Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be SO annoyed at someone for calling me shy!

187 replies

Wednesdayafternoon · 30/01/2022 16:04

It absolutely drives me crazy. I was recently at a birthday party for my reception child. One of the mums pointed out that I'm shy in the playground and it's just really annoyed me. Yeah I am quite shy but I'm okay with that and I don't mind I'm quite happy being who I am. But actually I make a conscious effort to not speak to this mum because She's an absolute gobs* so no it's not me being shy!!!!
Why do people think it is so appropriate to point out that somebody is shy. It really annoys me. If somebody is shy the last thing that they probably need to somebody pointing it out. I just think it's so annoying and I wish I had a really good comeback for it.
It's almost like they are pointing out that being shy of something that is negative or something to be embarrassed about when it isn't. It's just a type of personality and there is nothing wrong with it!!!

Rant over 🙈

OP posts:
RockinHorseShit · 01/02/2022 12:03

There's an answer to this & one I've used with success

'Oh, you think I'm shy? No, that's not actually true, I'm just fussy who I talk to & confident & sensible enough to avoid the gossip mongers or bores" smile sweetly & change the subject & watch them mentally implode whilst not knowing what to say

KedgeIsland · 01/02/2022 11:53

[quote Wednesdayafternoon]@KedgeIsland I really think you're thinking too much into things. I didn't respond because it room me back and I felt embarrassed and that's all there is to it. Also, I don't like confrontation or being out on the spot so I don't really want to talk back to someone like that.
I'm not at fault here and I'm not going to be made to feel so.

I'm in agreement with the majority, she was rude and it was unnecessary and people should be more socially aware and responsible to others.[/quote]
Of course you're not at fault. I've never suggested you are. You do seem quite angry about it on here, though, so I suppose all I'm wondering is why you didn't say something neutral in return that would have made you feel less got at in the situation.

You just keep saying you don't like confrontation, and don't want to be rude, but I've never suggested you be rude or confrontational in response -- you sound as if you don't see any middle ground between suffering in silence at having something pointed out that you feel self-conscious about, and going on attack mode.

If this is something that happens frequently, and it really bothers you, then think about a neutral reply?

Feelingstuckkkk · 01/02/2022 11:36

Totally agree with you OP, I am also very shy and have been since childhood. My DM literally used to introduce me by saying this is my daughter she's very shy. I used to be crippled with embarrassment and wanted the ground to swallow me whenever she said it. I don't think she had any clue how much worse it made me feel.
My DC is also very similar so using my experience and things I've read I know that I absolutely should not point out the shyness!

Being shy is seen as such a negative and really shouldn't be.

Ciaram55 · 01/02/2022 11:27

Calling someone shy who admits that they’re shy? hmm

So if you know yourself you're very loud you'd find it acceptable for someone you hardly know to say "you're very loud aren't you"

By your reckoning what if someone was self conscious about a large nose, is it fine for someone to say "haven't you got a big nose"Hmm

OhWhyNot · 01/02/2022 11:27

If people are uncomfortable around others not wanting to give them attention maybe they need to look at themselves more before commenting on others not paying them attention. What is there need …

Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 11:25

@KedgeIsland I really think you're thinking too much into things. I didn't respond because it room me back and I felt embarrassed and that's all there is to it. Also, I don't like confrontation or being out on the spot so I don't really want to talk back to someone like that.
I'm not at fault here and I'm not going to be made to feel so.

I'm in agreement with the majority, she was rude and it was unnecessary and people should be more socially aware and responsible to others.

OP posts:
Ciaram55 · 01/02/2022 11:20

Somebody pointing out what they see as a negative as in saying to the Op she was shy, and the op describing this person as a "gobshite" can't be compared. Both descriptions might be true, but the Op didn't voice her opinions aloud to that person. Why should this "loud" woman think it fine to make personal remarks like that. It's certainly not said as a compliment, as in "your hair always looks lovely"

KedgeIsland · 01/02/2022 11:10

[quote Wednesdayafternoon]@KedgeIsland it's not my shyness that's stopping me from saying something and I've never suggested it ever was, it's the fact that I think it's rude and like I've pointed out several times over this thread, it's not ok to put someone on the spot like that. It's unnecessary and rude and quite frankly really weird. That's my opinion. But the disadvantage that a shy or less confident person will likely have is that they don't feel brave enough to say anything back. [/quote]
But you've said you are shy -- are you saying that you are brave enough to say something back to people who remark on your shyness, and it's only other shy people who wouldn't be able to?

I think you're misunderstanding me, too -- I'm not in the least suggesting you be rude to this woman, but it's perfectly possible to say something neutral like 'Is that so?' or 'I wasn't aware that was how I came across' or 'I'm often preoccupied with X on the school run' or 'School playgrounds give me the creeps since my own schooldays.'

Ozanj · 01/02/2022 10:56

Shy is used for kids trying to get to grips with social norms. You are an adult and so there are other words to describe you deliberately ignoring someone in the playground from an external perspective - rude, antisocial, ignorant. It doesn’t cost money just to smile / nod a quick greeting. She used ‘shy’ because she still probably wants to see a positive in your lack of interaction or was trying to call you out as politely as possible.

Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 10:52

@KedgeIsland it's not my shyness that's stopping me from saying something and I've never suggested it ever was, it's the fact that I think it's rude and like I've pointed out several times over this thread, it's not ok to put someone on the spot like that. It's unnecessary and rude and quite frankly really weird. That's my opinion. But the disadvantage that a shy or less confident person will likely have is that they don't feel brave enough to say anything back.

OP posts:
KedgeIsland · 01/02/2022 10:22

[quote Wednesdayafternoon]@KedgeIsland but the point of this thread isn't necessarily a comparison between the two different personality traits. It's about how "self righteous" people feel to point out an insecurity. And you might argue how would they know it's an insecurity? But I think that people should be more socially aware that shy people OFTEN are shy because they have less confidence so why is it kind to point that out? It just isn't. Simple as that.[/quote]
I'm not disagreeing with you that she was rude. I'm just also saying that people who say they are shy on here are frequently extremely rude and self-righteous about people they perceive as 'loud' or socially confident.

You may say, 'Well, they're saying it on an anonymous internet forum, rather than to the 'loud' person's face', but my point is that it's shyness rather than them being a more tactful and polite person that is preventing the shy person from remarking on the loud person's loudness.

What kind of comeback is it that you wish you had? What is stopping you saying something to her about how it makes you feel bad?

Because if your shyness is stopping you responding assertively and civilly to someone who's said something to upset you, then I do think it's a negative thing in that it's restricting you.

Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 10:14

@KedgeIsland but the point of this thread isn't necessarily a comparison between the two different personality traits. It's about how "self righteous" people feel to point out an insecurity. And you might argue how would they know it's an insecurity? But I think that people should be more socially aware that shy people OFTEN are shy because they have less confidence so why is it kind to point that out? It just isn't. Simple as that.

OP posts:
KedgeIsland · 01/02/2022 09:43

[quote Wednesdayafternoon]@KedgeIsland no I wouldn't go up to someone and say they are loud because it's a weird thing to do!!!![/quote]
Well, I don’t disagree — I’m all in favour of people who recognise that not only is it possible to think a thing and not say it, it’s often better! — but I get a bit tired of the confusion about introverts and extroverts on Mn (which are not the same thing at all as ‘loud’ and ‘shy’,or ‘confident’ and ‘timid/anxious’) and of the frequent self-righteousness of those who identify as ‘shy’. Being ‘shy’ doesn’t actually make you in any way a better person than people who present as more talkative and socially confident..

This person was rude to comment on your shyness, absolutely, but we won’t be able to do any kind of comparative analysis between shyness/loudness and politeness standards, because we will never know what the shy person refrains from saying because they are too shy to say it. Is it politeness or shyness holding them back from saying ‘Actually, I just don’t talk to you because I think you’re awful’?

maplegrove · 01/02/2022 09:24

I agree OP. It’s one thing to think something about someone but another thing to say it to them. It wouldn’t be acceptable to say to someone you don’t know very well ‘your top is creased’ or ‘you’re too short’ etc. It’s just mean and unnecessary to say someone is shy even if they are acting shy. Sometimes it’s best to keep it to yourself.

Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 08:54

@KedgeIsland no I wouldn't go up to someone and say they are loud because it's a weird thing to do!!!!

OP posts:
Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 08:54

@Goldendeliciousness

I agree with OP.

It is rude is because it gets commented on often, people who are outgoing wouldn't get those others referring to them as loud constantly. I am shy and find social situations hard, to have someone comment that they have noticed that I am shy is not a compliment it just makes me feel more self conscious and makes me even shyer.

I think it is often as a sly way of putting someone down and in my experience it is always said by very loud individuals with little self awareness.

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

This!!!

OP posts:
Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 08:53

@Toanewstart22 I'm not ashamed of who I am and I am happy that I go into school and work and make effort with people. But not having a lot of confidence or being shy is often deep rooted, and for me it is. So whilst I'm happy with me and I push myself to be more confident, when someone feels the need to put me on the spot and say "god you're shy", "you're quiet aren't you", "do you ever speak", "let's bring you out of your shell" it makes me feel like absolute shit because I'm making an effort and I'm happy doing my thing.
I accept that people have their opinions of me, o have my opinions of others... but why is it so ok for people to comment on people who don't have a lot of confidence? Whether that person knows it or not! It absolutely isn't it. If you notice someone is shy or quiet and you feel it your responsibility to acknowledge that, then why not just try and chat to that person more... instead of labelling them and making them feel inferior!
It really isn't rocket science. It's just as simple as the above.

Yes im happy with me and I feel good about myself when I make the effort with others, but I just do not need people to label me shy or label me anything.

OP posts:
Goldendeliciousness · 01/02/2022 08:50

I agree with OP.

It is rude is because it gets commented on often, people who are outgoing wouldn't get those others referring to them as loud constantly. I am shy and find social situations hard, to have someone comment that they have noticed that I am shy is not a compliment it just makes me feel more self conscious and makes me even shyer.

I think it is often as a sly way of putting someone down and in my experience it is always said by very loud individuals with little self awareness.

KedgeIsland · 01/02/2022 08:41

[quote Wednesdayafternoon]@NuffSaidSam I am fine with going to school and making an effort to chat to others. I know I could be more confident but that's fine it's a work in progress. I don't need someone who doesn't know me to point this out.
People who are shy get comments like this all the time, at least I do. I make so much effort to push myself out of my comfort zones yet people still feel the need to point out my shyness. It's just unnecessary.

It would literally never occur to me to go up to somebody and say "oh wow you're really loud" or "you're so outspoken" or "do you ever stop speaking" so why is it so socially normal for people to point out when someone is quiet.[/quote]
Well, surely the reason you wouldn’t go up to someone and tell them they’re loud is because you say yourself you’re ‘shy’?

Why not tell the commenter that actually you’re the life and soul of the party, but you never speak to her because you think she’s awful?

5keletor · 01/02/2022 08:37

You sound much more like someone I'd prefer to be around OP, it's the more outgoing people are often more loud and annoying, I've found.

I get why you're annoyed, you wouldn't go up to her and say "you're very talkative!".

Ciaram55 · 01/02/2022 08:33

People definitely see it as a negative. Shy people tend to get ignored. I think people often see shy people as boring people. It's the outgoings ones who are "popular" and everyone wants to talk to. To point out someone's shyness is rude and unnecessary.

A shy person knows they are shy, they don't need to be told. As if you'd say to an overly loud person "aren't you loud".

MandalaYogaTapestry · 01/02/2022 08:23

The earlier post was for Toan

MandalaYogaTapestry · 01/02/2022 08:23

It has been pointed out many times that usually it is seen as non-desirable. It's not about your own personal perception. See above examples.

lollipoprainbow · 01/02/2022 08:15

People who are shy are well aware they are and don't need it to be pointed out !

Toanewstart22 · 01/02/2022 08:13

@MandalaYogaTapestry

To the people that are baffled and don't see the problem.

Try replacing shy with obese. Or having crooked teeth. Or - please forgive the crude example - inferile. Or whatever else that one would choose not to be if that were an option.

Then you will realise that some things may be true but should not be said to someone's face.

Odd analogy As I don’t regard someone being shy as a negative or criticism. It’s like saying someone is confident or quiet or loud or chatty etc
Swipe left for the next trending thread