Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be angry at my DH for talking to his mother

141 replies

wayovermyhead · 31/01/2022 16:23

My DH has been going through court to have access in our home for his elder children. We have 2 children together. Atm he sees his oldest 2 in his mothers house, staying there every weekend while I'm at home with the youngest 2. This is court ordered This is because his exw is adamant she doesnt want me around her children. This all started when i was pregnant and i feel she cannot move on from the fact i have 2 children with my DH as she always thought her children would be his only biological children. Our children have only seen each other once in 2 years.

She has spent the last 18 months lying and exaggerating "evidence" about me and making new and wild accusations at every hearing, however some information she is using is coming directly from DH mother who still rings her regularly for chats. This includes medical information about my pnd and teenage depression, and the fact i was severely ill during pregnancy with spd and hg sickness, stating i wasnt well enough to have them here and that my DH was practically my carer bizarrely. She also used when i changed jobs, when my children started nursery etc and my eldest childs medical problems.

Last week i was admitted urgently to hospital with a severe infection and was on iv antibiotics for 3 days. I was extremely ill and am still not better.

I asked my DP not tell his mother anything other than i was ok but rather keep the rest private, as i feel she will just pass this on to his ex who will then twist it in court somehow. I feel my MIL is very controlling and domineering and i refuse to have a relationship with her, but my DH loves her understandably and is with her all weekend and finds in difficult in knowing what he can say and what he cant.

I found out yesterday that he has told her everything and now i feel i cannot trust him and feel betrayed. He cannot see that his mothers want to know about whats going on is not as important as my right to privacy.

AIBU to be furious?

OP posts:
altmember · 31/01/2022 21:19

@wayovermyhead

The reason he is seeing his children at his mothers is because his exw keeps making new allegations every hearing and the court keep having to investigate it. He can take the children anywhere but our house but where else would he go overnight?
Whole situation sounds completely bonkers, unless you're missing something significant out.

You should go along to the next court hearing and point out that you aren't the psycho child molesting wicked step mother that his ex is painting you as. Doesn't seem right that she can throw all these wild allegations about and you not be there to defend yourself.

BertramLacey · 31/01/2022 21:15

Its true i can only go on what he tells me,as i am not allowed to see anything as its sealed to the participants.

How convenient. Except, since he's a participant he could read it and then pass it along to you. Personally, I wouldn't believe anything he says. He is between a rock and hard place, trying to keep you, the mother of his other children, and his own mother happy. However, that is a problem of his own making and he should deal with it better.

RedWingBoots · 31/01/2022 21:09

@fuckoffjournalists

The only reason the court would order contact like this for those reasons , I.e his x dosen’t like you is if he agreed to those conditions.
They wouldn't include the OPs children in it.

There is also case law which means the courts want siblings including half-siblings to have relationships with one another.

The father can facilitate this for all his children alone without any of their mothers involvement.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 31/01/2022 21:08

Let me get this straight , for three years the children came to your house without any problems, then you got pregnant and now DH only see's them every weekend at his Mothers house, even though there is no actual court order that stipulates this ? And he never takes your younger children with him, is that your decision or his ?

GettingItOutThere · 31/01/2022 21:06

is he really at his mums?

i believe he is lying to you, you should contact the police and do a sarahs law (is that the correct one?!?).

i call bull shit - someone is lying here and i think its your DH

fuckoffjournalists · 31/01/2022 20:57

The only reason the court would order contact like this for those reasons , I.e his x dosen’t like you is if he agreed to those conditions.

Randomitemsonthedoorstep · 31/01/2022 20:54

@Hapoydayz

The courts would do anything almost to maintain a sibling relationship, so why doesn't he take yours to meet the others?
My money's on it being because his ex has made her position clear in that she not the courts doesn't want OP's children around hers.

That's another thing you can do to catch him out OP, tell him to take your DC with him next contact weekend because after all its you who's the problem right? Not the children Wink

ToykotoLosAngeles · 31/01/2022 20:54

@Viviennemary

Sorry I thought OP said he wasn't allowed to talk to his mother. That is what the thread title implies.
Uh huh. And yet you read enough to know this was involving his ex. Who is not in the title. So determined to disagree with OP that you skim read it, maybe?
Hapoydayz · 31/01/2022 20:50

The courts would do anything almost to maintain a sibling relationship, so why doesn't he take yours to meet the others?

angelikacpickles · 31/01/2022 20:42

@Viviennemary

Sorry I thought OP said he wasn't allowed to talk to his mother. That is what the thread title implies.
Perhaps try reading a little more than the title before you start accusing people of being "horribly controlling".
Theunamedcat · 31/01/2022 20:37

@Viviennemary

Sorry I thought OP said he wasn't allowed to talk to his mother. That is what the thread title implies.
If you read more than the thread title you will see where you went wrong
Randomitemsonthedoorstep · 31/01/2022 20:36

If you want to find out if he's lying, OP, tell him you're making contact with cafcass / a solicitor yourself.

Tell him that you can't believe that you, a respectable mother of two whom also happens to be the mother of children's siblings, is being tarred by the courts as the reason your DH can't have his children at his home.

Watch his reaction, it will speak volumes.

Viviennemary · 31/01/2022 20:31

Sorry I thought OP said he wasn't allowed to talk to his mother. That is what the thread title implies.

LonelyInAutumn · 31/01/2022 20:25

@Viviennemary

You sound horribly controlling. Your DH isnt allowed to communicate with his mother because you don't like his ex being friends with his mother. I agree there is more to this.
@Viviennemary controlling because she doesn't want ALL of her medical history shared with people? Even down to issues from her teenage years? Right. Okay 🙄
GrandDuchessRomanov · 31/01/2022 20:10

Well if it was me and I was being cited as the reason that he couldn't have the kids at my home I would bloody well want to know what was being said about me!

Why on earth haven't you demanded to see what is being alleged about you?

ChristmasPlanning · 31/01/2022 20:06

Your DH should not share medical or other personal information about you without your consent.

However I agree it sounds unusual about where he stays etc. are you sure you are getting the whole truth?

Polkmn · 31/01/2022 20:03

@Viviennemary

You sound horribly controlling. Your DH isnt allowed to communicate with his mother because you don't like his ex being friends with his mother. I agree there is more to this.
That's a really unfair and shitty thing to say. Op hasn't said her H can't speak to his mother. She has said she doesn't want H speaking to his mother about her and her medical history as the mother keeps relaying to the Ex. I agree with a lot of posters you have an H problem not an Ex W or MIL problem.

You need to have this out with your H to get the truth of the situation as he seems to be the one painting you in a bad light. If he respected you as his wife and your privacy he wouldn't be using you to create drama, which he and his mother seem to thrive on.

2bazookas · 31/01/2022 20:00

Something doesn't sound right here. A court orders the father of 4, that he spends every weekend with 2, who can't meet the other 2?

You say the court has to keep investigating new allegations about you? Have you actually been at a court hearing , OR actually seen any official printed copy of the Court Order?

Or, is this all hearsay you get second hand from DH and his mother?

LagunaBubbles · 31/01/2022 19:50

You need to talk to your DH, something doesn't make sense.

mixum · 31/01/2022 19:49

I do not know anything about family law, but as you appear to be the reason (according to court reports) that siblings are not allowed to be together, are you entitled/justified in seeking to find out what the orders or interim orders say about your role in all this?

I would have thought that under GDPR that you have a right to access any information being held about you.

Have you tried to find out yourself, rather than taking the word of your husband and his "sealed to participant" order? Ask for a copy of any reports mentioning you from husband, if he refuses, ask the courts to provide it maybe?

Be proactive, you will not get any answers here and I am sure you know that.

Shadow1678 · 31/01/2022 19:48

OP you are being lied to. Tell your DH to show you all the court documents. Also contact a solicitor to ask your rights to see the docs , they will usually give an initial consultation for free and you can tell your DH you know your legal rights because you’ve had legal advice , I guarantee you he will shut himself when he realises he’s been caught out!
You need to stand up for yourself and your DC flowers 💐

StarryNightSparkles · 31/01/2022 19:46

Hi op, this whole situation is one big mess and I personally think it's all down to your husband. I think the ex wife has told him her demands and hes constantly jumping to them. I think she set out her stall when you were first pregnant and he agreed to keep the peace. Now times have moved on and he's dug himself into a massive hole.

You are his wife yet never seen any legal documents. Of course you can see and read them but more importantly why isn't he discussing them/reading them with you. Wouldn't these be available online?

His mother shouldn't be getting told your medical history and why hasn't your husband pulled his mum up for giving private information to his ex wife? Especially when they are in court. Not just about you but his life also.

Have you ever been to any of these hearings with him?

Personal I don't think that the court is involved in any way at all.

Why does your dh need to stay over?
Why can't he take you and your children?
Why is it every weekend?
The list of whys is endless in this situation and I am not sure why you haven't questioned all this before.

Honestly op I think you are so far in the woods that you can't see the trees. Everything you know is what he's told you, your anger to the ex wife and mother in law is because what hes told you.

Please open your eyes. He is putting everyone else before you but making it all your fault.

ANameChangeAgain · 31/01/2022 19:44

I don't think you are lying, but I think you have been fed some bs. Please listen to this
In 12 years - I have come across this less than a handful of times
And it’s ALWAYS been justified
The courts do this as a last resort
Now I might have watched too many made for TV films, but I don't think its about you at all, I think he's a bad'un and his ex will only allow visits with him under strict conditions. He is keeping you away because he doesn't want you to find out the truth. If I were you I would contact the police under Sarah's Law (is that the right one?) and find out if there is anything you should know.

ThistlesAndUnicorns · 31/01/2022 19:43

@Merryoldgoat

The thing is OP, the people on here have experience of the system and this just doesn’t make sense. So there are two possibilities:
  1. Your DH isn’t telling you the truth
  2. You aren’t telling us the truth

If she withdrew contact after uninterrupted contact with no issue the court wouldn’t order no contact with you present without compelling reason.

There is no reason you can’t see the court reports and documents. If your husband is a Litigant in Person then all of the documents will be going to him. There is no reason you can’t see them.

In the absence of a court order or direction during a hearing there is no reason he can’t bring them home.

So what’s missing? What is she accusing you of?

On a separate point, yes your DH should keep your health to himself.

I am often cried down when I say this but getting involved with someone where you don’t have a reasonable and trustworthy relationship with them is just courting disaster.

This. My comment may not have read well but I meant he can show you the documents AND you can go along to solicitors appointments - not that you had to do the latter to read the former.

Feel free to PM me if you want to talk outside the forum (although from my username you can tell I'm Scottish so the laws slightly differ if you're down south)

ElEmEnOhPee · 31/01/2022 19:39

Is your DH definitely staying at his mums each weekend? He's not off somewhere else and using the looking after the kids as an excuse? I don't understand how he hasn't taken your two for the occasional weekend at his mums too and even if it's a bit small surely he can have them all together for at least a couple of hours at the weekend?

Swipe left for the next trending thread