Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be SO annoyed at someone for calling me shy!

187 replies

Wednesdayafternoon · 30/01/2022 16:04

It absolutely drives me crazy. I was recently at a birthday party for my reception child. One of the mums pointed out that I'm shy in the playground and it's just really annoyed me. Yeah I am quite shy but I'm okay with that and I don't mind I'm quite happy being who I am. But actually I make a conscious effort to not speak to this mum because She's an absolute gobs* so no it's not me being shy!!!!
Why do people think it is so appropriate to point out that somebody is shy. It really annoys me. If somebody is shy the last thing that they probably need to somebody pointing it out. I just think it's so annoying and I wish I had a really good comeback for it.
It's almost like they are pointing out that being shy of something that is negative or something to be embarrassed about when it isn't. It's just a type of personality and there is nothing wrong with it!!!

Rant over 🙈

OP posts:
Ionlydomassiveones · 31/01/2022 23:45

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

ldontWanna · 31/01/2022 20:49

@surreygirl1987

I'm amazed at how many people on here don't see the issue with this!
Probably because they aren't shy.Grin
surreygirl1987 · 31/01/2022 20:10

I'm amazed at how many people on here don't see the issue with this!

Wednesdayafternoon · 31/01/2022 11:29

@HelloFrostyMorning

My favourite response is 'I'm only shy around people I don't like.' Grin
Hahaha yes I love this although I'm not ballsy enough to say it 🙈
OP posts:
Wednesdayafternoon · 31/01/2022 11:29

@Lavender24

I don't really understand why you're offended. One of the school mums commented to my Mum (she also picks up my DD) that I'm shy and I found it really funny. I'm far from shy, I just cba to talk most of the time.
But maybe that's the point. If you're not someone who is shy then maybe you don't understand why it's a frustrating comment to repeatedly have made to you.
OP posts:
Wednesdayafternoon · 31/01/2022 11:28

@billy1966

OP, it is rude to point that out to you.

A nice response to it is to answer "I'm not shy, I'm just not loud, there is a difference", with a false smile on your face.

Practice it in the mirror.
Flowers

I really like this response! Thank you 🥰
OP posts:
Lavender24 · 31/01/2022 11:17

I don't really understand why you're offended. One of the school mums commented to my Mum (she also picks up my DD) that I'm shy and I found it really funny. I'm far from shy, I just cba to talk most of the time.

HelloFrostyMorning · 31/01/2022 11:07

My favourite response is 'I'm only shy around people I don't like.' Grin

billy1966 · 31/01/2022 11:06

OP, it is rude to point that out to you.

A nice response to it is to answer "I'm not shy, I'm just not loud, there is a difference", with a false smile on your face.

Practice it in the mirror.
Flowers

HelloFrostyMorning · 31/01/2022 11:01

@ABCDEFyou

I get this a lot. It's bad enough when people who don't you know well comment on you but my mother does this to me too. I've asked her to stop several times but the next gathering or birthday party she will introduce me to someone and then tell them I'm shy, and I get a few "awwww bless you" followed by an evening of l people trying to "bring me out of my shell"

Or she will start telling an anecdote, then tell me to repeat it to a room full of people and make comments on how shy I'm behaving, or tell me I'm blushing.

God that sounds awful!. Sad Flowers

Sadly there are too many people like this. (A few of them on this thread it seems...)

HelloFrostyMorning · 31/01/2022 10:59

@LankylegsFromOz

I haven't read the comments, but maybe what she really wanted to point out was that you seem rude and stuck-up in the playground, but she wanted to give you the benefit of the doubt? 😉
Hmm How rude.
Hadtocomment · 31/01/2022 10:58

I can totally see your point op and I think it's really useful you putting it out there as I suspect a lot of people thoughtlessly say these things without realising how it could add to a self consciousness or make a socially less confident person feel really rotten. I know it's obvious when you think about it but I don't think it will be for many and good to make people more aware.

On the whether you're unreasonable front. Id be inclined to forgive the woman unless you have more reason than this to think she's trying to be mean to you as it sounds more likely she was just being thoughtless. For what it's worth anxiety can hit us all in different ways. When I'm socially anxious I can babble on rather than get quiet. Sometimes I know this but it can be as hard to stop as a shy person trying to be more chatty if fuelled by nervousness. Also quiet people can make more talkative people feel more responsible for the social interaction or to come up with things or whatever which means they may babble on more. There seems to be an assumption that talkative people are confident and quiet people may be less so but this isn't necessarily the case at all. Some people are confident of both personality types and some people are nervous or a bit anxious, chatterers or more quiet alike. Therefore I think it would be needlessly cruel to say some cutting remark as suggested above. We don't really have a context or anything to suggest she was actively trying to make you feel bad.

I don't think it's true that shy is a known negative or insult. In fact shy and loud can be used with loud being far more negative and associated with shallow or surface or crass or uncontrolled and can be used very insultingly traditionally particularly of women sadly. I don't agree with this at all and I also think some of the horrible insulting generalisations on this thread about loud or outgoing people (in this case it's a woman) are unnecessary and feed into unpleasant stereotyping.

I'm a chattier person usually but have been very shy at times in my life so I do also know how crap it can feel. I think I was brought up to think shy or quiet people are superior! Ie that quieter people are more profound or more interesting. Chattier people more superficial or not as focused. Etc. So in my experience the positive and negative has been the reverse of the assumption of many on here. I don't think any of these generalisations are true or fair by the way. I have friends who are very quiet and others where it's like going to a stand up comedy performance and all of them are great and interesting people and all are thoughtful and deep too. I do think that the chattering people may end up making these social blunders more. On the other hand sometimes the shy people can sometimes be so worried about making a social blunder they add to the pressure on themselves. So I think it's worth trying to forgive one unfortunate woman putting her foot in it as otherwise the pressure to never make a social mistake just increases which can also be another sort of rabbit-hole.

meloonhead · 31/01/2022 09:05

@wishtotravel

Bad enough for a child, but calling an adult shy is definitely a criticism. Imagine your making an effort to make conversation and be outgoing and someone still says it. It's hard to understand if you haven't actually experienced but yes, it will make you feel boring and unlikeable.

How about people just learn to be polite rather than using their 'loudness' as an excuse for poor behaviour.

meloonhead · 31/01/2022 09:01

@Marvellousmadness

So you admit you are shy And she said you were

I really dont see the problem

So you admit that you are underweight* And she said you were

I really don't see the problem

*or any other trait that is perceived bad

Wednesdayafternoon · 31/01/2022 06:34

@Marvellousmadness

So you admit you are shy And she said you were

I really dont see the problem

Read the thread please and you will see my explanation around this.
OP posts:
Wednesdayafternoon · 31/01/2022 06:34

@LankylegsFromOz

I haven't read the comments, but maybe what she really wanted to point out was that you seem rude and stuck-up in the playground, but she wanted to give you the benefit of the doubt? 😉
That's a really rude stuck up comment tbh.

You literally know nothing about me to say that, how awful of you.

Don't feel it necessary to respond on my thread again thank you.

OP posts:
wishtotravel · 31/01/2022 05:59

[quote Wednesdayafternoon]@NuffSaidSam I am fine with going to school and making an effort to chat to others. I know I could be more confident but that's fine it's a work in progress. I don't need someone who doesn't know me to point this out.
People who are shy get comments like this all the time, at least I do. I make so much effort to push myself out of my comfort zones yet people still feel the need to point out my shyness. It's just unnecessary.

It would literally never occur to me to go up to somebody and say "oh wow you're really loud" or "you're so outspoken" or "do you ever stop speaking" so why is it so socially normal for people to point out when someone is quiet.[/quote]
The thing is, and I 'm saying this nicely, of course you wouldn't think to go and say/ comment on someone's perceived personality, because, as you say yourself, you are shy. It doesn't come naturally to you to comment but from your OP we can tell that you think negatively about this person. If that other person is more outgoing it will be natural for them to communicate more. She didn't say you were boring, or stuck up or anything negative! You have difficulty in hearing the word shy because you perceive it as a criticism. Obviously there are circumstances where being shy makes things hard, so I understand why, but she didn't say you weren't a good person.
Personally I consider the adjective shy to be fairly neutral in everyday circumstances. It's not negative, just more a kind of saying this is how this person is, don't be offended if they are a little less chatty/ open than the average person, as a warning to not take it personally, especially if said by an outgoing person.

LankylegsFromOz · 31/01/2022 04:59

I haven't read the comments, but maybe what she really wanted to point out was that you seem rude and stuck-up in the playground, but she wanted to give you the benefit of the doubt? 😉

Marvellousmadness · 31/01/2022 03:10

So you admit you are shy
And she said you were

I really dont see the problem

ABCDEFyou · 31/01/2022 02:00

I get this a lot. It's bad enough when people who don't you know well comment on you but my mother does this to me too. I've asked her to stop several times but the next gathering or birthday party she will introduce me to someone and then tell them I'm shy, and I get a few "awwww bless you" followed by an evening of l people trying to "bring me out of my shell"

Or she will start telling an anecdote, then tell me to repeat it to a room full of people and make comments on how shy I'm behaving, or tell me I'm blushing.

lumpofcomfort · 31/01/2022 01:37

I would literally never occur to me to go up to somebody and say "oh wow you're really loud" or "you're so outspoken"

Quite, it would be considered rude. And the majority of people with any kind of social awareness would consider it rude and unnecessary to publicly point out that somebody is shy.

tomorrowalready · 31/01/2022 01:01

This is something I have had since I was a small child. At that age I was bewildered and self conscious but did not have the language to define personal remark makers as rude . Still don't understand why some people do this but fully recognise it as their limitations in not being able to have a thought without it leaking out of their mouths. Sad but true.

surreygirl1987 · 31/01/2022 00:57

Yes I agree it's dated. Although people still use the term a lot when speaking about younger children. I much prefer to be described as 'reserved' (I'm happy calling myself that).

Clarefromwork · 31/01/2022 00:52

I think a lot of people see it as negative trait when they point it out.
I remember when I reached the end of my contract in one of my first office jobs, the manager pulled me aside and said “ you’re painfully shy” I didn’t really know what to say to be honest. I wanted to say yeah I haven't spoken to you a lot because you haven't really spoken to me or asked how I’m getting on etc but I have spoken to others and made a few good friends. It just made me feel so rubbish.

Summerfun54321 · 31/01/2022 00:24

It’s so dated to call someone “shy”. It’s 2022 and people acknowledge that other people have feelings nowadays.

Swipe left for the next trending thread