Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think Spotify should continue to host Joe Rogan's podcast?

317 replies

lonelyapple · 30/01/2022 17:34

Quite a few singers (Neil Young, Joni Mitchell, Nils Lofgren to name a few) have said they want to have their music removed from Spotify as a protest against Spotify hosting Joe Rogan's podcast (they think he is spreading covid vaccine misinformation), so Spotify will have to choose between hosting their music or Joe Rogan's podcast.

I personally think this is ridiculous as Joe Rogan talks to a range of people about a range of different subjects and his podcasts are interesting and popular and people can always choose not to listen to them and even if they do, it doesn't mean they believe everything being said. I don't think Spotify should cave to such threats and I think this would set a dangerous precedent.

www.ft.com/content/a9fdaf0d-8d46-4a16-881f-a1b0635d3ce3

YANBU - Spotify should keep Joe Rogan's podcast.
YABU - Spotify should not keep Joe Rogan's podcast.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Cornettoninja · 30/01/2022 19:33

@LondonWolf

I saw a video of one of his podcasts and a colleague called him out very clearly on the fact he knows nothing just like everyone else and his stance is motivated by fear. He looked like a schoolboy.

He says this himself though. Constantly. That he doesn't know much but likes finding things out and talking about stuff. I find him to be likeable, if somewhat boring when he starts talking about weed and his diet of elk meat Hmm

Fair enough, I wouldn’t know, I don’t listen to him. I quite like a good conspiracy but I don’t find him entertaining in the slightest and my opinion of him has taken a nosedive since he seems to have no concept of the responsibility of popularity.

I do find it strange that he could be clearly telling people he knows fuck all and still wield clout. Idiocracy was bang on the money.

1Week · 30/01/2022 19:33

No, we are definitely going down a dangerous road.

I never thought I'd see the day when it was all the left leaning people advocating for suppression of speech, more deference to government and defending the rights of massive corporations.

HoliHormonalTigerlilly · 30/01/2022 19:33

@Diablo2

I don't like this deplatforming of people with different views.

I disagree with anti-vaxxers but it's my mind to make up. They should be entitled to have the same courtesy. Otherwise, we're all in an echo chamber, aren't we, only being able to listen to sanctioned opinions. I think it's a dangerous road to go down.

What if it was hosting a really sexist or racist podcast?
Lilifer · 30/01/2022 19:31

@LondonWolf

Neil Young? This Neil Young? The Neil Young who also has a tour coming up and seems to be trying to drum up some kind of interest in it?
Yeah thanks but no thanks Neil. Off you pop now and don't let the door hit your fuckin arse on the way out. Homophobic hypocrite!
Lilifer · 30/01/2022 19:29

@LondonWolf

Yes! I'm staggered at the numbers of people who seem to be fully down with censorship these days.

If you think he's a huge problem and feeding out unquestioned disinformation then you have not listened to the podcast. He pushes back, forces explanation and fact checks assertions in real time - well his assistant Jamie does. He's a valuable and essential voice in these days of cancellation for wrong speak.

Absolutely agree. I've listened to the Robert Malone interview, joe rogan regularily interrupts him to challenge his statements.

What right does Neil Young or Joni Mitchell have to decide what Joe Rogans 26 million odd listernship get to listen to? Fucking arrogance of them!

LondonWolf · 30/01/2022 19:26

I saw a video of one of his podcasts and a colleague called him out very clearly on the fact he knows nothing just like everyone else and his stance is motivated by fear. He looked like a schoolboy.

He says this himself though. Constantly. That he doesn't know much but likes finding things out and talking about stuff. I find him to be likeable, if somewhat boring when he starts talking about weed and his diet of elk meat Hmm

FluffyBooBoo · 30/01/2022 19:25

@maddening

He should keep his podcast, fucking media types and luvies trying to control speech are a pita.
Not being on Spotify wouldn't mean he would stop his podcast. There's loads of ways to listen to them.
FluffyBooBoo · 30/01/2022 19:24

It's a podcast. It's not going to be solely on Spotify, so it's not like he would be losing his only way to be heard.

I don't care either way. Imo Spotify is a business, and so this should be a business decision - and they know their business better than me.

Pumperthepumper · 30/01/2022 19:22

Should private companies be able to decide what is true or not? That’s where we’re heading

They’re not deciding what’s true or not though. They’re deciding how much controversy they’re prepared to allow on their site. Tesco do similar: if you stood in Tesco ranting about vaccines they’d ask you to leave.

Cornettoninja · 30/01/2022 19:20

Removing JR from one platform isn’t going to do anything against the tidal wave of rogan worshippers tbh.

I find it incredulous that a faintly successful comedian has managed to gain such a lucrative audience but there you go.

The man is just a contrarian who only subscribed to conspiracy, I may be misremembering but right back at the beginning when covid was only a ‘thing’ in Wuhan but he was the absolute complete opposite of the stance he takes now because that’s where the conspiracists happily sat before it became globally relevant.

I saw a video of one of his podcasts and a colleague called him out very clearly on the fact he knows nothing just like everyone else and his stance is motivated by fear. He looked like a schoolboy.

sashagabadon · 30/01/2022 19:20

@user1471504747

Free speech is not, and never has been, speech without any sort of consequences.

No company owes individuals a platform to spread their views. If your speech is incompatible with the platform they don’t have to continue to allow it. Same with MNHQ deleting posts and banning posters.

That’s all well and good until it is a private company banning something you agree with.

Should private companies be able to decide what is true or not? That’s where we’re heading.

Spotify have removed Neil Young in any case so it is Neil Young we don’t get to hear anymore not joe rogan ( assuming you have Spotify - I don’t)

Lilifer · 30/01/2022 19:17

It's ridiculous.

I think though that Spotify have already decided against removing Joe Rogan so bye bye Neil and Joni.

Quite disappointed in them (Neil and Joni) because I thought they would have believed in freedom of speech.

Thing about joe Rogan (because I've listened to these episodes that supposedly spread misinfo) he's very good at challenging the guests and does so frequently - no ones gets to spout off anything without being challenged, which is how it should be.

Good for Spotify, I'll keep paying my sub 👏🏻

Pumperthepumper · 30/01/2022 19:16

@user1471504747

Weird coincidence cross post with Pumper there Grin
Haha I was just thinking that!
LondonWolf · 30/01/2022 19:16

It's all a bit silly and has simply given massive publicity to a 3 hour podcast that no one in their right mind would have bothered listening to anyway.

Grin so you're in your right mind because you can't be arsed to listen to a long form podcast? Millions of people listen to him, all over the world. Many of his guests are hugely successful and at the top of their fields. I guess they're all limited thinkers right? Not like you!

The rest of your comment is spot on though.

maddening · 30/01/2022 19:15

He should keep his podcast, fucking media types and luvies trying to control speech are a pita.

user1471504747 · 30/01/2022 19:14

Weird coincidence cross post with Pumper there Grin

user1471504747 · 30/01/2022 19:13

Free speech is not, and never has been, speech without any sort of consequences.

No company owes individuals a platform to spread their views. If your speech is incompatible with the platform they don’t have to continue to allow it. Same with MNHQ deleting posts and banning posters.

Pumperthepumper · 30/01/2022 19:12

I honestly think people these days have absolutely no clue what censorship actually is.

Spotify is a private company. Facebook is a private company, Twitter is a private company. They can ban you for any reason at all that they like - they can choose who they host on their privately owned site.

The real danger here is thinking we’re entitled to say anything we like, anywhere, without consequence. That is not, and has never been, ‘free speech’.

1dayatatime · 30/01/2022 19:12

@Thievesoil

The censorship of free speech at present will be written about in years to come and not favourably

Has anyone listened to said podcast?

After all the publicity I did think I might listen to it on my dog walk see what all the fuss was about.

Then I the saw it was 3 hours long !! and thought nah I'm good and listened to great music instead.

To be fair Joe Regan has done over 1500 interviews from scientists to film directors to artists etc etc. Everyone seems to be up in arms because he interviewed Dr Malone, whose views seem (I haven't listened to the podcast) are to question the benefit of giving Covid vaccines to under 16s, similar to the position of the JCVI.

This then leads Dr Malone to be called an anti vaxxer and spouting harmful misinformation and also Joe Regan to be called an anti vaxxer and spouting misinformation for doing the interview and finally Spotify criticised for giving Joe Regan.

It's all a bit silly and has simply given massive publicity to a 3 hour podcast that no one in their right mind would have bothered listening to anyway.

But I agree with other posters about the worrying implications for free speech and de platforming along with nut job vocal proponents of this.

KellyABC · 30/01/2022 19:10

Agree with you @lampshading. There's a lot of dubious content on spotify made by very dubious people. Feels a bit weird that they focus on this one.

sashagabadon · 30/01/2022 19:10

I like James Blunt response. I paraphrase but he said something like “if Spotify don’t remove joe rogan i’ll release more music onto the service” Grin

LondonWolf · 30/01/2022 19:07

There's another thread going on about things from the past, which for many includes books. I like a hard copy of a book because who knows what will happen to the digital editions when authors are accused of wrong think?

Where is this thread please? Sounds interesting.

SnoopyLights · 30/01/2022 19:04

@lonelyapple

There's another thread going on about things from the past, which for many includes books. I like a hard copy of a book because who knows what will happen to the digital editions when authors are accused of wrong think?

I've had the same thought and am buying hard copies of books and music that I think will be cancelled at some point. It's ridiculous we have come to this point!

I've been doing this as well, making sure I have a hard copy of books I think might fall victim to cancel culture. I did joke that if 'they' wanted my books they would have to come and get them, but recent reports suggest that's a thing that's happening, so it's not even a joke any more.

If Spotify are happy to host someone's work, and Neil Young (or anyone else) doesn't want to share the platform with that person I think he should be welcome to remove his own work but not dictate that someone else's should be shut down on his say so.

If I disagree with someone or something I have the choice to ignore them, not buy their stuff, or argue my own point of view. I should not have the power to just shut them down to everyone else just because I feel like it.

LondonWolf · 30/01/2022 19:01

I do not believe Joe is medically trained and I worry hugely about vaccine misinformation.

So are you saying that vaccines should never be discussed in case said discussion says something negative about vaccines that you would class as "disinformation"? Are you saying that vaccinations may only be discussed in positive, glowing terms? Because that sounds an awful lot like compelled speech to me.

Anyway as I have already said he doesn't give medical advice, he hosts discussions with qualified doctors. People need to listen to them before commenting.

EmmaH2022 · 30/01/2022 18:57

X post

I think doctors on a podcast shouldn't be seen as your own doctor doing a consultation either.

Before my dad died, two members of the team treating him were completely at odds with what to do next.

We shouldn't ask doctors or scientists to be a hive mind (or anyone, for that matter).

Swipe left for the next trending thread