Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they should have increased tax rather than NI?

35 replies

needabreak5 · 31/01/2022 19:59

So those who earn below the threshold cumulatively across the don't have to pay more?

Eg students who only work in the summer, people on maternity pay, people who lose jobs, or reduce during the tax year. Anyone whose income massively fluctuates. If it was tax then they'd be able to claim it back. With NI they'll just be more out of pocket as you can't claim back in the next pay period or from HMRC :(

OP posts:
RandomLondoner · 31/01/2022 20:40

There is an excuse for putting it on NI, the increase is for "health and social care" which are some of the sorts of things NI is supposed to pay for.

If they just put it on tax they'd have to admit NI is just another income tax, and merge them properly. I would quite like that, to have a simpler and logically consistent system. Unfortunately my idea of doing it properly would mean a basic rate of tax of 40%, which would be less palatable to voters than the current smoke and mirrors set-up, even though it would make virtually no difference to take-home pay.

echt · 31/01/2022 20:34

@balancingfigure

Yes agree and for several other reasons!

Employers pay it to so they may reconsider jobs or just pay rises.

I don’t see why people with unearned income shouldn’t contribute too- wealthy old people, people with rental and investment income

Wealthy old people already pay tax at the same rate as non-OAPS. Landlords already pay tax.
user1497207191 · 31/01/2022 20:30

@Ifailed

NI is a tax.
Yes, but not on all income, only wages.
littleowls83 · 31/01/2022 20:29

I'm being hit by NI despite only earning about £7k a year as some months I do overtime as my work is really seasonal. Annoying. Its so people feel like they pay less tax, because something that doesn't have tax in the name isn't a tax, right??

Ifailed · 31/01/2022 20:22

NI is a tax.

TurquoiseDragon · 31/01/2022 20:22

They don't want to put it on taxes as it'll upset their friends.

user1497207191 · 31/01/2022 20:18

Yes, or better still scrap it and increase income tax instead. The burden needs to be spread over everyone according to all income, not just on a proportion of workers. Far too many people don’t pay NIC and the burden falls on too few.

OfstedOffred · 31/01/2022 20:14

I assumed it was slightly to stop employers under employing (refusing to give an employee more hours) to save on NICS

needabreak5 · 31/01/2022 20:09

Oh yes, the employers increase could well be paid for by not giving pay rises - so many employees will take the hit for that too unfortunately

OP posts:
balancingfigure · 31/01/2022 20:05

Yes agree and for several other reasons!

Employers pay it to so they may reconsider jobs or just pay rises.

I don’t see why people with unearned income shouldn’t contribute too- wealthy old people, people with rental and investment income