Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of lonely people have brought it on themselves?

557 replies

LovelyYellowLabrador · 31/01/2022 11:12

Just been watching a channel 4 thing on YouTube about lonely people
Most of them were like-no one calls…. They don’t see anyone all day
They maybe have had a marriage where their partner was the only other person they spent time with so when threat person has passed away they have no one else

Just think people need to think more about what they are doing
They expect their adult children to call them all the time and visit
Yet don’t stop to pause to think have I been a good parent am I draining or overly negative

Or they could think right no one’s called me, who am I going to call
How am I going to make and keep some friends

OP posts:
PussGirl · 03/02/2022 15:20

@MuddlingMackem - that is an excellent idea, thanks Smile

No University but there is an agricultural college nearby

DottyHarmer · 03/02/2022 14:30

Someone upthread gave an example of a Positive Person, Doris I think it was, who would go to live in a retirement community and make lots of friends etc.

A) those retirement places a la Thursday Murder Club are £££££££. One near me has flats at £800k plus all the extras. My granny lived in a council one and, ahem, it was not very her .

B) some people are not “joiners”. That’s not to say they don’t enjoy having company, but I know those retirement places can be just like school. I got talking to a lady at the hospital who was visiting a friend, and she said that there was the “Barbara’s sitting here” thing, and “Oh, sorry, the bridge club is full” etc etc. That would be more depressing than sitting by yourself in your too-large and I heated family home!!

MuddlingMackem · 03/02/2022 14:27

@PussGirl Mon 31-Jan-22 16:06:18
What she means by feeling lonely is that she doesn't like living alone. She is very sociable & chatty & would be ideally suited to a supported living type community, but she flatly refuses to entertain it.

If your mother lives in a University town and would consider a lodger, she could look to see if the companionship scheme runs there (where an older person has a student lodger as company and the student gets more affordable accommodation).

Mary46 · 03/02/2022 14:14

Its hard our mum is 80. Not much in her age group. We do what we can. Im trying have a few interests and not rely on 1 friend. My friend husb retired so that was hurtful as feel I dont see her now. Im 48. Its def hard as we age. Our mum is negative as are some of that age.

Cameleongirl · 03/02/2022 14:02

@TheApexOfMyLife I agree that being more relaxed about friendships is a positive ting - that doesn't mean being taken advantage of, just not getting overly upset when people don't behave as you hope they will.

I was planning to go out with a small group tomorrow night, but I've just had a call to say that one person has dropped out as her DH wants to do something else instead. She was apologetic, but essentially, the girls have been ditched! But we're not bothered, we'll have a good time regardless - there's no point getting offended, especially when someone doesn't have form for this.

Life is complicated, sometimes partners have to come first.

TheApexOfMyLife · 03/02/2022 13:26

Certainly @Ragwort.

I think sometimes the issue comes from what is expected from that friendship.
I mean just reading MN you realise that people have widely different expectations form their friendships. Some expect a friend to text right back, others don’t.
Some feel that proposing to meet up, do X and Y is overwhelming and the friendship is overbearing whilst others will think it’s just someone being enthusiastic etc….

Sometimes it’s easy to misjudge what the other is expecting. And people have little patience for those who don’t expect the same level of involvement in the friendship.

So to your earlier question about how to help those who are lonely, I suspect being more relaxed about ‘how things should be in a friendship ’ would be a good start (general comment, not aimed at you personally iyswim)

Ragwort · 03/02/2022 12:35

TheApex ... by 'giving nothing back' I mean no real conversation, constant moaning, negative attitude, never suggesting doing anything. Most friendships develop through shared interests, having things in common or at least having interesting things to talk about. I understand people are shy and reserved but if you go out to coffee with someone surely it is good manners to at least make some effort with the conversation?

WhatNoRaisins · 03/02/2022 12:10

@Ormally

WhatNoRaisins, I might be expressing this in a clunky way, but it made me think it could be down to a balance of neediness. In a way, a vicious circle, because people who make acquaintances (let's say through joining something) because they need to have connections and energy from others to be happier, may put people off more because they are not rubbing along already in terms of their own fulfilment, stability, social impression, or whatever.
I strongly suspect the advice to join a group or volunteer is only good advice if the activities are something which really appeal and you can take or leave the making friends part. If you're in a position where you feel desperate to make friends (I've been there) then unless you quickly click with people it's not a great solution.

I wish we could stop talking about it like it's a universal fix all for loneliness. It doesn't work for everyone. We need to talk about solutions to loneliness with some nuance.

Whatwhywhenwhere · 03/02/2022 11:47

Some people have difficult personalities- but they are usually the result of problems in childhood. Some people get ill and isolated. Some (older) people are proud and can’t tell anyone they are struggling etc. It makes you realise how important it is to nurture friendships and family.

Coffeepot72 · 03/02/2022 11:22

If I didn’t have children and was worried about old age I’d make sure that pension pot was full and plan a comfortable retirement as far as financially possible.

@JustDanceAddict we're quite well sorted financially, but its the fear of being 'the only one left' that worries me, and no amount of money can guard against everyone dying before me! So even though I have a nice group of friends now, I'm adamant I'll trying to keep maintain a decent circle, for as long as I'm able.

Vloggamamma · 03/02/2022 11:19

[quote ChangingLife]**@LuluBlakey1, @Coffeepot72, same boat here too except for the fact my parents are still here (but are getting older….).

That’s one reason why I really wanted to have two dcs. Nothing could tell me whether they would be close as adults. Tbf, I still don’t know that BUT at least they’ve had that opportunity. Being an only child (Esp when your parents were only children themselves) makes your family much smaller. And that means your support network much smaller.

I’d also say that true, deep friendship is rare. I think that if you have one or two very close friends (the type you can ring at any time etc…) you are doing well.
The others come and go ime depending on interest, circumstances etc… and yes drop out if things get harder.
Seeing how things always get harder as you get older, there is no wonder friendship disappear and people get more and more lonely as they get older.[/quote]
I know what you mean, DH is only child and from a different country. Covid scare with his parents and I remember thinking, poor guy nearly had his whole family wiped out. On the flip side my siblings are vile human beings to the extent that my hubby is glad to be an only child. I do blame my parents on raising them to be bullies and self entitled. One bullies her much younger husband, the other may as well be separated from his wife and the 3 rd has no relationship at all. The 3rd sibling is the black sheep none of us get along with and when my parents go he’s going to be on his own.

Ormally · 03/02/2022 11:18

WhatNoRaisins, I might be expressing this in a clunky way, but it made me think it could be down to a balance of neediness. In a way, a vicious circle, because people who make acquaintances (let's say through joining something) because they need to have connections and energy from others to be happier, may put people off more because they are not rubbing along already in terms of their own fulfilment, stability, social impression, or whatever.

WhatNoRaisins · 03/02/2022 10:54

I wonder if some of the difference between people who say they are happy with the number of friends they have and those who aren't could be how they see their acquaintances. For example you join groups and meet people who will talk while your there but it never goes beyond the group some will count them as friends and therefore joining of the group a success and to others it's just acquaintances and it's a fail. The exact same thing could be happening but with different perspectives for the person.

TheApexOfMyLife · 03/02/2022 10:22

Can I ask What do you mean by 'give nothing back'?

Ragwort · 03/02/2022 10:18

What practical steps can be taken to genuinely help to avoid other peoples loneliness?

As I stated earlier in this thread, I recognise I am fortunate in that I am confident, happy to join in new things, volunteer etc and, despite moving several times (I live nowhere near my family) have managed to accumulate a wide circle of friends and acquaintances.

I do meet people who say they are 'lonely' and do all the usual things like inviting them to coffee, suggesting groups, interests etc ... but if they still remain negative and 'give nothing back in the way of friendship' do I have to continue to seeing them? I know that sounds harsh written down but some people are totally draining to be around. What would other people do in this situation, how can we, as a society, help to overcome loneliness?

DottyHarmer · 03/02/2022 09:19

I must admit I do envy those with large close-knit families. Dm had a big family and thus thought having friends was “silly” . The trouble with her big family though is it got too big, in that if you have eight siblings they all form their own dynasties and no longer have time for brothers and sisters.

DepthOfTheAbyss · 03/02/2022 09:08

I have quite a few friends, who I’d class as genuine close friends but I feel like I’m the one who always makes the effort. No one else suggests meeting up but when I do suggest, it’s met with enthusiasm.
I’m someone who loves to go out and meet up with people, so I go to the effort but if I didn’t, I think I’d feel lonely too.

JustDanceAddict · 03/02/2022 09:02

@Coffeepot72

DH and I don’t have children, and neither of us have brothers or sisters. I work damn hard at making friends, as I have no family network to fall back on. Obviously one of us will die before the other, and I often worry about how old age will pan out for us.
Similar here although we have children and dh has a small family there is negligible family on my side so I make sure I nurture my friendships and I keep in touch w the one living aunt I have (who lives abroad). If I didn’t have children and was worried about old age I’d make sure that pension pot was full and plan a comfortable retirement as far as financially possible. I also don’t want to rely on my children for old age ‘company’ I want them to visit out of pleasure, not duty (and they may live miles away, dd is certainly putting down roots in her uni city).
ElizabethBennetismybestfriend · 03/02/2022 08:50

Joined a virtual WI when it began. Was ignored in the main meeting when everyone introduced themselves. - sorry we haven’t got time for you. I joined the book group and was told I was not welcome because I was an English teacher.

JustDanceAddict · 03/02/2022 08:11

I agree it’s a combination of factors as well
-being old and friends dying
-being older and too negative (MIL I’m
Looking at you!) so people cba
-friends moving away or moving yourself for work

  • working from home so not building relationships in the office
-being shy or neurodivergent so not making friends easily
  • being a ‘difficult’ person
I only have my ‘immediate’ family ie dh and kids due to most of them being dead(!) and being an only child, but I do have many friends and I make sure I put effort in with new people too if I feel a ‘connection’. I am lucky as I have had lonely times in my life but not now as I’m in ‘midlife’. The worst time as an adult was my DD’s first year. Only two ‘old’ friends had kids and I had to make such an effort to go to baby groups etc.
ChangingLife · 03/02/2022 08:07

@LuluBlakey1, @Coffeepot72, same boat here too except for the fact my parents are still here (but are getting older….).

That’s one reason why I really wanted to have two dcs. Nothing could tell me whether they would be close as adults. Tbf, I still don’t know that BUT at least they’ve had that opportunity. Being an only child (Esp when your parents were only children themselves) makes your family much smaller. And that means your support network much smaller.

I’d also say that true, deep friendship is rare. I think that if you have one or two very close friends (the type you can ring at any time etc…) you are doing well.
The others come and go ime depending on interest, circumstances etc… and yes drop out if things get harder.
Seeing how things always get harder as you get older, there is no wonder friendship disappear and people get more and more lonely as they get older.

ChangingLife · 03/02/2022 08:00

Because some people are so self absorbed they can’t think of anyone else except themselves. They are totally incapable of putting anyone other than themselves first. I know a man exactly like that.

In that case, it’s just as well they haven’t had children then….

TomPinch · 03/02/2022 07:52

@Whelmed

I worry about being lonely when I'm older, most of my friendships are from work/school so once those finish, there's not much left for me as it stands so I do need to make more effort to get involved in other things.

I know some older men who are desperately lonely now but totally ruined their relationships with children and relatives when they were younger due to their own selfish behaviour. And I see some men doing this atm, behaving selfishly and I won't be surprised if their DC go NC when they're older.

No doubt true, but there's more to the picture.

I'm male, and I've found striking up new male acquaintances increasingly difficult over the years. For example, for the last 7 years I've played in a cricket team. In this time we've never met other than for matches. I know next to nothing about them - not even their wives' names. I find that typical - easy to meet other men as part of a group activity but the socialising never goes beyond the activity.

Women are much easier to get to know.

I have church too, but the reality is that everyone is getting very old.

DW I think regards me as her best friend, which is nice. I'd be happier if she had a few others too, but she seems happy as she is.

TomPinch · 03/02/2022 07:42

@Ragwort

Thank you for the honest feedback regarding WIs, I agree, there are many different WIs and it is important to find your 'fit' .. for the record we don't sing Jerusalem at the one I attend and most of the committee are leftie Guardian readers Grin ... but I understand that it's a real 'image' problem. There are some really progressive WIs out there ... as for the WI that didn't welcome new committee members, that is shocking, I would love to step down from our committee if someone else would step up!
LOL at Jerusalem. Read the words. It's pretty anti-religious but no one seems to realise.
Shoeoholic · 03/02/2022 01:01

I think you are incredibly offensive with your assertions. You don’t seem to have been disadvantaged in anyway and are coming at this from your life experience. I am a single parent and have two children, one of whom is autistic- it is amazing the amount of people don’t want to be around you and your child because they don’t fit social norms. Lots of people post on social media about being inclusive etc but in my experience very few are, coupled with Covid where everyone has knuckled down and isolated it has been very lonely.

I’ve also seen my grandad who was extremely popular, head of various clubs disappear off the radar. It started with funerals becoming his main social occasion and then he had a stoke and he just deteriorated. He developed dementia and become very lonely because being honest it makes people uncomfortable and they stopped visiting 😢 He is now in a care home and during Covid has been incredibly isolated and the care home have developed strategies for keeping everyone out as much as possible. You will never understand the effect unless your loved one has been in a care home.

You seem to lack a lot of empathy in my opinion- there may be some people who’s actions have caused them to be lonely- but most is circumstantial and the society we find ourselves in today. Loneliness has been recognized as one of the biggest social issues of our time, which is why the government employed the first ever minister for loneliness!

You need to stop blaming individuals and look wider to the sort of society we have become.