Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of lonely people have brought it on themselves?

557 replies

LovelyYellowLabrador · 31/01/2022 11:12

Just been watching a channel 4 thing on YouTube about lonely people
Most of them were like-no one calls…. They don’t see anyone all day
They maybe have had a marriage where their partner was the only other person they spent time with so when threat person has passed away they have no one else

Just think people need to think more about what they are doing
They expect their adult children to call them all the time and visit
Yet don’t stop to pause to think have I been a good parent am I draining or overly negative

Or they could think right no one’s called me, who am I going to call
How am I going to make and keep some friends

OP posts:
Iveneverwonanoscar · 01/02/2022 18:07

@coronabeer

It's rarely as simple as you say.

Depression, for example can make a person withdraw from social life - and as loneliness increases, so too can the depression.

Lonely people can both crave company and fear it.

Fear of rejection can make it difficult to join social events of any sort, let alone attempt to initiate them.

Loneliness itself is a stigma - lots of people seem to think there must be something wrong with a person that they are alone, so they are effectively shunned.

I'm pretty lonely most of the time, I'll admit it. I can look back to times in my life when I was popular with a wide social circle, but those times melted away, basically because life got in the way. I've lived in loads of different parts of the country, so keep being uprooted from friends I do make. Good friends have likewise moved around or even emigrated. I had an unhappy marriage for years with little opportunity to have a social life. I have no extended family whatsoever apart from my elderly mother, who I rarely see. My brother died about 3 years ago. I moved to a new town during lockdown. I'm probably suffering from low-grade depression right now, but I've seen a couple of groups I might try out and hopefully something will grow from there.

I hope you find the right thing for you, you sound like a lovely person, and heading in the right direction if able to articulate the reasons you are feeling low.Flowers
GASB · 01/02/2022 18:07

I have often caught myself thinking this about my Mum. She spent 35 years spending the week at home and the weekend at her partners. During lockdown they managed to live together, but Mum’s I’ll health means she has to be at home for district nurse visits and her partner can barely manage to look after himself. Mum always says she’s lonely because she’s not used to being at home or alone.

georgarina · 01/02/2022 18:06

YBVVVU

Great that it's so simple and straightforward for you. Most likely relationships were modelled to you when you were growing up and did not suffer an excess of trauma.

Others are not that lucky.

Babiesandboardgames · 01/02/2022 18:02

I think you have a point OP.

I know 4 people who would describe themselves as "lonely"
1 . Is 97 and completely isolated at home as she's too old, friends have all passed away. No kids. Met her on a befriending service for lonely people. She was lovely, she was lonely due to difficult circumstances.

  1. 73 year old lady also on befriending site. Not a horrible person, but just talks about herself and doesn't ask you any questions. She's not interested in anything you say so her kids and grandkids don't see her.
  2. Best friends dad, drinks too much and is very unreliable and was difficult growing up. Then moved 3 hours away from everyone . He says he's lonely, again this is self inflicted.
  3. Woman I went on a singles tour with. Moaned that her only daughter and dgc don't see her. However, she also had some clear mh issues after her son passed away, she claimed she could still talk to her son and he was sending her visions. Daughter couldn't cope anymore and went v v LC.

In three of these four cases, imo, the loneliness was self inflicted. I do understand what I am talking about too as I made a lot of effort with loneliness charities.

Frollop · 01/02/2022 18:01

When your friends/family have partners and children and no time/don't want to meet you can find yourself alone.

If you're lucky you can make new available friends through work, hobbies or if you're confident to attend meet ups etc.

There are different levels of loneliness I guess
People with a partner/children but feel alone with no friends or feel alone in the relationship.

People with friends/family but feel alone with no partner

People with none of the above

I'm sure there's others categories

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 01/02/2022 17:57

YANBU.

I agree, most people are in situations of their own making. Being lonely might not be your fault - but it might be. Of course there’s lots of variables but we’re talking broadly here??!

We are all in charge of our own lives.

KarenTheGammonRemoaner · 01/02/2022 17:55

Well you could say this about almost anything to a degree. In poverty? Budget better. Unhealthy? Eat better. Overweight? Etc. Etc. But in reality people just don’t think about how to improve themselves most of the time and instead wallow in self-pity. I've been this way myself and I've dragged myself out of things but also often it takes a network around you to do that also. If you get stuck in a cycle it can be difficult to get out of it, not everyone can just whip up the mental ability to do it either as lots don’t seem to be able to take actions that aren't dictated to them by some outside source.

Hawkins001 · 01/02/2022 17:52

My main pickle was not socialising more at uni, instead I was the 00 library student reading 📚various topics on ancient history.

However after uni I met a group of people and I try not to just have one best friend, id rather have a mix of people I can chat and have their perspectives on x issues,

Adelyra · 01/02/2022 17:52

I have worked in social work-ish things and what I have learnt is that: we, women, need to look after our friendships. Children leave and husbands die.

Sign up for the free/inexpensive classes all the FE colleges offer. Find groups: walking, knitting, sea swimming, online/local book groups... Try and make the first step and invite people for a cuppa or a walk etc.

It's hard as we all have our stuff - neurodivergence, lack of confidence, caring duties, lack of money etc - but I think it's really important to keep a hand in even when you're really busy.

randomchatter · 01/02/2022 17:51

@ShavingTheBadger

There's lots of reasons - introversion, shyness, other neuro-diverse conditions. Sometimes it's because of caring responsibilities that they can't drop. For me it was all my mates getting married and having kids - you really do feel alone when that happens. It's not black and white.
Off topic but I do hope that introversion and shyness aren't really classed as neurodiverse conditions Hmm!!
Alip1965 · 01/02/2022 17:41

In my case my ex abusive partner got rid of all my friends and moved us to an isolated area where i knew no one. Left me with debts so i cant move etc. . Relatives have died and my self confidence is at rock bottom ... OP must be very lucky to not know how these things work or happen

DonaPatrizia · 01/02/2022 17:41

Even if someone has brought loneliness on themselves it doesn't mean they don't deserve sympathy.

mumof2exhausted · 01/02/2022 17:41

I think you are very naive to think it’s easy to just go and “make some friends”. I have a wonderful friendship group but honestly the last real friend I made was 8 years ago. And I’m only 40 and I have kids and work and have hobbies so have opportunities to meet new people easily. My dad has lost 10 of his friends recently as they have died. Should I tell him to buck up his ideas and make new ones quick smart?? Such an insensitive post.

user1485851222 · 01/02/2022 17:39

I recently admitted to myself, I'm lonely. I'm 59, married, 1 child. I've got to this age and realised that to some degree, I choose the wrong friends. All lovely, but a lot use me when they need someone. I help them get strong and then the friendship seems to become an occasional text message. I've looked in at myself & asked why, I decided, I like helping people, I like being wanted and then I inevitably end up feeling hurt. Yep I'm lonely, but hard to make new friends at 59......

Trippingslippingx1 · 01/02/2022 17:31

The loneliest I ever felt was in a relationship and also when I was surrounded by people very different to me at University.

My grandmother happily plodded along when she was widowed and would see friends once a month - she had her dog for company.

I think people assume being alone equals loneliness but I have had various expierences.

I have had many friends and partners treat me poorly and really had no other choice to cut them off - I am very loyal to the end so their behaviour had escalted. Would I prefer to be alone with a glass of wine and my TV instead of their bullying and negging - Yes. Would I prefer to be with someone with good energy and kindness - Yes.

Creamegg84 · 01/02/2022 16:34

My nan used to complain of loneliness constantly. She saw my mum twice a week and myself. No one else towards the end as mobility problems but her main issue was that she was deaf, so she couldn't even have the TV or radio for company. She suffered like this for years and refused to move anywhere which many elderly do. Eventually she went into a residential home. She only lived a few months but she had a lovely few months there with company, entertainment, a Xmas party.
A family friends father was told he didn't have long left. He lived alone and was giving up. He moved into a residential where you have your own flat but downstairs there's a lounge, restaurant, shop, hairdressers etc and actives. He had a new lease of life and lived ten years there.
My other nan who is 92 is currently in the process of moving into the same place for the same reasons.
These are the things people need now and I hope more and more of them will be built. I think they are age 55 and up. I know that i become a widow or divorced that's where I will go. I need the company and it will help me feel safe aswell not having to maintain my own home.

Topseyt · 01/02/2022 15:37

@TillyTopper

I think your view is very unreasonable. I don't think it's that simple in real life OP. For example, my DMum is 94, honestly her whole family (apart from me and her brother) and all her friends have died. Her 1 brother emigrated to Australia in 70's. My DDad died 2 years ago. She is now disabled as well (due to old age).

How upbeat do you think she feels? How should she go out and make friends? I'm sure there are lots of parallel situations for many people that find themselves in this situation whether old or not.

This is exactly the problem for my mother. She was an only child though, so never had siblings. Apart from that, everything you have said applies to her too, and is why I think the OP and a few other posters on the thread are being too harsh. She really only has me and my sister now that my Dad has died.

Life can be very unfair sometimes.

JanisMoplin · 01/02/2022 15:15

Effect!

JanisMoplin · 01/02/2022 15:00

@DottyHarmer

I think what a lot of us would like is local friends - someone you can have a quick coffee with or go to a film/a class together.

I have some friends from various life stages, but I see them rarely as they live far away (including US) and although we exchange birthday/Xmas messages, to meet up would involve staying over which is for most people a step too far. In some ways I wish it were the 1950s and people would lean over their fences for a chat.

Dm in the 1970s had a “coffee morning circle” . I can’t imagine that today, at least not round here, and even mentioning it on MN will probably lead to angry pitchfork wielding.

I have had these quick coffee mornings in the past and hope to have them again when the pandemic effort wears off.
Gwenhwyfar · 01/02/2022 14:56

"someone you can have a quick coffee with or go to a film/a class together."

I have to say that this doesn't interest me much. A quick coffee is the kind of thing people with buy lives have, if you're lonely walking/bus 30 minutes for a one hour coffee is just not worth it. It might not even make a dent in the loneliness and your travel time could be more than the coffee time.
As for the cinema, I'm only interested if there's a drink before and after. When I've met up with people JUST to watch the film, I've really felt used. Where is the socialising? Am I there just so they don't have to look like billy no-mates in the cinema?
And a class, I would just go by myself.

Gwenhwyfar · 01/02/2022 14:54

There is another thread where a woman with too much gin in her house said she can't have a party because all her friends live so far away they'd need to stay over.
Obviously, if you move somewhere new you have to try and find friends where you live now. It didn't sound like she had even tried.

DottyHarmer · 01/02/2022 14:19

I think what a lot of us would like is local friends - someone you can have a quick coffee with or go to a film/a class together.

I have some friends from various life stages, but I see them rarely as they live far away (including US) and although we exchange birthday/Xmas messages, to meet up would involve staying over which is for most people a step too far. In some ways I wish it were the 1950s and people would lean over their fences for a chat.

Dm in the 1970s had a “coffee morning circle” . I can’t imagine that today, at least not round here, and even mentioning it on MN will probably lead to angry pitchfork wielding.

Gwenhwyfar · 01/02/2022 12:36

[quote Sunpotter]@Gwenhwyfar that's a good point, although as a shyer person I also think there's value in 'keeping my hand in' with social skills, I definitely notice a difference in my comfort level/awkwardness when I've been seeing people less so I guess I'm trying to fend that off too.

And it increases opportunities to meet more people who may become closer friends, and have things to talk about with them etc.[/quote]
Oh yes, I agree. I go out even when I'm tired or in a bad mood (suspect I wouldn't if I had a boyfriend), but I sometimes worry it's counterproductive. If I'm not feeling great I'm not going to enamour myself to people.

Sunpotter · 01/02/2022 12:28

@Gwenhwyfar that's a good point, although as a shyer person I also think there's value in 'keeping my hand in' with social skills, I definitely notice a difference in my comfort level/awkwardness when I've been seeing people less so I guess I'm trying to fend that off too.

And it increases opportunities to meet more people who may become closer friends, and have things to talk about with them etc.

Gwenhwyfar · 01/02/2022 12:19

@Sunpotter

I agree to an extent.

Obviously we can't control our entire circumstances, but as somebody in my mid-30s without extended family, I see preparing for a social network in older years as important as preparing financially.

Part of that is overcoming shyness/rejection fear by suggesting social things and agreeing to invites even when I'm a bit knackered. It's not at all easy but it is important.

Yes, but if you're 45 now, the friends you have now may not be available or local by the time you're 65.
Swipe left for the next trending thread