Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of lonely people have brought it on themselves?

557 replies

LovelyYellowLabrador · 31/01/2022 11:12

Just been watching a channel 4 thing on YouTube about lonely people
Most of them were like-no one calls…. They don’t see anyone all day
They maybe have had a marriage where their partner was the only other person they spent time with so when threat person has passed away they have no one else

Just think people need to think more about what they are doing
They expect their adult children to call them all the time and visit
Yet don’t stop to pause to think have I been a good parent am I draining or overly negative

Or they could think right no one’s called me, who am I going to call
How am I going to make and keep some friends

OP posts:
LittleMissUnreasonable · 04/02/2022 14:13

I'm on the fence here... I was reading a wedding thread a few days ago full of people complaining if their DC didn't get an invite they wouldn't attend. Also saying they'd rather spend a childfree night with their DH than attend a friend's wedding Hmm (which is a hopefully once in a lifetime event), or they'd attend a friend's wedding and sneak off early evening to the hotel room with their DH. It's easy to see how people who treat friends major life events as inconveniences will ostracize themselves, or refuse to attend as it disrupts 'family time' will become 'that couple'.

On the other hand my late DGD was very lonely when my DGM died, through no fault of his own. He loved people and socialising with everyone. However he became too ill to attend his social clubs, his friends had mostly passed away and his neighbours were useless. I visited as often as I could, but it's people like that I truly feel sorry for

TheOnlyMrsMac · 04/02/2022 13:48

I wonder what happened to the OP - too busy socialising to come back? Wink

Gilly12345 · 04/02/2022 13:08

Friendships are much harder when you are older and when your children are grown up.

You can have work friends but don’t see outside work as we have homes to run, partners, elderly parents and your own interests/hobbies.

I have a few local friends i meet for a coffee/chat but not enough as I find myself lonely and have a good Husband and 2 grown up children who still live at home (only finished uni last year), I work part time and enjoy that as have a good work/life balance.

Having friends was easier when the children were young as you can have the social interaction with other Mums and you meet lots of people when your children are at clubs etc (waiting around when they were at swimming lessons, hockey club) now they drive and you are not needed.

Life is good but lockdowns haven’t helped and making new friends is not easy.

Inspectorslack · 04/02/2022 13:06

@2Rebecca

I think able bodied lonely people are responsible for relieving their loneliness by going out and joining groups/ meeting people etc. OK they may not want to do that but they have to appreciate that other people don't always want to trek round to their house and you have to meet people half way. You also need hobbies and enthusiasms. If you are frail and housebound then you are more dependant on other people visiting but most lonely people are capable of leaving their house and meeting people. They just choose not to. Also being alone and being lonely are different. Some people are happier in their own company than others. If you develop dementia that can make you more lonely as you lack the imagination and motivation to do stuff, you can also forget that you had a visitor a couple of hours ago.
What about those with diagnoses that impact on their ability to be social? It’s more than just the physically disabled who struggle.
TheApexOfMyLife · 04/02/2022 13:04

@2Rebecca

I think able bodied lonely people are responsible for relieving their loneliness by going out and joining groups/ meeting people etc. OK they may not want to do that but they have to appreciate that other people don't always want to trek round to their house and you have to meet people half way. You also need hobbies and enthusiasms. If you are frail and housebound then you are more dependant on other people visiting but most lonely people are capable of leaving their house and meeting people. They just choose not to. Also being alone and being lonely are different. Some people are happier in their own company than others. If you develop dementia that can make you more lonely as you lack the imagination and motivation to do stuff, you can also forget that you had a visitor a couple of hours ago.
How are your frail and housebound people going to make friends in the first place though? Seeing that so many people moan about having to go to other people houses, they dint like peole visiting either so it has to be out and about (pub/activity) etc…

Eg I’m close to being housebound. I can’t go out and have a ‘hobby’ as such so the few people I’ve been meeting, I do that at home (mine or theirs).
But that’s apparently suffocating. Hmm

Seriously I think the British are extremely socially awkward. They have so many rules that it automatically reject potential friends just because they can’t do X and Y. They don’t want to meet up at home (cost of always going out anyone?). They don’t want 1-1 ‘because it’s suffocating’.
Basically they are happy with friends from afar.

It’s disheartening tbh. Even more so when you read the many threads of people asking how in earth they can start making friends again after moving etc…. It shouldn’t be that hard.

WhatNoRaisins · 04/02/2022 13:00

I'm not how I feel about the no vacancy people. I mean at least you know not to waste your time there and time is a precious thing for most of us.

I do think a lot of people who claim to be open to new friendships aren't really, they just feel you have to say so, kind of like all those women who claim they'd consider an unattractive man with a good personality, you know most people don't.

2Rebecca · 04/02/2022 12:54

I think sometimes people can try to hard as well. A relative of mine had a new neighbour who kept popping round with a bottle of wine and bringing presents for the children. This relative works full time and drinks very little alcohol and didn't want to spend an hour 2-3 times a week chatting to this neighbour who she had very little in common with rather than chatting to her children and husband and also disliked her children expecting a present every time they saw this neighbour. They ended up falling out but could have been friends if the neighbour had been less intrusive.
I think it's easier to make friends in areas which lots of people move to.

Coffeepot72 · 04/02/2022 11:12

I think "right place right time" also plays into this. I'm in a fairly good place now with friends, but that hasn't always been the case, and throughout I've always been the same person! However going through a friends 'dry spell' about 10 years ago made me realise how important it is, to keep making an effort. Even when you find yourself in "wrong place, wrong time" situation.

InisnaBro · 04/02/2022 10:44

[quote DottyHarmer]**@InisnaBro* - that may be true - and then they feel worse by another group, the Superiors* . You know the ones, the posters who arrive on “friends” threads and sneer that they have enough friends, no vacancies here, and that it’s sad to try to make friends at the school gate/work/ through hobbies/anywhere.

I don’t know why they do it; you wouldn’t go on a thread for the blind and boast that you had 20/20 vision. But I suppose it does give some insight into how some people think and why they avoid new people like the plague.[/quote]
Well, I suppose it’s potentially useful on an anonymous forum for people who are making efforts to make friends to hear that it may not be anything they’re doing wrong, the person who’s refused an offer of coffee may just feel they have no room for more relationships in their life?

I certainly recognised in a place I lived unhappily for almost eight years that my inability to make friends there was just a mismatch between me and my environment, nothing to do with some failing in either.

I’m a normally socially-confident person and I did all the things that would be normally suggested on here, for years — volunteer, join things, support local businesses, have a child at the village school, go to the pub and church, get involved in the PTA etc etc, to no avail. It certainly wasn’t a particularly welcoming environment, and people tended to stay there all their lives or move back to ‘settle’, so they were strongly embedded in their originally peer group and, even if they weren’t, I think the people I met simply had little or no practice in ‘making friends’ from scratch because they’d never really had to. Plus, when it came down to it, I just wasn’t the ‘type’ for them. Or, I suspect, vice versa, if I’d ever had a chance to know them better.

Coffeepot72 · 04/02/2022 10:31

@InisnaBro - that may be true - and then they feel worse by another group, the Superiors . You know the ones, the posters who arrive on “friends” threads and sneer that they have enough friends, no vacancies here, and that it’s sad to try to make friends at the school gate/work/ through hobbies/anywhere.

Ah yes, the 'friends' equivalent of a 'smug married'?

2Rebecca · 04/02/2022 10:23

I think able bodied lonely people are responsible for relieving their loneliness by going out and joining groups/ meeting people etc. OK they may not want to do that but they have to appreciate that other people don't always want to trek round to their house and you have to meet people half way. You also need hobbies and enthusiasms. If you are frail and housebound then you are more dependant on other people visiting but most lonely people are capable of leaving their house and meeting people. They just choose not to.
Also being alone and being lonely are different. Some people are happier in their own company than others. If you develop dementia that can make you more lonely as you lack the imagination and motivation to do stuff, you can also forget that you had a visitor a couple of hours ago.

DottyHarmer · 04/02/2022 10:14

@InisnaBro - that may be true - and then they feel worse by another group, the Superiors . You know the ones, the posters who arrive on “friends” threads and sneer that they have enough friends, no vacancies here, and that it’s sad to try to make friends at the school gate/work/ through hobbies/anywhere.

I don’t know why they do it; you wouldn’t go on a thread for the blind and boast that you had 20/20 vision. But I suppose it does give some insight into how some people think and why they avoid new people like the plague.

InisnaBro · 04/02/2022 09:06

@Ragwort

Perhaps it's a lot to do with your upbringing and whether your parents had friends, were outgoing, sociable and 'joiners'. My DM is 89 this year but she has always had loads of friends, joined everything going, volunteered etc etc. she was an only DC but her DPs (my DGPs) were also active and busy. My DM, widowed recently, but active in the community, goes to yoga, theatre, bridge and looking for ways to 'help old people' Grin. So for me, it was the norm to always make the effort, find new hobbies and organisations to join .. that's how I met my DH, through a shared hobby, and our DS (also an only DC) is the same ... he's doing his 'sandwich year' out from Uni and really finds it easy to join things and make new friends.

Perhaps if you haven't had the 'model' of making friends then it is clearly not so easy.

I had the opposite, @Ragwort, in that both my parents are timid, socially-isolated people with no friendships, and I was taught some deeply odd scripts about human interaction as a child — my mother is a people-pleaser who trots around collecting the vulnerable and unwell and then being bitter when they only phone when they want something, and I suspect my father is not NT and can manage minimal interactions — but by my late teens, I’d figured out I needed to behave entirely differently around other people to the way I’d been taught. I have good, lasting friendships as an adult, despite moving around internationally.

I know it’s a truism to say that Mn is dominated by introverts who refuse to answer the doorbell, but I think a more important thing — given the number and frequency of threads on friendship — is that it’s dominated numerically by quite disordered friendship situations (naturally enough, as people only post about problems), and also by quite disordered ideas about friendship, both by people in disordered friendships and people who avoid friendship entirely because it’s ‘too much drama’.

WhatNoRaisins · 04/02/2022 08:56

Well obviously someone with no other friends would only be meeting 1:1 in any case. Doesn't take a genius to work that one out. The issue for me is if said person either never wanted to consider expanding beyond 1:1. That could be a warning sign of a suffocating friendship.

Fritilleries · 04/02/2022 08:50

@WhatNoRaisins

I think because to me bringing people together and meeting friends through friends is a very normal thing and what had worked for me before. People who only see me as a 1:1 and not for mixing with any of their other friends have felt a bit like a dead end socially. Fine if the 1:1s work for you but not so good for expanding your social contacts.

I'd struggle to find enough time to sustain a series of 1:1 only friendships rather than at least some overlap and group things.

What if those 1:1 people genuinely don't have any other friends? Where does a group materialise from? How does a lone individual go from 1:1 to part of a group if the initial 1:1 is seen as strange or needy?
WhatNoRaisins · 04/02/2022 08:45

I think because to me bringing people together and meeting friends through friends is a very normal thing and what had worked for me before. People who only see me as a 1:1 and not for mixing with any of their other friends have felt a bit like a dead end socially. Fine if the 1:1s work for you but not so good for expanding your social contacts.

I'd struggle to find enough time to sustain a series of 1:1 only friendships rather than at least some overlap and group things.

MrsSkylerWhite · 04/02/2022 08:38

Harsh. It’s really not that simple. There are as many reasons for loneliness as there are lonely people.

Fritilleries · 04/02/2022 08:36

Hence I said we're screwed.

TheApexOfMyLife · 04/02/2022 08:36

@WhatNoRaisins

Only wanting to meet 1:1 can be a sign of a needy person yes. If the other person does have other friends but won't mix us together I'd worry I was just a pity friend.
Also quite interesting that you make meeting up as a 1-1 such a personal issue - it means YOU are a pity friend. Why should it say anything about YOU as a person??? Confused

But you are NOT mentioning the other person - who might be shy, have different interests from your usual friends, doesn’t have friends etc etc…

TheApexOfMyLife · 04/02/2022 08:33

@WhatNoRaisins

Only wanting to meet 1:1 can be a sign of a needy person yes. If the other person does have other friends but won't mix us together I'd worry I was just a pity friend.
You see that’s exactly what I was saying upthread.

People are so fixed about certain ways of doing things. They ABSOLUTELY do not want to get involved in a friendship that could be ‘too overwhelming’ (one that will ask them to act like friends rather than acquaintances??) so a 1-1 is a no-go.
And there are many other rules that friends need to meet, often totally unconscious.
But if you fail to meet them, then you are labelled as overbearing, too many red flags, can’t be bothered with (That often includes not reacting the ‘right way’ because people have a different background btw)

The ‘being negative’ comment for example is an interesting one for me.
I have a good friend who I haven’t been seeing for a few months. That’s because she is struggling MH wise and is worried she will be afraid/negative so is keeping to herself instead if reaching out to get support from her friends. I find that really sad tbh but is the direct consequence of telling people ‘they are negative so you don’t want to be friend with them’.
And then, to top it up, people will wonder why they have been ghosted because said friend hasn’t contacted them/doesn’t answer quickly enough/doesn’t want to meet up. So they decide that actually they are not friends anymore, despite not having a clue as to why.

And then you wonder why some people have no/few friends??

WhatNoRaisins · 04/02/2022 07:59

If you only want 1:1 and most of the people you meet want to eventually branch out to friendship groups that would be challenging.

At no point have I said meeting 1:1 in of itself is weird. If that's what people take from what I've said that's on them.

Fritilleries · 04/02/2022 07:55

@WhatNoRaisins

Only wanting to meet 1:1 can be a sign of a needy person yes. If the other person does have other friends but won't mix us together I'd worry I was just a pity friend.
Well then. That explains this entire thread. We're screwed with that kind of thinking.
WhatNoRaisins · 04/02/2022 07:26

Only wanting to meet 1:1 can be a sign of a needy person yes. If the other person does have other friends but won't mix us together I'd worry I was just a pity friend.

Fritilleries · 04/02/2022 07:23

Meeting 1:1 is seen as weird and needy? What if you don't have "other friends" and are trying to build a social network from scratch? With attitudes like yours, no wonder some of us really struggle.

DaisyChains3 · 04/02/2022 07:23

There’s nothing wrong with meeting one to one. However someone who can’t interact in groups or with others can be a strain. Some people have really poor social skills through no fault of their own and it can be draining if that person looks to you for everything. I have known a couple of people like this. Good friends one to one, but when I see them with other people, I realise they are quite socially awkward.