Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not drive kids to see dad?

91 replies

Mummsnett · 01/02/2022 10:27

I split with my partner of 8 years in October, we have 2 young kids, and they have remained with me in family home, which is in my name. He has moved two hours away with his sister, in the town where he also works.
I couldn't take anymore of being the facilitator and organiser of my partner as well as our kids, and feeling like he didn't do the same for me. The relationship was fine, but I felt lonely and the entire emotional, physical and logistical burden of family life fell to me. I'm much happier without him, as I feel like I can concentrate on myself and our kids without also having to look after him. That being said, I don't and have never claimed to want to parent our kids alone.

He has always had a "me first" perspective on life, and that was one of my biggest bug bears. Regardless of situation, he thinks of himself first, and others (including his kids) second.

Initially on breaking up he was sad, hopeful and angry, then reached acceptance and we managed to organise that he would come over during the week for a couple of nights, working from my home, to help with school pickups, dinners, bedtime routine etc. And then also weekends. During this time he slept in with the kids which they loved. Him being here was awkward for us both, but in a respectful way. It was short term until he gets the keys to his place which is ten minutes drive from here at the end of the month.

At the weekend however he suddenly cycled back to a place of anger and announced he won't be coming over either during the week or at weekends. Instead, he has told me I can drive to meet him halfway to his sisters an hour away to drop them off and pick them up again on the weekends.

On mulling this over I think it's unreasonable. I'm being left to look after the kids, deal with all logistics, meal times, bedtimes etc as well as working FT myself, and then I now have to drive two hours each way because he's not comfortable coming here anymore. I feel like he can decide he needs space but no consideration is given to me, I'm just expected to pick up the slack. I know I instigated the break up, but it's hard for both of us.

Help!
Am I being unreasonable saying to him that I won't drive the kids to meet him, and instead he can come here?
It's only for another month so I don't know if it's worth rocking the boat, or if I'm being a pushover.

OP posts:
Singlebutmarried · 01/02/2022 13:47

Share the responsibility for the next month. But bay it back to him with,

So how do you see this working. Let me know what the arrangements are and we can go from there.

EdHelpPls · 01/02/2022 13:46

I agree you should accommodate. My ex was similar to yours. He moved to a place that would take an hour and two buses to get to from mine as he can't drive. For my kids sake I drive them there and back every weekend (though it's only a 45 min return trip for me, but still 1.5 hours every weekend)
It irks me no end.

2 hours each way for your kids could be tough. I didn't see their ages but I wonder if instead he could have them the half term break instead of every weekend, just for this month? You drop them off on the Friday night/Saturday morning and he drops them home on Sunday afternoon the following week?

Unless you'd be concerned if he could manage them for a week, id say that could be in the kids best interests.

LittleOwl153 · 01/02/2022 13:44

I would have a think about how you want things to be when he moves back to the area - and look at implementing a path to that now.

You don't say what the current pattern is but is he expecting to have the kids every weekend? I would not want that as you get no down time with them. Perhaps the starting point is every other weekend?

Another thing to think about being February the kids will have half term in there somewhere. Could they go up to his sisters for a longer period over that time (where yes perhaps you share the travel) but that he comes down for another weekend (depending on when half term actually falls for you) before he moves - even if that means staying in a hotel or something?

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 01/02/2022 13:34

I think you’ve been very accommodating emotionally and literally! He’s had almost five months of this set up.
Now he’s lost his temper and has issued you a set of demands on an unidentified and unjustifiable basis.
Tell him he can have them for more time for a month to reflect the fact he didn’t want to continue with an arrangement which has worked well up until now.

If he doesn’t want to that’s his decision.

Cabbagepie · 01/02/2022 13:26

I think it is reasonable to share responsibility for transport for a month in these circumstances but wouldn't necessarily jump to his demand. Think what works best for you - meeting half way twice a week or one take and the other pickup - there are advantges and disadvantages to each.

RandomMess · 01/02/2022 13:08

I would be very reluctant to set a precedence that you share the travelling whether it be an hour or 10 minutes because he has this history of expecting you to facilitate things. Also if you set a precedence and it ends up in court you could be stuck with it.

You start sharing it now and he may decide to stay out where he works and you are lumbered with carrying on.

I would offer to do it as a one off and he can have them EOW for now. After all you are doing the lions share of the work.

I

Zilla1 · 01/02/2022 12:47

If it helps you feel better, could you see it as part and parcel of the deal for you to stay in the home, he had to move two hours away to stay with his sister until he enters accommodation closer to the DC. In that case, it might feel reasonable though I recognise if he has always prioritised himself over his DC which IMO is contemptible.

MrsBertBibby · 01/02/2022 12:26

Also, there is no Court rule that the parent who moved must travel. Courts can and do expect both parents to help in travel where that is in the child's best interests.

Dixiechickonhols · 01/02/2022 12:24

If it is just a month and there’s a week school holiday is there a compromise to be had. Eg he has them for longer stint over holiday to avoid some of the travelling.

MrsBertBibby · 01/02/2022 12:23

Given that this has come from him getting angry, I'd say no.

If he'd asked sensibly, I'd consider it, but in this situation you can't be rewarding his bad behaviour.

RedCandyApple · 01/02/2022 12:23

I don’t think your kids will think you are a push over I think you letting him sleep in your house says “push over” more Tbh and is confusing for the kids

DDivaStar · 01/02/2022 12:21

Although technically he moved you instigated the split and this is a temporary arrangement to get him out of the family home as you've requested. He can't find somewhere to stay on your doorstep instantly. In this instance splitting the travel seems fair.

GettingThemFromHereToThere · 01/02/2022 12:19

@Mummsnett

Thank you all for your replies. They're very mixed, which reflects how I go back and forth in my thinking on this too.

He's not being deliberately mean and I won't be involving the courts. I recognise that he is having a difficult time adjusting to this new normal and this pattern of behaviour of him doing his own thing and relying on me to pick up the pieces is well established in our relationship.

So my problem is whether to disrupt it for what is a short term scenario, and potentially cause long term damage to our co parenting relationship, or do I just go with the flow and suck it up. Should I start this new part of our relationship with a shred of self respect and draw a line in the sand in how much I will/won't do?!

I'm leaning towards its easier to go with the flow and drive the distance for the next month, purely to keep the peace and because I'm thinking of our kids and how important it is for them to see him and to see us having a good relationship etc. If he's going to be uncomfortable in my home I don't want that negativity. But then I don't want this to continue with the kids growing up seeing one parent (the mother) being a pushover... Eurgh, it's so complex.

If I'm honest, you don't come across like a pushover. You own the house outright. You ended the relationship. You got to keep your normal, whereas his life his changed radically.

I don't think the kids would think that at all. They'd see that dad has had to move away for a month as he had little option and mum is being kind and helping him out.

My BILs wife left him a few years back. They were renting and she kept the house. He was fair away from his family as she wanted to move with hers years back. He had no friends locally.

She decided she'd had enough being with him for various reasons, not dissimilar to yours. His life was SHOOK. He was depressed for ages, really struggled to keep it together.

I know your husband wasn't pulling his weight but it's possible it wasn't intentionally. It doesn't excuse it, but it does mean that he may be very shocked and hurt right now.

Give him a break, help him out, and don't play on the mantra of you being the good Samaritan; it sounds like you didn't do too badly out of the split.

Dishwashersaurous · 01/02/2022 12:15

It's much better for the kids understand that things have changed, to not have him sleeping in your house.

Driving half way seems a sensible compromise

Hb12 · 01/02/2022 12:12

Under the circumstances I would do it, with a strict time limit of the month. You are facilitating your kids seeing their dad, not helping him out. Once he is in his place he won't need to do it any more.

AmandaHoldensLips · 01/02/2022 12:12

In my experience, the more you do, the more that will be expected of you. It's "wife work" and all the inconvenience of children is beneath him.

Mummsnett · 01/02/2022 12:07

Thank you all for your replies. They're very mixed, which reflects how I go back and forth in my thinking on this too.

He's not being deliberately mean and I won't be involving the courts. I recognise that he is having a difficult time adjusting to this new normal and this pattern of behaviour of him doing his own thing and relying on me to pick up the pieces is well established in our relationship.

So my problem is whether to disrupt it for what is a short term scenario, and potentially cause long term damage to our co parenting relationship, or do I just go with the flow and suck it up. Should I start this new part of our relationship with a shred of self respect and draw a line in the sand in how much I will/won't do?!

I'm leaning towards its easier to go with the flow and drive the distance for the next month, purely to keep the peace and because I'm thinking of our kids and how important it is for them to see him and to see us having a good relationship etc. If he's going to be uncomfortable in my home I don't want that negativity. But then I don't want this to continue with the kids growing up seeing one parent (the mother) being a pushover... Eurgh, it's so complex.

OP posts:
GettingThemFromHereToThere · 01/02/2022 11:58

You say the house is yours, so I assume he's only moved to his sister's to save money to enable him to get his own place?

If that's right, then YABU. You ended the relationship (which is fair enough) but you can't expect the person without accommodation to be instantly independent.

If my partner asked me to leave hypothetically, I'd be screwed. I'd also need to move in with family temporarily which could well be a distance away.

You made the choice to end it, you have the house (which presumably he contributed towards over the 8 years), so I think the fair thing to do is for you to help facilitate the contact for the next month.

Holskey · 01/02/2022 11:52

I think you're being unfair. The burden of facilitating shared-parenting shouldn't just be his alone.

He's obviously hurt and therefore shouldn't be staying at your home with you. Given he has actually arranged accommodation nearby, presumably for the sake of the kids, and is only so far away because he is staying with family in the meantime, I think splitting the travel is the only decent thing to do.

You can't break up with him, then expect him to stay with you, and consider him selfish for not wanting to do so. You should both facilitate the shared-parenting and split the driving.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 01/02/2022 11:41

Does he want to see his kids or jus have a pop at you?

Ask him.

Shitfuckcommaetc · 01/02/2022 11:39

@sueelleker

He's the one who decided to move; travel is therefore up to him.
I think "decided" isn't quite right here. Its a stop gap for a few weeks because basically he's homeless until then?

Tbh I'd just meet halfway, it's only for a few weeks

SpilltheTea · 01/02/2022 11:28

It's not your job to facilitate him. Why should you and your children be disrupted when he could just suck it up for a month? It's only temporary for him too.

Thelnebriati · 01/02/2022 11:16

So you couldn't take having to facilitate or organise him any more, that caused the split, he feels hurt, and then he demands you facilitate and organise him seeing his kids?
He really isn't getting it, is he.

sueelleker · 01/02/2022 11:13

He's the one who decided to move; travel is therefore up to him.

HeddaGarbled · 01/02/2022 11:11

*The principle of "he moved so he does the driving" isn't really fair here though. He didn't initiate the split and clearly doesn't particularly want to be living with his sister 2 hours away. This is a stop-gap while he sorts out a new place which OP says is 10 minutes away but he can't start there till end Feb. So under these circumstances I think it's fair enough for the travelling to be split evenly. It's only temporary. But I would suggest that rather than you both meeting half way twice, he picks up from your place then you pick up from his at the end of the visit, so you each only have to get the car out once rather than 2 shorter journeys (that's more efficient for fuel too).

The idea of him coming and living back in the family home for regular visits was unworkable and shouldn't have been started really - you both need proper closure and separate lives, not this half-in, half-out mixture*

I agree with every word of this post from @BuanoKubiamVej

Swipe left for the next trending thread