Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think Spotify should continue to host Joe Rogan's podcast?

317 replies

lonelyapple · 30/01/2022 17:34

Quite a few singers (Neil Young, Joni Mitchell, Nils Lofgren to name a few) have said they want to have their music removed from Spotify as a protest against Spotify hosting Joe Rogan's podcast (they think he is spreading covid vaccine misinformation), so Spotify will have to choose between hosting their music or Joe Rogan's podcast.

I personally think this is ridiculous as Joe Rogan talks to a range of people about a range of different subjects and his podcasts are interesting and popular and people can always choose not to listen to them and even if they do, it doesn't mean they believe everything being said. I don't think Spotify should cave to such threats and I think this would set a dangerous precedent.

www.ft.com/content/a9fdaf0d-8d46-4a16-881f-a1b0635d3ce3

YANBU - Spotify should keep Joe Rogan's podcast.
YABU - Spotify should not keep Joe Rogan's podcast.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
MidCenturyClegs · 03/02/2022 03:17

Yes.. it's awful that social media platforms have algorithms which send people down rabbit holes, but people should hfs the right to choose what they want to listen to. Joe Rogan has some alleged bizarre views on vaccination but he has also had great interviews with women like Abigail Shrier on women & children's rights.
I think cancellation often comes from the Left which is veering on Marxism. Western leftists cherry pick Marxist policies but the one that's always retained is the demand that everyone thinks the same. We don't - but we are being told that if you like some things Rogan says we are right-wing. We are more complex than that

oldwhyno · 02/02/2022 13:38

YANBU

Spotify should keep Rogan.

Neil Young, Joni Mitchel are free to do what they've done. I don't think I'd have done the same thing, but it should be their prerogative, and if believe strongly enough to take such a hit to their income, then I respect their committment to their principles.

I thank Megan for providing us with an absolutely 24 carat gold, and embossed example of virtue signaling.

Pumperthepumper · 31/01/2022 18:11

[quote MarshmallowSwede]@Pumperthepumper

Yes I believe in free speech. Any other questions?

I’m an adult and I believe that others are entitled to their views and opinions. It doesn’t mean I have to agree.

Only small minded weak people can’t tolerate opposing views. Or children.

Have a good evening[/quote]
Of course, this isn’t against anyones rights to free speech.

And I don’t believe that’s the question I asked you.

MarshmallowSwede · 31/01/2022 18:02

@Pumperthepumper

Yes I believe in free speech. Any other questions?

I’m an adult and I believe that others are entitled to their views and opinions. It doesn’t mean I have to agree.

Only small minded weak people can’t tolerate opposing views. Or children.

Have a good evening

jcyclops · 31/01/2022 15:38

If the content is illegal then the content should be banned, and if necessary the content provider should also be banned. Examples of such content are incitement to violence, holocaust denial etc.

Legal content should not be banned, even if you, or the prevailing orthodoxy, think it is wrong or even dangerous. Lawmakers have the option of making it illegal.

Young, Mitchell et el are perfectly within their rights to remove their content from Spotify for whatever reason they like - maybe they don't want to be on the same platform as James Blunt. Spotify are perfectly within their rights to host, or refuse to host anything they want. BTW, Joni Mitchell in "This Flight Tonight" says "Up go the flaps, Down go the wheels" which is totally dangerous if you were to do this whilst trying to land an aircraft - perhaps she should be removed from Spotify.

I find it interesting that Spotify have all but removed R.Kelly's music but continue to host content by other convicted law breakers - from drugs offences through to murder - Gary Glitter, Lostprophets (Ian Watkins), Chuck Berry, Paul McCartney, Sex Pistols (Sid Vicious), Phil Spector, Lil Wayne, Ike Turner, James Brown, Tupac and countless others.

AintNobodyHereButUsChickens · 31/01/2022 14:05

I read that James Blunt threatened to release music unless they removed him which made me laugh Grin

lljkk · 31/01/2022 13:38

Rohan comes across well in that vid.

Lilifer · 31/01/2022 13:28

[quote Cornettoninja]@Lilifer it was from a speech he made where he was clearly thinking out loud and also suggested getting uv light into veins to kill off covid. He also was a very big backer of early reports hydroxychloroquine was a cure for covid which lead to a couple obtaining a product meant for fish and one dying.

www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-52407177.amp

www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2020-06-05/cdc-some-people-did-take-bleach-to-protect-from-coronavirus?context=amp

www.bbc.co.uk/news/52012242[/quote]
Well there is no legislating for stupidity like the kind that you reference with that couple, anyone who's daft enough to treat themselves with bleach off the back of Trumps musings is just thick as two planks IMO.

Hydroxychloroquine was being investigated as a possible treatment back in 2020 along with things like dexethasone and has since been rejected which we all know so it isn't outrageous that Trump would talk about it at the time when it was being trialed as a possible treatment.

Cornettoninja · 31/01/2022 13:13

@Lilifer it was from a speech he made where he was clearly thinking out loud and also suggested getting uv light into veins to kill off covid. He also was a very big backer of early reports hydroxychloroquine was a cure for covid which lead to a couple obtaining a product meant for fish and one dying.

www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-52407177.amp

www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2020-06-05/cdc-some-people-did-take-bleach-to-protect-from-coronavirus?context=amp

www.bbc.co.uk/news/52012242

Lilifer · 31/01/2022 12:55

@LondonWolf

Thanks @LondonWolf I will check that out. I am actually someone who did listen to that entire podcast with Robert Malone and JR can handle himself well enough to challenge RM to back up his claims and did do a lot.

Same. I like how he immediately pushes back "Jamie can we look that up/check that out?" etc. and Jamie fact checks it there and then. I just don't really recognise the claims people who haven't even bothered to listen are making about the podcast. He has so many different types of people as guests as well, I mean Amanda Knox for example, and others who have been cancelled, or get so much hostility elsewhere. There's a lot of misinformation out there it's true but he's one of the lesser offenders imo.

People are happy to spout off negative opinions about people/things/podcasts they haven't even listened to, I don't really understand it, maybe laziness or they feel like they already know enough from reading 2nd hand accounts on social media like MN, Twitter etc
LondonWolf · 31/01/2022 12:47

Thanks @LondonWolf I will check that out. I am actually someone who did listen to that entire podcast with Robert Malone and JR can handle himself well enough to challenge RM to back up his claims and did do a lot.

Same. I like how he immediately pushes back "Jamie can we look that up/check that out?" etc. and Jamie fact checks it there and then. I just don't really recognise the claims people who haven't even bothered to listen are making about the podcast. He has so many different types of people as guests as well, I mean Amanda Knox for example, and others who have been cancelled, or get so much hostility elsewhere. There's a lot of misinformation out there it's true but he's one of the lesser offenders imo.

Lilifer · 31/01/2022 12:35

[quote LondonWolf]Joe Rohan's response to the accusations of misinformation etc. For those who haven't listened to the actual podcasts. It's only ten minutes...

twitter.com/joerogan/status/1488019683404136448?s=20&t=kiUI1NtkgeHf49AH9cFnDA[/quote]
Thanks @LondonWolf I will check that out. I am actually someone who did listen to that entire podcast with Robert Malone and JR can handle himself well enough to challenge RM to back up his claims and did do a lot.

Lilifer · 31/01/2022 12:33

@Cornettoninja

maybe stray into the point at which those actions prevent other people from going about their lawful business?

I agree but the line where it’s ‘just’ freedom of speech/opinion and where it becomes something that encroaches on others ability to ensure that harm doesn’t come to themselves is really blurred. I’ve worded that badly I think, but perhaps it’s reliant on what the majority of the audience does with that information that makes the difference which would make it really difficult to ever draw formal boundaries.

Again, I don’t really have more than a fringe knowledge of JR but I’m also aware that the American view point is going to be very different because they’re dealing with a very different environment in their society. The January 6th storming of Capitol Hill off the back of the Qanon movement and things like people consuming poisons off the back of a presidents musings is a very different background to be discussing the influence of media platforms to the one we have in the UK.

Who is consuming poison (what poison) on the back of a presidents musings??
LondonWolf · 31/01/2022 12:33

Rogan obvs

LondonWolf · 31/01/2022 12:33

Joe Rohan's response to the accusations of misinformation etc. For those who haven't listened to the actual podcasts. It's only ten minutes...

twitter.com/joerogan/status/1488019683404136448?s=20&t=kiUI1NtkgeHf49AH9cFnDA

Aderyn21 · 31/01/2022 11:57

Yes that's true. And a country where citizens are routinely armed, does have an effect on these things.

Cornettoninja · 31/01/2022 11:51

maybe stray into the point at which those actions prevent other people from going about their lawful business?

I agree but the line where it’s ‘just’ freedom of speech/opinion and where it becomes something that encroaches on others ability to ensure that harm doesn’t come to themselves is really blurred. I’ve worded that badly I think, but perhaps it’s reliant on what the majority of the audience does with that information that makes the difference which would make it really difficult to ever draw formal boundaries.

Again, I don’t really have more than a fringe knowledge of JR but I’m also aware that the American view point is going to be very different because they’re dealing with a very different environment in their society. The January 6th storming of Capitol Hill off the back of the Qanon movement and things like people consuming poisons off the back of a presidents musings is a very different background to be discussing the influence of media platforms to the one we have in the UK.

maddening · 31/01/2022 11:40

I agree, I am pro vax, but if you think your position cannot stand up to mere discussion what does that day about your position.

He has merely interviewed vax-sceptics, not waged a war on the vax position.

I also think trying to silence the conversation gives more sway to conspiracy theorists in any case.

If the position is sound it can handle debate.

Lilifer · 31/01/2022 11:30

@Wanderingowl

I'm super pro-vax. I had Covid in 2020, got triple vaxxed in 2021, got Omicron in 2022. Will be getting my DS vaccinated once he's past the post infection wait period. However, I don't agree with de-platforming Rogan. I'm not an expert on him, so I could be wrong, but as far as I know he isn't anti-vax, he just isn't super gung-ho about it and acknowledges that there are potential downsides to the vaccine, which there are. An open discussion about what can go wrong but why it's still important for most of us to get vaccinated is actually important. Shutting down any negative talk about the vaccine is authoritarian and takes us to a place where anyone pointing out the potential issues is seen as anti-vax. It creates a them and us which is so, so, so fucking far from helpful that it's actually very dangerous. I disagree with some of what I have heard from Rogan but I don't think he's saying anything that needs to be shut down rather than discussed. He's not a Covid in the 5G, vaccines are Bill Gates microchips realm of stupidity. He's just talking about potential downsides, which are actually real.

The whole situation just has echoes of the whole JK Rowling's hateful comments about trans people situation. So many people I actually know accuse her of being a harmful, hateful transphobe, when nothing she said was hateful. People can disagree with her opinion but by being open to hearing her and talking it through, consensus could be found. By accusing her of hate and attacking her, all that happens is lines are drawn and ultimately people will suffer.

I'm so, so, so fucking beyond tired of this shitty polarisation of society that's happening. While we attack people for disagreeing with us even a little and refuse to listen to anything we don't like or that challenges the narratives we've attached ourselves to. It's fucking stupid and regressive and really, really dangerous.

great post 100% agree!

Aderyn21 · 31/01/2022 11:20

cornettoninja I think your examples would maybe stray into the point at which those actions prevent other people from going about their lawful business? Obviously we can't have people inciting violence against others and that's the point at which the line has to be drawn I think, but showing videos of people committing murder is a bit different from expressing anti vax opinions or other generally unpopular opinions.

I was in Cardiff a while ago and a woman was holding up a large colour banner showing an aborted foetus. Do I think she should have the right to say she is anti abortion? Absolutely! Do I think she should be able to force other people (including children) to see images they haven't consented to see? Absolutely not!
She should have freedom to speak but not freedom to do iyswim.

mummykel16 · 31/01/2022 11:12

@Buwch

biden kamala and others all said they wouldn't take it, no good tying to gild the lily You are lying.
Hardly, there would be no point.
Bendyrabbit · 31/01/2022 10:55

Again I’ll say things that were disinformation this time last year are now assimilated into the mainstream. We’re trying to shut down any discussion and censor the news about the vaccines but all it does is make people more distrustful.
I was called a shill on these boards for discussing the side effects my family had experienced. Now all these rare side effects are accepted and are being researched such as period problems, heart problems and the effect on blood clotting conditions and allergic reactions such as anaphylaxis.

I wonder if in another year some of the things Rogan is discussing such as heart problems in athletes and young people will be mainstream too. Remember when the lab leak theory was enough to get you banned from social media, now it’s a mainstream news story.
Cloth masks not being very effective is now said by CDC in America, the vaccines not stopping transition was a shibboleth last January, now an accepted fact.Natural immunity was only supposed to last 5 months, now we see natural immunity is much longer lasting.
This is a new situation and it’s fast moving. If we ban anyone that doesn’t agree with the governments policies discussing covid and the vaccines we are going further down a very dark road as there has already been huge censorship and deplatforming around this issue.
Obviously the vaccines stop serious illness and death. But to pretend there are no side effects at all and that everyone has the same covid risk profile isn’t true.

Cornettoninja · 31/01/2022 10:55

@MidCenturyClegs

I think everyone has a right to air their views. Most intelligent people will read and listen to a variety of opinions before informing their own.
(Disclaimer - I’ve picked up on your post but I’m not ‘interrogating’ you personally but your post illustrates a bigger point of view)

Do you think that the anarchists cookbook should be freely for sale? Do you think that terrorist propaganda videos including the torture and beheading of their prisoners are ok to be given a platform in popular media if there’s a disclaimer? Are you against celebrity injunctions taken out to protect privacy? Are we saying that people in other circumstances who succumb to any type of brainwashing weren’t intelligent (I’m thinking along the lines of heavens gate and jones town)?

I’m absolutely not drawing any direct comparisons with JR but I am curious where the popular boundary falls because we absolutely do censor speech and the press but seem to have a lot of people who think this is a new thing.

FluffyBooBoo · 31/01/2022 10:54

it's totally fine to just shut people down when they say things you don't like

It's totally fine for any private company to serve whoever they choose. That's not the same as 'shutting people down', as there are always other avenues, and places that are run by people that hold similar beliefs and values. That's what happens with newspapers - they have columnists and journalists that reflect their own political stance. There's no obligation for them to give space to viewpoints they don't agree with. And with the internet, it's very easy to create your own space that you can fill with anti-vaxxers or Katie Hopkins fans or whatever you want. It has literally never been easier to showcase your views, even if one platform doesn't want you, than it is now. And it's fair to say that this 'stooshie' won't do JR's listening figures any harm at all.

Wanderingowl · 31/01/2022 10:53

I'm super pro-vax. I had Covid in 2020, got triple vaxxed in 2021, got Omicron in 2022. Will be getting my DS vaccinated once he's past the post infection wait period. However, I don't agree with de-platforming Rogan. I'm not an expert on him, so I could be wrong, but as far as I know he isn't anti-vax, he just isn't super gung-ho about it and acknowledges that there are potential downsides to the vaccine, which there are. An open discussion about what can go wrong but why it's still important for most of us to get vaccinated is actually important. Shutting down any negative talk about the vaccine is authoritarian and takes us to a place where anyone pointing out the potential issues is seen as anti-vax. It creates a them and us which is so, so, so fucking far from helpful that it's actually very dangerous. I disagree with some of what I have heard from Rogan but I don't think he's saying anything that needs to be shut down rather than discussed. He's not a Covid in the 5G, vaccines are Bill Gates microchips realm of stupidity. He's just talking about potential downsides, which are actually real.

The whole situation just has echoes of the whole JK Rowling's hateful comments about trans people situation. So many people I actually know accuse her of being a harmful, hateful transphobe, when nothing she said was hateful. People can disagree with her opinion but by being open to hearing her and talking it through, consensus could be found. By accusing her of hate and attacking her, all that happens is lines are drawn and ultimately people will suffer.

I'm so, so, so fucking beyond tired of this shitty polarisation of society that's happening. While we attack people for disagreeing with us even a little and refuse to listen to anything we don't like or that challenges the narratives we've attached ourselves to. It's fucking stupid and regressive and really, really dangerous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread