Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think Spotify should continue to host Joe Rogan's podcast?

317 replies

lonelyapple · 30/01/2022 17:34

Quite a few singers (Neil Young, Joni Mitchell, Nils Lofgren to name a few) have said they want to have their music removed from Spotify as a protest against Spotify hosting Joe Rogan's podcast (they think he is spreading covid vaccine misinformation), so Spotify will have to choose between hosting their music or Joe Rogan's podcast.

I personally think this is ridiculous as Joe Rogan talks to a range of people about a range of different subjects and his podcasts are interesting and popular and people can always choose not to listen to them and even if they do, it doesn't mean they believe everything being said. I don't think Spotify should cave to such threats and I think this would set a dangerous precedent.

www.ft.com/content/a9fdaf0d-8d46-4a16-881f-a1b0635d3ce3

YANBU - Spotify should keep Joe Rogan's podcast.
YABU - Spotify should not keep Joe Rogan's podcast.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
1dayatatime · 31/01/2022 10:44

@MidCenturyClegs

I think everyone has a right to air their views. Most intelligent people will read and listen to a variety of opinions before informing their own.
True but for many people listening to different opinions, then critically evaluating them in order to form your own opinion takes time and head space they don't have or don't want to do.

It is far easier to accept the "one acceptable and established truth" and shout down anyone exploring or even mentioning alternative views as "spouting ant vaxx misinformation".

LondonWolf · 31/01/2022 10:36

This assertion that private companies can do what they like, surely raises the question of just how much power these private companies now hold, with unelected, unregulated people getting to decide who speaks and when - even POTUS. It would take a very honourable person indeed not to nudge things nicely along their own personal political path in my opinion. Personally I find it terrifying but others seem not to mind at all - they're right here on this thread asserting that there's no such thing as cancel culture and it's totally fine to just shut people down when they say things you don't like.

MidCenturyClegs · 31/01/2022 10:33

I think everyone has a right to air their views. Most intelligent people will read and listen to a variety of opinions before informing their own.

Lolamento · 31/01/2022 10:24

Funny this but they do not take down tick tok lefties and crazy people influencing young teenagers into abomination.

Sunnysidegold · 31/01/2022 10:07

I don't know this podcast but think it's important to have free speech. If you ban Rogan for this then where does it stop? Surely they could put some sort of disclaimer on the start of the episode?

bluebeach · 31/01/2022 10:05

Joe rogan should not be de platformed. We always need to hear both sides of a story. I want to hear about all the scientific studies not just the ones that back up a narrative that’s been decided already. Things change and are newly discovered all the time. By the way, I’m vaccinated but I believe in freedom of speech and the autonomy to be able to decide freely what we put in our bodies.

Barrawarra · 31/01/2022 09:55

Absolutely Aderyn, since most people will at least know someone who’s had minor negative side affects such as menstrual impacts, up to more serious issues like heart or neurological issues, and feeling that questions about that are mocked and minimised is a sure way to encourage distrust.

Aderyn21 · 31/01/2022 09:49

Shut down obvs 😆

Aderyn21 · 31/01/2022 09:49

If you shit down any discussion that isn't 100% positive about vaccination, then I think you actually increase vaccine hesitancy, since people then don't trust the information and feel the truth is being hidden.

Barrawarra · 31/01/2022 09:43

I think a lot rests on what was actually said, and the likelihood of harm that it could cause, which in this case is likely highly contested. I don’t think booting trump off Twitter for trying to incite people to overthrow the govt (I didn’t read the tweets so again I cannot be confident that’s exactly what was said, but from other evidence it’s certainly his style).

In the case of ‘antivax’ information, my understanding of often what is actually said is not that no one should get vaccines, but is a critical look at vaccine injury, efficacy, and cost benefit analysis of whether vaccines are a good idea for young and healthy people. There are of course the ‘world is run by lizards’ people who think vaccines have microchips in, but I think we are all robust enough to cope with the knowledge that some people believe that, without being compelled to join in? To me it is very troubling not to be able to share and discuss data that suggests there can be issues with vaccines and govt strategy around them.

FluffyBooBoo · 31/01/2022 09:17

@LondonWolf

I find it interesting that a newspaper sacking a columnist is considered censorship. No paper owes any individual a platform for their views

I would argue that if you set yourself up as a disseminator of "news" then you have a duty to present all sides not just the ones you personally agree with.

a) that still doesn't mean any individual has a right to be shown in print. b) the kind of places that would hire Katie Hopkins in the first place are not going to be giving much space to left wing viewpoints. Sacking her isn't going to change that.
LondonWolf · 31/01/2022 09:09

I find it interesting that a newspaper sacking a columnist is considered censorship. No paper owes any individual a platform for their views

I would argue that if you set yourself up as a disseminator of "news" then you have a duty to present all sides not just the ones you personally agree with.

UnicornsReal · 31/01/2022 09:04

@Aderyn21

Personally I define freedom as being able to say/do whatever you like up to the point where it begins to inhibit another person's freedom to go about their lawful business.

So Joe Rogan's podcast (or any anti vax opinion) doesn't inhibit anyone else from going ahead and getting vaccinated. You might argue that in not vaccinating, those people put others at risk but as a society we only are obliged to have vaccinations of there's a direct benefit to the individuals having it - that it protects society via herd immunisation is a nice side effect but not the main reason.

Of course other artists also have the freedom to remove their content from Spotify. The market will decide whose work is most valued by the consumer and Spotify will likely respond accordingly.

If the consequence of free speech is that you lose your livelihood, then you effectively don't have free speech. I think it's essential to protect that freedom because who wants to live in a country where only sanctioned opinions are allowed?

Yes, exactly.
DGRossetti · 31/01/2022 09:00

[quote EmmaH2022]How cheesy is this 😂
Reminds me of being a kid

[/quote] For some reason, reading that reminded me of FRANKIE SAYS ! from the (earlier Smile) 80s.

(Ask your grand parents)

Lilifer · 31/01/2022 08:49

"There is also no such thing as ‘cancel culture’, it’s simply that some people who previously spoke without thought and without consequence now experience reality like the rest of us. "

Tell that to Kathleen Stock
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-59084446 and JK Rowling

Aderyn21 · 31/01/2022 08:46

I think what I'm getting at Fluffy is that no one gets her up when horrible people lose their platform for spouting horrible things, but this has a knock on effect and it's really easy to find yourself on the wrong end of 'acceptable'. My kids think I'm awful because I'm not wholly in favour of treating trans people as their preferred sex, without any checks and balances, for example. People have been vilified for not holding the current 'acceptable' view.
In order to have free speech we have to accept hearing views we don't like and accepting that people have a right to hold those views, even when they are personally abhorrent to us.
Once a person's ability to keep their job is threatened, because they hold an unpopular pov, then there's no free speech and we are all just pretending to have freedom.

This whole Spotify thing is a few celebs throwing their toys out of the pram because they've been told no!

Things are getting very divisive in society - it's think how I think or else! We've seen it with Brexit, with women's rights and now with vaccinations.

I'd also rather live in a world where I know what people are really thinking, hiding opinions doesn't make them go away and I'd rather know who I was talk to in life.

FluffyBooBoo · 31/01/2022 08:27

Oh, I see you have completely misconstrued what I said. I clearly wasn't talking about JR in that comment. I was talking generally about an assertion that suggested that you don't have free speech if it loses you your livelihood.

I was just wondering how that works in reality.

JustMakingDreams · 31/01/2022 08:24

why not

FluffyBooBoo · 31/01/2022 08:24

Fluffy Spotify aren't being forced to pay JR - it's financially beneficial for them which is why they do it

I don't know where I suggested that they were.

Empressofthemundane · 31/01/2022 08:14

I agree @Aderyn21

Aderyn21 · 31/01/2022 08:14

Fluffy Spotify aren't being forced to pay JR - it's financially beneficial for them which is why they do it.

I don't believe employers should have any right to ask employees not to express their personal opinions on the employees own social media. Or to ask employees to publicly endorse views which run counter to the employees own opinion, so long as the employees aren't refusing to do their job. Employers should imo have a right to not allow employees to use work facilities to promote their views though.
Too many people are forced out of their work by having opinions which run counter to the 'mainstream' (which might not actually be mainstream, just very loud) and this has to stop (thinking of those who publicly support Rowling).

FluffyBooBoo · 31/01/2022 07:53

Yes I do. But MN is very much a hive mind when it comes to conservative views and politics so it's not surprising that no one had much to say about it on this platform

I find it interesting that a newspaper sacking a columnist is considered censorship. No paper owes any individual a platform for their views.

FluffyBooBoo · 31/01/2022 07:47

@UnicornsReal

The whole point of this thread is that Joe Rogan’s views are being cancelled. He’s being forced off Spotify. What did you think this thread was about?
His views aren't being cancelled. Neil Young have Spotify a choice, and they choose JR. Neil Young's music has been taken down (which was his choice).
LondonWolf · 31/01/2022 07:44

@FluffyBooBoo

Do people see Trump being booted off Twitter as censorship? Or Katie Hopkins column being stopped?

Because I don't remember people on here being this up in arms about those things that actually happened...

Yes I do. But MN is very much a hive mind when it comes to conservative views and politics so it's not surprising that no one had much to say about it on this platform.
UnicornsReal · 31/01/2022 07:43

The whole point of this thread is that Joe Rogan’s
views are being cancelled. He’s being forced off Spotify. What did you think this thread was about?