Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they should have increased tax rather than NI?

35 replies

needabreak5 · 31/01/2022 19:59

So those who earn below the threshold cumulatively across the don't have to pay more?

Eg students who only work in the summer, people on maternity pay, people who lose jobs, or reduce during the tax year. Anyone whose income massively fluctuates. If it was tax then they'd be able to claim it back. With NI they'll just be more out of pocket as you can't claim back in the next pay period or from HMRC :(

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ancientgran · 31/01/2022 21:53

@Mountaingoat12

It’s a tax that focuses directly on earnings rather than income or wealth. Those with income from sources other than working or those with amassed wealth are not affected. This is unfair.

If you want to raise taxes, how about hitting the one vast source of untaxed income many wealthy pensioners have - capital gains made on their main residential property?

Do you mean capital gains when they sell up? Surely that couldn't be introduced just for pensioners, shouldn't anyone making capital gains pay?
meditrina · 31/01/2022 21:45

I think it's to tax the workforce only, as a way of getting back sine if the costs of furlough

Not everyone got furlough, of course, but the reason it existed was to preserve jobs (preventing lay offs, keeping employers afloat), which was in the interests of the whole workforce. Who are now starting to pay for it

twominutesmore · 31/01/2022 21:24

"Plenty of pensioners on really high incomes still relative to the working population. Why don’t they have to pay when someone earning 12k does?!"

Because it is an insurance that pays out when you are eligible. Pensioners pay in for 40 or 50 years and then claim their state pension.

Pensioners who work will pay the social care levy though I think.

Topicall · 31/01/2022 21:20

I expect this was the discussion in Cabinet:

  1. What will raise money without any of us sitting round this table having to pay anything noticeable?
  2. What will raise money in such a way that people who may vote for us will know that we have put their interests before the interests of those who are unlikely to vote for us? I imagine that's how most decisions are reached.
TurquoiseDragon · 31/01/2022 21:18

@Kendodd

And besides, why do they need to do this at all? Where the fucks the 350 million a week we were promised?
Farage denied ever making that promise the morning after the referendum. Despite posters on buses, etc.

And that money has effectively been spent on all the negotiations, Covid, etc.

It was never really there, it was just a soundbite to reel people in to the Leave side.

user1471453601 · 31/01/2022 21:08

It's not just "wealthy" pensioners who pay tax. I pay tax pro rata compared to my earnings prior to retirement . I pay no NI. No idea what the thinking behind that is. I cost, for example, the NHS much more the older I get.

I totally agree that the raise should be on income tax, not NI.
It's ridiculous, I "earn" way above the minimum wage, and I live mortgage free. So my disposable income is way for than when I actually worked.

There's an argument I've heard that I've worked for 40+ years, so it's ok. To my mind, it isn't fine. I'm financially able to contribute more, but I now give to various charities instead of paying my way.

I'm in no way suggesting those pensioners who live only on RP and pension credit should pay more tax, but just that retired people like me, who are quite financially comfortable should.

Why should I dodge this "tax" increase while working families pay for it?

It just seems wrong.

Mountaingoat12 · 31/01/2022 21:03

It’s a tax that focuses directly on earnings rather than income or wealth. Those with income from sources other than working or those with amassed wealth are not affected. This is unfair.

If you want to raise taxes, how about hitting the one vast source of untaxed income many wealthy pensioners have - capital gains made on their main residential property?

Oblomov22 · 31/01/2022 20:57

I feel this is very unfair aswell.

ancientgran · 31/01/2022 20:57

@canary1

Totally agree. It’s a disgrace that some people like wealthy OAPs are not sharing the burden
What about wealthy non OAPs? Surely it is the wealth that is relevant not age.
Kendodd · 31/01/2022 20:56

And besides, why do they need to do this at all? Where the fucks the 350 million a week we were promised?

SoManyTshirts · 31/01/2022 20:54

It’s not just pensioners and the idle rich who don’t pay NI, it’s also (off the top of my head from tax law circa 1987) landlords and people who are self-employed through their companies and take their pay as dividends. The ones who complained that they weren’t eligible for furlough on the back of their non-existent contributions.

As pension is determined by the NI you have paid, paying it after retirement age could theoretically increase the amount of your state pension in future years - if you don’t already have the max entitlement. Can’t see HMRC’s IT department being able to cope with that.

TurquoiseDragon · 31/01/2022 20:52

It's all about appearances. Nothing else.

All monies raised by the Government goes into one, big pot. It's called the Consolidated Fund. The Chancellor then decides each year how he's going to dish it out.

None of the money is separated into different pots when it's collected. EG, money raised by Vehicle Excise duty is not set aside to repair roads, like some people think. NI is not set aside to pay pensions.

It's all smoke and mirrors.

Kendodd · 31/01/2022 20:51

I agree. Or better still put it on unearned income like inheritance tax.
NI will hit the poorest the hardest which I suppose is only to be expected of the Tories.

Beancounter1 · 31/01/2022 20:51

There is an excuse for putting it on NI, the increase is for "health and social care" which are some of the sorts of things NI is supposed to pay for.

That idea was put about only in recent decades - New Labour I think started that particular scam. NI was originally just a contribution to pensions and benefits, nothing to do with NHS or social care.

Rich politicians and their rich donors don't like increasing income tax as it affects their own finances too much.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/01/2022 20:50

@needabreak5

Oh yes, the employers increase could well be paid for by not giving pay rises - so many employees will take the hit for that too unfortunately
Yep my employer has done just this!
echt · 31/01/2022 20:49

But they don't pay NI, so they won't share the burden of the tax (and NI is a tax) increase

I'm not arguing against these people paying tax as the OP suggests, just pointing out they already do.

trunktoes · 31/01/2022 20:46

Well someone who is earning 100k in pensions has probably paid loads of NI and won't be using it for as long as those who are younger. I think part timers should pay more. They still use the doctors etc

Wfhquery · 31/01/2022 20:46

@canary1

Totally agree. It’s a disgrace that some people like wealthy OAPs are not sharing the burden
Pensioners will pay the increase if they have earning income from 2023, its social care levy so seperate to ni, it’s just added to ni for 22-23 to give time for computer systems to be updated
catinthewindow · 31/01/2022 20:45

@needabreak5

Wealthy old people already pay tax at the same rate as non-OAPS. Landlords already pay tax.

But they don't pay NI, so they won't share the burden of the tax (and NI is a tax) increase.

Exactly this. I work with numerous people on good salaries but over retirement age. You stop paying NI once you qualify for pension. This makes sense when you’re thinking about someone not working and relying on a low pension. But I don’t understand at all why someone earning 100k doesn’t have to pay NI just because they’re 65+ or whatever the age is now. Plenty of pensioners on really high incomes still relative to the working population. Why don’t they have to pay when someone earning 12k does?!
Wfhquery · 31/01/2022 20:45

@balancingfigure

Yes agree and for several other reasons!

Employers pay it to so they may reconsider jobs or just pay rises.

I don’t see why people with unearned income shouldn’t contribute too- wealthy old people, people with rental and investment income

Tax on dividends is going up by same amount as ni increase
needabreak5 · 31/01/2022 20:43

@littleowls83 this is exactly the issue I'm talking about! It's not right that you'll be hit by the increase, when someone with a more passive income doesn't share it.

OP posts:
canary1 · 31/01/2022 20:42

Totally agree. It’s a disgrace that some people like wealthy OAPs are not sharing the burden

JuergenSchwarzwald · 31/01/2022 20:42

Employee NI should be done away with altogether and we should just have income tax. They think we are to stupid to realise NI is a tax Angry

HainaultViaNewburyPark · 31/01/2022 20:41

It’s a deliberate ploy to exclude pensioners from having to pay anything extra. An increase in income tax would be fairer.

needabreak5 · 31/01/2022 20:40

Wealthy old people already pay tax at the same rate as non-OAPS. Landlords already pay tax.

But they don't pay NI, so they won't share the burden of the tax (and NI is a tax) increase.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread