Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Violence from son involving husband ***Title edited by MNHQ on behalf of OP***

112 replies

Thehop · 31/01/2022 07:51

Good morning

We’ve been having a lot of physical trouble with my 11 year old lately. He’s a big lad. Wears medium size mens clothes. If I ask him to do anything he pins me to walls, punches me, calls me a bitch and a slag etc.

He did it again this morning and my husband broke him away from me. He was hitting my husband and spitting at him and my husband leaned his head towards him as he held his hands and shouted. It was very intimidating, designed to be so…..all we wanted him to do was pack his school bag and get his shoes on.

He’s lurched towards my husband and they’ve knocked heads.

My husband is devastated. Says he’s assaulted him and has rung the police to report this himself. I’m waiting to speak to my ex husband.

Does anyone know what will happen now please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Undecicive · 07/05/2022 11:40

I'm glad to hear your update OP, well done to you all and I hope things will keep improving.
It's reassuring to hear that his school is also helping to sort out the bullying.

Thehop · 07/05/2022 08:55

@Undecicive thank you for asking. I really didn’t think to update but actually things are much better! Not perfect, by any stretch, but hugely improved!

We got no support offered from social services (just an online course for me about calm parenting, which was useless) so we’ve paid for weekly counselling for him and come up with an activity we do outdoors, all together at some point each weekend away from screens. Even if it’s a wood walk, we have to do it regardless of the weather and it’s done us all good. We’re talking more, shouting less. We take turns choosing paid for/free stuff and have happily sacrificed takeaways to cover it.

we’ve tightened up rules/consequences at home. The internet gets turned off at the first sign of unreasonable behaviour until he’s talked to us and calmed down, which was something we should have brought in years ago. The boys Phones are blocked from 10pm-8am to make sure they’re getting a good chunk of sleep media free. They’re no longer given pocket money if bedrooms aren’t tidy. It sounds like small change but I’m certain looking after his space and being expected to function within the home more has all added to him feeling part of a unit. I can’t believe how simple some of these things were and what I let him behave like before, wrongly thinking I was being nice to him and he’d be happier!

he has opened up about some bullying and struggling with peer pressure at school and school have been very proactive. He has only had one detention this term (was getting 2/3 a week up to new year) and hasn’t hit me or my husband since. He said things are better at school and school are checking in with him regularly to keep on top of the group that was a problem.

not perfect, there’s still far more shouting and falling out with his brother than I’d like, but we’re a work in progress and making things better day by day.

thank you @KaraVanPark and @2018SoFarSoGreat for the hopeful responses. It’s really good to hear that some kids are shit at this age and become decent human adults! We’re a nice normal family. So average, and I really thought we’d sail through this stretch. Just goes to show it can happen and can get better. Thank you both.

OP posts:
2018SoFarSoGreat · 07/05/2022 00:10

@Thehop I only saw this thread today, and am so very sorry for what you are/were going through. When my DS was around this age, it was hell on wheels for all of us in the family. It did pass, eventually, and he is a wonderful young man today, and we are very proud of, and very close to him. It will most likely eventually pass, but for now please get all the help you can.

oakleaffy · 07/05/2022 00:05

That is appalling behaviour- And not by your husband!
Your son sounds like he needs urgent help.
Poor husband.

RedDiamond · 06/05/2022 22:57

@Hucklead - hold your horses!!! @Undecicive only asked for an update!

Zombie threads are when they are a year or too old, not a few months...

Hucklead · 06/05/2022 22:53

ZOMBIE!

Mariposista · 06/05/2022 22:01

Your poor husband. Of course he hasn't assaulted him. You need help OP, your son is over the age of criminal responsibility and if he treats a member of the public the way he treats you and his stepdad he will end up in a cell, no doubt about it. Big hug to you both

KaraVanPark · 06/05/2022 21:11

My eldest was aggressive, very angry, would hit door and it wasn’t until I changed their diet and cut out all E numbers artificial colours that they stopped be so angry. Google adverse effects of E numbers.
some people say it’s a myth but it worked of my dc and myself too

watchingrnfire · 06/05/2022 20:34

What did I just read!?? I'm shocked. Why is he allowed to behave like that with you, pinning you to the wall and punching you??? My god, if my son was to do that, I swear I'd hand him in to the authorities, there's no way I raised a child to treat me like that.

Have you sought help? This certainly is not normal behaviour, you should not put up with this, your husband was right to be intimidating towards him, kids like that need to be taught they can't get away with behaving in that manner.
He needs help, how will he towards other kids and when he's older and has a partner.

AllyCatTown · 06/05/2022 20:23

The police officer suggested a punch bag outside for red list angry moments so I’ve got that to investigate today

That’s terrible advice. I can’t believe the police advise that! They’ve done studies and punching out on punchbags etc just reinforces the idea that when you’re angry you use physical violence. It doesn’t decrease attacks on people.

SeenYourArse · 06/05/2022 20:11

Sounds to me very much like your husband knew he wouldn’t be able to stay in the house if he rang the police and told them some nonsense so he’s given himself a path out!

Chonfox · 06/05/2022 20:07

Why's it happening though? If this is a complete change in behaviour then presumably there's a root cause? Do you have any idea what could have caused it? Could he be angry at his dads lack of involvement now he's getting older and becoming more aware? Or if you're honest was it simply that he was easier to manage when younger?

I'm trying to temper my response as I know it's not particularly helpful if you're not the type, but I would retaliate so hard if an 11 year old boy did this to me. Physically hard. He absolutely shouldn't get away with being violent towards women. Especially his own mother! It doesn't bode well for his future at all, or that of future partners. I personally admire your husband's restraint...

It's good you're seeking help. If it doesn't improve send him to his dads.

Pinkpigs · 06/05/2022 19:35

Gosh I hope you are ok start to record the out burst he has or just have him removed from your home

Undecicive · 06/05/2022 19:23

OP, did you get any help for yourselves? How are things now?

NameGoesHere · 02/02/2022 06:04

You need to see a doctor about your son pronto.

Aussiegirl123456 · 02/02/2022 05:18

I can only imagine how difficult this is for you. I hope you manage to get to the bottom of what is happening with your son. Hand hold xx

wombat1a · 02/02/2022 04:15

I think your Dh has done the right thing, he has been assaulted by your DS while trying to protect you. Your DS needs to be arrested and if the CPS find there is cause charged with assault and battery.

This may get your DS the help he needs but being upset that your DH has to report your son for assaulting both you and him is BU.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 02/02/2022 02:55

I agree, a good update.

Now you need to find some further support for your son before this escalates any further - he clearly needs it, whether it's in school or out of school, SOMETHING is going on and he needs to find other ways to channel his frustrations and anger.

I wouldn't force him to go and stay at his dad's - I think that would only make things worse in terms of how he's feeling - but I would definitely seek professional advice for him.

I'm in Australia and currently they're being exceptionally good at picking up on secondary students' mental health and wellbeing - but the UK might still be utter shite at it, not sure, probably area dependent. I would have a talk with both your GP and your DS's school though, see what you can glean from them, if your son won't talk to you directly. Show him that you love and support him but you can NOT have that behaviour continuing in your home because it's absolutely inappropriate, verging on criminal.

I wish you luck getting to the bottom of what's happening with him Thanks

Mumdiva99 · 31/01/2022 11:27

Good luck going forward.

KurtWilde · 31/01/2022 10:45

Great update, OP. In hindsight mentioning you're a childminder might not have been the best policy as you'll get people wading in about that and clouding the real reason you posted. Please don't let them get to you, you've handled it well today, you've spoken to your clients, and there's nothing more you can do on that score.

SolasAnla · 31/01/2022 10:41

Sorry OP but your attitude to the violence from your son is 100% wrong.

You have other children to whom he is being violent towards. The abuse of their toys is a proxy for abusing the younger children directly.

He is being physically and verbally abusive to you in their presence.

Your husband had to use physically restraint on your son as he was abusing you. Your son felt safe enough with your husband to physically challenge his restraint.

As a result of all this you think your husband needs to move out so that you can continue to be a childminder.
Yet you see no problem with having the son who instigated the violence remain with your home with the other children and with the children you are being paid to safeguard.

You need to look for help in setting boundaries for yourself before you will be able to deal with your sons issues.

TheFrogAndHen · 31/01/2022 10:39

That's a good update OP.

Thehop · 31/01/2022 10:36

Thank you all.

Just to be clear, I’ve spoken to OFSTED this morning and advised them of the police visit. I’ve also send a blanket message out to parents advising them I’ve had a police visit this morning with regard to my sons violence towards me and now his stepdad and thy we were seeking support from the MASH team. He never sees minded children in the morning as leaves before them. There are only 2 days a week he’s back in time to Liz due to after school routines and clubs. The 2 families he does cross over with I’ve emailed and asked for a chat to get them up to speed and offer either a change of days, not holding them to their notice period if they want to move, or my real assessment strategies for keeping minded children and my own separate. (This is quite easy to do here thanks to the set up of the house and me finishing at 6pm) I’m being completely open with parents. This is very difficult for me as I pride myself in a very calm, peaceful ethos. We are very much a curiosity/outdoor setting where we talk much about feelings and how we affect others and being a positive member of society. To have it go so awry with my own is heartbreaking. Personally and professionally. I’m hoping seeing me be completely honest about needing guidance and support will be healthy for my family and my customers, and that they see me putting more importance on safeguarding than on maintaining appearances.

I have never minded him going to live with my ex, he’s always hated the idea. The boys see their dad when their dad instigates it and had, literally, 2 nights there last year. He doesn’t know them well so it hasn’t happened but we’ve never needed court to sort contact, we’ve always said the boys can go where they want when they want in terms of houses. Of he wants to go stay with or live with his dad for a while that might be good for him and I’ll support it.

I’m absolutely supporting my husband, I really am sorry about the thread title. I’m conscious that I don’t want to appear to cover anything up and be transparent and wasn’t thinking very straight when I posted I don’t think.

I’m 100% certain that police man’s judgement is correct and this wasn’t my husband assaulting my son. I’m also in full agreement that we need outside influence to make change.

OP posts:
HullP · 31/01/2022 10:36

@Hotchox

If this hasn't been said already, I'm surprised the parents of the kids who come to your house aren't supposed to be informed of a violent incident with police involvement at the place they leave their little kids. Regardless of who head-butted who (which you can't even seem to make your mind up over) - no one in their right mind would want their kids in a place where that goes on, and they should be informed. If you've not done this, then for that alone YABU
I've NC for this in case anyone else on here knows the person it was quite big at the time around my area.

But I would think you do absolutely have to inform parents of something like this. Especially if it's an ongoing issue with the son.

I had a friend who was a childminder. Her son had been taking drugs on a night out with his girlfriend and she sadly ended up dying when they got back to my friends house. Obviously there was police involvement and they found some drugs in his room. She was no longer able to be a childminder after that. She wasn't even minding at the time and she wasn't taking anything, but because it was in her home that's what happened.

I agree OP should be required to inform parents of this. It's difficult for OP as it would likely affect her work but the children's safety should be absolutely paramount.

Gizacluethen · 31/01/2022 10:34

Your son needs to go live with his dad. You're clearly not dealing with this if he had you pinned up against a wall hitting you. Change his school and send him to his dad and even get him into a counsellor/psychiatrist.

And I'd be fucking fuming if you were my childs childminder and I didn't know you were being assaulted by someone you're allowing near my child. Your husband is moving out because your son headbutted him but sure a medium sized male is romping about the house kicking toys and hitting their childminder. I think you're in big trouble if that comes to light.

Swipe left for the next trending thread