comment out if the blue about accent is no different than a comment out fo the blue asking a non white person ‘so where you are coming from?’

lemonsaretheonlyfruit · 02/02/2022 08:29

This is exactly what people think. I’m interested in this thread because on Saturday in a queue at the airport, DH and I were making small talk with two women also queuing, as you do. Out of nowhere one of them commented on my accent. I don’t live in my region of origin, but have lived where I live now for decades. When she mentioned my accent she said “you’re from x aren’t you, I can tell by your accent”. So random, so rude - we were talking about masks and vax ffs

Baffled as to how this is rude! If she had imitated your accent or mocked it then that would have been rude. Assuming she did neither of those then that's just called 'having a conversation' surely.

SirChenjins · 02/02/2022 08:21

This is exactly what people think. I’m interested in this thread because on Saturday in a queue at the airport, DH and I were making small talk with two women also queuing, as you do. Out of nowhere one of them commented on my accent. I don’t live in my region of origin, but have lived where I live now for decades. When she mentioned my accent she said “you’re from x aren’t you, I can tell by your accent”. So random, so rude - we were talking about masks and vax ffs

See that wouldn't bother me at all - that's not mocking an accent, to me that's just saying that you recognise another accent. She might have lived there, she might have family from there, she might have been on holiday there - it's just one of those things that's said in passing. Unless she then went on to mimic you, or say something derogatory about your region - in which case that's not OK.

RampantIvy · 02/02/2022 08:16

Everyone I work with thinks I have a posh accent BTW. I don't. I have a south London Accent instead of a South Yorkshire accent.

RampantIvy · 02/02/2022 08:15

“you’re from x aren’t you, I can tell by your accent”. So random, so rude

In what way is that rude? Confused

If I was talking to a random stranger at, say, Leeds Bradford airport, and the person I was chatting to asked what part of London I was from I wouldn't find that in the least bit rude. Honestly, asking where someone is from isn't the least bit rude. I'm baffled.

Sahgah · 02/02/2022 07:54

I find it extremely tiring. After living for over 10 years overseas now I'm over people making comments on my accent. I find it rude but if I voice my objections I'm labelled as sensitive and that I can't take a joke.

JosephineDeBeauharnais · 02/02/2022 07:50

@headintheproverbial

OP - in what way don't you 'have an accent yourself'. Do you think that somehow YOUR accent is ground zero, the standard by which the rest of us are judged?!
This is exactly what people think. I’m interested in this thread because on Saturday in a queue at the airport, DH and I were making small talk with two women also queuing, as you do. Out of nowhere one of them commented on my accent. I don’t live in my region of origin, but have lived where I live now for decades. When she mentioned my accent she said “you’re from x aren’t you, I can tell by your accent”. So random, so rude - we were talking about masks and vax ffs.
RampantIvy · 02/02/2022 07:16

Oops. That wasn't meant to happen Blush

It's the same in our house. I'm from London, DH is a Geordie and DD was born in Barnsley. When she went to secondary school everyone told her she had a posh accent. She has a generic "northern" accent as does DH, because she grew up not hearing a strong local accent at home.

DH had to soften his strong accent when he first went to university because no-one could understand him. He went to university long before there were so many local accents on TV.

RampantIvy · 02/02/2022 07:10

For example late DH and I had totally different accents and our daughter has another. At times this caused some gentle ribbing and DD occasionally makes a joke about something I say and vice versa but it is all very good natured and always is within context

Nillynally · 02/02/2022 05:25

No it's rude. I'm from the midlands but have lived down south for many years so have a mixed accent, my grasses and baths are short vowel sounds rather than grar-ss barth which can be jarring when I speak and still fully grown adults will mimic me mid sentence and ask why I say it like that.

So for me of course, nothing to do with race and in the grand scheme of things accent related not a huge issue but it is rude.

If however, I hear a very strong accent, for example S Wales or W Yorkshire, my inner voice takes on the accent and I love to try to replicate it (never in front of others though!) so I see why people do mimic but to do so at peoples expense is horrible.

Bearsar90 · 02/02/2022 04:48

'Mocking' is never ok.

In context impersonating an accent for humour at nobody's expense isn't unacceptable eg acting.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 02/02/2022 04:34

[quote GrandTheftWalrus]@ZZTopGuitarSolo I actually say yo-hurt and I'm Scottish.[/quote]
Interesting, my granny and grandad said it the way I do - they were Dundonians. Well, they pronounced the R more strongly than I do. But I have a feeling my niece and nephew, who are Glaswegian, pronounce it YO-gurt.

Staryflight445 · 02/02/2022 03:46

When I moved from Yorkshire to Lincolnshire as a teen I really struggled with the sudden mocking of how I spoke.
I’ve had to completely change how I speak even though you can still tell sometimes where I’m from.

I dread to think how it feels to have an accent from another country and go through it. You can’t win though can you? If you didn’t speak English people would be moaning about that as well.

GrandTheftWalrus · 02/02/2022 03:13

@ZZTopGuitarSolo I actually say yo-hurt and I'm Scottish.

avamiah · 02/02/2022 02:41

I was born and brought up in Anfield, that’s Liverpool for anybody who doesn’t know but I have lived in London for 14 years.
I have a “scouse” accent, it’s not as strong as it used to be but that’s because my friends are all from Essex (Chigwell) .The funny thing is they love doing a scouse accent and I love doing a Essex accent, they love it when I say “what’s appening babes”.

We are good friends and nobody is mocking anybody in fact it’s the opposite we love each other’s accents.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 02/02/2022 02:06

I think it's not until you're a minority in some way that you really realise what a fucking PITA it is being different, and how relentless it can be being reminded that you're different.

I have an English accent and live in the US. The first time it was Ok that someone pointed out my accent. The second was still OK. The third it started to get boring. It went on and on.

Mostly it's people saying "I love your accent." Because gosh, yes, I really want to have this conversation with a total stranger for the fifth time this week, instead of actually being shown where the yoghurts or batteries are (and oh yes, it's so hilarious that British people don't say YO-gurt or BAD-ries).

Eventually one day a YMCA member of staff imitated something I'd just said, in a vaguely mocking manner. I'm sure she thought it was funny. I just stared at her in disgust.

It's just. So. Fucking. Relentlessly. Boring.

I know it happens in reverse too - my American kids experience it every time they visit the UK.

Kanaloa · 02/02/2022 01:38

@GabriellaMontez

Mocking isn't nice for any reason. It's laughing at someone.

But it can be funny to have a laugh at someone's accent. If everyone is laughing...

If it’s not ok to laugh at someone how is it ok to laugh at someone as long as everyone else is also laughing?

Can you do it about other stuff? Like a fat colleague? I mean they have more control over their weight than I do over the accent I got from the place I was born, and as long as we’re all having a laugh at the fat person then surely it’s ok?

Or maybe we can all laugh at the person with glasses? It’s just a laugh.

AutomaticMoon · 02/02/2022 00:13

I’d only mock the accent of supervillains such as Klaus Schwab. I’m from Europe too but people have accused me of sounding Canadian or American when in reality I first spoke English in South Africa so perhaps used to have a tinge of their accent? I was more offended at work as coworkers would refuse to pronounce my name the English way, even after I repeatedly asked them nicely, I got sworn at instead. This was in a care home, btw.