Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of lonely people have brought it on themselves?

557 replies

LovelyYellowLabrador · 31/01/2022 11:12

Just been watching a channel 4 thing on YouTube about lonely people
Most of them were like-no one calls…. They don’t see anyone all day
They maybe have had a marriage where their partner was the only other person they spent time with so when threat person has passed away they have no one else

Just think people need to think more about what they are doing
They expect their adult children to call them all the time and visit
Yet don’t stop to pause to think have I been a good parent am I draining or overly negative

Or they could think right no one’s called me, who am I going to call
How am I going to make and keep some friends

OP posts:
Whydoesthecatalwaysdothat · 01/02/2022 23:22

Loneliness is complicated but work in healthcare and you will see the correlation in loneliness and ability of people to help themselves first hand. Unfortunately, loneliness for some people is a self fulfilling prophecy. It's very frustrating.

Doris is 85. She lost her husband Fred five years ago. Ten years ago they moved into sheltered accommodation as they anticipated that they would struggle with the maintenance and upkeep of their 3 bed semi. In sheltered housing, there is a manager Doris can call on and a 24/7 emergency helpline. Doris enjoys going to church and has recently started to attend the day centre as she struggles to get out and about on her own. Doris doesn't have children but she has a couple of friends she sees fairly regularly. She has also made some new friends at the sheltered accommodation and goes to the weekly coffee morning. As her mobility is limited she has been spending more time at home so is learning to crochet and planning to crochet Christmas baubles to help fund the local cat rescue.

Mavis is 85. She lost her husband Bob five years ago. Forty years ago, they moved into the large detached family house that was to become their 'forever home'. Mavis is struggling with the maintenance and upkeep of the house. She cannot afford to heat the whole house and, as her mobility prevents her from getting up the stairs, she now lives downstairs. Despite encouragement to move into more suitable accommodation from her family, Mavis wants to stay in the house. Mavis didn't work and dedicated her life to her husband and two children. Her children live nearby but both work and have families. They see Mavis on a regular basis, take her out and help her as much as they can physically manage. Despite this, Mavis says that she sees them rarely. The GP referred Mavis to the Social Prescriber as she frequently complained that she was lonely when attending appointments for her various ailments. Mavis attended one coffee morning organised by the Social Prescriber. She didn't want to attend the following week and proclaimed that the Social Prescriber was useless. Mavis spends a lot of time at home but has no hobbies other than watching TV and listening to the radio.

This is very simplistic but there are lots of people like Doris and Mavis out there. In terms of loneliness in old age, I cannot stress how important it is to plan ahead for your life. What will you do if an when your husband dies? Where will you live? How will get around if you can no longer drive? What will you do if your mobility declines? How are you going to entertain yourself on the days you can't get out and about?

HenriBond · 01/02/2022 23:16

Sadly some people don't seem to realise that relationships are a privilege not a right. We have to work at them and it has to be a two way process. But I do think people can find themselves in difficult and unexpected circumstances - for a whole range of reasons e.g..marriages end, friends die or move away, family emigrate, Lockdown puts a stop to many activities and community groups, people get Depressed and others think they are being antisocial - there can be dozens of reasons people feel isolated. So I think yes, some people would benefit from realising that they need to put a bit of effort into making and sustaining relationships, but others have put in that effort and still end up feeling very alone (because Life so often just isn't fair or kind).

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/02/2022 22:39

@Whydoesthecatalwaysdothat

Until you work with the general public on a 1:1 basis you would never be able to imagine how very different people are in terms of motivation and helping themselves.

On the one hand, you have the motivated crack on with it types who realise that they have control over their lives and the direction it takes. On the other hand, you have the people with a bit of a victim mindset who wait for people to come and help them. People seem to fall on one side or the other with a few in between. It's baffling and an absolute eye opener.

Victim Mindset?

Not everybody does have control over their own lives. That's the whole point of abuse and coercive control.

keffie12 · 01/02/2022 22:33

Dont judge anyone until you have walked a mile in their shoes

Mischance · 01/02/2022 22:30

@Whydoesthecatalwaysdothat

Until you work with the general public on a 1:1 basis you would never be able to imagine how very different people are in terms of motivation and helping themselves.

On the one hand, you have the motivated crack on with it types who realise that they have control over their lives and the direction it takes. On the other hand, you have the people with a bit of a victim mindset who wait for people to come and help them. People seem to fall on one side or the other with a few in between. It's baffling and an absolute eye opener.

Slightly simplistic maybe. What about all those in between?
Whydoesthecatalwaysdothat · 01/02/2022 22:19

Until you work with the general public on a 1:1 basis you would never be able to imagine how very different people are in terms of motivation and helping themselves.

On the one hand, you have the motivated crack on with it types who realise that they have control over their lives and the direction it takes. On the other hand, you have the people with a bit of a victim mindset who wait for people to come and help them. People seem to fall on one side or the other with a few in between. It's baffling and an absolute eye opener.

Dovecare · 01/02/2022 22:11

I am concerned that I may be a bit lonely if my husband passes before me. In my case it is because my place of work was 40 miles away so I left my colleagues/friends when I retired 5 years ago. My career was a life long commitment so other all friendships originated at work. I need to form some social groups before it is too late.

RidingMyBike · 01/02/2022 21:07

Different lifestyles now and different expectations of women? As kids we were taken to various elderly relatives and friends' houses weekly or fortnightly. To sit in silence and behave whilst Mum nattered away with them. I hated it as a child. They seemed to have the same conversation every time! But Mum was in the town where she'd been born, she'd known these people all their lives and felt she had a duty to them. She was also either SAHM or very part-time.

Another generation further on, I've moved multiple times, have never lived in that town again and work full time. The time when I'm not working I'd rather spend having fun with DD plus I don't have any elderly relatives here! Church is a good way of interacting with other generations and we do go regularly but there often tends to be an expectation of what I can do for them/church vs. the free time I actually have! I can't volunteer on a weekday or offer to drive someone to hospital appt etc because I'm at work!

noirchatsdeux · 01/02/2022 20:48

My parents cut us off from maternal extended family when I was 10.. they had cut us off from paternal extended family when my mother was pregnant with me and they had moved to the other side of the world, even though my father knew his father was dying of cancer. My paternal grandmother blamed my mother - she thought my mother knew - and the truth of the situation only came out when my father left my mother when I was 21. We saw my paternal grandmother once after he left...she lived another 30 years and we never saw her or any of my father's family again.

My parents made some very stupid decisions when I was 10, my mother's family made their opinions (entirely valid) known, and so my parents cut them off too. My mother was one of 9, so a very large family...we'd been very close to all of them up to that point. My parents actually made our family 'disappear' for 7 years, for most of the 80s. My whole childhood my parents strongly discouraged myself and my brothers from having hobbies, friends, outside interests etc Contact with my mother's family was only resumed when my younger brother got drunk on his 18th birthday and rang my grandmother. My father left my mother 6 months after that for the woman he'd been having an affair (one of many he'd had their whole marriage) for a year. My mother ended up going back to our home country (on her own), did reconcile somewhat with her family but the damage was never really repaired and they never totally forgot or forgave...particularly as my mother never actually apologised for any of it. She is now the oldest of the last 3 siblings left, and her younger sister is terminally ill with cancer.

None of the above is my fault. Like others have posted, I've found, particularly in the last 20 years, that most people are only there for the good times, and the pandemic has made that even more true. I consider myself lucky to have one good friend, but have only seen him once in the last year as he has health anxiety made worse due to covid and is still petrified of catching it, so won't socialise.

My whole childhood was toxic, chaotic and stressful. I'm 53, being treated for C-PTSD, on top of being bipolar. I was in a car accident when I was 17 and my physical disability now means I can no longer work....I haven't worked full time in 7 years. I now have no family in the UK, I'm not on good terms with my mother and haven't seen her in 13 years. My partner of 12 years lives 200 miles away for work and I see him on average once a month for about 5 days. During the lockdowns I went a total of 15 months without seeing anyone but delivery drivers and the postman.

I'm also lucky that I like being on my own and only rarely feel 'lonely'...but when I do, I'm sad that decisions that were made when I was a child are still having an effect 40 years later.

BacksideFirst · 01/02/2022 20:38

How to make friends?

Friendships can change and before you know it, you can find yourself alone. Also some of my family I now no longer see. These things can change slowly,

notjaneausten · 01/02/2022 20:36

I have become extremely deaf, noticeably so over the last couple of years.
I could go for days without speaking to anyone, as I can no longer use the phone. I don’t strike up conversations, as I can’t hear the answers. I used to happily holiday alone after my marriage ended, it’s very difficult to do when so much depends on being able to hear. It’s also embarrassing to be unable to hear how loud I’m speaking, as I can’t hear myself. Yes, I have a hearing aid, and regularly see an audiologist..

Siepie · 01/02/2022 20:35

I think it can be a mixture. On MN you see posters talking about only needing their DH or actively avoiding making friends at baby groups, the school playground, work, etc. If they got divorced or had a fall out with their existing friends, they could probably become lonely quite quickly.

On the other hand, it can depend who you're surrounded by. If you move house and try to make friends with other mums in the school playground, but those mums are the type who don't want 'mum friends' then you're not going to get very far.

When I was at uni, I had a nice group of friends during term time. But they were all very close to their families and went home for the entire 3 month summer holidays. My parents were abusive and I couldn't go home, so I'd spend the summers lonely. I'm not sure how I could have solved that, other than interviewing potential new friends about how much time they spent with their parents Grin

Sunsetmom · 01/02/2022 20:35

Whilst there may be reasons for children not to bother with their parents, no one deserves to be lonely at any age.
Relationships are a two way thing however I have known people who are lonely that have done the reaching out to family and friends and got nothing back and therefore given up trying!

Ellowyn · 01/02/2022 20:22

I love being alone and I've never been lonely one day in my life. I don't like being around people and enjoy my own company. The funny thing is people have always wanted to be around me because apparently I'm fun, so it seems as if I've spend my whole life trying to be alone.

I have totally stopped communicating with people and I'm hoping they think I've died in the pandemic. I'm sure there is something mentally wrong with me, but I don't care because I'm as happy as a pig in slop.

I post here because I like being able to say things and not have people wanting to meet up, get together, FaceTime, and all that. Also, now as old as dirt, I have almost no filter.

XenoBitch · 01/02/2022 20:15

An old married work colleague of mine never had any children as she was too selfish

This always baffles me. How is someone being selfish by not having children?

optimistic40 · 01/02/2022 20:13

Probably different for different people. I've had a few problems with loneliness over the past couple of years. I'm a single parent and work from home. I can't leave the house in the evenings when the children are in bed. I can (and do!) on Saturday nights when they're at their dads'. But that still leaves me alone a lot of the time, and I am someone who loves alone-time - just not having it imposed upon me. Going to start going into the office again more now!

iamnlhfss · 01/02/2022 20:12

An old married work colleague of mine never had any children as she was too selfish

FFS. Can we stop with this narrative that people who do not have any children do not have them because they are "too selfish"?
What the absolute fuck?
How do you know why someone doesn't have children?
We also do not know the reasons why some people have children.
And some people have children for selfish reasons - I know two people who have done this and openly said it's because they want to ensure they have someone to care for them in their old age.

Squirrelsbizaare · 01/02/2022 20:08

@Babiesandboardgames

I think you have a point OP.

I know 4 people who would describe themselves as "lonely"
1 . Is 97 and completely isolated at home as she's too old, friends have all passed away. No kids. Met her on a befriending service for lonely people. She was lovely, she was lonely due to difficult circumstances.

  1. 73 year old lady also on befriending site. Not a horrible person, but just talks about herself and doesn't ask you any questions. She's not interested in anything you say so her kids and grandkids don't see her.
  2. Best friends dad, drinks too much and is very unreliable and was difficult growing up. Then moved 3 hours away from everyone . He says he's lonely, again this is self inflicted.
  3. Woman I went on a singles tour with. Moaned that her only daughter and dgc don't see her. However, she also had some clear mh issues after her son passed away, she claimed she could still talk to her son and he was sending her visions. Daughter couldn't cope anymore and went v v LC.

In three of these four cases, imo, the loneliness was self inflicted. I do understand what I am talking about too as I made a lot of effort with loneliness charities.

What a horrible post. The woman that is struggling to cope after the death of her son, that has mental health problems as a result, it's her own fault ? I am wondering also if the 73 year old that talks about herself all the time, possibly doesn't understand how the befriending service works and thinks you are there to listen. Why are you volunteering for a befriending charity, if that is how you view you clients.
boardbored · 01/02/2022 20:08

Friendship is a numbers game. For every people you meet one or two will be arseholes, five or six will be nice / not nice / normal and in the remaining one or two then there might be someone you like and who likes you back.

So to make a few new friends you really need to have met 50 people and been pleasant and interesting to them.

It is a lot like hard work ! But it pays off.

Sam1111 · 01/02/2022 19:59

It doesn’t have to be a man… I said men/people!
I’ve voiced my personal opinion on my circumstances I’m not getting involved with stupid questions!

Crikeyalmighty · 01/02/2022 19:58

There are so many reasons this can be - like @coronabeer I have had a lot of moving around due to a H who has itchy feet. I worked through necessity, so never really did the school gates thing and in my first marriage old friends took the side of my husband upon divorce. Working for ourselves too meant lots of people we ‘know’ but not really friends on the doorstep - I am a really sociable and chatty person and go out my way for friends I do have- and I can honestly say at times I am pretty lonely as I’ve got older. Please ladies don’t make your marriage a ‘fortress family’ — I did and I really regret it in recent years

2bazookas · 01/02/2022 19:51

velvetchair how do you meet people?

Get a dog and take it for walks. No better way to meet people and have something easy to talk about.

Coffeepot72 · 01/02/2022 19:47

DH and I don’t have children, and neither of us have brothers or sisters. I work damn hard at making friends, as I have no family network to fall back on. Obviously one of us will die before the other, and I often worry about how old age will pan out for us.

Mirw · 01/02/2022 19:46

Sounds like you are scared this will happen to you.. There are as many reasons that people are lonely as there are lonely people. For example, for some it is about losing their hearing and there are so few hearing people who are willing to make the effort for the deaf person... Too much bother!! When it happens to them, completely different reaction... For others, a similar reaction like their mental health problems are catching. So think before you accuse. The majority of lonely people are that way because others won't make the effort and so the lonely people give up.

XenoBitch · 01/02/2022 19:46

Hmm, some people have no one as they lost a spouse and have no children (or any who still speak to them!).

Some people just shut everyone else out.

And some are lonely, and do nothing but moan they are lonely, yet do nothing about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread