Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think Spotify should continue to host Joe Rogan's podcast?

317 replies

lonelyapple · 30/01/2022 17:34

Quite a few singers (Neil Young, Joni Mitchell, Nils Lofgren to name a few) have said they want to have their music removed from Spotify as a protest against Spotify hosting Joe Rogan's podcast (they think he is spreading covid vaccine misinformation), so Spotify will have to choose between hosting their music or Joe Rogan's podcast.

I personally think this is ridiculous as Joe Rogan talks to a range of people about a range of different subjects and his podcasts are interesting and popular and people can always choose not to listen to them and even if they do, it doesn't mean they believe everything being said. I don't think Spotify should cave to such threats and I think this would set a dangerous precedent.

www.ft.com/content/a9fdaf0d-8d46-4a16-881f-a1b0635d3ce3

YANBU - Spotify should keep Joe Rogan's podcast.
YABU - Spotify should not keep Joe Rogan's podcast.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
FluffyBooBoo · 31/01/2022 07:40

@UnicornsReal

It’s cancel culture gone mad. Free speech is very important. There are plenty of very dubious lyrics in many songs. Are they all to be banned too? Michael Jacksons music is on Spotify despite him having been a paedophile . That’s much worse in my opinion.
What was cancelled?
UnicornsReal · 31/01/2022 07:37

It’s cancel culture gone mad. Free speech is very important. There are plenty of very dubious lyrics in many songs. Are they all to be banned too? Michael Jacksons music is on Spotify despite him having been a paedophile . That’s much worse in my opinion.

1dayatatime · 31/01/2022 07:35

@Crikeyalmighty

"I work in music. I don’t think it’s a deal Spotify should have done . I certainly think given the health situation that anyone spouting anti vax shouldn’t be Given the money and airtime to do "

+++++

Could you elaborate further and explain who said exactly what - that is ant I vaxx and why this means that someone should therefore have their contact with Spotify pulled.

Or are you simply dismissing it as "spouting anti vaxx" on a podcast you have never listened to - simply because someone somewhere told you he was ant vaxx.

This thought process is truly scary and can you see how it is frighteningly like the medieval witch hunts or trials or the Stalinist purges or the Maoist cultural revolution.

FluffyBooBoo · 31/01/2022 07:33

@lljkk

Trump supporters are all over the idea that DT has been unfairly censored, and even his critics have said it's a difficult call. DT repeatedly violated Twitter policies for years but the crunch point was when he encouraged overthrow of the US government & violating the US Constitution. Not just encouraging overthrow, but violent overthrow.

Hopkins has defenders, too. I don't follow the KH situation so much but I think she's made a lot of downright hateful statements -- hatemongering is against most platform policies.

Obviously they both have people in support of them.

But here, on Mumsnet, I don't remember anyone getting this het up about censorship on either of those occasions. You know, when people actually did lose their 'platform'.

FluffyBooBoo · 31/01/2022 07:31

If the consequence of free speech is that you lose your livelihood, then you effectively don't have free speech

Do you think so? So you think businesses should be forced to keep paying someone that is bringing their business into disrepute in the name of free speech? Which may well lead to the business going under and everyone losing their livelihood?

lljkk · 31/01/2022 07:28

Trump supporters are all over the idea that DT has been unfairly censored, and even his critics have said it's a difficult call. DT repeatedly violated Twitter policies for years but the crunch point was when he encouraged overthrow of the US government & violating the US Constitution. Not just encouraging overthrow, but violent overthrow.

Hopkins has defenders, too. I don't follow the KH situation so much but I think she's made a lot of downright hateful statements -- hatemongering is against most platform policies.

Countrydiary · 31/01/2022 07:28

I think the issue isn’t that Spotify is hosting the podcast, it’s that they are paying Rogan to make the podcast/for exclusive access. For me, there’s a big difference in allowing all the different voices to be heard on Spotify (definitely a freedom of speech issue) to actively supporting certain voices. Spotify are essentially publishers of vaccine misinformation by paying Rogan.

Aderyn21 · 31/01/2022 07:24

Personally I define freedom as being able to say/do whatever you like up to the point where it begins to inhibit another person's freedom to go about their lawful business.

So Joe Rogan's podcast (or any anti vax opinion) doesn't inhibit anyone else from going ahead and getting vaccinated. You might argue that in not vaccinating, those people put others at risk but as a society we only are obliged to have vaccinations of there's a direct benefit to the individuals having it - that it protects society via herd immunisation is a nice side effect but not the main reason.

Of course other artists also have the freedom to remove their content from Spotify. The market will decide whose work is most valued by the consumer and Spotify will likely respond accordingly.

If the consequence of free speech is that you lose your livelihood, then you effectively don't have free speech. I think it's essential to protect that freedom because who wants to live in a country where only sanctioned opinions are allowed?

FluffyBooBoo · 31/01/2022 07:10

Do people see Trump being booted off Twitter as censorship? Or Katie Hopkins column being stopped?

Because I don't remember people on here being this up in arms about those things that actually happened...

MissTrip82 · 31/01/2022 06:27

There are no free speech issues raised by the reality that commercial enterprise can offer one a platform or not as they see fit. Joe Rogan is no more entitled to a platform than I am.

There is also no such thing as ‘cancel culture’, it’s simply that some people who previously spoke without thought and without consequence now experience reality like the rest of us.

Of greater concern to me than people peddling nonsense about the vaccine is what has happened to the education system that generations who have enjoyed compulsory education far beyond of that of previous generations remain so ignorant and lacking in ability to reason.

Lilifer · 31/01/2022 00:37

[quote Buwch]@Lilifer

Back in Sept 2020, the chief of the CDC and Trump has a public disagreement about the vaccine rollout.

The CDC said they were hopeful it would be ready in November or December, but there would only be a limited number available to start (so the most vulnerable would be prioritized).

Trump, disagreeing with the CDC, said it would be ready in mid October and 100 million doses would be distributed to Americans by the end of the year. He said the chief of the CDC was mistaken.

In light of the disagreement between Trump and his own government’s scientists, Trump’s opponents said they would not trust Trump’s word alone on the safety and efficacy of the vaccines; they would take any unless they were approved by the CDC or other, qualified experts.

FWIW, the vaccine rollout did no start until December. About 5m doses were given by the end of the year (about a 20th of the amount Trump claimed).[/quote]
I see, thanks for that it makes more sense now in that context 👍🏻

DreamTheMoors · 31/01/2022 00:27

@heronsinflight

There is a back story here. Many musicians were already deeply unhappy about the absolute pittance that Spotify pays in royalties. They then diverted $100m from their inadequate royalty budget to sign Joe Rogan to an exclusive deal. That was widely seen as a massive kick in the teeth and a lot of musicians remain very bitter about it.
Exactly.

Because Spotify isn’t a music-platform.
It’s a money-making-platform.

They’re always gonna do what’s best for their bank account. Joe Rogan is better right now.

* I will note that over 120 scientists & doctors wrote to Spotify & complained about the dangerous misinformation on Rogan’s show - that it alarmed them. Evidently, it alarmed others too. I don’t listen to Rogan, so I’ve no idea what he says, except that he pushes unfounded Covid cures like hydroxychloroquine, etc. Many, many people consider him an “expert,” although he’s a pundit, and a provocateur - nothing more.

tttigress · 31/01/2022 00:27

Isn't the main winner from this whole thing Joe Rogan?

He has been getting free advertising for weeks. I know many here would refuse to listen, but I think even more would be curious as to the content, and then become fans when the realised what he is saying isn't as black and white, as the media are making it out to be.

Somerford · 31/01/2022 00:18

@Pumperthepumper

I think it's quite disturbing that there's a mass campaign to get someone to lose his job based on a series of rumours rather than anything he's actually said, yes. Would you be ok with that?

That’s not what’s happening though - the interview is still on Apple Podcasts and YouTube. What’s happening is a private company deciding they can’t be arsed with the grief, as is their right. He can make his own hosting site with his own audience. It’ll just cost him a lot of money.

I think Neil Young might be a bit long in the tooth to set about creating his own hosting site regardless of the cost. Joe Rogan can crack on with his podcast though, which a private company is clearly happy to go on hosting.
sweetieqie · 31/01/2022 00:14

*I define censorship as a world-wide blanket ban on opinion. Interestingly, Joe Rogan’s interview is still on Apple Podcasts and YouTube.
*
I haven't watched rogan's stuff so can't comment much but:

•'Worldwide' is a high threshold for censorship
•right now, his stuff is still available. But if all of them got rid of him, and he had no platform to be accessed, I'd say that is censorship even though they all are private tech companies. It's not the same as hate speech, actual misinformation etc. People think any criticism or anecdote towards the COVID vaccine is a conspiracy, which is a bit far.

Buwch · 30/01/2022 23:52

@Lilifer

Back in Sept 2020, the chief of the CDC and Trump has a public disagreement about the vaccine rollout.

The CDC said they were hopeful it would be ready in November or December, but there would only be a limited number available to start (so the most vulnerable would be prioritized).

Trump, disagreeing with the CDC, said it would be ready in mid October and 100 million doses would be distributed to Americans by the end of the year. He said the chief of the CDC was mistaken.

In light of the disagreement between Trump and his own government’s scientists, Trump’s opponents said they would not trust Trump’s word alone on the safety and efficacy of the vaccines; they would take any unless they were approved by the CDC or other, qualified experts.

FWIW, the vaccine rollout did no start until December. About 5m doses were given by the end of the year (about a 20th of the amount Trump claimed).

SuperWoofing · 30/01/2022 23:52

[quote Pumperthepumper]@SuperWoofing you’re looking a bit desperate for a fight here. I could just as easily say ‘you’re saying anyone can do absolutely anything and still keep their job, better hope some mad racist misogynist doesn’t come for you!’

Spotify don’t have to host anyone they don’t want to. Neither does mumsnet - this post would be deleted if I broke their talk guidelines. That’s because private companies can choose who they host.[/quote]
Ok, and they have decided to host Joe Rogan and not host Neil Young. I imagine you think you're making some kind of insightful arguments but you actually aren't. I have to go to bed so I will leave you to your pointless ramblings about people being racist in Tesco

AKASammyScrounge · 30/01/2022 23:43

There's far too much cancelling and censoring these days. And it's done by virtue signalling celebs or
pathetic pipsqueaks exercising anonymous power from behind a computer screen.

I, and most other people, don't need a pipsqueak or a pop star to direct our thinking and draw conclusions for us.
I also dislike the current trend for 'blackmailing' companies to obey random critics.

Viviennemary · 30/01/2022 23:40

I wish spotify would just close down altogether. Cant see the point of it tbh.

LondonWolf · 30/01/2022 23:38

Biden, Harris et al said they wouldn't take it if it was recommended by Trump alone.

Isn't it a good thing that they were allowed to say this and discuss their reservations without being condemned for "anti vaxx" rhetoric and threatened with being removed from their jobs? Smile

Lilifer · 30/01/2022 23:38

@Buwch

biden kamala and others all said they wouldn't take it, no good tying to gild the lily You are lying.
Any links on this please? Have not heard this before. In fairness a lot of folk were wary of the vaccine at first because it emerged so soon in to the pandemic but if this is true it makes the pair of them look damn silly
Pumperthepumper · 30/01/2022 23:37

@SuperWoofing you’re looking a bit desperate for a fight here. I could just as easily say ‘you’re saying anyone can do absolutely anything and still keep their job, better hope some mad racist misogynist doesn’t come for you!’

Spotify don’t have to host anyone they don’t want to. Neither does mumsnet - this post would be deleted if I broke their talk guidelines. That’s because private companies can choose who they host.

SuperWoofing · 30/01/2022 23:34

@Pumperthepumper

Are you talking about Spotify not wanting the crap of dealing with Neil Young? Anyway, you don't seem to be a fan of freedom of speech so I'm not sure there's much to be said really. You'd better just hope the mob never comes for you.

Regardless, they can do what they like. You don’t seem to understand what ‘freedom of speech’ means, despite it being pointed out to you so many times.

Ok, so you're happy for someone to be censored for something they've never said, you're happy for someone to be subjected to a campaign for them to lose their job based on rumours and lies. That seems to be it really. Like I said, just hope that the mob never comes for you.
Lilifer · 30/01/2022 23:33

@Pumperthepumper my understanding of censorship is not that far off from yours except that I would not say that it has to be world wide, for eg individual countries may practice censorship according to their own political systems. I would say though that attempting to pressurise Spotify to shut down discussions on vaccines amounts to asking them to censor those discussions and I think that is wrong. I am glad that Spotify seems to agree with me.

rubicscubicle · 30/01/2022 23:32

I don't listen to him.

Just once heard him sprout some nonsense about black people and coming from the darkest part of the world.

But here is what was reported a few weeks ago.

www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/jan/14/spotify-joe-rogan-podcast-open-letter

As for Trump, don't some of his cures for Covid, involved like.............bleach. 😂😂

Do you think Spotify should continue to host Joe Rogan's podcast?
Do you think Spotify should continue to host Joe Rogan's podcast?