Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he did not deserve a jail sentence

63 replies

meadowandpetals · 30/01/2022 18:39

I know this story is many years old but I recently came across it. AIBU to think a prison sentence was too harsh of a punishment for what he did? What he did was wrong and he should have been punished in some way in my opinion but I don’t think he should have jailed. However that is just my opinion. Would love to hear others take on this.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-16288257.amp

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AuntViv · 31/01/2022 20:29

Oh dear, when I was 19 I was selected for jury service. I was such an immature 19 year old, I remember crying to my dad that i didn't want to do it.

I was in one trial and it clashed with a gig I wanted to go to. I basically told the judge that I had a dentist appointment so I could leave an hour early. I thought I could slip out, and it would carry on without me and that is just catch up the next day. I mean what a twat I was !
The judge made me explain why I had arranged a dental appointment during court and luckily a fellow judge stood up for me about how hard it is to get dentist appointments for me as a student.
I was mortified when everyone had to leave early with me Blush

Honestly now with the benefit of maturity I know I was a complete idiot

NewPapaGuinea · 31/01/2022 05:42

I did jury duty a few years ago. Turned up on Wednesday and was sent home as the judge was playing golf. Whether or not that was his prearranged day off we all had wasted our time travelling in. Some from 20 mile away 🤷‍♂️

Longdistance · 31/01/2022 05:30

He got off lightly with two weeks. Bloody idiot!

user313213521 · 31/01/2022 04:56

@gabsdot45

Very disrespctful to the court and the other jurors. My brother was on a jury last summer and it took over his entire summer. He had to cancel his holidays because of it. And the case ended up being thrown out in the end.
It's stories like that which remind everyone why anyone who can get out of jury service does get out of jury service.

There's no guarantee travel insurance would pay out for something like this, especially for the other members of the family meant to be going on holiday.

As a self employed person, the thought of being called up for jury service is the stuff of nightmares, especially when it could knock out an entire peak season and so destroy my income for a whole year.

Graphista · 31/01/2022 04:31

I'd rather prison spaces were reserved for violent offenders

BUT this is a serious matter, I'd have hit him with a HUGE fine and community service of a creative sentencing type - like having to sit in on jury selections for 6 months or depending on his skills/qualifications doing some court work

malificent7 · 31/01/2022 04:25

Slight derailment but why do the jury

( bunch of random with no legal experience) get to decide the fate of a defendant? Lack of bias?

malificent7 · 31/01/2022 04:22

Why do they not have jury back up ( like a reserve,) plus a big fine in event of this happening?

Flutterflybutterby · 31/01/2022 03:19

I wouldn't do jury duty, and I think it's outrageous that they force unwilling people to.

Namenic · 31/01/2022 00:55

Disproportionate compared to violent and sexual crime.

DerAlteMann · 31/01/2022 00:55

He got off lightly IMO.

Whatinthelord · 31/01/2022 00:38

@sadpapercourtesan

I don't think he should be in prison, but I think we need a complete rethink of the way we use imprisonment. I would like to see custodial sentences used only for people who need to be segregated from the general public because they pose an ongoing risk to others.
I agree with this.

I think a 2 week prison sentence for this seems not only pointless, but ridiculous, because it only wastes even more of the tax payers money. I think a large fine or community sentence would have been much more appropriate.

I totally agree what he did was shitty and needed consequences, but there’s nothing to suggest that he poses any risk to others to justify being jailed and we know that time in custody is not even particularly effective at preventing future offending!

I agree with others that compared to other crimes where people manage to receive no jail time ( things like have CSA images) it just doesn’t make sense.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 30/01/2022 23:33

@meadowandpetals

I understand what he did was a very serious matter but when you hear of people violently attacking others and not going to prison it makes you feel it’s not fair that those people did not locked up when I think they should have.
He got 14 days. Yes it was fair.

I wonder how he's doing now, ten years later?

LovedayCL · 30/01/2022 23:32

@meadowandpetals

I understand what he did was a very serious matter but when you hear of people violently attacking others and not going to prison it makes you feel it’s not fair that those people did not locked up when I think they should have.
Yes, he probably could driven to court, with no license, in a car that he stole, over the limit. For the third time. And not got a prison sentence. But in this case he personal affronted a judge which is much worse than those other things.
Blinky21 · 30/01/2022 23:27

@sadpapercourtesan exactly! Recidivism rates for those who get custodial sentences have long been much higher than those who get non custodial sentences and there is much evidence that short prison sentences don't work as they don't offer enough time to rehabilitate an offender. Custodial sentences should be reserved for only the very worst offenders in my view

Blinky21 · 30/01/2022 23:22

Seems harsh, I used to regularly work in courts and 99 per cent of the time contempt is overlooked. Prison in this case is a waste of taxpayers money, they should have just fined him

AKASammyScrounge · 30/01/2022 23:22

@lonelyapple

Yes, ridiculous! People get away with no jail time for far more serious things.
What serious things?
Greenfields124 · 30/01/2022 23:14

"Disrespect a posh white man (judge), you’re going to jail, beat a woman- very likely you’ll never be arrested never mind sent to jail.

What a world…"

Totally agree.

TrashyPanda · 30/01/2022 23:12

He is a part.
When I was called for jury service, on the first day we were told to see the clerk of court if we had any existing arrangements/responsibilities.

I had just got a new puppy (as in he was 12 weeks old, so couldn’t be left all day). I told him this and was immediately excused.

So why didn’t this numpty speak up?

Greenfields124 · 30/01/2022 23:11

Totally ridiculous!
Especially comparing it to a documentary I have just watched on stalking, where they let perpetrators get away with it over and over again. Awful.
Our justice system is useless.🤦🏼‍♀️

NoJaffaCakesAreKeptInThisVan · 30/01/2022 23:07

Well he shouldn’t have skipped jury duty but most likely had pre-booked tickets for Chicago…can you get compensation for issuing pre-booked shows, holidays etc?

user1471447863 · 30/01/2022 23:07

@CounsellorTroi 100% this. This is why forcing people to do jury service is stupid. Many do not want to be there. The whole system needs modernised

DePfeffoff · 30/01/2022 23:04

The criminal justice system is in chaos with cases taking ludicrously long to come to trial. It doesn't need to be made even worse with jurors wasting court time in this way. If this happened now, I suspect it would be treated with just as much seriousness.

blyn72 · 30/01/2022 22:58

Poor kid, a custodial sentence does seem OTT and will hardly do any good. It may do him some harm, a lot can happen within a fortnight.

I think a fine would have been more appropriate for someone of his age. It's a pity he was found out.

Bazinga007 · 30/01/2022 22:46

He should have got longer and made to pay for the cost of delaying the trail.

CounsellorTroi · 30/01/2022 22:45

It looks like he was too immature to be doing jury service in the first place.

Swipe left for the next trending thread