Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how you feel today if you voted for Boris Johnson at the last election?

545 replies

Readyforthegoodlife · 31/01/2022 16:20

It’s absolutely no surprise that Boris is behaving in this way but I cannot actually believe that we have a prime minister like this. He is utterly morally bankrupt. If you voted for him how do you feel now?

OP posts:
Yeahthat · 01/02/2022 11:53

@potniatheron

Exactly. Gordon Brown is another who I'd put in that category.

truthfullylying · 01/02/2022 11:52

Nadia Whittome's recent calls for an open border (to the entire world) immigration policy are an example as to why. Labour has been entirely captured by the transatlantic twitter class There are wacky Tories too, what matters is party policy not what one far-leaning MP says. Labour really hasn't been captured, the latest NEC makeup is decidedly centre.

Middle class student politics, is what Labour is now No, what was the partially the case under Corbyn is admin history. The drop in membership after Starmer took over was a certain type of person leaving.

potniatheron · 01/02/2022 11:50

OhWhyNot - yes! She was super popular with a lot of immigrant families. My family was split...my grandmother told me the Tories were 'only for rich people', my dad liked her cos of right to buy. It's not black and white but so many people behave like it is.

All politicans are the same...I ust try to pick the least worst for me and mine.

truthfullylying · 01/02/2022 11:49

@potniatheron

Hi truthfullylying, I think we're almost getting down to a philosophical issue, which is what do people actually have in mind when they vote. If I'm understanding you correctly, when you go into the voting booth, you have in mind the proper long term, decades hence, and a comparison of living standards in the UK and other European countries. You think of all the 70 million peopple in the UK, rather than you and your network. That's cool. For me, when I go in the voing booth, I've got in mind the parties' manifestos and the interviews they give on TV before the election, and what their policies will mean for me and my family over the next 5 years. How we will live, our livelihoods, our living standrads over the next five years. Because that's what I am focussed on - me and my family being OK over the next five years.

So we have two different perspectives when we vote, and I personally think yours isthe more privileged perspective, but of course, that doesnt assign any greater moral weight to your perspective or mine. They're just different. You're doing you and I'm doing me. That's all good.

If Labour have better policies for me at the next election, I'll vote Labour. But I have no idea currently what Labour's policies are, other than woman is just a feeling, and lots of party members hate the leader and want Jeremy Corbyn back. So if Kier wnats my vote, he better pull his finger out.

Finally I should add that I understand the structural issues you refer to. I would suggest that they are attributable to a number of macroeconomic issues which are beyond the control of any British government - the flood of cheap debt in the early 00s, ultra low interest rates since 2007, the rise in asset prices across the developed world, the economic growth of China, the shift to a digital world. In social terms, the effects of social media and hyper-individualisation and the collapse of religion and regional identities also play a role. In my view.

So we have two different perspectives when we vote, and I personally think yours isthe more privileged perspective I reject your description of me as privileged. You have nothing upon which to base that and it is inaccurate!
DarleneSnell · 01/02/2022 11:48

Feel fine. Certainly wouldn't prefer Starmer, Sturgeon or Drakeford.

potniatheron · 01/02/2022 11:44

I agree with you Yeahthat.

Nadia Whittome's recent calls for an open border (to the entire world) immigration policy are an example as to why. Labour has been entirely captured by the transatlantic twitter class that seems to be inspired by whatever the latest idiocy to come out of America is.

  • this is what I'm saying. Middle class student politics, is what Labour is now. I personally think Kier Starmer's an adult, but he's the only one in the room at Labour at the moment. If they had a front bench with the likes of David Blunkett, Robin Cook, Mo Mowlem, this would be a different conversation entirely.
OhWhyNot · 01/02/2022 11:42

Did you know that many of our lives improved under Thatcher years … why do you think she was so popular with many working class people, with many immigrants (my Asian family love her)

It doesn’t suit the argument does it that all Tory polices are awful terrible and the poor suffer and all Tory voters are scum

Politics isn’t so black and white it isn’t so simplistic

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/02/2022 11:41

@Polkmn

I have voted YABU as nobody other than his local constituents actually voted for Boris. In the election, you vote for your lost favoured MP and rhr party with the most MPs voted for in local constituencies come into power. It just so happened at the last GE that was Boris. I did vote Cobservative but not for Boris. I can't stand the over inflated, blundering buffoon. I voted as I liked my local MP and what they stood for. Not all Tory MPs think the sun shines out of Boris' arse, just as not all Labour MPs are raving Corbynites.
But you knew you were getting Boris, didn't you? We all knew voting Labour would have led to Corbyn being Prime minister, as all the pathetic "but Corbyn" posts on any thread about Tories illustrates. You're really making a distinction that doesn't exist.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/02/2022 11:38

Many working class people have been better off under the Tories
I'd love to see the working out behind this - or maybe it's just another "everyone knows that" down the pub wisdom not actually based on any facts or data, like the people who illogically call Tories a "low tax" party when the evidence points the other way. Did you know that the burden of taxation, both in absolute terms and as a proportion of GDP actually rose during the Thatcher years?

Polkmn · 01/02/2022 11:37

I have voted YABU as nobody other than his local constituents actually voted for Boris.
In the election, you vote for your lost favoured MP and rhr party with the most MPs voted for in local constituencies come into power. It just so happened at the last GE that was Boris. I did vote Cobservative but not for Boris. I can't stand the over inflated, blundering buffoon. I voted as I liked my local MP and what they stood for. Not all Tory MPs think the sun shines out of Boris' arse, just as not all Labour MPs are raving Corbynites.

IntermittentParps · 01/02/2022 11:35

His behaviour was hypocritical and dishonest, but that's not egregious for our politicians.
Is it not? Hmm I tend to believe that politicians should – must, in fact – be held to higher standards than the rest of us.
And it wasn't 'just' hypocritical and dishonest. It's being investigated by the police.
More to the point, when challenged on it, rather than at least holding up his hands at the start and admitting to it all, he's defended, deflected, blustered and gone on nonsensical counterattacks. Of which the Jimmy S one is the most offensive, not to mention wrong-headed considering his own history when talking about this issue.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/02/2022 11:34

[quote Yeahthat]@AllThingsServeTheBeam

I'll bite.

  • I don't particularly care that Boris Johnson had some parties/work events with the addition of cake. His behaviour was hypocritical and dishonest, but that's not egregious for our politicians. I don't imagine that shuffling the deck, changing some faces around and bringing the other lot in for four years will change that. There's reprehensible and useless individuals at all levels of British politics and in every party. We need fundamental change, and given that that's not possible at present, the best I can do is vote for myself, my family, and my community is to vote for the "least worst" option. At the last election, that was the Conservative party.
  • Do I still believe that Corbyn and Labour would have been worse? Yes. I found him to be dangerous (comments praising Chavez, Maduro and Venezuela as an exemplar for all the world, Antisemitism etc). Do I care whether you think that's valid or true? No. I won't be canvassing the opinion of internet warriors before I cast my vote.
  • Will I vote Conservative at the next election? Very likely, yes. Nadia Whittome's recent calls for an open border (to the entire world) immigration policy are an example as to why. Labour has been entirely captured by the transatlantic twitter class that seems to be inspired by whatever the latest idiocy to come out of America is. See also Starmer and Rayner taking the knee. Empty, gesture politics great for generating retweets, but absolutely useless to me as a voter.[/quote]
His behaviour was hypocritical and dishonest, but that's not egregious for our politicians That poverty of ambition disgusts, but doesn't surprise me. There are decent MPs on all sides. Boris isn't one of them.
Iggly · 01/02/2022 11:34

[quote Yeahthat]@AllThingsServeTheBeam

I'll bite.

  • I don't particularly care that Boris Johnson had some parties/work events with the addition of cake. His behaviour was hypocritical and dishonest, but that's not egregious for our politicians. I don't imagine that shuffling the deck, changing some faces around and bringing the other lot in for four years will change that. There's reprehensible and useless individuals at all levels of British politics and in every party. We need fundamental change, and given that that's not possible at present, the best I can do is vote for myself, my family, and my community is to vote for the "least worst" option. At the last election, that was the Conservative party.
  • Do I still believe that Corbyn and Labour would have been worse? Yes. I found him to be dangerous (comments praising Chavez, Maduro and Venezuela as an exemplar for all the world, Antisemitism etc). Do I care whether you think that's valid or true? No. I won't be canvassing the opinion of internet warriors before I cast my vote.
  • Will I vote Conservative at the next election? Very likely, yes. Nadia Whittome's recent calls for an open border (to the entire world) immigration policy are an example as to why. Labour has been entirely captured by the transatlantic twitter class that seems to be inspired by whatever the latest idiocy to come out of America is. See also Starmer and Rayner taking the knee. Empty, gesture politics great for generating retweets, but absolutely useless to me as a voter.[/quote]
So why does it not matter what the Prime minister said or does but it does when it can to Corbyn?

If it’s about the policies, then fair enough. But on the one hand you’re saying it’s ok to express racists lying tendencies as long as they’re Tory (current Prime Minister) but not to express other tendencies because they’re Labour?

So for you, you could have an extreme right wing nasty arse of a leader as long as they had a blue rosette.

Which I suspect is the case for most die hard Tory voters.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/02/2022 11:32

@Adeleskirts

I’m also fine, I think work parties are ludicrous and we need to understand better but do believe we’d be in even more shit if Corbyn and Labour got in, so for me all good. It’s pick your poison. Always has been.
What "more shit"?
Clavinova · 01/02/2022 11:24

EmmaGrundyForPM
he had been an accomplice in having a journalist beaten up

The journalist wasn't beaten up and Boris Johnson didn't supply the address his friend asked for;

"As we all know, Mr Johnson never provided me with any address and it is perfectly clear from the tape recording in question that he was simply placating a friend he considered to be letting off steam."

order-order.com/2013/03/27/darius-guppy-breaks-boris-silence/

Yeahthat · 01/02/2022 11:24

@AllThingsServeTheBeam

I'll bite.

  • I don't particularly care that Boris Johnson had some parties/work events with the addition of cake. His behaviour was hypocritical and dishonest, but that's not egregious for our politicians. I don't imagine that shuffling the deck, changing some faces around and bringing the other lot in for four years will change that. There's reprehensible and useless individuals at all levels of British politics and in every party. We need fundamental change, and given that that's not possible at present, the best I can do is vote for myself, my family, and my community is to vote for the "least worst" option. At the last election, that was the Conservative party.
  • Do I still believe that Corbyn and Labour would have been worse? Yes. I found him to be dangerous (comments praising Chavez, Maduro and Venezuela as an exemplar for all the world, Antisemitism etc). Do I care whether you think that's valid or true? No. I won't be canvassing the opinion of internet warriors before I cast my vote.
  • Will I vote Conservative at the next election? Very likely, yes. Nadia Whittome's recent calls for an open border (to the entire world) immigration policy are an example as to why. Labour has been entirely captured by the transatlantic twitter class that seems to be inspired by whatever the latest idiocy to come out of America is. See also Starmer and Rayner taking the knee. Empty, gesture politics great for generating retweets, but absolutely useless to me as a voter.
Iggly · 01/02/2022 11:24

They got swept up in the boom/bust economy money sunk into the NHS that had to be paid back

Paid back to who? Who do we owe debt to? And why is this debt always deemed a bad thing?

Iggly · 01/02/2022 11:23

@OhWhyNot

That’s the thing people believe that all Tory polices negatively impacted working class people

I think it’s hard to understand for many how important it was to be able to buy your own council home, it was beyond so many peoples reach to buy before. It allowed many workings class people to be home owners this was such a shift

No the money wasn’t put back as it should have been not just under Tories but Labour too

Selling council housing was just privatisation of housing using another name.

Having non means testing social housing was and is a good thing. The problem is, the Tories didn’t like it because they personally couldn’t profit from it. So they badged right to buy as a way of people owning their own home.

But who benefits? Banks from mortgage profits and landlords who can build up a cheap property empire.

Social housing is a fantastic tool for social mobility. Having worked on the board of a housing association, I can see that the state can run social housing and put the profits back into the maintenance of houses - to benefit the taxpayer and tenants. I think this would have avoided epic house price increases and the 2008 financial crisis which can be traced back to encouraging those who could barely afford it to get a mortgage.

Once the banks ran out of customers who could afford it, they turn to those who can’t.

The Tories always have the bottom line profit interests of their friends at heart. They’ll pretend it benefits the majority, but any such benefit is incidental, not intentional.

OhWhyNot · 01/02/2022 11:22

I think the mismanagement of funding under the Blair/Brown years has not helped

They got swept up in the boom/bust economy money sunk into the NHS that had to be paid back

There were many positives under Blair (who I voted for) but the longer outlook was not always well planned. The housing costs, foreign investments into property really took hold under Labour and they have admitted mistakes they have made

It’s not so black and white. I work for thr NHS, studied under both governments had to pay for my degree, now get UC (which for myself has worked out better than tax credits) and I am better off not everyone is

user1493494961 · 01/02/2022 11:17

Great, thanks.

Alexandra2001 · 01/02/2022 11:14

More of course should have gone into social housing but from all governments but to dismiss the Tories as only benefitting wealthier people is simply not true. Many working class people have been better off under the Tories

I ve been poor and struggling and i'm now what many would consider "better off"
Its due to Labour and universal education and the ability to access free HE.
If i were in the position now as i was then, i would be stuck in poverty, the tories do nothing for the poor, you only have to look at how they freeze working benefits, removed Surestart, run down the NHS, invest, in real term, below inflation increases in education, took away social housing, trebled tuition fees (that def doesn't effect the rich) increases NI but left investment income un taxed.

How many food banks were there under Blair?

EmmaGrundyForPM · 01/02/2022 11:10

Some people are being deliberately obtuse. A general election is absolutely about who you want to run the country. At the last GE loads of people were saying they wouldn't vote Labour because they didn't want Corbyn as PM.

Everyone knew what Johnson was like. He had been sacked from previous jobs for lying, he had been an accomplice in having a journalist beaten up, and many other things that made him unfit to be PM. And yet people still voted Tory. They are now trying to pretend they weren't voting for Johnson, they were just voting for their local candidate. Yeah, sure you were.

potniatheron · 01/02/2022 11:09

Hi truthfullylying, I think we're almost getting down to a philosophical issue, which is what do people actually have in mind when they vote. If I'm understanding you correctly, when you go into the voting booth, you have in mind the proper long term, decades hence, and a comparison of living standards in the UK and other European countries. You think of all the 70 million peopple in the UK, rather than you and your network. That's cool. For me, when I go in the voing booth, I've got in mind the parties' manifestos and the interviews they give on TV before the election, and what their policies will mean for me and my family over the next 5 years. How we will live, our livelihoods, our living standrads over the next five years. Because that's what I am focussed on - me and my family being OK over the next five years.

So we have two different perspectives when we vote, and I personally think yours isthe more privileged perspective, but of course, that doesnt assign any greater moral weight to your perspective or mine. They're just different. You're doing you and I'm doing me. That's all good.

If Labour have better policies for me at the next election, I'll vote Labour. But I have no idea currently what Labour's policies are, other than woman is just a feeling, and lots of party members hate the leader and want Jeremy Corbyn back. So if Kier wnats my vote, he better pull his finger out.

Finally I should add that I understand the structural issues you refer to. I would suggest that they are attributable to a number of macroeconomic issues which are beyond the control of any British government - the flood of cheap debt in the early 00s, ultra low interest rates since 2007, the rise in asset prices across the developed world, the economic growth of China, the shift to a digital world. In social terms, the effects of social media and hyper-individualisation and the collapse of religion and regional identities also play a role. In my view.

Adeleskirts · 01/02/2022 11:07

I’m also fine, I think work parties are ludicrous and we need to understand better but do believe we’d be in even more shit if Corbyn and Labour got in, so for me all good. It’s pick your poison. Always has been.

Alexandra2001 · 01/02/2022 11:07

@Inastatus

The people who did this are extremists, not the average voter the poster is clearly referring to. There are just as many examples of attacks against Tory MP’s - David Ames for instance. It is a sad fact that many MP’s from all parties have to deal with threats and abuse as part of their role

Did you read her post? she clearly stated Tory voters/MPs don't abuse the left... Do you agree with BJ taunting starmer with a blatant lie yesterday on Saville? vile... is BJ an extremist?

As for it being part of their role?? wtf! thats clearly a crazy pov, no one in any role should have to put up with abuse and independent research has shown its predominately women that are subject to the cruelest & most vile of abuse.
Don't really know why you are defending it, either that or you need to reword what you wrote.

Swipe left for the next trending thread