Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Joint money in HIS pension fund

57 replies

ByMyName · 31/01/2022 15:07

DH and I consider our money joint. We put almost everything in a joint account. I have my own business can can do some planning around income. DH is on a normal job and cannot do a lot of planning.

DH’s income means that we will lose 30 hours government childcare funding. One option is to put extra money in his pension fund. About £8k-ish extra/year. But it has to be in his pension fund and we cannot have a joint pension fund.

Is there any reason not to do it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BABAHOTEL · 01/02/2022 13:59

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@BABAHOTEL an isa is avoiding tax. So is a pension. Both are perfectly lawful ways of avoiding or “planning” for tax. Imo nothing immoral about it either.[/quote]
Of course it's tax avoidance, perfectly legal, perfectly legitimate and very sensible. But we all do it to avoid tax.

Tax avoidance is not illegal but tax evasion is.

Everanewbie · 01/02/2022 13:05

[quote ByMyName]@Everanewbie we got professional advice. However, they said there was no reason not to do it!! This is why I wanted to check if I was missing something.[/quote]
Not advice, but maybe a direct response of generic in this field. So I would say the reasons that MAY exist:

Annual allowance of £40k for pension contributions. However even if this is exceeded, carry forward from previous years may be available. Also whether contribution is within 100% of earnings for the year.

Lifetime Allowance. If DH is lucky enough to have pension benefits that exceed £1,073,100 it is worth factoring in, but even still, not completely dismissing. Benefits may still outweigh a Lifetime allowance charge.

Perceived Unfairness

Emergency cash/cash flow and can you essentially write off access to the money until DH reaches age 55.

Hopefully you've engaged a qualified financial adviser here rather than an accountant overstepping their brief. An adviser must factor these issues in before outlining their recommendation to you in writing where the benefits and downsides are explained in detail. Don't be afraid to go back to them if you have any questions for them.

Everanewbie · 01/02/2022 12:52

@EatingGreens

Tbh the op and Dp can afford to pay for their own advice too and not scrounge it from MN. 😉
I can see your point here. I can also see that it may be galling to a lot of people here that an obvious high earner is looking to engineer a situation where her family receives something their income suggests they should not.

But to be fair I think she is asking for advice on a perceived unfairness of building up her husband's pension whilst leaving hers unfunded. She is obviously paying for advice from a professional as there is no way a layperson is coming up with that kind of complex tax/income planning strategy on their own.

As regards to the ethics, well, don't hate the player, hate the game. I don't see any obligation to arrange ones finances is a manner that sees them maximise tax and minimise benefit entitlement.

There are lots of things that go on, from businesses 'employing' spouses then paying salaries and divs to maximise a second set of personal allowances, take in cash in hand work which minimises tax and maximises potential entitlement to benefits, right up to using mundane things such as ISAs, trusts, pensions, buying yourself a laptop/phone/truck and saying its for work etc. etc.

He/she without sin cast the first stone.

CayrolBaaaskin · 01/02/2022 12:49

@SamphiretheStickerist I don’t agree it is “convoluted” for a person to pay extra into their employers pension. It’s usually really simple. Bdw no such thing as joint pensions in the U.K.

CayrolBaaaskin · 01/02/2022 12:45

@BABAHOTEL an isa is avoiding tax. So is a pension. Both are perfectly lawful ways of avoiding or “planning” for tax. Imo nothing immoral about it either.

MostNamesAreTaken · 01/02/2022 12:37

Another risk - any chance he will exceed lifetime pensions allowance? Something to factor in .

You are very fortunate to have these problems!

MostNamesAreTaken · 01/02/2022 12:32

I am afraid I can't remember the details of the top tax band, but would that 8k also be subject to the high marginal tax rate (60%) as you lose your personal allowance? So 8 k pre tax would only be worth 3.2k post tax? If so it seems like a financial no brainer, but you need to make sure no benefits in kind or bonus etc tip you over the 100k.

BABAHOTEL · 01/02/2022 12:06

[quote ByMyName]@Everanewbie we got professional advice. However, they said there was no reason not to do it!! This is why I wanted to check if I was missing something.[/quote]
Honestly, don't listen to financial advice off MN, as you will see people are not clued up and give out misinformation.

My particular favourite is from @mathanxiety, who is American, so presumably has little knowledge of the UK taxation system, but suggests you invest in gold! I mean just what sort of batshit advice is that!

ByMyName · 01/02/2022 11:53

@Everanewbie we got professional advice. However, they said there was no reason not to do it!! This is why I wanted to check if I was missing something.

OP posts:
FindingMeno · 01/02/2022 11:40

This is a perfect example of how the rich stay rich.

SickAndTiredAgain · 01/02/2022 10:23

Everyone else gets free childcare

Well, no they don’t.

But I put more money into my work pension than DH does because it makes more financial sense - eg my company matches contributions to a lot higher level than his so we don’t want to miss out on that. So my pension is bigger than his with what is effectively joint money but it works out best overall.

OnaBegonia · 01/02/2022 10:08

Everyone else gets free childcare
And that makes it ok?
You're attempting to make his income lower so you can claim childcare that you could afford with he £8k you're trying to hide.
That's immoral to me.
Yet here on MN if someone claims benefits for an extra day their scum.🤷🏼‍♀️

perimenofertility · 01/02/2022 10:00

@Mumofsend

If you can afford to chuck an extra 8k into a pension you can afford the cost of childcare Confused
Hmm, yes this was my thought. You're creaming 8K off DH's earning into a pension to reduce his pay so that you can get the free childcare. I'm so pleased you can benefit from this free childcare that my tax goes towards.
EatingGreens · 01/02/2022 09:59

Tbh the op and Dp can afford to pay for their own advice too and not scrounge it from MN. 😉

Mumofsend · 01/02/2022 09:56

[quote ByMyName]@gogohm I don’t feel what I’m doing to be immoral in the slightest. DH and I are both in key working positions. We contribute to society plenty. Everyone else gets free childcare, and if there is a legal way for us to get it - why not?[/quote]
Yet its low earners who are scrounging cheats Hmm you earn over the threshold, you can easily afford the childcare. It's immoral to evade it.

EatingGreens · 01/02/2022 09:49

Not everyone gets free childcare.

It's up to you to arrange your tax schemes within the law but own your own actions op and don't assume about others.

user1471457751 · 01/02/2022 09:44

@SamphiretheStickerist the bit where she can't!! She mentioned that in her OP. They are trying to reduce his income so they can get help with childcare. A way to reduce income is to put into your own pension. You can't just give it away

Everanewbie · 01/02/2022 09:32

OP. Who's idea was this? As a finance professional I find it unlikely that you would have come up with this strategy yourselves. If you have consulted a professional, ask them to spell out the pro's and cons clearly.

It sounds like your husband is a high earner, meaning that you'll get the double bubble of greater tax relief on the contribution (and higher starting point for compound growth to provide flexibly for BOTH of your retirements) and the reduction of his income below the free childcare threshold. As previous posters have pointed out, pensions would be considered in any divorce and death benefits are paid with an expression of wish in mind and are outside of the estate.

Assuming you have no pressing need for the money and have sufficient emergency funds etc. the only real issue is the fact that it would be 'in his name'. If that is more important to you than extremely beneficial tax treatment and the restoration of free child care, well, you'll be missing out.

BABAHOTEL · 01/02/2022 08:53

[quote ByMyName]@HighlandCowbag you are 100% right, it’s only for a
Couple of years. I think it’s the best option to do it for 2 years for DH and 2 years for me.[/quote]
Perfect solution!

Pootlepoodle · 01/02/2022 08:49

Well, it’s convoluted to deter people from “tax planning” as in the case of OP.

BABAHOTEL · 01/02/2022 08:49

@PicaK

The danger is if you divorce. It's all very well saying the money should be split but men go very funny about their pensions at that point. To get a proper valuation of a pension costs about £3k and takes months and months. Then you still have to negotiate and agree. Going to court will cost you c20k each. And then £s in a pension aren't seen as equal to £s in a bank. Ask people on the divorce board how many of them feel they got a fair split of the pension. I'd be really wary. Plus he could drop dead so you'd only get a reduced amount.
You're also incorrect with the death benefits of a DC scheme. You don't get a reduced amount.

You would if it's a DB scheme, but presumably she'd also get death in service if he's still an active member,

BABAHOTEL · 01/02/2022 08:47

@PicaK

The danger is if you divorce. It's all very well saying the money should be split but men go very funny about their pensions at that point. To get a proper valuation of a pension costs about £3k and takes months and months. Then you still have to negotiate and agree. Going to court will cost you c20k each. And then £s in a pension aren't seen as equal to £s in a bank. Ask people on the divorce board how many of them feel they got a fair split of the pension. I'd be really wary. Plus he could drop dead so you'd only get a reduced amount.
You're very much confused with this. A DC pension is an instant valuation. A DB scheme produces a CETV which is valid for three months.

Not that many DB schemes in operation now, most likely the DH has a DC scheme, which is very easily valued and split.

SamphiretheStickerist · 01/02/2022 08:31

OK! That makes more sense now. But it shouldn't be that convoluted! Bloody ridiculous!

nellly · 01/02/2022 08:27

@SamphiretheStickerist

No! Do not. Share any money equally between your pension funds. Why on Earth would you not?
Because thats exactly how it would have to be done to not lose the 30 free hours it would have to come off his wage before tax direct to his pension. Doesn't mean they can't make extr arrangements to even things out by also adding to OPs though
PicaK · 01/02/2022 07:41

The danger is if you divorce.
It's all very well saying the money should be split but men go very funny about their pensions at that point.
To get a proper valuation of a pension costs about £3k and takes months and months.
Then you still have to negotiate and agree. Going to court will cost you c20k each.
And then £s in a pension aren't seen as equal to £s in a bank.
Ask people on the divorce board how many of them feel they got a fair split of the pension.
I'd be really wary. Plus he could drop dead so you'd only get a reduced amount.

Swipe left for the next trending thread