Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have shouted at MIL for being racist?

189 replies

Eurydice84 · 01/02/2022 09:40

MIL has many annoying habits. One of them (which has been going on for a while) is that she mocks Italian accent and gestures (I am Italian). This could be funny from a friend once in a while, but the way she does it - when talking to DD, whom I am raising bilingual, and in a sneaky way - really upsets me. DH told her more than once that I hate it and she should stop.

Anyway yesterday she was doing it a lot. At first I made some subtle comments it should stop, then DH had a word, but it carried on so I lost it and shouted at her. I said it is disrespectful, borderline racist and if she carries on she is not welcome in my house anymore. She then left without having dinner, after DH also said she was out of order.

I feel I was wrong at shouting, but I felt really violated and needed to stand up for myself. I went through all the alternative options first (DH having a word, etc).

Now it's an incredibly awkward situation as she lives quite close and I am dreading having to see this woman again. She looks after DD once a week.... not sure I can cope with it anymore!

OP posts:
ChargingBuck · 01/02/2022 12:55

@Soul11Soul

If only life were as simple and black and white as you make out *@AmaryllisNightAndDay*.

Relationships aren't that simplistic. Presumably OP loves her partner and her child. Presumably she loves her family being together. Given they have been so kind and thoughtful towards the mil up until this point in time, her partner loves his mum. He may be more likely to forgive his mum's behaviour because he knows her and understands her. Op herself has said that she wouldn't be bothered if this was a friend of hers but hates it because it's her mother in law because she feels like it is done to wind her up. How does she know this? She is attributing negative motivations to behaviour to one person that she wouldn't attribute to another. Her husband is less likely to attribute the same negative motivations because he knows and loves his mum. People are complicated and stupid and imperfect, they make mistakes and when given the opportunity can and sometimes do learn from them.

For example I can see my own mum doing this. It wouldn't be because she is xenophobic. It would be because she is socially awkward and it would be a misguided attempt to use humour and ribbing to bond. She is also very insecure and would probably be intimidated by someone she regarded as excitingly different. Of course Ops mother in law could just be mean and cruel, none of us know.

@Soul11Soul & if your mother did this, as you are certain it would not be in malice, when the recipient of her 'bonding' said "please don't do that", she'd stop it pronto, no?

I doubt she'd need to be told dozens of times, or have your partner tell her as she wouldn't listen, or carry on when it's obvious her target was upset.

By your assertion - your mum isn't nasty enough to do that.
There's no need to defend someone else's, - who is.

Mischance · 01/02/2022 12:54

She sounds grim, both to do it at all and to ignore being told that it offends you.

Thank goodness your husband stands up for you.

Nanny0gg · 01/02/2022 12:54

@GrendelsGrandma

I wouldn't be quite as up in arms about doing the voice per se, I think it might be a generational thing as this used to be commonplace (see Manuel in Fawlty Towers etc).

However given that it's 2020 not 1980 and you have spelled out to her multiple times that it's rude and unwelcome, YANBU. Maybe having lost your rag at her will make her finally take notice.

Oh for the Love!!

Some of that 'generation' have moved on you know.

Just pack it in with the 'generational' crap

HaveringWavering · 01/02/2022 12:53

@ChargingBuck I don’t think that the definition of the MIL’s rude behaviour really matters here, all that matters is that she is behaving unacceptably towards OP. However surely the point is that the MIL would mock any Italian in the same way, regardless of their skin colour? So the mocking is not based on a racial characteristic but on nationality/culture?

Nanny0gg · 01/02/2022 12:50

@DisforDarkChocolate

This isn't borderline racist, it is racist.
I know this isn't Pedant's Corner, but no it's not.

She's Xenophobic not racist. And I do think it's important to use the right words

Either way, totally unacceptable.

ChargingBuck · 01/02/2022 12:49

@TheFrendo

That is not racist as Italians are not a race.

It is rude, unpleasant, unfunny and insulting to you. But not racist.

Again - we don't know that.

You know black people can live in Italy, being Italians, right?
Same as white Italians?
Same as black people can live in Britain, being Brits?
All of these picking up generational native mannerisms & speech patterns?

The assumption that OP - & her DH & MiL - are white is unconscious bias, which, while not malignly intended, shows how deep our expectations of "whiteness = default normal person" goes. i.e. - racism.

CoilWatershed · 01/02/2022 12:48

What are you getting at here? Are you really suggesting, that if the Op has some Burly brothers, that she sends them to scare and threaten an old lady? WOW.

The MIL might br more hesitant to be racist to their faces.

Although I doubt you as an apologist care.

Soul11Soul · 01/02/2022 12:45

@Lesperance

In the ops third post she says...

As I said, I wouldn't take offense from a friend, in a light-hearted context.

So no...I didn't "extrapolate wildly". The op is clear that she would react differently if a friend did it.

Skeumorph · 01/02/2022 12:44

Off point but the username Chickenstripper is inspired.

OP how about that one - just start calling your MIL Chickenstripper, for no reason. Next time she starts with her weird mocking - 'Shut it Chickenstripper'

HaveringWavering · 01/02/2022 12:44

@ChickenStripper but you’d already explained that. I said that I saw your point.

I then stated again that my suggestion was completely unconnected to any prejudice about people from particular nationalities, by explaining that I would simply have matched the nationality of the brother to that of the OP. I did not deny your statement that it might have been PERCEIVED that way. I’m not sure why you feel the need to keep repeating that point?

fuzzwuss · 01/02/2022 12:38

The only surprising thing about your reaction is that you waited so long to make your position clear. Coming from a family with a number of nationalities, and also the mother of bilingual children, I am outraged on your behalf about her behaviour. Your MiL is incredibly rude, and as a pp said, this is a power play to make sure you understand your place. Do not even for one second think about making peace. Find alternative childcare and stick to your boundaries. You have to stand up to bullies, and this is exactly what she is.

ChickenStripper · 01/02/2022 12:36

[quote HaveringWavering]@ChickenStripper I am at a total loss as to what you are getting at. What do you mean about naming other nationalities? I picked them at random! I’ll say this very slowly- the nationality of the burly brother in my scenario was irrelevant. The only qualification was that he should be the same nationality as the OP, and burly![/quote]
As people would say you need to go away and think about what you said. Let me explain it slowly - if I were Italian and you said get one of my burly brothers to go round and deal with her I would think she is basing this on thinking that all Italians are tied to the Mafia. If I were Scottish and you said that I would think you are saying Scottish men are rough. Need I go on? I am pointing out to you that we don't always see the insult unless it applies to us and that everyone can hold some less than satisfactory stereotypes/misperceptions. Here you are commenting on this and not even seeing your own comment for what it is in some people's eyes. OK point made.

HaveringWavering · 01/02/2022 12:32

Oh and by the way @ChickenStripper one of the nationalities I listed was my own!

KittenKong · 01/02/2022 12:32

OP mentioned that she mocks her Italian accent and hand gestures. The assumption is xenophobia rather than race since race wasn’t mentioned on the OP or subsequent posts (and it would be relevant).

My parents would have loved one of us bringing an Italian home. Dad lived there for a couple of years when he was young and they both loved all things Italian.

scottishnames · 01/02/2022 12:31

Posted too early, Chickenstripper I meant to sign off with a good ol' 1960s slogan 'Peace and Love'!

RantyAunty · 01/02/2022 12:30

You did the right thing. You've tried being polite about it.
Hopefully she doesn't do it again.

I hope it's not white people correcting others for their use of racist or xenophobic.

My exH family were xenophobic and would make comments and one day I blew up and shouted at them to stop it. They never did it again.
My ex regularly slags off my country of birth. The nut didn't fall far from the tree.

I also had plenty of people mock me being deaf. After their stupid fake lip reading, flailing around sign language, and raising their voice, sometimes I say, well done on being a horse's arse.

scottishnames · 01/02/2022 12:30

ChickenStripper Many of those TV programmes were widely criticised at the time. It was a hot topic; no-one around at the time could have been unaware that (a) discrimation was against the law and (b) a growing number of people found it totally unacceptable.

And, in any case, as I said in my second post, mocking people for perceived differences has been bad manners for the past 100 years and more.

But I do absolutely accept your wider point - attitudes among older people in the 1960s and 1970s were slow to change. There was an horrendous amount of casual racism on TV and elsewhere. However - I presume - the OP's MIL would have been a child at that time. She would have grown up to adulthood when attitudes were changing. She's had ample time to learn.

And as to your experience re accents and dialects; that's very sad to hear. And I'm sure you're right about the ghastly social prejudice behind it. But there is surely a big difference between being taught - however misguidedly - to 'talk posh' and the face-to-face, individual mocking of someone who looks different or speaks with a different accent?
In any case, we're both agreed that the OP's MIL behaved very badly.

My original point was to call out the casual ageism that sometimes seems to infest Mumsnet. People seem to have no idea of the rapid and far-reaching changes that took place in the late 20th cent, and and how many of us 'oldies' argued and campaigned to bring those changes about! Being old does not make anyone lose the progressive ideas of their youth - or indeed get rid of their intellect, manners etc etc etc.

HaveringWavering · 01/02/2022 12:29

@ChickenStripper I am at a total loss as to what you are getting at. What do you mean about naming other nationalities? I picked them at random! I’ll say this very slowly- the nationality of the burly brother in my scenario was irrelevant. The only qualification was that he should be the same nationality as the OP, and burly!

ChargingBuck · 01/02/2022 12:27

@WhatATimeToBeAlive

YANBU, but she is xenophobic, not racist.
How do you know?

OP hasn't specified what colour she, or anyone else mentioned is.

cutebutscary · 01/02/2022 12:26

It's awkward isn't it ? MIL situations can be fraught . I think she should apologise to you and her son needs to tell her this. This isn't your fault

ChickenStripper · 01/02/2022 12:22

[quote HaveringWavering]@ChickenStripper I see your point but how is it relevant to the OP? The MIL was clearly mocking her accent and gestures, this was not a situation where OP might have taken offence to something that was not meant to be offensive.

For the avoidance of doubt I would have made the same “burly brother” suggestion if OP had said she was Bulgarian or Scottish or Portuguese.[/quote]
and that is exactly my point - you are being as bad as her MIL. You have just added to your post by naming 3 other nationalities. Unbelievable.🙄

HaveringWavering · 01/02/2022 12:20

@ChickenStripper I see your point but how is it relevant to the OP? The MIL was clearly mocking her accent and gestures, this was not a situation where OP might have taken offence to something that was not meant to be offensive.

For the avoidance of doubt I would have made the same “burly brother” suggestion if OP had said she was Bulgarian or Scottish or Portuguese.

ChickenStripper · 01/02/2022 12:16

@HaveringWavering

Do you mean Mafia style? Are you buying into a misconception here?

No, I mean that bullies think twice about mocking burly men rather than women.

You see though what i am getting at? How one person thinks something is OK to say but another one sees offence in it?

It's like the current situation with Whoopi Goldberg denying that the Holocaust was "racism" as Jews were not black.

6demandingchildren · 01/02/2022 12:15

My grandson is being brought up bilingual and I try to learn with him, I have even been to madeira (when his dad was born) to learn some more, met a lovely waiter who corrected me as my accent is way off, but I thought that is what families do Hmm

AskingforaBaskin · 01/02/2022 12:15

@BlondeDogLady

At first I made some subtle comments it should stop, then DH had a word, but it carried on so I lost it and shouted at her. I said it is disrespectful, borderline racist and if she carries on she is not welcome in my house anymore

You've taken it way too far, imo. Some things can't be unsaid and you were pretty brutal.

I love an Italian accent. So do most people - it's seen as one of the sexiest accents on the planet.

Your MIL is lonely. And now she will be even more lonely, and upset to boot. I wouldn't be happy with myself if I had done this.

Awww the xenophobic has found the consequences of her own actions. My heart bleeds.

If there was only a way she could've stopped this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread