Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of lonely people have brought it on themselves?

557 replies

LovelyYellowLabrador · 31/01/2022 11:12

Just been watching a channel 4 thing on YouTube about lonely people
Most of them were like-no one calls…. They don’t see anyone all day
They maybe have had a marriage where their partner was the only other person they spent time with so when threat person has passed away they have no one else

Just think people need to think more about what they are doing
They expect their adult children to call them all the time and visit
Yet don’t stop to pause to think have I been a good parent am I draining or overly negative

Or they could think right no one’s called me, who am I going to call
How am I going to make and keep some friends

OP posts:
Sudoku88 · 02/02/2022 23:18

@XenoBitch

An old married work colleague of mine never had any children as she was too selfish

This always baffles me. How is someone being selfish by not having children?

Because some people are so self absorbed they can’t think of anyone else except themselves. They are totally incapable of putting anyone other than themselves first. I know a man exactly like that.
D0lphine · 02/02/2022 21:17

Read "Elinor Oliphant is completely fine".

Great book about loneliness. Technically Elinor would fall into the category of it being "her fault" because she is a difficult person, judgmental of others and acts superior.

However, when you get to know her history it all makes sense. She discussed her traumatic childhood, upbringing in care, lack of socialisation, lack of trust in people etc.

Coffeepot72 · 02/02/2022 21:01

*it is incredibly difficult to be in this position. I am no one's daughter, grandaughter sister, aunt, sister-in law. It felt, until I met DH that I was almost invisible . Most people gain their support and sense of mattering and identity from their family contact. When you have none you can feel like you just do not matter.

I have friends- all of whom had families for high days and holidays. Now I have DH and his family- his parents are very nice, decent oeople but they are not my family. There is no one who I can reminisce with about my childhood- no one who knew my parents and grand-parents, no one who remembers what I remember or shared those experiences*

————————

I could have written this. I do my best to cultivate friendships because if anything ever happened to DH, I’d be totally on my own due to no family network. Luckily I have some nice friends but they all have their own families. It’s not my fault I have no siblings or parents but I do my best to make the best of it. This thread has really made me think, and sadly some people are very judgemental

Vloggamamma · 02/02/2022 20:10

@LuluBlakey1

I am an only child, born to older parents. My parents are dead. I have no siblings, no grandparents, no aunts and uncles and only one cousin in this country- who lives 300 miles away.

An estranged uncle's wife is still alive - although frail and very elderly. I help her since his death because she would have no one otherwise, but she uses me rather than has any affection for me. She has no other family.

It is incredibly difficult to be in this position. I am no one's daughter, grandaughter sister, aunt, sister-in law. It felt, until I met DH that I was almost invisible . Most people gain their support and sense of mattering and identity from their family contact. When you have none you can feel like you just do not matter.

I have friends- all of whom had families for high days and holidays. Now I have DH and his family- his parents are very nice, decent oeople but they are not my family. There is no one who I can reminisce with about my childhood- no one who knew my parents and grand-parents, no one who remembers what I remember or shared those experiences. There is no one who rings me on Christmas Morning or my birthday because I am their family and matter to them.

This probably all sounds self-pitying, it isn't meant to. It's just how it is and I have grown used to it. Even having DH and now our DC, I still feel it. I think I have quite a hard inner shell because of it.

I am perfectly capable of ringing friends or going for a chat with my MIL. But on Christmas morning- it is DH's phone she rings or FIL rings, or his sister rings.

I was ill a few weeks ago, had quite a nasty accident that could have killed me. It struck me that if not for DH, no one would have been very interested. I spoke to my cousin and told them, never heard anything since. My uncle's wife asked when I would be well enough to do her shopping again. PIL asked DH is they could help. Couple of friends texted once each to ask what had happened and was I ok and that was it.

It is lonely. Most of the time, I don't mind it. I never mention it. I have never told DH or anyone else how I feel about it- I don't want to sound self-pitying. but apart from DH I don't feel I matter to anyone for being me.

I am sorry to read this . I also think your aunt is very cold asking when you could do her shopping after you had an accident. I hope she at least remembers to thank you from time to time. You do matter to your DH and DC and one day on Christmas morning it will be your DC ringing you . You will probably have grandchildren and so you are building a bigger picture. Kudos to you , you sound like you,won’t be offloading or guilt tripping to your child.. something my mother has done my whole life. My father and mother are not in a loving relationship and all my life she has used me as her councillor or tells me she will be lonely if I go to work etc.
Vloggamamma · 02/02/2022 19:18

@restingbitchface30

There are tons of factors why people are lonely. I’m not lonely because I have my partner and children but if I didn’t I think I’d be incredibly lonely. I have no friends because I let no one in. I have been hurt so much in the past I don’t want to let anyone in now. My family are horrid. Like beyond horrid. My partners family don’t really bother with me. So loneliness isn’t always someone’s fault. I don’t think it would be my fault but the failures of so many people over the years.
So agree with this. Was horribly bullied in school , siblings also still bully me and I’ve read so much about this where people are bullied well into their 70s by siblings. Interestingly I’ve also read if you’ve been bullied ie by siblings , it’s likely you will get bullied elsewhere in life and of course this makes sense if it started in the home with people who are supposed to love you and that you can trust. I’m the youngest with my siblings being a good bit older , my eldest brother and sister gang up on me at every chance so I now try not to be in a room on my own with them. SIL is also a complete bitch to me and they have all raised their kids to disrespect me and cheek me up. My view on other people is now so low I only trust my hubby.
DaisyChains3 · 02/02/2022 18:36

@Larryyourwaiter

I also went to my local WI and the average age was about 80, I lasted 2 meetings. I have a friend who was travelling to one with a younger dynamic but it is 40 miles away and honestly I could not be arsed. Personally I think I would do better in a city making friends than where I live.
In my experience it’smuch harder to make friends in cities.
Ragwort · 02/02/2022 18:31

Meredith no, sorry Grin ... but have a look on the NFWI website to find your local WI, get in touch and go along for a 'taster' meeting ... you might enjoy it.

MeredithGreyishblue · 02/02/2022 18:27

@Ragwort

Thank you for the honest feedback regarding WIs, I agree, there are many different WIs and it is important to find your 'fit' .. for the record we don't sing Jerusalem at the one I attend and most of the committee are leftie Guardian readers Grin ... but I understand that it's a real 'image' problem. There are some really progressive WIs out there ... as for the WI that didn't welcome new committee members, that is shocking, I would love to step down from our committee if someone else would step up!
Are you in the North West? I'd travel to that one!
XmasElf10 · 02/02/2022 18:26

I am autistic, friendships are really hard for me. I want friends but find them hard to make and confusing and exhausting to keep. I have a boyfriend (who is as nuts as me 😂) and live close to family. Without them I’d be alone and probably lonely. I’m not sure I’d that is my fault…. It certainly isn’t anyone else’s but I’m not really sure how I would change it. Your post makes me feel bad that I don’t manage to do better at this friend stuff. I am loyal, kind, funny (or at least I think I am) and generous. I think I’d be a great friend.

Ragwort · 02/02/2022 18:20

Thank you for the honest feedback regarding WIs, I agree, there are many different WIs and it is important to find your 'fit' .. for the record we don't sing Jerusalem at the one I attend and most of the committee are leftie Guardian readers Grin ... but I understand that it's a real 'image' problem. There are some really progressive WIs out there ... as for the WI that didn't welcome new committee members, that is shocking, I would love to step down from our committee if someone else would step up!

Sam1111 · 02/02/2022 18:10

Here here 😊

sillysmiles · 02/02/2022 17:59

@2bazookas

velvetchair how do you meet people?

Get a dog and take it for walks. No better way to meet people and have something easy to talk about.

But those people are acquaintances not friends. I talk to lots of people on dog walks, but I might not meet the same person for a few months, if at all.
Larryyourwaiter · 02/02/2022 17:46

I also went to my local WI and the average age was about 80, I lasted 2 meetings. I have a friend who was travelling to one with a younger dynamic but it is 40 miles away and honestly I could not be arsed. Personally I think I would do better in a city making friends than where I live.

DottyHarmer · 02/02/2022 15:54

I wouldn’t mind belting out Jerusalem! Religious or not it is a wonderful tune.

I did investigate the local WI when we first moved here and the lady I rang was friendly, but she warned me the youngest member was 80…

I think some kind of “women’s group” would be a goer, but as others have observed, everyone now is “too busy” (or at least say they are busy; it seems a sin worse than death to admit you’re at a loose end).

As for being like a parish council, I think every single group no matter what the hobby (and men as well as women) gets a bit like that. Everywhere there are bossy boots/gossips/queen/king bees.

MeredithGreyishblue · 02/02/2022 15:49

@haismfh

The WI thing - yeah, I'm probably stereotyping and this is going to sound bad, but the impression I have is of a group of older ladies, mainly Anglican with some Methodists perhaps (certainly very few Catholics as they are frowned on), all belting out the hymn Jerusalem and loving the Queen. Plus all the baking and sewing and stuff and then sitting around gossiping, plus a lot of politics going on within the group itself - who is the leader and on the committee etc. Like a parish council type of thing but with no men.

As I said, I've never been, but that's my impression from the groups that were near where I used to live in the UK and the people who went to them.
I think they have an image problem and to attract younger members a lot would have to change.

I'd seen the stuff that @RidingMyBike below mentioned. About social issues and "modern" women and whatnot but when I brought it up they said it "Wasn't appropriate."

I think the WI itself is making strides to be different but some groups, who are all of a certain mentality, won't want their third Wednesday of the month to change. The words they used to talk about where the charity money was going in Africa was quite Hmm. Joyce Grenfell would have had a field day.

Maybe we need to start them, not join them.

haismfh · 02/02/2022 15:26

The WI thing - yeah, I'm probably stereotyping and this is going to sound bad, but the impression I have is of a group of older ladies, mainly Anglican with some Methodists perhaps (certainly very few Catholics as they are frowned on), all belting out the hymn Jerusalem and loving the Queen. Plus all the baking and sewing and stuff and then sitting around gossiping, plus a lot of politics going on within the group itself - who is the leader and on the committee etc.
Like a parish council type of thing but with no men.

As I said, I've never been, but that's my impression from the groups that were near where I used to live in the UK and the people who went to them.
I think they have an image problem and to attract younger members a lot would have to change.

Coffeepot72 · 02/02/2022 15:26

We have quite a good, young-ish WI in our village. It all stopped for COVID, obviously, and I think it's re-started again. I may re-join again at some point. I just wanted to give people hope, there are some good WIs out there!

MeredithGreyishblue · 02/02/2022 15:17

@Ragwort I tried one near our old house. I was about 38. And the youngest by at least 20 years. They wanted new, young members but..

  • the top woman said social media was evil therefore refused to have the group on it or to have it even mentioned on Facebook to attract anyone.
  • they had a full schedule of events for the year that were really dull. And geared to older people. Tai Chi for arthritis and a chair fitness session, notably. And a chap talking in local dialect about life in the 50s.
  • they were really negative as a group! About everything and everyone. Local gossip.

I was gutted! I really wanted to love it. I'd heard so much positivity from other groups about welcoming younger members

ChangingLife · 02/02/2022 15:04

But the WI is struggling in some areas due to lack of new members, I would love to hear, on this anonymous forum, what the issues are, why more women don't want want to join ... please be honest.

Have you been to one of the WI group?
I struggled to find anything in common with the people there (and that was a group with 'young members' aka women in their 50s who were more or less all working...)

RidingMyBike · 02/02/2022 14:59

The WI varies hugely from place to place. There was a newish one in the town I've relocated from which had lots of younger members, speakers on a wide range of topics including politics, philosophy, social justice etc as well as crafts and baking. They also had subgroups for book groups, volunteering/local initiatives etc.

It's rather like when I was involved in Girl Guiding - the first unit where I was a Guider we stayed after the meeting, had a cup of tea together whilst we cleared up, chatted and I got to know the others. The other units I've worked with (I'm a multiple relocater!) everyone disappeared as soon as the meeting was over so it took up hours of my time volunteering for very little relationship building from my POV. I didn't mind the hours for the first unit as it was really enjoyable.

Coffeepot72 · 02/02/2022 14:47

So with all of this in mind, what constitutes a decent network? As I mentioned in an earlier post, DH and I have no children, and no siblings (we’re both only-children). I’ve got one really close friend, three pretty close friends and five fab mates who I regularly go the pub with. Have I done enough?? But not sure what to do if everyone dies before me?

DaisyChains3 · 02/02/2022 14:27

Positive Living groups are a great way to meet people. There are a lot of interesting groups in England. Doesn't seem to exist in Scotland.

beethecrackon24995 · 02/02/2022 14:13

OP you haven't got a bleedin clue have you.

RidingMyBike · 02/02/2022 14:11

Just remembered - my old church (I've since relocated) had a 'Young wives' group'. They asked if I'd like to go along. It turned out to be more accurately described as the 'Very elderly widows' group'. They'd just kept going and never got round to changing the name. They were also mystified about why nobody younger had joined and I had to point out that meeting at 1pm on Wednesdays meant most women now were at work!

That was one of the problems with inter-generational groups - those of us that were younger wanted to meet at 8pm on a weeknight after work and children's bedtimes. Working full time meant we didn't really want to meet at a weekend as that was family time.

RidingMyBike · 02/02/2022 14:04

I suspect my DM would describe herself as lonely, at least some of the time. She was widowed years ago but sees far more people regularly than I do (recently had a conversation about the number of people/places we'd have to list to test and trace if we got Covid: mine was 1, hers over 10 for the same period of time!) but I don't think really acknowledges that in her head. She wouldn't ask those people for help though because she 'wouldn't want to put them out', even though they're available and on her doorstep! She's refused to learn how to use Zoom. She downsized recently into a still quite large bungalow and was most miffed that I wouldn't come to help her pack, despite her easily being able to afford to pay for it and multiple of her friends offering to help (she wanted someone [me] to boss around and wouldn't have felt comfortable doing that to her friends).

Her preferred activity is to go somewhere like a garden centre cafe and have lengthy chats over multiple coffees. I can't do that with her easily as, even though we've moved closer to her, we're still about 2 hours away. And I work full time (she refuses to acknowledge how much worse my pension will be compared to the final salary one she started claiming age 55! Confused). She's also annoyed because we took the risk from Covid seriously (DH was shielding) so haven't eaten or drunk inside places, avoided going anywhere crowded etc, whereas she was breaking rules right, left and centre. I stood up to her about that and put DH first and she was furious. That meant when we saw her at New Year and went out for a coffee we insisted on sitting outside which she hated because it was cold and January and we didn't sit chatting for long.

One weekend her car was at the garage so she didn't go to church and then was moaning about not seeing anyone. I asked why she hadn't asked them for someone to give her a lift, but she 'didn't want to put them out' so goodness knows what will happen once she can't drive any longer.