Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of lonely people have brought it on themselves?

557 replies

LovelyYellowLabrador · 31/01/2022 11:12

Just been watching a channel 4 thing on YouTube about lonely people
Most of them were like-no one calls…. They don’t see anyone all day
They maybe have had a marriage where their partner was the only other person they spent time with so when threat person has passed away they have no one else

Just think people need to think more about what they are doing
They expect their adult children to call them all the time and visit
Yet don’t stop to pause to think have I been a good parent am I draining or overly negative

Or they could think right no one’s called me, who am I going to call
How am I going to make and keep some friends

OP posts:
thevassal · 31/01/2022 15:27

Agree with @pyri - there are so many people on mn who say their dh is the only company they need, or are mocking about "school gate mums" and people who dont just "go to work to work" like them but are actually friends with their colleagues and -gasp - socialise with them outside of work! They dont seem to think they are only one failed relationship or early death away from regular companionship to none.

Also I feel a lot of people get used to the madness of that stage of life with partner, young kids, working full time etc and friendships just fade away through being too busy/exhausted to maintain them. Then 15 years later kids have all moved out, you're retired or only working part time and have time and space to invest in friends again but all your old friends haven't heard from you in years and it's harder to make new ones, most people already have tight friendship groups etc.

Obviously that's not everyone and loads of people are lonely through no fault of their own. But I think a lot of people are guilty of putting making and keeping good friends low on their priority list and then being surprised when they in turn aren't at the top of anyone else's list.

stuffnthings · 31/01/2022 15:26

@Kelly7889

Loneliness is a state of mind. I don't think it has anything to do with having a big family or no family, or seeing loads of people or none. You can work in a room of a hundred people and be lonely, even if you know them all. Lonely people are lonely because they are not happy with themselves.
I think this is probably a bit of a sweeping statement.

If it was just a 'state of mind' and 'not happy with themselves', then I'll just have a quick chat to myself, then the feeling of loss and loneliness I have sometimes after my DW died last year (only early 40s) would dissipate.

I don't actually feel unhappy, actually quite positive, but I do feel lonely often, despite having plenty of close friends and family, who I see regularly. I think loneliness is more complex.

GrendelsGrandma · 31/01/2022 15:25

Does it matter if they brought it on themselves? It only matters that people find a way out.

Loneliness is a trap. Once you're in it, you need company so much that it scares people off. Then you become a bit unused to people and come across as strange. Then you might become angry or bitter that you tried to make friends but they rejected you for being too needy or weird.

It's a bit like saying homeless people just need a roof over their heads - maybe for a small proportion but for many people it's a complex situation that can't be put right overnight. For example mental or physical health issues, mobility problems, poverty, fear of going out etc.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 31/01/2022 15:23

It's very, very rarely the case that people are lonely because they don't bother to make an effort. There are all sorts of reasons people might be lonely or struggle with friendships.

  • they're scared of rejection, so it's easier not to try.
  • they're scared of meeting new people and embarrassing themselves, --- they're unwell (mentally or physically) and can't actually leave the house or make the effort to visit other people very often.
  • they have depression and/or anxiety and find simple tasks like calling a friend or going out for coffee incredibly difficult.
  • they've been so wrapped up in other aspects of life - work, relationships, raising a family - that they haven't been able to prioritise friends and then when they realise, it's too late.

Yes, some people are unpleasant and push people away, but how many of those people are unpleasant due to an underlying illness or problem that leads to them feeling depressed and low and lonely?

I used to have a client who was an alcoholic - she's sadly now passed away. But for her, it was a vicious cycle. She struggled with her MH (had several diagnosed illnesses) and drank as a result of that.

When she was sober, she was lovely and a joy to talk to, but her illnesses meant she couldn't stop drinking, and when she drank she was unpleasant and people got fed up of dealing with her binges and her behaviour. So when she sobered up, she felt lonely, so she drank and pushed people away even further...

Nobody owes anyone friendship - so yes, in a way you do need to look at your own actions, but it's never as straightforward as people just not trying hard enough.

sanbeiji · 31/01/2022 15:22

YANBU.
OP Isn't slagging off the people who have TRIED, and haven't ended up with any friends.

She's talking about people who do nothing, and expect friends to fall out of the sky, or be courted. Or people who don't behave.

The world has changed, if you're busy with work/life and never go anywhere you won't naturally meet people, like school or uni. YOU have to go out, YOU have to send people messages, arrange things.

If you won't do that fine but don't moan about it. Social anxiety, introversion blah2 everyone has loads of excuses for why they think they don't need to make any effort.

BungleandGeorge · 31/01/2022 15:17

@Mischance totally agree, as a single person you’re frequently left out because people want to socialise with couples. Not to mention some women suddenly become worried you’ll go off with their husband

TooTiredToSleepRightNow · 31/01/2022 15:17

I moved away when I got married and became isolated because of the nature of the relationship (only realised when I moved) toxicity all round and my own family wouldn’t visit or care about what I was going through. . Now I’ve got out of the situation I’m very depressed because of years being on my own around toxic people and losing out on potential friendships. I have lost my confidence to even talk to others. But to everyone else I look normal as I can hold conversations which are probably verbal diarrhoea on my part anyway. Now my mother wants to be my best friend but I have no time for her. She only rings to be nosey really, conversations are so empty she doesn’t have my back and never has and but she will always deny any wrong doing or neglect. I’ve gone really low contact and actually have an aversion to speaking to her. Father never bothered anyway. I don’t see the point in maintaining pointless phone conversations and tick box visits. I get nothing from them now as I’m so used to being on my own. I have been in hospital with my little one, could have done with family around but all they think they need to do is make a phone call to show how much they care. I would love a social life but haven’t found any friends firstly due to being isolated and now I just don’t know how and where to meet people and also feel I’ve lost my social skills, lots of anxiety, can’t manage my time, no organisation so prefer to stay home (I work from home too) lockdown made things worse but now I’m ok on my own as I’m so used to it. Friends would be great but not holding my breath. Feel I’ve missed the boat now. Lost touch with the ones I moved away from. Just trying to focus on my health and savings so when the time comes I have choices.

Cameleongirl · 31/01/2022 15:13

My Dad, unfortunately, is very moody and has lost friends over this. He can be quite nasty at times and for some reason, he's never learnt that this puts people off, both family and friends!

Kdubs1981 · 31/01/2022 15:11

@Kelly7889

Loneliness is a state of mind. I don't think it has anything to do with having a big family or no family, or seeing loads of people or none. You can work in a room of a hundred people and be lonely, even if you know them all. Lonely people are lonely because they are not happy with themselves.
This is nonsense.
Cameleongirl · 31/01/2022 15:10

@MatildaTheCat

I’m in a very fortunate position in that I do have a lot of friends but I really do work at that. There seems to be a theme here that friendships fade out and are therefore lost but if you were friends and had things in common once then you probably still do.

Last week I met a friend from 25 years ago. We’ve had extremely sporadic meetings in the last 20 odd years and I hadn’t seen her for six years but we had a great catch up and will see each other again in a few months.

It’s whether people are willing to reach out- my own widowed mother is terrible at this, she has an underlying fear of rejection- to reconnect or indeed connect in the first place. It’s certainly much harder for some people.

@EmmaH2022 you say the lockdowns have lost you friends, is it really too late to message those people and say you’ve missed them and would love to catch up?

I agree with you, @MatildaTheCat, you do need to work at friendships and one of the positive things about SM and WhatsApp is that you can easily keep in touch with people from years ago.

I'm on a WhatsApp group with my closest university friends (we're 47 now). We're very scattered geographically, but it's the perfect way to keep up with each other's news. We did occasionally meet up pre-pandemic and we hoping to arrange a group holiday when everything gets back to normal.

I also keep in touch with a group of Mums from my DC's primary school and we meet up every few months. I don't over-think getting in touch, I just suggest a Happy Hour and whoever can make it comes.

I haven't got a huge circle of friends, just a few close ones and some less close who are part of groups. I do try to be nice to people and I don't worry if we don't click - I used to worry more but can't be bothered now!

BungleandGeorge · 31/01/2022 15:09

@OutwiththeOutCrowd

People are often at their least attractive and least able to present themselves as good friendship/companionship material when they need the most compassion and help. I think that should to be factored in.
Agree with this. A lot of the time friends desert you because they’re only interested in the friendship when it’s fun and times are good. And it’s often those who you don’t suspect who disappear as soon as bereavement/ illness/ divorce/ fertility problems etc appear. I think mental health problems are a huge factor too, especially depression, it’s a downwards spiral. For some people a bit of compassion/ help in making friends can make all the difference. Support groups are a really important resource. There are of course others who just aren’t very personable and make little effort but I certainly don’t think that accounts for many. The parent and child relationship is very complex. From the outside it seems like some children are selfish, others have been parented poorly.
Nothinglikeachocolatebrownie · 31/01/2022 15:05

I tend to agree OP, although in some cases it's unfortunate that people are lonely, it is often overlooked that loneliness is the result of that person's own behaviour and actions. I think often women are tasked with accompanying the elderly and picking up the slack with family relationships and now women just aren't keen on doing that anymore. So you have older people who feel entitled to have company, and suddenly they don't receive it because they really aren't that pleasant to be around.

SartresSoul · 31/01/2022 15:04

It’s a vicious cycle really, often caused by depression and/or anxiety. You get comfortable in the house not seeing people and socialising becomes almost impossible. How do you meet friends as an adult? You have to really put yourself out there and make an effort, that can be all too much for people struggling with their MH.

Joystir59 · 31/01/2022 15:03

The most important relationships to nourish are those we have with friends. I'm 64. I've been in several long wonderful relationships and am deeply grieving at the moment. Friends get you through all of what life throws at you. Look after your friends!

giveyou2reasons · 31/01/2022 15:02

I'm one who doesn't feel the need for many people in my daily life. A "DH is my best friend" person. If I outlive him, I trust that I will be able to find a friend, if I want more interaction than I get from my family. After all, I won't be the only one who's lost their best friend and doesn't have a large group of close friends to fill in the gap. I can be friendly and sociable, but I don't need a lot of people to feel happy in my day-to-day life, and there's nothing wrong being satisfied with less social interaction.

Yes, sometimes people are lonely because of their actions. People bring all sorts of things on themselves. In my case, I'd rather live my life as I wish. Stressing myself over spending my life maintaining extraneous relationships I don't currently need or desire only because I might outlive my DH and end up feeling lonely... seems rather strange to me!

Larryyourwaiter · 31/01/2022 14:57

It’s very complex.

I had a good group of friends but some moved on, we all had children at different times, jobs changed. I’m still good friends with one of them as we have a similar outlook and see each other when we can, no drama or expectation.

I thought children would bring me new friends but lots of the other parents are pricks. I’ve gotten sick of feeling as a convenient free babysitting service for them. One I do see and has never done anything helpful for me, still constantly drops hints about me taking her kids for the weekend because her and her poor husband have no one to take them. Like me!

In fhe last few years I’ve seen an elderly neighbour push away us and her well established group of active female friends. It was some misguided attempt to get her son to let her move near him as now she has no ties here, not happened, never will. Now she hardly goes out.

PearlclutchersInc · 31/01/2022 14:56

Big on the empathy - not (the way you come across)

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 31/01/2022 14:52

@BiBabbles well said.

BiBabbles · 31/01/2022 14:44

Last stats I saw said 45% of adults, or 25 million people in England describe themselves as occasionally, sometimes, or often lonely.

Some might be assholes or actively became hermits, I think it's unreasonable to think 'a lot' of those brought it on themselves and really, the whole post ignores how people can be lonely in a crowd. People can make all those calls and think every day about how they're going to make more friends and maintain friendships, try all the groups they can find and still feel lonely. They can try all that and still end up alone for days at a time, longer even. Doing all the right things can help, but it does not mean reciprocation is going to happen.

It's been argued by many how current social structures encourage loneliness. It's hard to fight against a system that can suck up all your time and energy before getting into stats like the above that show how disabled people and other marginalized groups are more likely to feel lonely & the stigma around loneliness - that it's a sign of something wrong with a person for them to fix - doesn't help anything.

Loneliness is an emotion, a sensory signal. It just signals wanting connection, sometimes a specific type of understanding from others. There are things that can be done just like other emotions that make it more or less likely, but we're not always in charge of how we feel and telling people they brought it on themselves? While that may be true of the assholes, but they're not going to listen, and those who already blame themselves or fear being a problem for others aren't going to be helped by it either.

Kelly7889 · 31/01/2022 14:41

Loneliness is a state of mind. I don't think it has anything to do with having a big family or no family, or seeing loads of people or none. You can work in a room of a hundred people and be lonely, even if you know them all.
Lonely people are lonely because they are not happy with themselves.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 31/01/2022 14:35

Virtual friends are not the same than friends in flesh tbh Why not have both? It's not an either or situation, is it?

Mary46 · 31/01/2022 14:35

My mum is 80. Its not easy. Friends are elderly or have other commitments. She set in her ways. Only so much u can do in the week too

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 31/01/2022 14:34

Someone mentioned 'third' places which aren't home and aren't work. The church used to operate like this and still does for some people. I used to go occasionally and it would be the only outing many would have in a week. Other churchgoers would take responsibility for visiting those in hospital or house-bound as well, and enjoy the activity.

People who have the time, energy and religious inclination to reach out continually to others are rare these days.

I don't blame anyone, but the loss of community-based places, not just religious, even youth groups, makes people insular. My 16 and 17 year old would do fantastically in a youth group, away from school, but there are none any more.

Being part of something bigger isn't very fashionable, and there aren't the social structures to support it.

On here, lots of people with nice houses and nice husbands are delighted not to return to the office, and can't see why they should disrupt their WFH to go meet the younger members of staff, or those who would otherwise be isolated, or to brain-storm creatively. I also love WFH but I see the value to my students and to the community I work in of me leaving my house a couple of times a week and interacting with them, even though it would be easier to stay home.

You don't think you will be that widow. I have been, and I was so grateful I had a big group of local friends and colleagues to rally me round me in the early days. Without work friends, built up over the years, and lots and lots of friends (as they can't all drop everything, many are also stressed, busy, traumatized themselves), it would have been a lonely time, but it wasn't.

I think it's a mix of no funding or interest in maintaining third spaces, the tendency towards individualism (which is great if all you need is set up in your home, not great for everyone else) and just the pandemic shutting a lot of things down and them taking ages to restart, it's all creating a perfect storm of loneliness for the coming years.

user1497207191 · 31/01/2022 14:32

@ChangingLife

Virtual friends are not the same than friends in flesh tbh.
That depends on the person really. I always find it easier to "talk" to people by phone or online etc rather than face to face. I've a lot more "friends" now than I did years ago before technology. I find face to face can be very exhausting, not just at the time, but before and after.

After suffering pretty horrendous bullying for years in my teens due to how I looked, that made me very self conscious and I would just "hide away" so people couldn't actually see me. That's why I found phone and internet to be so much better for personal interactions as I wasn't so obsessed about how I looked and it stopped me from constantly being frightened of negative comments/bullying, even as an adult. That kind of thing stays with you throughout your adult life and shapes your lifetime of how you deal with people.

I set up my online business just over 20 years ago at a time when much fewer people were online, and in fact I was one of only about a dozen similar businesses who did everything online at that time, hence why it grew so quickly. It was only by being online and being able to avoid F2F that I could start the business.

Steelesauce · 31/01/2022 14:29

Its a complex issue. I feel sorry for elderly people who suffer with disabilities and struggle to get out. Some have vile family members also. You can see they are caring individuals and just get taken advantage of. On the other hand, there are cantankerous old folk who I am not surprised in the slightest they are lonely.

When you are younger, especially in the busy family life stage. It is important to make effort. I'm a lone parent and I make so much effort to maintain friendships. We're all busy and effort and understanding should be on both sides. I know people who stop bothering with others over forgetting to reply to a text or cancelling a meet up. I've had friends for 20+ years, sometimes we don't see or speak for long periods of time but I know I can ring them if I need something and they will be there, and I would do the same.