Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how you feel today if you voted for Boris Johnson at the last election?

545 replies

Readyforthegoodlife · 31/01/2022 16:20

It’s absolutely no surprise that Boris is behaving in this way but I cannot actually believe that we have a prime minister like this. He is utterly morally bankrupt. If you voted for him how do you feel now?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 01/02/2022 13:23

It’s beyond me why anyone would want to come here. The UK looks like a basket case to the rest of the world.

Yeahthat · 01/02/2022 13:20

@Blossomtoes

Agree that it could be made better. However, Whittome's idea of simply opening up in an entirely unrestricted manner to anyone and everyone who wants to come here, is arrant nonsense.

Blossomtoes · 01/02/2022 13:17

[quote Yeahthat]@Blossomtoes

That's called a functioning immigration system. No, it doesn't mean simply free movement for all.[/quote]
Then we clearly don’t have a functioning immigration system. It can only be made better.

Yeahthat · 01/02/2022 13:16

@Blossomtoes

That's called a functioning immigration system. No, it doesn't mean simply free movement for all.

Yeahthat · 01/02/2022 13:14

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Quote:

"To stop people dying in the Channel, we must completely reimagine our immigration system.

The status quo is free movement for the rich only. FM for all would not only benefit the person moving, it would reduce exploitation by criminal gangs and employers, benefitting everyone.

There’s enough to go around. We’re the 6th richest nation but £ is in the hands of people who don’t care about the working class, whether from Stoke or Syria. "

mobile.twitter.com/NadiaWhittomeMP/status/1475185226984964106

"Enough to go around". Brilliant idea! Just throw taxpayers money round like confetti, while we can't house, provide adequate medical care, and a quality education for all of our own citizens!

Blossomtoes · 01/02/2022 13:11

[quote Yeahthat]@Iggly

ie trade is mutually beneficial. Telling British taxpayers (as Nadia Whittome has attempted to do) that they should be responsible for anyone, anywhere in the world wants to come and live here is NOT beneficial to me, my family, my community nor the country, in any way. I don't intend to ever vote for anyone who thinks this way. This is a nation-state, not an NGO.[/quote]
Why wouldn’t it benefit you? There are huge staff shortages in the NHS and social care, those could very easily be filled with immigration and it would benefit all of us.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/02/2022 13:08

[quote Yeahthat]@Iggly

ie trade is mutually beneficial. Telling British taxpayers (as Nadia Whittome has attempted to do) that they should be responsible for anyone, anywhere in the world wants to come and live here is NOT beneficial to me, my family, my community nor the country, in any way. I don't intend to ever vote for anyone who thinks this way. This is a nation-state, not an NGO.[/quote]
Can you post a link that substantiates that claim about Nadia Whittome?
I googled but all I can find is her speech praising a House of Lords Amendment to the new Immigration Bill - and that's not the same thing at all.

Yeahthat · 01/02/2022 13:00

@Iggly

ie trade is mutually beneficial. Telling British taxpayers (as Nadia Whittome has attempted to do) that they should be responsible for anyone, anywhere in the world wants to come and live here is NOT beneficial to me, my family, my community nor the country, in any way. I don't intend to ever vote for anyone who thinks this way. This is a nation-state, not an NGO.

Yeahthat · 01/02/2022 12:50

@Iggly

Where did I say that I believe the UK is or can be wholly and entirely self-sufficient?

I stated that I don't pay taxes in order to rectify historical injustices such as colonisation or the slave trade, and that I want a government which is patriotic and puts this country first.

SalsaLove · 01/02/2022 12:50

I didn’t vote for him, but early on I thought he was treated unfairly and generally got dumped on because of partisanship. Now, I really loathe him. He’s not a moral man.

Shmithecat2 · 01/02/2022 12:47

The policies/manifesto aligned mostly with what I agreed with at the time so I feel fine 🤷‍♀️

JustAnotherPoster00 · 01/02/2022 12:44

bUt cOrByN

Blossomtoes · 01/02/2022 12:39

That's overblown, cliche, guilt tripping nonsense and you know it.

No, @potniatheron, it’s the truth based on your own words.

potniatheron · 01/02/2022 12:24

Hi truthfullylying, ok that's cool. You vote the way you vote because you want to see greater social mobility. I also want to see greater social mobility. I've experienced a lot of social mobility in my life and I think it's a good thing as long as it's based on merit. I also think social mobility should go down as well as up. There are too many mediocre people out there who have a platform just because they're middle class. I would like to hear more working class voices and views in public in general.

You've helped me gain greater perspective on why I vote the way I do and why my voting patterns have changed so much at different points in my life.

Iggly · 01/02/2022 12:21

So I should say I only partly agree but I’ve tried to inform myself!

Iggly · 01/02/2022 12:20

Political debate has become so simplified so black and white. It’s odd that so many will call those who voted for Johnson to be PM or voted leave stupid when they can’t move on themselves from Tory = damnation for the poor

I agree.

I took it upon myself to try and find out what the Tories stood for and went and read some founding texts.

And actually, I couldn’t find anything that said that fundamentally would change the system to make it easier overall for those who were born without wealth to gain wealth.

We have limited resources and the Conservatives want to keep it in the hands who have it already. Ultimately that will only keep the rich richer and leave not much for the rest of us however they try and spin it.

OhWhyNot · 01/02/2022 12:16

Again you are looking at the party as a whole only one way of thinking

Not all Tory MP’s back every policy, not all Tory voters back every policy

I’m a labour voter and party member (returned after the Corbyn years) I do not back every policy or think all Labour/Tory voters have the same views.

Political debate has become so simplified so black and white. It’s odd that so many will call those who voted for Johnson to be PM or voted leave stupid when they can’t move on themselves from Tory = damnation for the poor

And like wise though posted as positive remarks Asian immigrants are more diverse than how you seem to perceive them to be

Iggly · 01/02/2022 12:12

[quote Yeahthat]@Iggly

Great. I don't pay taxes in order to rectify historic injustices, nor do I want a government which thinks that its job is to even things up for the rest of the world.

I want a government which puts this country first.

Until the Labour Party has the desire to do so (or is capable of so much as appearing to actually like the country that they want to govern), I won't be voting for them.[/quote]
We don’t live in a bubble of the UK only. We benefit from a global economy.

So until we become wholly self sufficient - which is never as we have a terrible habit of selling our assets to international/foreign corporations - then sadly, we do have to pay attention to global events.

Yeahthat · 01/02/2022 12:10

@Iggly

Great. I don't pay taxes in order to rectify historic injustices, nor do I want a government which thinks that its job is to even things up for the rest of the world.

I want a government which puts this country first.

Until the Labour Party has the desire to do so (or is capable of so much as appearing to actually like the country that they want to govern), I won't be voting for them.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/02/2022 12:08

@OhWhyNot

Did you know that many of our lives improved under Thatcher years … why do you think she was so popular with many working class people, with many immigrants (my Asian family love her)

It doesn’t suit the argument does it that all Tory polices are awful terrible and the poor suffer and all Tory voters are scum

Politics isn’t so black and white it isn’t so simplistic

I am not crazy enough to claim everything one party does is good or bad. I believe Thatcher and her policies were where the rot set in for a decent society in the UK and the start of a more selfish individualistic culture that's been popular ever since.

Like most post-war governments, Thatcher never had a majority of voters voting for her BTW.

I am planning to leave the UK after 59 years as it is becoming far too selfish, nasty and corrupt place to live - and I never thought I'd say that.

I ma pleased the Thatcher years were beneficial for you - in my opinion we became much poorer as a nation then and since.

truthfullylying · 01/02/2022 12:01

@potniatheron

Hi truthfullylying, I didn't say that. I said that "I personally think yours [ie your perspective'] isthe more privileged perspective".

I didn't describe you as privileged because I don't know you. I also made it clear that I was only epxressing my personal view, which is not very important, since we don't know each other. I just thought your position was interesting and it got my thinking about the varying things that people take into account when they vote, and how those differ from person to person.

My perspective is not privileged. Privileged means: enjoying a privilege or having privileges. A privilege is a special advantage. A view can not have privileges, but a person holding a view can - however I am not privileged.

It is a phrase many Tories use to shut down people who disagree with them - they say people only want x y or z because of 'privilege'.

It is precisely because I do not have a privileged background that I favour greater fairness and genuine social mobility.

Alexandra2001 · 01/02/2022 11:58

@OhWhyNot

Did you know that many of our lives improved under Thatcher years … why do you think she was so popular with many working class people, with many immigrants (my Asian family love her)

It doesn’t suit the argument does it that all Tory polices are awful terrible and the poor suffer and all Tory voters are scum

Politics isn’t so black and white it isn’t so simplistic

Very true, many Asians have a fantastic work ethic and have the family back up to make businesses successful.

But not everyone can be a self made millionaire nor are ALL tory policies bad, atm i can't think of one, though there must be surely? I was going to suggest environmental protection but then they have cut funding to the EA so it wont be enforced.....

But when a footballer has to shame a Tory Government into funding means tested school meals (for the very poorest) during a pandemic, then something is very wrong with that party - in govt spending terms it was a very small amount.

They can't but help themselves to try and xxxx over the poor where ever they can.

potniatheron · 01/02/2022 11:58

@Yeahthat - maybe, I personally think he made some big mistakes, like giving independence to BoE. I also think his policy making was sometimes more driven by his hatred of his next door neightbour than political expediency!

But yes he was a lot better than the current lot (although I did read an interview with Rachel Reeve recently and thought she was pretty good)

Iggly · 01/02/2022 11:54

@potniatheron

I agree with you Yeahthat.

Nadia Whittome's recent calls for an open border (to the entire world) immigration policy are an example as to why. Labour has been entirely captured by the transatlantic twitter class that seems to be inspired by whatever the latest idiocy to come out of America is.

  • this is what I'm saying. Middle class student politics, is what Labour is now. I personally think Kier Starmer's an adult, but he's the only one in the room at Labour at the moment. If they had a front bench with the likes of David Blunkett, Robin Cook, Mo Mowlem, this would be a different conversation entirely.
What exactly did Nadia say?

My understanding is that she’s tried to make an evidence based argument for freedom of movement across the world. One of her arguments is that if you’re rich, you can go where you like but if you’re not, you’ll be exploited and have to stay put (by westerners - we benefit from this cheap labour). That we in the West can’t have it both ways of benefiting from our location through better resources, benefiting from cheap labour and not letting others benefit too.

It’s an interesting argument actually especially given that the British empire was founded on a parasitic approach to world domination.

She also made the point about the evidence of benefits to immigration.

The reason it won’t work is that we live in a capitalist society which ultimately is based on the premise of exploiting labour for profit.

potniatheron · 01/02/2022 11:53

Hi truthfullylying, I didn't say that. I said that "I personally think yours [ie your perspective'] isthe more privileged perspective".

I didn't describe you as privileged because I don't know you. I also made it clear that I was only epxressing my personal view, which is not very important, since we don't know each other. I just thought your position was interesting and it got my thinking about the varying things that people take into account when they vote, and how those differ from person to person.