Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of lonely people have brought it on themselves?

557 replies

LovelyYellowLabrador · 31/01/2022 11:12

Just been watching a channel 4 thing on YouTube about lonely people
Most of them were like-no one calls…. They don’t see anyone all day
They maybe have had a marriage where their partner was the only other person they spent time with so when threat person has passed away they have no one else

Just think people need to think more about what they are doing
They expect their adult children to call them all the time and visit
Yet don’t stop to pause to think have I been a good parent am I draining or overly negative

Or they could think right no one’s called me, who am I going to call
How am I going to make and keep some friends

OP posts:
RidingMyBike · 06/02/2022 15:38

@Jannt86 but you can to a certain extent work on childhood experiences and try and change how you behave? I was brought up to be a doormat - other people were always right, you went around not putting others out, didn't assert yourself and martyred yourself helping people. My DM way of acting is to adopt as many people as possible who need help, moan about one person to a different person and circle around her acquaintances moaning about all of them. That was how I learnt friendship operated. It's kind of backfired on her in this age of social media!

But I've managed to unlearn it and found much more positive ways of interacting with people and not being a doormat. It has taken a lot of effort and I did go through a lot of counselling in my 20s which helped.

RidingMyBike · 06/02/2022 15:33

It's if you go and do things and see people that's at the right amount for you. And that will vary between people. Pre-Covid, and whether I was single/living on my own or living with DH, I found my limit was being out twice a week - and that's not wild nights out, that's going to a craft group, or meeting a group of friends for a meal or having a coffee with one friend or attending a meeting at church. Sometimes I did do more than that, but it was too much and left me feeling like I couldn't keep up - bearing in mind if you work full time you've got to do your cooking/housework/making packed lunch sometime!

I did really struggle with one now-ex friend who was a teacher and lived alone and who was 'too busy' during term time to ever want to speak on the phone or email or even msg. She lived a couple of hours away so visits involved an overnight stay so were less often. But as soon as the school hols started she was at a loose end and wanted to be on the phone having lengthy chats several times a week. I was never quite sure why she thought it was ok to ignore me during term time and then expect me to be instantly available in the school hols! She ended up an alcoholic and, after trying to help her get help multiple times, all she wanted was 2am lengthy drunken conversations I had to say I wasn't going to take calls during the night again as it was affecting my work. But apparently this wasn't being a good friend! Confused

Momijin · 06/02/2022 13:38

@Leighcloon she wouldn't want my pace of life, no, but she would like to do more. It would be perfect if she lived close to me or someone like me where she could join when she wanted. At least that's what I think.

Leighcloon · 06/02/2022 13:36

I never suggested that an unlikeable person has in any way 'brought it on themselves', @Jannt86. I think you're relating my question back to the OP's post, whereas I was only responding to yours.

But, since you ask, I think 'likeability' is pretty subjective -- no one is universally likeable. I'm certainly not, though I have good, lasting friendships that enrich my life. Equally, I'm not everyone's cup of tea.

I do think, though, that you can learn social skills, even if you were raised with poor friendship models and some deeply odd ideas about human relationships.

My parents gave me very odd, unhelpful childhood scripts about friendships. I've talked about them on here before under previous user names. My father is not NT and his only 'friends' are people he's never met in the flesh, who live on the other side of the world and with whom his interactions are purely formal conversations about the weather and hobby-related stuff. He knows nothing about these people beyond their names and equipment types.

My mother is a chronic people-pleaser who chooses to be a shoulder to cry on for the unwell and unlucky because it makes her feed needed, and then gets very bitter when they don't invite her to 'fun' stuff when they're feeling better. I don't think she has a single real friend in the world, because her only contribution to these relationships is to abase herself to the other person's needs and nod along with whatever they're saying -- there's nothing of herself in there. Her phone calls with them can last an hour in which she sounds like a Samaritan.

I had to learn as a young adult how to negotiate friendships, after I'd realised how skewed my parents' ideas about them were.

I think it's a realisation that would benefit many Mners who struggle with friendships, whose posts express bafflement that no one invites them to things when they're 'been there for them' for years. Positioning yourself as a service provider/permanently available listening ear or shoulder to cry on/rescuer is no way to make friends.

Jannt86 · 06/02/2022 13:17

@Leighcloon

Another important thing to remember is that being unlikeable doesn't mean that you're unkind or unworthy.

Well, no, but surely it might go some way to explaining why you might struggle to make friends, @Jannt86?

Maybe so but please do explain how such a person has 'bought it on themselves' You can't really choose to be more likeable. You can choose to be louder or quieter or fake or less fake. You can even choose to be prettier/less pretty to a degree. What you really can't choose though is the social skills and human connections that are necessary to truly make friends. Half of this is down to how you were raised as a child and the experiences you had as a child, the other half is your DNA. I'd love to hear what part of that an individual has control over...
Leighcloon · 06/02/2022 13:13

@Momijin

I think that making and keeping friends takes some effort, compromise and putting yourself out there and being out of your comfort zone for a while.

One of my closest friends is single and lives a very solitary life. Her work doesn't give her the opportunity to meet many people. But she doesn't join anything or make any effort to meet and get to know people local to her. She hasn't had a boyfriend in many years but she would never do online dating. She has lived in the same place for 15 years and doesn't have any friends. In the same time, I have moved twice and set up completely new friendship groups and have had 2 long term relationships and a couple of short relationships. I know most of my neighbours and am good friends with a few. When my kids were little, all my socialising was with other mums, but I didn't know anyone when I moved here so I had to start speaking to other mums at playgroups. Then when I split up with my ex and worked from home, I started new hobbies and did online dating because I had more free time and I didn't want to spend all my time at home.

I invite people round, I organise outings, parties, walks in the woods etc.

I completely understand that it is easier for some people than others but I know if I was to suddenly live in my friend's world in her circumstances that within a month I would have met the neighbours, joined local clubs, looked at online meetups and would have a pretty packed calendar.

My friend is lovely and I love her dearly. She's happy to join stuff but is shy so what may be slightly uncomfortable to me would be excruciatingly painful for her.

Is she unhappy, though, @Momijin? I do agree with you that if you move a lot (I have), and if friendships are important to you, then you need to be quite proactive about making new ones, but it may be that your friend is happier not to have a 'pretty packed calendar'? Or that the effort needed for someone you say is shy, and who also sounds rather passive, to put herself out there for friendships or relationships outweighs for her the advantages of having more friends or a relationship?
Momijin · 06/02/2022 13:08

I think that making and keeping friends takes some effort, compromise and putting yourself out there and being out of your comfort zone for a while.

One of my closest friends is single and lives a very solitary life. Her work doesn't give her the opportunity to meet many people. But she doesn't join anything or make any effort to meet and get to know people local to her. She hasn't had a boyfriend in many years but she would never do online dating. She has lived in the same place for 15 years and doesn't have any friends. In the same time, I have moved twice and set up completely new friendship groups and have had 2 long term relationships and a couple of short relationships. I know most of my neighbours and am good friends with a few. When my kids were little, all my socialising was with other mums, but I didn't know anyone when I moved here so I had to start speaking to other mums at playgroups. Then when I split up with my ex and worked from home, I started new hobbies and did online dating because I had more free time and I didn't want to spend all my time at home.

I invite people round, I organise outings, parties, walks in the woods etc.

I completely understand that it is easier for some people than others but I know if I was to suddenly live in my friend's world in her circumstances that within a month I would have met the neighbours, joined local clubs, looked at online meetups and would have a pretty packed calendar.

My friend is lovely and I love her dearly. She's happy to join stuff but is shy so what may be slightly uncomfortable to me would be excruciatingly painful for her.

Leighcloon · 06/02/2022 13:04

Another important thing to remember is that being unlikeable doesn't mean that you're unkind or unworthy.

Well, no, but surely it might go some way to explaining why you might struggle to make friends, @Jannt86?

Jannt86 · 06/02/2022 12:52

I think there's a fundamental truth being missed here and that's that lonliness isn't a choice like choosing to have toast for breakfast is. Another important thing to remember is that being unlikeable doesn't mean that you're unkind or unworthy. I am an extremely empathic person. I would go to the end of the earth for you if you were my friend but there's only so much trying and putting yourself out there that you can do before it feels futile. My own parents are fairly selfish and don't offer much in the way of practical support with my child. My in-laws did some pretty horrific things and put our child at risk without us realising which resulted in ss being heavily on our backs through literally no fault of our own. When I dare to communicate that I'm remotely upset about this I'm gaslighted into being the unreasonable one. Nevertheless I have chosen to forgive them. Our house is an open house and they know they can visit whenever they want... but they don't... I ask to meet up with my SIL who has kids a similar age and it's met with a flat 'no'. We again get no practical support from any of them. I have been to every baby group etc going. I am always the one to 'make the first move' and will happily chat to anyone. However it's either met with straight up snubbery or never escalates to more than a polite hello. I've even met up with people on the peanut app and my daughter has literally been the perfect playmate but then when I suggest meeting up again it's ignored. Please some of the wise people on here who think lonliness is a choice do tell me what more I can/should do??

Mary46 · 06/02/2022 12:41

They not much when you 80+. Her choir stopped. Cold church. I call where I can. She negative. So u wouldnt be calling alot listening to negativity. No easy answers. My dad did everything for her

WhatNoRaisins · 06/02/2022 12:26

It's what meets your needs I think, the fact that your needs change over time makes it more complicated. I found having kids has given me a need to have other friends with small children to do things with for example.

InisnaBro · 06/02/2022 12:23

@Coffeepot72

I asked this question earlier in the thread but I don’t think anyone commented on it, but what constitutes a decent network of friends? And what’s the definition of a good social life!
Well, whatever you personally find satisfactory, presumably? It’s very personal — I think of myself as someone with a lot of friends, though I’m always open to more interesting new people in my life. However, I also need a lot of time alone and, by the standards of some Mners, whose friendship groups seem to involve a lot of ‘checking-in’ messaging and drama about being excluded from meet-ups, I’m probably quite solitary. Certainly, having moved around a lot, many people I consider good friends live in different countries and I don’t see them very often.
Coffeepot72 · 06/02/2022 11:51

I asked this question earlier in the thread but I don’t think anyone commented on it, but what constitutes a decent network of friends? And what’s the definition of a good social life!

TheApexOfMyLife · 06/02/2022 11:13

@Ragwort

Xeno yes ... until one of them is left alone. My DF died last year and I am so glad my DM has a wide network of friends - both 'old' friends and 'new' ones and the confidence to go out and join new activities... she is amazing for 88!
She is also extremely lucky to be in good health so she can actually go out and meet people.

At that age, many people have mobility issues that will stop them from doing that. Hell, I’m just turning 50yo and I have been struggling with socialising for more than 10 years now, just because of that….

DaisyChains3 · 06/02/2022 10:20

@Ragwort

Xeno yes ... until one of them is left alone. My DF died last year and I am so glad my DM has a wide network of friends - both 'old' friends and 'new' ones and the confidence to go out and join new activities... she is amazing for 88!
Yes my mother is the same. However my father didn't like people and was very antisocial. So they never had people round or spoke to the neighbours. My mother's friends were formed through her religion, so when my father died they were a lifeline.
WhatNoRaisins · 06/02/2022 06:52

Neither of my parents socialise much. Growing up I never remember them talking to neighbors or having guests over. I do worry how they'll cope in old age.

Ragwort · 05/02/2022 22:14

Xeno yes ... until one of them is left alone. My DF died last year and I am so glad my DM has a wide network of friends - both 'old' friends and 'new' ones and the confidence to go out and join new activities... she is amazing for 88!

XenoBitch · 05/02/2022 22:08

My mum has a social life... is out all the time. My dad.... "I don't need anyone, I have your mum". A lot of couples out there are the same.

Gwenhwyfar · 05/02/2022 21:07

Ironically, I find the opposite a bit. There are times in my life when I would have so loved to have been introduced to new people, but my old friends just met me one to one.

DaisyChains3 · 05/02/2022 20:59

Yes I understand. I have had the same problem with a couple of friends. It is suffocating.

Ragwort · 05/02/2022 20:36

Daisy in the context of this thread I was trying to make the point (probably not very well) that there are people I know who say they are lonely and don't have many friends but won't join in anything except being 'one to one'. I know people who are happy to meet me for a coffee but if I suggest doing something with a wider group such as an organised activity, they don't want to do it ... so I find their attitude to me is rather needy.

DaisyChains3 · 05/02/2022 16:09

The point is many people don’t have friendship groups. They have very few if any friends. So naturally they see these people one to one.

Gwenhwyfar · 05/02/2022 11:58

[quote TheApexOfMyLife]@Gwenhwyfar, really??

People don’t want to mix friendship groups because they present differently in each group. Nothing to do with the fact that they have interests so different that those people are likely to NOT be compatible?

I mean I used to go diving and caving. Still have friends that are doing that (can’t due to my health).
I also really enjoy reading and book club. I tend to be quite nerdy in j’y readings too.
Do you think those two groups of people will be likely to have shared interest there?[/quote]
Why not? People who dive and people who read can talk about other things can't they?

In any case, the people I'm talking about go out for dinners or drinks with their different friendship groups.

Gwenhwyfar · 05/02/2022 11:57

@2Rebecca

True, but I don't understand how some people reach adulthood without having an interest or hobby. I have loads and most of my groups are meeting up again in person and I'm in Scotland.
I don't have any hobbies as such. I like going on the internet, watching TV and going to the pub just like millions of people do. I can't be that weird surely?
Gwenhwyfar · 05/02/2022 11:54

@Coffeepot72

Whereas my 90+ yo great uncle, when he could no longer manage the stairs to his flat, the Housing Association found him a place in residential care where he had his own bedroom/living room/bathroom/kitchenette. He could walk down the corridor for lunch and tea with other people, and use a communal lounge if he wanted to, but also had privacy and could make his own drinks and breakfast

That would suit me down to the ground, particularly if I could take the cat!

Can I have one of these now or do I have to be 90+?