Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be SO annoyed at someone for calling me shy!

187 replies

Wednesdayafternoon · 30/01/2022 16:04

It absolutely drives me crazy. I was recently at a birthday party for my reception child. One of the mums pointed out that I'm shy in the playground and it's just really annoyed me. Yeah I am quite shy but I'm okay with that and I don't mind I'm quite happy being who I am. But actually I make a conscious effort to not speak to this mum because She's an absolute gobs* so no it's not me being shy!!!!
Why do people think it is so appropriate to point out that somebody is shy. It really annoys me. If somebody is shy the last thing that they probably need to somebody pointing it out. I just think it's so annoying and I wish I had a really good comeback for it.
It's almost like they are pointing out that being shy of something that is negative or something to be embarrassed about when it isn't. It's just a type of personality and there is nothing wrong with it!!!

Rant over 🙈

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jedsnewstar · 01/02/2022 23:43

HelloFrostyMorning
@Jedsnewstar
It’s not a positive character trait though. Sorry if that offends people but it just isn’t. It’s not the same as being quiet and reserved. That’s a personality trait. Shyness is symptom of low self esteem, that’s not something to be celebrated.

Being a loud and arrogant gobshite who likes the sound of their own voice, and demanding to know why other people aren't as obnoxious and loud as you is not a positive personality trait either.

If being shy is ok the why is OP so annoyed with being called it. I agree with her the playground person was rude to say it, because as I said it is not a positive thing to say about someone.

I also said being quiet and reserved is a positive trait and not once did I say being a loud gobshite was a great thing. Your assumption that someone who thinks being shy is not a good think is clearly a loudmouth is laughable really. I was actually terribly shy and worked hard to get over it, I still get told to ‘speak up’ all the time or that I’m ‘softly spoken’. It’s embarrassing so I work on that to, but that’s a harder nut to crack.

My Nanna was the most gentle, sweet lady I've ever known. Many may have thought she was shy, but I loved that about her.

I don’t get your point. She was gentle and sweet and I assume quiet and reserved which I said was a positive trait. You are implying that people would confuse this with her being shy, meaning she wasn’t actually shy.
If you had said my Nanna was shy I loved this about her then fine.

Ciaram55 · 01/02/2022 15:42

I hate it when people say "it's the quiet ones you have to watch"....Yeah ok. Confused

2orangey · 01/02/2022 15:19

YANBU

I bloody hate this! 'You're so quiet' is the usual one I get.

Just what are they expecting for a response?

Some people say it is just making a conversation. Well, I can't think of a worse conversation opener.

Give me just about anything else - weather, what was on TV last night, what you had for dinner - and I will try my best to respond and engage.

But bringing up my 'flawed' quiet personality (as seen in out culture). How is that paving the way for a decent conversation?

Imagine if the quiet ones turned around one day and said to the noisy ones 'you're so loud! Turn it down!'

merryhouse · 01/02/2022 14:34

I dunno... if she'd called you a stuck-up cow would that have been better?

(spoiler.... it's not)

Saysama · 01/02/2022 14:16

Dear Lord. Okay, then.

Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 14:14

@Saysama I just don't understand what you're asking of me and why you're sending me other peoples messages. I don't think you're understand my point either so I just respectfully don't want to continue chatting because frankly it is making me feel stressed.

The overall consensus on this thread is that she was being rude, and I agree. The further thread has gone on the more comfort ive had with how it's made me feel and reading others who have experienced the same.

To those who have resorted to name calling etc shame on you.

To those who have tried to give me advice, thank you.

To those who still think it's ok to call someone out for being shy, unprovoked... well maybe you should rethink that approach.

But the purpose of this thread for me is done now!

OP posts:
Saysama · 01/02/2022 14:08

“If you or any others haven't understood my response to such question, then simply ask instead of asking the same question over and over again.”

What does that even mean? Also:

Me: You claim that you think being shy is a perfectly fine personality trait (you loved it in your grandmother), but having said (perfectly fine) personality trait pointed out is apparently deeply frustrating and an insult not to be borne? Why?

@KedgeIsland: You just keep saying you don't like confrontation, and don't want to be rude, but I've never suggested you be rude or confrontational in response -- you sound as if you don't see any middle ground between suffering in silence at having something pointed out that you feel self-conscious about, and going on attack mode.

If this is something that happens frequently, and it really bothers you, then think about a neutral reply?

AND

But you've said you are shy -- are you saying that you are brave enough to say something back to people who remark on your shyness, and it's only other shy people who wouldn't be able to?

I think you're misunderstanding me, too -- I'm not in the least suggesting you be rude to this woman, but it's perfectly possible to say something neutral like 'Is that so?' or 'I wasn't aware that was how I came across' or 'I'm often preoccupied with X on the school run' or 'School playgrounds give me the creeps since my own schooldays.'

Just a few examples. There are more. You feel that your responses to the above addressed what was being said to you? Really?

milkieway · 01/02/2022 13:59

YANBU at all OP

I never understand why people feel the need to tell someone they're shy? What are their reasons for doing this? What on earth do they expect the person to say back to them?

Similarly I don't think people should tell children they're "shy" either but there we go

Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 13:55

@MeSanniesareBrannies oh hello! "Literal jibberish"..... okaaayyyy 🙊😳

My question is, to the user who I had directed my question to, had pointed out that in the past I had not taken on board what people were saying hence why I kept having the same question asked to me, The typical question "you say you're shy so why are you bothered". Well I have given multiple perfectly good explanations to this point, yet not one single person who I directed my response to has asked me to elaborate or disagreed further with me. So it isn't clear to me and has become incredibly frustrating to me why I keep getting asked the same thing. If you or any others haven't understood my response to such question, then simply ask instead of asking the same question over and over again.

That ok?

OP posts:
MeSanniesareBrannies · 01/02/2022 13:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 13:34

@Saysama so after reading my response to the typical @you say your shy so what's the problem" what further would you like elaborating/disagree with because nobody has actually said that just repeated the same thing....
would you care to elaborate?

OP posts:
ThreeRingCircus · 01/02/2022 13:33

Incredibly rude of her and I'm amazed by the "grow up" responses. It IS rude to make a personal comment on someone's character in a public place and when you don't know them very well.

You'd never say "Gosh, you're really overweight aren't you?" Or "I've noticed you're so loud in the playground" or "you always look half asleep on the school run." It's bloody weird to make a negative personal comment to someone when you don't know them. And calling another adult shy is never meant as a compliment so maybe the people telling you to grow up or that think there's nothing wrong with this should spend more time thinking about why they are so rude and trying to work on that.

icannotbebothered · 01/02/2022 13:18

Yeah I always get called quiet, it's like.. okay? And? I just don't feel the need to talk when I have absolutely nothing to say

Saysama · 01/02/2022 13:11

“I've also said a few times in this thread that it's fine if you don't understand but people who disagree on this thread seem to be selectively reading as I've pointed out a few times!”

This is exactly the sort of thing I mean. That doesn’t actually address what I said.

Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 13:10

@Ozanj

Shy is used for kids trying to get to grips with social norms. You are an adult and so there are other words to describe you deliberately ignoring someone in the playground from an external perspective - rude, antisocial, ignorant. It doesn’t cost money just to smile / nod a quick greeting. She used ‘shy’ because she still probably wants to see a positive in your lack of interaction or was trying to call you out as politely as possible.
Just seen this comment. I've stated on this thread a number of times I make an effort in the playground, so what's your point here? I actually rarely stand on my own, I always make small talk and chat and smile. You have no basis for your comment whatsoever so yeah that is but no thanks for the input!
OP posts:
Whatwhywhenwhere · 01/02/2022 13:08

Has it occurred to you that she might feel rejected by you? Or feel that you don’t like her or are judging her? It’s just that sometimes shy people are (falsely) seen as cold and aloof.

If she has an expectation of you mirroring her behaviour or reciprocating, she might feel slightly hurt. Hence the hurtful comment. Just a thought.

RockinHorseShit · 01/02/2022 12:49

Ozanj
Shy is used for kids trying to get to grips with social norms. You are an adult and so there are other words to describe you deliberately ignoring someone in the playground from an external perspective - rude, antisocial, ignorant. It doesn’t cost money just to smile / nod a quick greeting. She used ‘shy’ because she still probably wants to see a positive in your lack of interaction or was trying to call you out as politely as possible.

Get off your entitled high horse, NOBODY owes you social interaction of any kind, nobody at all. If someone doesn't want to engage in small talk or social niceties for the sake of it, that's entirely their call. Not yours or anyone else's ... & from experience, they're probably just quite aware & don't want to engage with someone they don't like

Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 12:47

@Saysama

Some people are ‘saying the same things and not acknowledging your response’ because your response doesn’t actually address what they’re saying. It’s like you genuinely cannot engage with nuance or understand any point that isn’t ‘yes, she was rude’. It’s very interesting to read.
I've also said a few times in this thread that it's fine if you don't understand but people who disagree on this thread seem to be selectively reading as I've pointed out a few times!
OP posts:
Saysama · 01/02/2022 12:42

Some people are ‘saying the same things and not acknowledging your response’ because your response doesn’t actually address what they’re saying. It’s like you genuinely cannot engage with nuance or understand any point that isn’t ‘yes, she was rude’. It’s very interesting to read.

ldontWanna · 01/02/2022 12:30

@Ozanj

Shy is used for kids trying to get to grips with social norms. You are an adult and so there are other words to describe you deliberately ignoring someone in the playground from an external perspective - rude, antisocial, ignorant. It doesn’t cost money just to smile / nod a quick greeting. She used ‘shy’ because she still probably wants to see a positive in your lack of interaction or was trying to call you out as politely as possible.
Why is it anyone's job to call OP and anyone out?

No one owes someone else a nod or a smile . Yes it's nice if they do, but the lack of it is not behaviour that needs calling out.

If you go through life calling people out for silly things no wonder they won't smile and nod at you.

KedgeIsland · 01/02/2022 12:25

I'm only repeating myself because I don't think you understand my point, @Wednesdayafternoon, but I'll leave it there. And no, it would never occur to say 'Gosh, you're very shy, aren't you?' any more than it would strike me as a witty and original remark to shout 'What's the weather like up top?' at a tall person.

Wednesdayafternoon · 01/02/2022 12:09

@Ciaram55

I don't think the Op seems angry. She's responding to posts that probably seen very unreasonable. What the OP describes IS rude.

There is absolutely no need to point out someone's shyness. It serves no purpose whatsoever other than making the shy person feel small and somehow not good enough. Also actually makes them retreat even more back into themselves. Why does anyone want to do that to someone?

Thank you for your reply and for understanding!

I'm not angry at all. I was annoyed and ranting on Sunday but don't worry @KedgeIsland I'm perfectly happy now!
It is frustrating when a small number of people seem to be saying the same thing and not acknowledging my response. But hey, these are most likely the people who would make a point of calling me shy in the first place so each time their own 🙃

OP posts:
KedgeIsland · 01/02/2022 12:09

@Ciaram55

I don't think the Op seems angry. She's responding to posts that probably seen very unreasonable. What the OP describes IS rude.

There is absolutely no need to point out someone's shyness. It serves no purpose whatsoever other than making the shy person feel small and somehow not good enough. Also actually makes them retreat even more back into themselves. Why does anyone want to do that to someone?

She says she's 'really annoyed' twice in her OP, and describes the other woman as 'an absolute gobshite' -- that's what I'm referring to, not her subsequent posts. As well as the fact that it bothered her enough to post here about it some time after it happened.
Ciaram55 · 01/02/2022 12:06

Another good response is "yes I am, and your point is?"

Ciaram55 · 01/02/2022 12:03

I don't think the Op seems angry. She's responding to posts that probably seen very unreasonable. What the OP describes IS rude.

There is absolutely no need to point out someone's shyness. It serves no purpose whatsoever other than making the shy person feel small and somehow not good enough. Also actually makes them retreat even more back into themselves. Why does anyone want to do that to someone?

Swipe left for the next trending thread